Sunday’s Dugout Discussion

by Mark on December 6

The Sunday service gets under way at the Cottage as mid-price fantasy hopefuls – Dempsey and Bent go head to head at 3pm. That’s followed by a tea-time treat as Spurs pay a visit to Goodison to test their makeshift back four. Come 4pm, Lennon and Defoe owners will be pacing like expectant fathers. It should be interesting.

As always, our live chatroom will be opening up to welcome your cries of joy and woe. Get involved by visiting this page.

In our Fantasy Football Scout Cup Final, we have Breakballartist needing big big things from Darren Bent. Donnellyc is currently leading the final by 50 points to 39 and has Defoe, Hangeland and Dempsey against Breakballartist’s Hangeland and Bent. A final good luck to both our finalists.

{ 1123 comments }

goblinz December 7 at 4:54 am

any1 have any ideas on what transfer i should make this week?

Don December 7 at 4:59 am

bullard out for maybe lennon/valencia/giggs.

Barkerov December 7 at 5:08 am

Bullard for Matt Taylor, Saha for a better striker

goblinz December 7 at 5:09 am

should i keep kuyt??

Barkerov December 7 at 5:11 am

As a Kuyt owner I think the answer is almost certainly no.
But Having said that he will play and maybe score unlike Bullard.

Don December 7 at 5:11 am

taylor is like ayoung and gerrard this season, pricey yet no returns…

Barkerov December 7 at 5:12 am

I disagree on both counts

Edmund Burqa December 7 at 5:10 am

bullard out valencia/lennon/giggs/swp

Don December 7 at 5:12 am

a mfield with fab milner lennon swp and valencia is what im looking at now. if mcity do keep on winnin ofc

goblinz December 7 at 5:14 am

is it ok if i go kuyt>arshavin bullard> giggs/taylor for 4 pt hit?

Barkerov December 7 at 5:18 am

I think thats sound. You could also get Drobga for Saha and Bullard for Ohara
but It may not be worth 4pts. Arshavin is a good shout particularly if he plays up front. Go with what you like

goblinz December 7 at 5:23 am

i already have saha. now thinking whether its better to get rooney or valencia

Edmund Burqa December 7 at 5:26 am

i have rooney but would also like valencia for my team, tho, i will probably hedge with swp

Sean_FF December 7 at 9:21 am

A.Reid is a simple, clean swap for Bullard if you want to replace Bullard straight away without point hits.

Sure he hasn’t set the world on fire over the last 4 games, but he has had 3 away games and one at home to Arsenal. Expectations cannot have been high.

Sunderland have 4 out of there next 6 games at home. Sunderland at home are a much better side than Sunderland away, and it is reflected in Reids points per game (6.3 at home, 3.2 away). This should spell returns for Reid, who has been a consistent performer this season when the fixtures have suited.

Oh.. and Sunderlands next game? Pompy at home.. potentially instant returns on investment. ;)

Edmund Burqa December 7 at 5:24 am

robinho back, barry under the knife, fixtures very nice thru wk 26, tevez playing well, ade good for the odd controversial goal

Don December 7 at 5:18 am

but guys, gerrard will have 3 sweet opponents after arsenal, worth waiting for it?

Barkerov December 7 at 5:21 am

I reckon Gerrard is not worth getting until Torres is back. He seems to be regaining fitness and with the addition of Torres causing havoc its only a matter of time until he is brought down in the box by some clumsy defending earning Gerrard some spot kicks

Don December 7 at 5:27 am

so, until torres is back, gerrard isnt worth it? that sound reasonable

Edmund Burqa December 7 at 5:38 am

i do like pool’s fixtures, i thought maybe gerrard (if fit) or benayoun but not sure on benny’s injury status (placenta in short supply?) but someone will score goals, surely? i dumped gerrard before halloween and havent looked back, BUT, injured or not, he will not miss a PK like three of my players did this wknd!!!

