October
20

The Saturday Surgery

Filed under: Matchday Surgery - Posted by: Mark

Back to life, back to normality. Gameweek 8 is finally here as domestic bliss returns to our weekends. With decisions still to be made, our Saturday Surgery Chatroom is now open to collect your thoughts, advice and aimless banter.

If you’ve been hibernating during the break, don’t fret, we’ve collected a fortnight’s coverage here on the Scout in one handy post – view the bumper edition of the Catch-up right here. The Pre-Match preamble is warming up…

About The Author

“Mark created the beast. He's now looking to tame it.”

Mark

> See all posts by this author

538 Responses to “The Saturday Surgery”

  1. October 20 at 10:46 am

    VanPersienator says:

    Does anyone know if Gerrard or Sahin is playing in the hole today?

    • 2 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 10:49 am

      ronh says:

      Racist!!!

      Are you implying that are northeners are miners?!!

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 10:47 am

        VanPersienator says:

        Sand pit mate. Gerrard is so old he has entered his second childhood already

        • 0 replies
         
    2. October 20 at 10:50 am

      Jonah says:

      I genuinely think Sahin has more threat than Gerrard from open play, if that’s any help.

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 10:50 am

        VanPersienator says:

        Got the armband on Stevie G at the moment but I’m starting to haver…

        • 0 replies
         
  2. October 20 at 10:46 am

    Count Of Monte Hristo - Heisenberg 1 Gus Fring 0 says:

    Do you think I will regret selling Hazard? Cazorla had to come in but I can’t help but think the Belgian will score really well in the coming weeks.

    • 4 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 10:44 am

      Di Canioooohhh says:

      I didn’t make the switch because, at the end of the day, Hazard is a better player, playing for a better team. But that’s just my opinion. Could go either way mate.

      • 0 replies
       
    2. October 20 at 10:45 am

      VanPersienator says:

      I just sold Haz because he only seems to do well against the lesser teams and Chelsea’s fixtures are firming up. Also Mata was a hell of a lot cheaper and has come into form

      • 0 replies
       
    3. October 20 at 10:49 am

      Kosteevo says:

      No. It’s the right move in every way. Caz will rack up the points and Haz will maybe get an assist. I sold Haz for Mata. Already have Caz.

      • 0 replies
       
    4. October 20 at 10:53 am

      Silva is Gold. says:

      I have had Hazard from the start, don’t see any reason to ditch and lose the 0.4 if it was not for that i’d have caz.

      • 0 replies
       
  3. October 20 at 10:46 am

    De Gea Bar says:

    Morning lads. Worth taking a -4 hit this week to oust an almost redundant McAuley (already have Foster) or an ‘injured’ Reid (West Ham) for Stoke defensive coverage for the next few gameweeks? Do it now or use FT next week?

    • 4 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 10:46 am

      juancarlos says:

      no point doing it now, as STO play at OT

      • 0 replies
       
    2. October 20 at 10:49 am

      danishdynamite says:

      Next week

      • 0 replies
       
    3. October 20 at 10:51 am

      De Gea Bar says:

      Cheers boys. Just needed clarification!

      • 0 replies
       
    4. October 20 at 10:51 am

      Disco Pat says:

      De gea bar, keep til next week. Stoke would need a clean sheet this week to justify the -4and since playing united I don’t think they will. That said I’ve a sneaking suspicion about McCauley Against city as city struggling for clean sheets and reckon McCauley might get something. Ps west bron won 3 of last five equivalent fixtures against city!

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 11:09 am

        De Gea Bar says:

        Thanks Disco. McAuley is benched at the min. So you think he should start?

        • 0 replies
         
  4. October 20 at 10:48 am

    JKisthe1 - Los Colchoneros 2 - The Revenge says:

    ok so main rival wc last week. This week he has gone -4. Anyone want to take a guess as to transfers he might have done.

    Foster, Ruddy

    Hangeland, Cashley, Olsson, Demel, Fonte

    Sahin, Forehead, Bale, Duff, Dyer

    RvP, Torres, Defoe

    • 4 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 10:47 am

      HAZARDOUS MATERIAL says:

      The only thing I can guess is Santi in.

