Getting a good start is not essential to win the Fantasy Premier League, but it certainly helps. To achieve a top 100,000 or even top 10,000 ranking straight away creates vital momentum – it can also show how well your summer research has paid off.
To prepare for next season’s opening fixtures I thought I’d take a look back at the Scout Picks Gameweek 1 team in 2016/17 to find out what we got wrong, what we got right and what lessons Fantasy managers may learn.
In addition, I’ve also compared our selection to that week’s best scorers.
I’ve chosen the Scout Picks to look at early season success or failure as it is a good indicator of how many of the FFS Community approached the start of the season – using the tried and tested criteria of last season’s form, fixtures and pre-season knowledge.
Hopefully this may give you some thoughts about how best to prepare for the start of next season.
LAST SEASON’S GAMEWEEK 1 SCOUT PICKS
Tom Heaton (4.5)
Goalkeeper
Team: Burnley
Fixture: SWA
What we said: “With the third highest number of saves in 2014/15 – the last time Burnley were in the Premier League – we feel he has plenty of points potential this week when Swansea visit. A clean sheet also looks likely as Swansea look to adapt to life without their top scorer last term, Andre Ayew, who has moved to West Ham.”
What actually happened: We were half right. Burnley conceded 0-1 to Swansea so missed out on a clean sheet, but Heaton still picked up a total of 4 points thanks to seven saves. This was to typify his season, with save points helping to make up for conceding, particularly on the road.
Christian Fuchs (5.5)
Defender
Team: Leicester
Fixture: hull
What we said: “Managerless Hull are decimated by injuries, leaving little hope of attacking returns when Leicester visit. Last season’s fifth highest point scoring defender in FPL last term, Fuchs is our pick of the Foxes’ backline thanks to his knack of picking up FPL bonus points. Last season no other defender earned more than the 12.5% owned Austrian’s tally of 25.
What actually happened: The Austrian formed part of a less than successful Leicester triple up, with the champions losing 2-1 to relegation favourites Hull. A yellow card meant Fuchs finished with 0 points. Disaster.
George Friend (4.5)
Defender
Team: Middlesbrough
Fixture: STK
What we said: “Promoted Middlesbrough’s team sheet is awash with strong budget options this season, with their left-back no exception. Priced at 4.5, he has a strong chance of a shut out when Stoke visit and his 2.5 interceptions per match with 2.3 tackles won last season bode well for bonus potential.
What actually happened: Boro drew with Stoke leaving Friend with just 2 points. We were also wrong to back him, not his teammate Ben Gibson, early on. Friend finished with less than half of Gibson’s tally.
Virgil Van Djik (5.5)
Defender
Team: Southampton
Fixture: WAT
What we said: “With three goals and 29 goal attempts in 2015/16, we are hoping for returns at both ends of the pitch for the Southampton centre back when Watford visit.”
What actually happened: Another 1-1 draw, and a yellow card, which meant the Dutch defender handed us just 1 point. His one goal and no assists, before injury ended his season in Gameweek 23, proved we were also wrong to trust his promising underlying attacking statistics
Riyad Mahrez (9.5)
Midfielder
Team: Leicester
Fixture: hull
What we said: “The 26.5% of FPL managers that have already drafted him in certainly don’t need reminding of a stellar 2015/16 campaign, where he finished as FPL’s top scorer with 240 points. Encouragingly, 12 of Mahrez’ 17 goals arrived away from home last term.”
What actually happened: Leicester may have lost but we were right to back Mahrez’s away form. He scored and picked up a bonus point to take his tally to 8 points.
Eden Hazard (10.0)
Midfielder
Team: Chelsea
Fixture: WHU
What we said: “Three goals in pre-season and the faith of new manager Antonio Conte give us cause for optimism ahead of West Ham’s visit to Stamford Bridge. Despite a relatively small tally of just five strikes last term, he has still earned the backing of 17% of FPL managers and could give Hammers’ expected right-back Michail Antonio a torrid time down the flank on Monday night.”
What actually happened: We ignored his dire previous campaign and backed him to bounce back. He did just that this week and over the season. Against West Ham he scored and earned maximum bonus to take his points tally that week to 10.
Dusan Tadic (7.5)
Midfielder
Team: Southampton
Fixture: wat
What we said: “Under new manager Claude Puel, Southampton have revamped their formation to create a midfield diamond with Dusan Tadic sparkling as the most advanced player behind a front two.”
What actually happened: We were wrong this week and over the season. Despite being on penalties and that shiny role at the tip of the pre-season diamond he failed to provide returns in Gameweek 1, scoring just 2 points. While assisting seven times over the season provided some evidence of our faith, his goal tally of three was not what we were hoping for.
Andros Townsend (6.5)
Midfielder
Team: Crystal Palace
Fixture: WBA
What we said: “He excelled for Newcastle at the tail end of last season and we anticipate he will do the same again in a wide role at Alan Pardew’s Crystal Palace. Priced at 6.5 he faces a West Brom side that has struggled in pre-season, where the Baggies kept just one clean sheet in six friendlies.”