Edmund Burqa December 7 at 5:27 am

pool’s fixtures very nice including arse, imo…can’t see another arse clean sheet for at least a month..lol

Edmund Burqa December 7 at 5:29 am

arsenal’s fixtures juicy thru gw22

Barkerov December 7 at 5:33 am

How long till bentdner is back? He will surely be a nice alternative once fit again. If Wenger plays him as the lone striker/center forward that is

Edmund Burqa December 7 at 5:46 am

i dumped bendtner mid august but maybe he should be on my watchlist

Don December 7 at 5:51 am

any1 knows how long vds will be out? was thnking to get kuzschak in CYKI

TorresMagic December 7 at 6:00 am

Knee soreness

kurtkantoi December 7 at 5:56 am

http://fantasy.premierleague.c.....?id=168922

I’m thinking to get rid of Gerrard for Giggs..good idea?

Don December 7 at 5:59 am

giggs? hw bout lennon valencia ?

norwegianviking December 7 at 6:49 am

Short term Lennon, long term Giggs or Valencia. I prefer Giggs because of price.

RaspingDrive December 7 at 6:25 am

A 0.2m swing (Kuyt went down, Lennon went up) couldashoulda done the transfer last night. Win some, lose some.

P-a-H December 7 at 6:34 am

Hi guys,

I have to sell Lampard or Fab?

Need to get a more balanced midfield:
Current Mid:
Lamp, Demp, Reid, Bowyer, Fab

Who should I bting in?

Thanks your help will be brilliant.

goblinz December 7 at 6:35 am

these are the transfers im looking to do.

kuyt>arshavin
bullard>valencia

after gw16. i will take out saha>fletcher
does this look ok?

Keith December 7 at 7:16 am

k.. here’s my team as it is right now and would like some suggestions for my transfers
Sorenson Hart
A.Cole Evra Dunne Scharner Mears
Fabregas Dempsey Dunn Reid OHara
Drogba Bent Defoe
5.3 in the bank..
happy with my forward line and dont wanna touch it.. my initial planned transfer was Dempsey(6.6) to Lampard/Gerrard and Dunne to Ridgewell leavin 1.3 in the bank.. however everyone’s suggestions for arshavin means i can do Dempsey to Arshavin and Dunne to Ivanovic with 1.2 left in the bank or just get carvalho at 6.9.. what should i do.. dempsey and dunne are the ones who got to go

Keith December 7 at 7:18 am

is carvalho or ivanovic a better bet? if i get arshavin in for dempsey i can afford carvalho in for dunne.. or just get ivanovic ofcourse.. if i get lamps i cant get ivanovic cause i’d already have 3 from chelsea

jesse December 7 at 7:16 am

which is the best option guys, your thoughts pls:

gw16 gw17
option 1: dempsey -> lennon -> valencia
option 2: dempsey -> valencia -> gerrard

jesse December 7 at 7:19 am

oops not supposed to appear like the above. try this for size

which is the best option guys, your thoughts pls:

…………………gw16…… gw17
option 1: dempsey -> lennon -> valencia
option 2: dempsey -> valencia -> gerrard

Keith December 7 at 7:37 am

the problem with gettin a player in just for one week is there’s a chance you’ll be stuck with them for a while or you may have to get rid for a hit.. valencia looks a better bet long term so try option 2.. and get gerrard in when he starts firing

metalhead December 7 at 7:35 am

what makes sense now out of:
1. carvalho->cashley
2. brown->evra
3. rooney->defoe
4. dunn/reid->valencia

i am currently leaning towards 3 & 4 for this week (free transfers) and 1, 2 over subsequent weeks.

metalhead December 7 at 7:36 am

bfore anyone else asks, i want rooney out to get the cash needed for all other options :)

ben December 7 at 7:54 am

hmm. All of these look good, but 1 and 2 can definitely wait (I’d say do 1 last). I really dont think rooney should be sold though. He scores in patches, and is at the beginning of one of those patches. I dont know how he got no bonus, he was superb. He was instrumental in 2 of the goals, and scored one as well. As much as Id like defoe vs. Wolves, I think Rooney is a keeper

metalhead December 7 at 8:20 am

I hear ya but I cant do anything other than 1 if i don’t sell Rooney.