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 10:48 am

        JKisthe1 - Los Colchoneros 2 - The Revenge says:

        Santi in for Bale seems silly for me, but then again chances are he hasn’t looked at Bale’s fixtures after this week

        • 1 reply
         
        1. October 20 at 10:52 am

          HAZARDOUS MATERIAL says:

          Not for me. He has Defoe after all..

          • 0 replies
           
    2. October 20 at 10:48 am

      Di Canioooohhh says:

      Torres to Suarez, Cole to Verm?

      • 0 replies
       
    3. October 20 at 10:52 am

      aaamanion says:

      berba for torres, and forehead to caz?

      • 0 replies
       
    4. October 20 at 10:53 am

      Hobo says:

      Maybe Defoe to Berba was one, personally I wouldn’t want Defoe and Bale vs Chelsea

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 10:52 am

        HAZARDOUS MATERIAL says:

        +1

        • 0 replies
         
  5. October 20 at 10:49 am

    Silva is Gold. says:

    Who do you bench?

    Sterling (RDG) Hazard (tot) Bale (CHE) Nolan (SOU) Kacaniklic (AVL)
    Kone (swa) Suarez (RDG) RVP (STO)

    • 2 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 10:52 am

      juancarlos says:

      Kone

      • 0 replies
       
    2. October 20 at 10:54 am

      Hobo says:

      Kaca not guaranteed to start so for that reason Kaca

      • 0 replies
       
  6. October 20 at 10:49 am

    Kanus hat trick says:

    Ameobi FTW. 7 in 12 v Sunderland. 463 people agree with me!

    • 0 replies
     
  7. October 20 at 10:51 am

    Kanus hat trick says:

    I thought it’d gone quiet. NEW POST

    • 0 replies
     
  8. October 20 at 10:51 am

    Wabba says:

    In order to still get my WC team cos of price change FU I need to downgrade demel. McCartney a viable option?

    • 0 replies
     
  9. October 20 at 10:52 am

    All Up On The Interwebs says:

    is this liverpool lineup for reals?

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 10:53 am

      Disco Pat says:

      What Liverpool line up

      • 0 replies
       
  10. October 20 at 10:52 am

    juancarlos says:

    predictions about Zabaleta? Will he start or not?

    • 0 replies
     
  11. October 20 at 10:53 am

    iankehoe says:

    Anyone think berba is too hyped for today? Just back from injury and probably won’t play 90

    Having said that, got an awful feeling he will score a hat trick if I leave him out

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 11:01 am

      jimnastics says:

      I think he’s a decent pick, but nothing like the “must have” many people are billing him as. Plenty of good choices in the same price range.

      • 0 replies
       
  12. October 20 at 10:53 am

    Quish_ says:

    Quick question. Hughes or Cuellar? 4.5m defender

    • 2 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 10:56 am

      The Gamesmaster ™ says:

      Hughes

      • 0 replies
       
    2. October 20 at 10:56 am

      juancarlos says:

      Cuellar

      • 0 replies
       
  13. October 20 at 10:53 am

    The Gamesmaster ™ says:

    Who to play

    A barfa away to Sunderland
    B Davies(swansea defender) home to Wigan

    • 0 replies
     
  14. October 20 at 10:54 am

    De Gea Bar says:

    Another one for you – worth taking a -4 hit to get rid of Poldi for Berbs this week? I personally think he’s a keeper for the next two GWs at least. I think he’ll fire against QPR next week

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 10:55 am

      iankehoe says:

      No, particularly not if you have santi. Been burned too often doubling up on arsenal, particularly against so called lesser teams

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 10:58 am

        De Gea Bar says:

        I’ve got Santi and Poldi. Just need the latter to score more (assists he can get easily)

        • 0 replies
         
  15. October 20 at 10:55 am

    Hahahahahahazard says:

    anyone have rooney instead of RVP?

    • 0 replies
     
  16. October 20 at 10:55 am

    phat frank says:

    Excuse me, WHO should I drop? Torres or Defo for Giroud???