What actually happened: He didn’t excel to put it bluntly. West Brom beat Palace and Townsend achieved a mere 2 points. It wasn’t until Gameweek 5 where we saw his first double digit return. We had to wait until Gameweek 27, ironically against West Brom, for his second.
Sergio Aguero (13.0)
Forward
Team: Manchester City
Fixture: SUN
What we said: “Given his pedigree, it is no surprise the Argentine leads our Captain Poll for Gameweek 1 and is currently the most popular player in FPL, with a 41% ownership. There is a word of caution, though. While City have regularly put the Black Cats to the sword at home, Sunderland’s new manager David Moyes has a far better record. In his last four seasons with Everton he was only beaten once away to City in the league.”
What actually happened: Sunderland did indeed put up a good fight, but ultimately lost 2-1 with Aguero scoring and earning maximum bonus points. While his season was marred by rotation and suspension Aguero proved a strong pick for this opening fixture based on form and fixture. Was he worth 13.0 though? Arguably not.
Jamie Vardy (10.0)
Forward
Team: Leicester
Fixture: hull
What we said: “A goal against Manchester United in the Community Shield will have further fuelled his confidence and optimism amongst his 23.7% FPL managers. Vardy makes our XI at the expense of Zlatan Ibrahimovic (11.5), due to the Manchester United striker’s lack of Premier League pedigree and slightly less favourable fixture, away to Bournemouth.”
What actually happened: In hindsight the attacking double up of Mahrez and Vardy was a mistake. We heavily backed the champions and we fell flat on our face. Vardy failed to score and handed us just 2 points.
Andre Gray (6.5)
Forward
Team: Burnley
Fixture: SWA
What we said: “The Burnley forward looks primed to take advantage of Ashley Williams’ departure to Everton this week, as Swansea make their way to Turf Moor. With nine goals in pre-season Gray certainly has strong form on his side to punish the Swans.”
What actually happened: He blanked in Burnley’s 1-0 loss to Swansea. Granted he brought in 10 points the following week but another attacking return didn’t arrive until Gameweek 15, in a season where he fell out of favour and was also suspended for historic social media comments.
Total Scout Picks GWK 1 Score: 42 (Gameweek average 44)
Gameweek 1 Dream Team
Foster (10)
Kingsley (8), Collins (8), McAuley (7)
Coutinho (15), Fer (11), Lallana (11), Martial (11), Capoue (10)
Negredo (9), Ibrahimovic (9)
Lessons to learn
Be wary of fixtures
The dream team is an interesting comparison as it shows that in defence in particular, opening fixtures can be a lottery. All four of the dream team’s backline were away from home, with tough fixtures in some cases.
Among 2017/18 defences this may mean we should consider Swansea away to Southampton and Stoke away to Everton. Both are the sort of away fixtures that may cause an upset.
We swerved Arsenal v Liverpool entirely in our XI at the start of last season. Too tough to call we thought. But with a 4-3 scoreline to the Reds, with Coutinho excelling, perhaps we should be backing players in tough to call clashes more often.
Could a Leicester attacker against Arsenal away prosper next season? This very well may be next season’s high scoring opening day clash.
3-5-2 may once again be profitable
The Dream Team was a 3-5-2 with all five midfielders scoring double digit returns and not a single attacker managing the same feat. This was something eagle eyed FPL managers picked up on quickly. Could the same happen again in 2017/18?
New players to the Premier League can prosper
Laughably with hindsight we didn’t back Zlatan Ibrahimovic as he was new to the Premier League. He outscored our choice of Vardy and carried on doing so for most of the season, in spite of his brief goal drought in early autumn. Should Manchester United bring in Alvaro Morata or another new face, with proven pedigree on a big stage, the chances are we won’t be as wary again.
Be cautious about pre-season performance
Watford Etienne Capoue sits in the dream team, laughing away at us for not backing him in our Picks. We backed him all pre-season after seeing him take on a more attacking role in friendlies but failed to back him in our Scout Picks. He didn’t even make the bench.
On the flip side we did back Tadic, who also did well in pre-season, but he let us down.
This proves that pre-season can be a useful guide but proceed with caution before believing a strong performance in friendlies can lead to a strong start to the season.
Champions don’t always prosper
How did the England Rugby team do after winning the World Cup? Or Andy Murray this year after his incredible 2016? Or Chelsea after they won the league in 2014/15? We know the answer – they were terrible. Nevertheless we still tripled up on assets from champions Leicester, who, guess what, were also awful last season.
This may lead us to temper interest in Chelsea early on next season. Granted they play Burnley at home in Gameweek 1, but as we saw with last season being champions does not necessarily mean they will once again prosper. History suggests a Chelsea triple up may disappoint us after Gameweek 1 next season.
6 years, 9 months ago
I don't know about anyone else, but I always have an average start to a FPL season. Last season I got 50 - just about the average. The Scout Picks did even worse.
Next season I'm determined to do better so thought I'd take a look at what went right or wrong at the start of last season via the picks.
Hope you find this useful. the lessons around formation, fixtures and champions so often failing after their success I think could very well carry on into 2017/18.