P-a-H December 7 at 7:40 am

My team for GW16
Soren (Jensen)
Evra, Dunne, Zayatte (Mears, Bikey)
Lamp, Reid, Bowyer, Fab/Lennon (Dempsey)
Zamora/Defoe, Rooney, Drogs

Fab out Lennon in?
Zamora out Defoe in?

I’m very worried about dropping Fab…

ben December 7 at 8:03 am

DONT DO IT!!!

Defoe and Lennon are great, but so is Fabregas, and he is on penalties, and arsenal have good fixtures, and zamora played out of his skin yesterday (even though their fixtures stiffen somewhat now). Also, Zamora can be benched while Lennon and Defoe cannot, so you may have selection headaches some weeks (I try avoid this)

P-a-H December 7 at 8:13 am

Thanks,

Whats your suggestion then? I have 2 transfers 0.7 in the bank.

I have a feeling we will c 3 goals from Defoe this weekend?

metalhead December 7 at 8:24 am

i reckon you want fab out to have enuf cash? I wud think about lamp->lennon & zamora->defoe if you are really keen on this

ben December 7 at 11:28 am

y do people want to get rid of lampard? He missed a penalty and got 0 points. Had he scored, he would have 7, and all this talk of selling would be laughed off. I have faith in Lampard. He is too good a player, playing for too good a team, to not perform exceptionally well over the season.

Sorry P-a-H, I know this probably just confuses. For me, Lampard and Fabregas are worth ten Lennons

Warky Talky December 7 at 8:25 am

Morning all,
Team in my name…i’ve got 2 free transfers this week…had always planned to do:
Arshavin + Milner OUT for Lamard and Reid IN

but now having 2nd thoughts…esp with Milner, despite his tough fixtures…
Other option is: Arshavin, Collins, Scharner OUT, Lampard, Chimbonda, Ridgwell IN (4 point hit)…

Help much appreciated!

velonce December 7 at 8:26 am

Hey fellas, first time on here and some advice for my team would be appreciated.

Hangeland -> A. Cole
I have 2 free transfers this week and am looking at bringing A.Cole in. Swapping out Hangeland seems the most obvious choice but I’m a little reluctant only because I have lost so much value on him and a +0.1 in value would also mean a +0.1 in sale value.

Lampard -> Valencia
The other option I’m looking at is swapping Lampard for Valencia although another tough decision since both teams have decent fixtures.

Advice on other areas would be great too. I am aware I need to get rid of some hull and fulham players due to the missing gameweek. Also need to bring in a GK because of that.

FireUp December 7 at 8:28 am

Mornign guys from Sunny South Africa

I have Bent but want to downgrade to strengthen midfield. Everyone seems to be talking up Sunderland and Bent. How come?

MattLevett December 7 at 8:42 am

I guess people talk up bent because who else do you get for the money ? (£8m ) He’s top 4 in points. And is a virtually guaranteed starter. He’s had a bad couple of weeks but he’ll come good again. He thrives n confidence and regular play.

FireUp December 7 at 8:46 am

yeah i guess, Isnt Defoe in that range? Sunderland are never gonna pull a Spurs or Man U or Arsenal and have a few big scoring game. so if Bent plays out of his skin he scores one.

sannfy75 December 7 at 8:28 am

i have defenders of evra, alexander, bikey, zayatte and sharner. who should i get rid of to get ivanovic/carvalho/ashleycole? (help me to decide on which chelsea defender to get too). and i am only playing with 3 defenders.

tj46 December 7 at 8:53 am

I think zayatte + one of alexander/bikey have got to go= get in a brum defender + a chelsea defender in for them;
If you have money->cole; else ivanovic.
For brum, go for ridgewell.