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 11:00 am

      Hahahahahahazard says:

      tough one. torres

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 11:01 am

        phat frank says:

        Yeah probably makes sense, spurs fixtures look better in the nxt couple wks

        • 0 replies
         
  17. October 20 at 10:55 am

    China Mag says:

    Anyone still play the skysports game. Just checked in after a month or so of not making any changes, and i’m 29,037 with 331pts. How does this compare with others? Is it worth paying more attention?

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 10:58 am

      China Mag says:

      I’ve just realized that there is no point in having rotation risks such as Tevez, as there is no squad. But i might as well keep him this week. Right? He’s bound to play after having a break

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 11:01 am

        DElford says:

        You would think so but he played 120 mins in a mid week game, definitely thought he would be benched but then Tevez started. I hate Man City for FPL to much of an unknown

        • 0 replies
         
  18. October 20 at 10:55 am

    DElford says:

    Need some help

    Foster or Gazzaniga?

    • 0 replies
     
  19. October 20 at 10:56 am

    ronh says:

    Interesting fact.

    In every game that Tevez has started, he has got less than 5 points once.

    And that was the game that he got subbed off after 65 mins, the same game he got 2 bonus points in…

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 11:01 am

      Crouch Potato says:

      Doesn’t surprise me, a class act.

      • 0 replies
       
  20. October 20 at 10:57 am

    Hahahahahahazard says:

    Anyone think I should put in rooney?

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 11:02 am

      blo_in says:

      Depends who you’re replacing…..?

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 11:06 am

        Hahahahahahazard says:

        am thinking of putting him in my team for defoe

        • 0 replies
         
  21. October 20 at 10:59 am

    Brutus619 says:

    Captaining Bale over VP, Aguero and Baines (my other team choices). Good choice or crazy?

    • 4 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 10:58 am

      De Gea Bar says:

      I think he’ll bag 5pts minimum this week

      • 0 replies
       
    2. October 20 at 11:04 am

      Crouch Potato says:

      What are Bales returns, it terms of home and away? I see Spurs as a perfect counter attacking side with their pace, suited to teams coming at them.

      • 0 replies
       
    3. October 20 at 11:06 am

      Brutus619 says:

      He’s done better away than at home in terms of big performances (11+16 A vs 8 H). But I think this being a big match will be one where should shine hopefully.

      • 0 replies
       
    4. October 20 at 11:08 am

      nanoo says:

      i would stay away from captaining any chelsea / spurs players…gonna be tight

      • 0 replies
       
  22. October 20 at 10:59 am

    A.D.D says:

    I have vaze te, clyne and demel (3 injuries) this would mean i have to play guthrie. I have 0.8 in the bank

    FOSTER – berg

    clyne – CUELLAR – RAFEL – BAINS – demel
    GUTHRIE – PIENAAR – SANIT – HAZARD – MICHU
    SUAREz – RVP – vazte

    Please help! what should i do!
    i dont have a free transfer

    • 3 replies
     
    1. October 20 at 11:02 am

      A.D.D says:

      please fellas, legends….

      • 0 replies
       
    2. October 20 at 11:04 am

      A.D.D says:

      clyne for Davies or …..play clyne or guthrie?

      • 0 replies
       
    3. October 20 at 11:08 am

      Crouch Potato says:

      Vaz tez to someone would be my move, perhaps Kone?

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 11:37 am

        A.D.D says:

        and i missed the deadline… went clyne to play… eventhough WH are very good at home

        • 0 replies
         
  23. October 20 at 11:00 am

    Christian says:

    Berbatov to score a minimum of 2 goals.

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 11:13 am

      nanoo says:

      min 1 IMO

      • 0 replies
       
  24. October 20 at 11:01 am

    blo_in says:

    Thoughts…..?

    Jaask

    Baines, Raf, Caulker,

    Mata, Bale, Pienaar, Sterling,

    Berbs, RVP, Aquero

    • 0 replies
     
  25. October 20 at 11:03 am

    The Gamesmaster ™ says:

    Who to play

    A barfa away to Sunderland
    B Davies(swansea defender) home to Wigan.

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 11:16 am

      Di Canioooohhh says:

      barfa, if anyone’s gonna unlock the door its him.

      • 0 replies
       
  26. October 20 at 11:08 am

    juancarlos says:

    Foster
    Ivanovic – Demel – Zabaleta
    Hazard – Bale – Noble – Gervinho (VC)
    Ba – Torres – Tevez (C)

    Federici – Maloney – Cuellar – Clyne

    can go like this? I have 1 FT in the pocket

    • 0 replies
     
  27. October 20 at 11:16 am

    nanoo says:

    should leeds be fined for one of the d/head supporters?

    • 1 reply
     
    1. October 20 at 11:20 am

      Adam West says:

      if it was at home it is their responsability to keep their supporters off the pitch.

      • 1 reply
       
      1. October 20 at 12:40 pm

        nanoo says:

        yep fare enough….has not happened for a while….i am sure there will be some heads rolling

        • 0 replies
         
  28. October 20 at 12:34 pm

    Peteex says:

    Why isn’t Bale in Tottenham squad today?

    • 0 replies
     

Commenting is now closed for this post.

Scout Picks

For Gameweek 38

  • Boruc
  • Zabaleta
  • Vertonghen
  • Johnson
  • Walcott
  • Michu
  • Coutinho
  • Bale
  • van Persie
  • Carroll
  • Sturridge
  • Rangel
  • Nolan
  • Rodriguez

Recent Comments

Next Six Ticker

The Watchlist

Goalkeepers

Player Club Factors
No Change Hart MCI B, Vs
Up Cech CHE B, Vs
Up Robles WIG C, Vs, £
No Change Lloris TOT C, Vs
No Change Foster WBA C, Vs
No Change Vorm SWA C, Vs
No Change Mignolet SUN B, Vs
No Change De Gea MUN A
Up Boruc SOT B, Vs, £
No Change Jääskeläinen WHM A
No Change Begovic STO C
No Change Howard EVE A

Defenders

Player Club Factors
No Change Kompany MCI B, Vs, Rest
No Change Vertonghen TOT A, Vs, Rest
Up Luiz CHE A, Vs, Rest
No Change Baines EVE A
Up Boyce WIG C, Vs, OoP
Down Bassong NOR B, Vs
Up McAuley WBA C, Vs
Down Johnson LIV B
Up Jones MUN A
No Change Sagna ARS B
Up Huth STO C
No Change Cuéllar SUN B, Vs, £
No Change Rangel SWA C, Vs
Up Clyne SOT B, Vs, £

Midfielders

Player Club Factors
Up Bale TOT A, Vs
No Change Mata CHE C, Vs, Rest
Up Walcott ARS C, OoP
Up Hazard CHE B, Vs, Rest, Inj
Up Maloney WIG B, Vs, £
No Change Y Touré MCI B, Vs
No Change Silva MCI B, Vs, Inj
No Change Fellaini EVE C
No Change Coutinho LIV B
Up Morrison WBA C, Vs
Down Cazorla ARS C
No Change Snodgrass NOR B
Up Kagawa MUN B, Rest
Up Walters STO B
Down Lallana SOT C, Vs
Down Sissoko NEW C

Forwards

Player Club Factors
Up Tevez MCI A, Vs, Rest
Up Koné WIG B, Vs, £
Down van Persie MUN A, Vs
Up Sturridge LIV B
Up Lukaku WBA B, Vs, Rest
Up Benteke AVL A
Down Aguero MCI B, Vs, Inj
Up Rodriguez SOT A, Vs, £
Up Defoe TOT B, Vs, Rest
Down Lambert SOT C, Vs
Down Rooney MUN C
Up Carroll WHM A, VsX
Up Ba CHE C, Vs, Rest
Down Berbatov FUL C
Up Cissé NEW B
Down Remy QPR B

Selection Factors

A, B, C Current Form
Vs Favourable Fixtures
VsX Unfavourable Fixtures
Rest Rotation Risk
Inj Injured/Returning from Injury
OoP Out of Position
£ Potential Bargain
Sus Suspended/Near Suspension

“I am happy with the way I’ve started, but on the other hand, I should have scored four or five more, so that’s something for me to work on.”

Robin Van Persie talks about his early form at United ahead of his first Manchester derby