Your immediate priority should be getting rid of zayatte

swindonabroad December 7 at 9:00 am

i agree. Cole the best bet to get in and out with bikey

FireUp December 7 at 8:42 am

if you get A Cole and you play Evra and Cole every week (barring injury of course) and rotate the others i think thats top call. So any of the others. i personally have Bikey and ridgewell

xabi_14 December 7 at 9:01 am

I feel very unlucky this week (as lots of others will I guess) having missed out on 20 points from two missed pens! Fab (C) and Defoe.

PMcC December 7 at 9:05 am

I am gutted guys, was away in leeds this weekend and just got checking my fanatsy score. Lampard, Fabregas and Defoe all missed pens plus i had Drogba as captain who would have got an assist for Lampard’s penalty! such an unlucky week!

swindonabroad December 7 at 9:10 am

Also had the miss fromf ab. And i dropped sorenson for hart so didnt even get the points for saved pen.
And had drog as captain. Guess alot us in the same position!

Have already done Gerrard to Lampard and Collins to Samba yeasterday when in a bad mood/ hangover!

TorresMagic December 7 at 9:23 am

Hi swindonabroad, whats happened to you. After GW 11 you had your biggest lead of 71 on me. Nows it 17, have the wheels completely fallen off?

swindonabroad December 7 at 9:31 am

i know mate.

some bad desicions, some bad transfers, used the wildcard badly.

A little bad luck but basically my fault.

Happy with my team now, just did gerrard to lamp and collins to samba. Should be good for a few weeks.

How are you doing?

TorresMagic December 7 at 9:37 am

I’ve got a team with 3 proper strikers at last, it only took 15 GW’s. Midfield is my weakest area atm but I have 4 green arrows to keep me happy. Hopefully break the 50K barrier this end by the end of GW.

swindonabroad December 7 at 9:42 am

Just saw your 4 green arrows, good work!

hoping to stop takin transfer hits now for a while

jamsiep December 7 at 9:09 am

How guarenteed is Matty Taylor of starting at the moment? Looking through the Bolton 606 page, in between all the sack Megson posts!, it seems as though many fans are fed up with the form of Taylor, and those who post what they would like the Bolton line-up to be often leave out Taylor.

Marknlard December 7 at 9:24 am

He’s had a falling out with Megson, but I think he’s still a pretty strong starter. Wouldn’t read too much into the 606 forums.

jamsiep December 7 at 9:26 am

Am with a bit of a dilemna…. I want to get a Bolton player in.. and am currently looking at Taylor/Ivanovic or Lee/any Chelsea def

tj46 December 7 at 9:25 am

He does play regularly though, and I think he is their best midfielder and the best bet to get them goals after davies.
Only think he’s missed that one match, and megson said that the only reason he missed the chelski game was that he was trying to match chelsea’s diamond- something that obviously didn’t work.

Jimi December 7 at 9:23 am

best midfielder for £8.0m?

xabi_14 December 7 at 9:26 am

valencia is looking good.

tj46 December 7 at 9:27 am

Valencia. Although benayoun might be a good bet for pools fixtures after arsenal – WIG por WLV. And lennon will be a good bet for ngw against wolves.
But long term I’d say valencia.

Jimi December 7 at 9:44 am

already have 3 manu players, but yeah i would look at valencia if not.

don’t trust rafa, so staying away from liverpool atm.

really thinking about getting essien in, he’s got at least 5 gw’s till African nations, and chels have awesome fixtures.

so i’m looking at essien or lennon atm, or another i’ve missed.

PMcC December 7 at 9:24 am

Any news on whether Shawcross, Dunn and O’Shea will be fit for forthcoming weekend?

Warky Talky December 7 at 9:33 am

Havent seen anything myself im afraid…i’m hoping Dunn is ok though…would be annoying if his injury drags on like Collins’ has…

ben December 7 at 12:18 pm

or like Pienaar’s did!

PMcC December 7 at 9:34 am

i have been doing really well but injuries have taken their toll the last few weeks and been struggling to get 11 fit players…could be doing with them 3 being fit this week.

Warky Talky December 7 at 9:36 am

Thoughts on the below appreciated:
a) Arshavin and Milner OUT, Lampard and Reid IN (no points hit)
b) Zamora and Arshavin OUT, Rooney/Drogs and Nzogbia IN (no points hit)
c) Arshavin, Collins, Scharner OUT, Lampard, Nelson, Ridwell IN (4 point hit)

Got to do this by Weds as going away…arghh!

Chill Pill December 7 at 9:37 am

I wouldn’t do any of those personaly.

Warky Talky December 7 at 9:47 am

ha ha! thanks Chill Pill…that hasnt helped at all!

You got any other suggestions? I want a chelsea attacking player for their fixtures ideally and drogs on 4 yellows and soon to be ANC bound doesnt seem to make much sense!

jamsiep December 7 at 9:50 am

why take Arshavin out now, when he finally is showing glimpses that he may hit some serious form, fixtures are very good.

Warky Talky December 7 at 9:53 am

Is a good point…but ideally i dont want 2 arsenal midfielders and i want some chelsea exposure…i think Fab is more reliable at the moment. I’ve always kind of wanted Fab, Gerrard, Lamps as my midfield trio…think they could come good over Christmas!

mo December 7 at 10:02 am

Hi guys,

Had a horrible few weeks and need to turn it around again. Any suggestions to egte ball rolling again?

skully December 7 at 10:06 am

i plan to sub OUT geovani…any ideas?..

huddlestone?? bowyer (already had carr, hart)..nzogbia??

Keith December 7 at 10:07 am

k.. here’s my team as it is right now and would like some suggestions for my transfers
Sorenson Hart
A.Cole Evra DUNNE Scharner Mears
Fabregas DEMPSEY Dunn Reid OHara
Drogba Bent Defoe
5.3 in the bank..
happy with my forward line and dont wanna touch it.. my initial planned transfer was Dempsey(6.6) to Lampard/Gerrard and Dunne to Ridgewell leavin 1.3 in the bank.. however another option is arshavin, which means i can do Dempsey to Arshavin and Dunne to Ivanovic with 1.2 left in the bank or just get carvalho at 6.9.. what should i do.. Dempsey and Dunne are the ones who got to go

Keith December 7 at 10:08 am

Course i can get gerrard, ridgewell and ivanovic for dempsey dunne and scharner.. which is very temptin

breakballartist December 7 at 10:12 am

Dont go Fabs and Oursharon; if Arsenal bomb, its a GW down the drain.

Keith December 7 at 10:17 am

who do i replace dunne and dempsey with then? the rest of my team i dont wanna touch honestly.. how bout the gerrard, ridgewell ivanovic option?

Keith December 7 at 10:19 am

i got just the enough cash to do
Dempsey and Bent
to
Valencia and Rooney
but i dont wanna get rid of bent with their fixtures

titihenry December 7 at 10:12 am

Despite bad fixtures, do you guys think It is worth sticking with Milner and his new central role? Anybody seen the game vs Hull?

I have watched West Ham-Man U and was not impressed by Rooney.
The 2 wingers were sollicited a lot (giggs and valencia) so they are probably good punts for the coming weeks.

Anderson was really good.

Second half Man U defence : evra brown Carrick Fletcher and still a clean sheet.

breakballartist December 7 at 10:16 am

Milner is a season keeper at the price.

Ty_Durden67 December 7 at 10:29 am

Hi guys,
Had a decent GW (63) and currently have the following line-up for GW16:
Sorensen (Hart)
Evra ACole Vermaelen (Dunne) (Bikey)
Fabregas Reid Dempsey O’Hara (Dunn)
Bent Rooney Drogba (C)
With 0.7 in the bank, I plan to do a Vermalen –> Terry move, how does that sound (considering Arsenal’s upcoming DGW)? Any better suggestion?
Cheers

bialk December 7 at 10:53 am

Which combo is better -
1. Rooney + A.Read or
2. Bent + Valencia

Ty_Durden67 December 7 at 11:07 am

A

dieHai December 7 at 11:14 am

Looking to bring in either Rooney or Drogs to exploit both team’s next two home fixtures. Wish I could get both but has to be one- which should I go for?

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: