Scout Notes

Scout Scribbles – Lukaku Boost for Toffees

Romelu Lukaku looks primed to return for Everton’s weekend tie against Burnley. Callum McManaman’s reserve outing provides a timely boost for West Brom, while there’s mixed news on the fitness of Newcastle United’s injured duo. Elsewhere, Palace hope to welcome back Jordon Mutch and Frazier Campbell, and Stoke are optimistic that Victor Moses will feature again this season.

Lukaku poised for weekend comeback

Romelu Lukaku trained with the Everton first team on Tuesday and is expected to recover from his hamstring injury in time for Saturday’s visit of Burnley. Toffees boss Roberto Martinez also revealed that Leon Osman – who’s suffering from a soft tissue problem in his groin – has a chance of being passed fit for the weekend:

“Rom is training today with the group and I would expect him to be fully fit for Saturday. Last Saturday he wanted to be involved but it was a real risk in terms of where the injury was. But he’s been working really well with the medical department and probably now we’ve got the green light to allow him to join the group. If he trains and doesn’t get any reaction over the next few days then clearly he will be fully fit and available for the next six games, which is exactly what we want. With Leon, we’re really pleased with the scans and it’s a soft tissue problem that, knowing Leon, maybe he’s got an opportunity to make it for Saturday.”

The Scout Says: Prior to being sidelined through injury, Lukaku had turned in some of his finest displays of the season. From mid-February onwards, the Belgian racked up eight goals and three assists in nine appearances across all competitions and started to finally look back in form after a barren first few months. The Toffees host Burnley on the back of three wins and a draw in their last four and with four home fixtures in the final six (BUR, MUN, avl, SUN, whm, TOT), Lukaku, at 8.7 in Fantasy Premier League (FPL), may yet have a part to play in our run-ins.

McManaman impresses in warm-up ahead of Eagles tie

Callum McManaman clocked 62 minutes of pitch time during West Bromwich Albion’s defeat on penalties against Nuneaton Town in the Birmingham Senior Cup. The English winger was said to have been “lively throughout” by the club’s official site.

The Scout Says: Although the Baggies’ defence will be Tony Pulis’ primary concern in light of shipping 10 goals in the previous three encounters, five strikes in seven outings suggests their offense could also do with a boost. McManaman might not be famed for his goalscoring prowess (ten in 79 appearances for Wigan), but his propensity for beating a man would add an extra dimension to a side that deployed midfielders James Morrison and Craig Gardner on the flanks against Leicester City. Between them, they attempted three dribbles and completed just two against the Foxes, whereas McManaman’s 57-minute stint against Swansea City yielded eight attempted and four successful dribbles. A return to action at Selhurst Park on Saturday could see Pulis revert to the 4-2-3-1 he employed against the Swans, with Gardner dropping out and a three of McManaman, Saido Berahino and James Morrison playing behind central striker Brown Ideye.

Contrasting fortunes for Magpies duo

Reports indicate that Newcastle United starlet Rolando Aarons has suffered a fresh hamstring injury that rules him out of the remainder of the season. Meanwhile, head coach John Carver said that summer signing Siem de Jong – who’s been sidelined with a collapsed lung – is poised to feature in the Magpies’ Under 21s fixture against Derby County on Wednesday night but is unlikely to be available when Tottenham Hotspur visit on Sunday.

We’ve got a reserve game tomorrow night, and Siem de Jong will definitely play in that.

The Scout Says: Having slumped to their fifth successive defeat, the Toon are in dire need of any sort of catalyst to kickstart their floundering campaign. With two goals in five appearances in all competitions before succumbing to injury, Aarons – with his searing pace and capable finishing – could’ve been just that. De Jong, however, also possesses the potential to reignite Newcastle’s attack. The Tyneside outfit have recorded a solitary goal in their last five matches and are clearly suffering from the long-term ban Papiss Cisse picked up in Gameweek 28, so could profit from the inclusion of support forward De Jong – who netted an average of one goal in three matches for Ajax – for a home clash against Swansea in Gameweek 34.

Potters refuse to rule Moses out for season

Stoke City are hopeful that can Victor Moses can recover from the hamstring injury he sustained against West Ham United on Saturday before the season is out. The former Palace winger returned to parent club Chelsea to receive treatment.

The Scout Says: Moses recorded two goals in four starts from Gameweek 26 to 29 and looked to be rediscovering the kind off attacking flair that attracted numerous suitors during his spell at Palace. As transpired in the Hammers encounter last weekend, Moses’ absence could pave the way for Mame Biram Diouf to slot back into the starting line-up for Southampton’s visit next Gameweek as the lone striker, with Jonathan Walters – who was fielded up front last week – dropping back to the right flank in a 4-2-3-1 set-up. Mark Hughes will be tempted to keep faith in Mark Arnautovic, though; handed a second start in seven, the Austrian’s late leveller at West Ham served up a ten-point return, his highest of the season.

Palace hopeful on Souare as duo plot return

Crystal Palace are optimistic that left-back Pape Souare can shake off a dead leg in time to feature against West Brom on Saturday. Elsewhere in the Eagles camp, Fraizer Campbell and Jordon Mutch could also be back in contention for the Baggies clash after recuperating from hamstring complaints.

The Scout Says: Considering Souare has logged just three starts since a January move to Selhurst Park and the competent Martin Kelly waits in the wings to reclaim the berth, the Senegalese defender’s absence seems of little consequence. Certainly, with a single clean sheets in 12 under Alan Pardew, few, if any, will be considering the Palace backline. Further up the field, given that the Eagles are experiencing a rich vein of form – winning four matches on the bounce – Campbell and Mutch will struggle to forge a way back into the starting XI, with weekend bench roles looking the obvious outcome.

857 Comments Post a Comment
  1. Rupert The Horse
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 11 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    I may as well get Fabregas now I suppose, he won't get injured now surely.

    1. La Roja
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Dont jinx it

    2. Mr Sarcastic
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      What could happen? Surely he won't break his nose or anything like that.

      1. Rupert The Horse
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 11 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Ha. True.

  2. jackx13
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 11 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Is there even a case for captaining Silva instead of Kun this GW?

    1. La Roja
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Of course there is if your balls getting bigger by the deadline.

    2. BeardedOldMan
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Yes, he's my VC atm, and is a good candidate

    3. Daniel Levy- Not the Chairm…
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      yes, a strong one

  3. Daniel Levy- Not the Chairm…
    • 9 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Building on from all these award style hot topics, what for you has been the best/most enjoyable game of the season?

    1. Daniel Levy- Not the Chairm…
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      As a West Ham fan I would have to say our victory over Man City. As a neutral, the Everton vs Chelsea and the Manchester Derby (part 2).

      1. Doolittle
        • 11 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Everton Chelsea was great for a neutral, but as an Evertonian it was torture.

    2. Rupert The Horse
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Southampton 8-0 after I brought in Tadic and Pelle that week.

    3. Kings of Lyon ★
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      GW8 by far

      1. Rupert The Horse
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 11 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        This.

    4. Daniel Levy- Not the Chairm…
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      not really FPL related just in general.

      1. Rupert The Horse
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 11 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        I can't separate myself from FPL anymore so I can't answer that.

      2. The Light Knight
        • 12 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Juanfield if non FPL wise

      3. Kings of Lyon ★
        • 13 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        I only watch the PL for FPL 🙂

    5. The Light Knight
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Captaining Kolarov vs Burnley for his biggest haul of the season...so far

    6. Mr Sarcastic
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Game of Thrones

      1. The Light Knight
        • 12 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Was that when Puncheon had to go for a no. 2?

        1. Corkyote FFS CWC Champion 2…
          • 11 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          nice

    7. Doolittle
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Ignoring FPL, Spurs 5 Chelsea 3 or Leicester 5 Man Utd 3.

    8. Forza
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      I went to the Etihad for the Manchester derby, being behind the goal for Aguero (c)'s goal was great 🙂

  4. Wingate
    • 13 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Well, I know you're all wondering..... SO here it is... my next 3 weeks planned out 😉

    For GW33: Sanchez to Bolassie
    For GW34: Dawson, Boyd and Eriksen to Skrtel, Henderson and Sterling -4
    For GW35: Henderson/Sterling and Kane to Ramsey and Giroud -4

    ...and that is how I will break into top 1,000

    (Im writing this down so I can take a picture of it and remember it 🙂 - Any thoughts? )

    1. Puyol Pants Up
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Liverpool face QPR at home on GW 35. Something to consider.

    2. Mr Sarcastic
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Nice to know I'm getting 8 points closer of top 1000.

      Wouldn't do Henderson/Sterling => Ramsey for a hit gw35.

      1. The Gambler.
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        this

      2. Wingate
        • 13 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        YOU GUYS ARE RIGHT!! 🙂

        Will just do Kane to GRU GW 35 and then GW36 when LIV face CHE and ARS host Swans... THEN we take the hit to Get Ramey and another in ahead of the double......

        This is why this place is great!

        1. Mr Sarcastic
          • 13 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          So now I'm only getting 4 points closer, stupid stupid stupid me!!! 😉

  5. Somalion
    • 14 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Y'know, if City get Klopp, and City need a good man on the wings and a good CM, prepare to see Reus and Gundogen on the way... 😯

    1. La Roja
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Gundiboy could be great replacement for yoyo

      1. Somalion
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        He could be exactly what that City team need, which is worrying.

    2. The Light Knight
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      United apparently no longer in for Gundogan, and Citeh are.

      1. Somalion
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        It could well happen.

    3. Rafabio
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Meh. Until that spinal issue flares up again (Gundogan).

      If City get Klopp, he will need lots of time and money to get them playing "his way". With FFP in play, he won't have much money to work.

      Reus will probably end up at Madrid.

      1. Somalion
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Mmm, a big clear out will help the FFP issue though.

  6. Rupert The Horse
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 11 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    It's confirmed, Klopp to leave at the end of the season.

    1. Numb
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Going to Citeh then

      1. Rupert The Horse
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 11 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Would be interesting.

  7. Zizou
    • 14 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    which looks better for the double in gw34

    a) fabregas hazard sterling hendo
    vardy aguero murray

    b) silva hazard sterling hendo
    vardy aguero costa(if fit)

    the first one does however allow me to do murray > giroud in gw35

    1. The Gambler.
      • 14 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      b all day

  8. Kip
    • 10 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Can anyone explain the sudden love around here to play the WC before the DGW?

    2 weeks ago there seemed to be a consensus it'd be wiser to use it for GW35 and beyond...

    1. The Gambler.
      • 14 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      is there? are you sure people arent just posting their DGW34 WC teams?

    2. Kings of Lyon ★
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Liverpool DGW got thrown into 34

      1. Kip
        • 10 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        hmm ok.

        With Pool, Chelski and Leicester as the main targets for the DGW it doesn't seem hard to use the FT's to field 7 DGW players without using the WC though. IMO it is still a better option to use it afterwards and bring in arsenal, tekkers, everton, sunderland etc.

        1. Kings of Lyon ★
          • 13 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          For many it is. For me its not I could only get 6 with a hit and it would mean a weaker team this week. Im happy with my plan(s)

    3. Rupert The Horse
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      You are wrong.

  9. goriuanx
    • 13 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Brendan get binned. Klopp get hired.

    And then I wake up with Ashley Williams as our captain.

    1. Numb
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Klopp's going to Manchester Blues

      1. goriuanx
        • 13 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Ancelotti going City

        1. Numb
          • 9 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          We'll see

        2. The Light Knight
          • 12 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          Hmm, Ronaldo or Lallana? Tough decisions ahead for Klopp

          1. goriuanx
            • 13 Years
            9 years, 25 days ago

            😆

    2. The Gambler.
      • 14 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      can we really attract Klopp? surely City will mop him up lol

      1. goriuanx
        • 13 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        FSG can, the club in its current structure can't. Let's see, I do think Brendan will get binned

        1. Numb
          • 9 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          Benitez more likely for Liverpool, maybe Stevie Me coming in as Assistant after his year in the sun

      2. Somalion
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        You're right, and Klopp having to work under financial constraints before will not sign himself up for Liverpool's financial constraints.

    3. The Light Knight
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      ...and your new stadium is announced, just outside Liverpool, well in fact it's just over the border.... well look it's in Swansea

      1. The Gambler.
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        say what??

    4. Numb
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Is that a dream or a nightmare?

  10. The Gambler.
    • 14 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    For GW34............

    Schmeichel
    Ivanovic - Skrtel - Schlupp
    Sterling - Hendo - Hazard (c) - Silva
    Aguero - Vardy - Remy

    Subs: Davis, PVA, Alderweireld, Young

    cash for Remy/Kane to Giroud (dependent on Costa)

    Thoughts?????????

  11. Jimbo123
    • 14 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Which transfer would you suggest in order for me to be able to afford Skrtel next week:

    a.) McAuley -----> Morgan

    b.) Siggy------> Puncheon

  12. Jonny Sutt
    • 9 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    For the next 2 game weeks guys

    A) Cahill hendo giroud
    B) bellerin sterling remy

    Rest of my team looks like this

    Schmeicel myhill
    Ivan Moreno Bruce clyne
    Silva hazard Sanchez Ameobi
    Aguero Kane

  13. sweglet
    • 9 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Austin and Sanchez out for Remy and sterling?

    1. Numb
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Lol no

    2. Rupert The Horse
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      This week?

  14. Somalion
    • 14 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    I do think PSG will go in for Klopp as well, btw.

    1. Darth_Newdar
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 10 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      I'm sure I remember hearing that Klopp wanted to work in England?

      1. Somalion
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        They always say that, mind. 😉 I think the PL is a likely destination, but PSG will go for him as well, I have no doubt.

    2. goriuanx
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Aye, shout.

      Although Klopp is best under financial constraints in comparison to Madrid City etc

      1. Somalion
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        I can only speak from what I've seen and I think he is increasingly fed up of losing players to bigger teams and some of the attitudes in the BL at the moment. I would reckon he'll go to a club where losing his star players is unlikely, instead of losing them every single season.

  15. Darth_Newdar
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 10 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    So, who to get in for Giroud? I had decided on Remy before the weekend, but now unconvinced... looking at Murray, Vardy and Rooney at the moment. (Not often you can say that!) What does everyone else think?

    1. Rupert The Horse
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Why Rooney?

      1. Darth_Newdar
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 10 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Well, Man United are (slowly) getting better, and I currently don't own a United player. Although the fixture against Chelsea is obviously bad.

    2. Kings of Lyon ★
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      One week punt Lukaku longer term Vardy. No scope to just bench him?

  16. Numb
    • 9 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Who would be your ideal manager for the club you support (name the club)?

    E.g. world top managers include Mourinho, LVG, Simeone, Klopp, Guardiola, Ancelotti etc

    1. Kings of Lyon ★
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Rangers - Mourinho

      1. Numb
        • 9 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        The negativity puts me off with him - gets results for sure but I like to see attractive football as well

        1. Kings of Lyon ★
          • 13 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          He'd play attractive football with Rangers no need for negativity. If he ground out 1-0's against Celtic (and in Europe) we wouldnt mind

    2. The Light Knight
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      United- Fergie

      1. Numb
        • 9 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Good answer - but he's too old surely?

        1. Lucy.
          • 10 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          Age is only a problem for mortals, no? 😉

    3. Lucy.
      • 10 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Klopp at Southampton. But Koeman will do for now. 😉

    4. Numb
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      United - LVG for now, Simeone or Guardiola next

    5. Corkyote FFS CWC Champion 2…
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      I'm happy with Rogers at Liverpool

    6. goriuanx
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Liverpool - in a dream world, Simeone/Klopp. Realistically, De Boer.

      1. Lucy.
        • 10 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Not happy with Rodgers?

        1. goriuanx
          • 13 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          Nope.

          1. Lucy.
            • 10 Years
            9 years, 25 days ago

            I wouldn't be either but lots of Pool fans seem to love him...

    7. Doolittle
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Everton, Guardiola 😎 Mourinho would probably get the best results, but couldn't stand him at my club. Simeone would be good, but his football isn't the most attractive.

  17. Corkyote FFS CWC Champion 2…
    • 11 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Stuck between cash league and OR. I need to play safe in the former but I really want to gamble heavily on the latter!!

    1. Kings of Lyon ★
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Im in the same boat. Cash league over punts though

      1. Corkyote FFS CWC Champion 2…
        • 11 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Yeah of course you're right. Shame though 🙂

  18. Aguero Vs Silva (c) Analysis
    Tommy J
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 14 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    I've lost whoever asked whether its worth having Silva as capt over Aguero. I've done a little analysis and in the 21 games they have played where both have ben on the pitch(although some of those games were limited minutes), Silva has outscored Aguero in 9 games and Aguero has outscored Silva in 9 games. They had 3 tied scores. In aggregate Aguero over those 21 games only scored 4 more points than Silva. So yes it is wortn a punt but it's 50:50 whether it's the right decision.

    Analysis:

    Mins Silva Mins Aguero Diff
    1 NEW(A) 2-0 90 9 8 6 3
    2 LIV(H) 3-1 64 3 23 6 -3
    3 STK(H) 0-1 90 2 90 2 0
    4 ARS(A) 2-2 90 2 66 6 -4
    5 CHE(H) 1-1 90 1 90 2 -1
    6 HUL(A) 4-2 77 8 71 8 0
    7 AVL(A) 2-0 83 3 90 7 -4
    8 TOT(H) 4-1 69 2 90 19 -17
    9 WHU(A) 1-2 90 10 90 2 8
    10 MUN(H) 1-0 0 0 83 8
    11 QPR(A) 2-2 0 0 90 13
    12 SWA(H) 2-1 0 0 90 2
    13 SOU(A) 3-0 0 0 90 7
    14 SUN(A) 4-1 0 0 73 16
    15 EVE(H) 1-0 0 0 6 1
    16 LEI(A) 1-0 90 3 0 0
    17 CRY(H) 3-0 68 16 0 0
    18 WBA(A) 3-1 62 14 0 0
    19 BUR(H) 2-2 90 6 0 0
    20 SUN(H) 3-2 89 2 0 0
    21 EVE(A) 1-1 90 7 24 1 6
    22 ARS(H) 0-2 90 2 90 1 1
    23 CHE(A) 1-1 89 7 83 5 2
    24 HUL(H) 1-1 73 2 90 5 -3
    25 STK(A) 4-1 79 5 72 11 -6
    26 NEW(H) 5-0 58 17 59 9 8
    27 LIV(A) 1-2 90 2 90 5 -3
    28 LEI(H) 2-0 78 11 84 2 9
    29 BUR(A) 0-1 73 2 90 2 0
    30 WBA(H) 3-0 80 9 90 2 7
    31 CRY(A) 1-2 90 3 90 2 1
    32 MUN(A) 2-4 90 4 90 12 -8
    -4

    Silva 9
    Aguero 9
    Same 3
    Only one played 11

    1. Lucy.
      • 10 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Nice work!

    2. Corkyote FFS CWC Champion 2…
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Top work, not sure it helps though 🙂

      1. Tommy J
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        I would captain Aguero over Silva personally because I just feel he's getting back to Form and has the hunger to score.

        1. Corkyote FFS CWC Champion 2…
          • 11 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          Same for me, hard to separate them even though Silva has scored very well (for him) and Aguero has been out of sorts for most of the season.

    3. Doolittle
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Excellent, cheers Tommy.

    4. Beavis
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 12 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Penalties swings it imo.

      1. JK - Cønt ⭐
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 12 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        ^this^

        Aguero has pens, which gives him that extra avenue to get points.

    5. Carlos Kickaball
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      What a waste of time!

      Common sense and a basic knowledge of football will tell you to captain Agüero.

      If you don't believe me just add 13/14 season into your analysis, or look at background stats.

      1. FortunesAlwaysHiding
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 10 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        There are ways of responding and yours isn't a particularly pleasant one.

        1. Carlos Kickaball
          • 9 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          Thanks, I'll bear it in mind, it was nothing personal agains the poster, and I'm always critical of hulked posts if I feel they are not helpful. I'm sorry that you felt my critical response, required a critical and personal response that had nothing to do with the topic.

          1. The Enlightener
            • 10 Years
            9 years, 25 days ago

            If you could see this from an objective point of view, it might be more clear that your response wasn't particularly pleasant. If you don't like the hulked post, fine. Move on. Tommy J put some effort into that and is just offering it up as food for thought. No harm, no foul. And, I know the Prem in and out and have been at this FPL thing for a while now. On numerous occasions this season, I have captained Aguero, and several other big hitters, and gotten little to nothing in return. We are dealing with this season more than any other, so bringing up 13/14 has some merit, but that's in the past now. Silva has been strong this year. Aguero more hot and cold. The topic is certainly worthy of conversation, and that's what this forum is here for.

            1. Carlos Kickaball
              • 9 Years
              9 years, 25 days ago

              Yeah, and my opinion is that it is so open and shut, that spending too long analysing it is a waste of time. I honestly don't see why that is particularly offensive, especially in seen as other people saying they found it useful.

              1. Carlos Kickaball
                • 9 Years
                9 years, 25 days ago

                Should be "especially seen as other people have said they found it useful"

                More added on chickens post.

              2. The Enlightener
                • 10 Years
                9 years, 25 days ago

                Your opinion isn't the problem. It's the delivery of said opinion. That's all. Just comes off poorly and seems a bit overboard.

              3. Donkey_Sanctuary
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                • 11 Years
                9 years, 25 days ago

                I think that he has kind of proved the argument against your case that it's "open and shut". Had the stats been that Aguero had outscored Silva 15 times and Silva had outscored Aguero 3 times then it would be open and shut. However, it actually looks as if it's more of a 50/50 coin toss

                1. Carlos Kickaball
                  • 9 Years
                  9 years, 25 days ago

                  It's misleading because Silva has played a lot of games in the number 10 role, when City have not had enough strikers, and he has had a particularly fortunate and good season, which will only regress. It's also misleading because how many times one has outscored the other isn't a particularly good measure, as it considers being outscored by 1 or 7 points the same, and doesn't take into account the fact that one of the games Silva outscored Agüero in, Agüero only played 8 minutes!

                  Anytime goalscorer from Paddy Power

                  Agüero 4/9
                  Silva 13/10

                  FFS points predictions

                  Agüero 6.2
                  Silva 5.0

                  Points per minute from this season

                  Agüero 162/2002 = 0.0809
                  Silva 152/2122 = 0.0716

                  If you look at the background numbers, or the previous season under the same manager, you'll see strong evidence for Agüero.

                  1. Tommy J
                    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                    • 14 Years
                    9 years, 25 days ago

                    Pellegrini is playing one striker in the main at the moment so that looks likely to continue.

                    I excluded any comparison for when Aguero was out.

                    I'm not too sure why you keep bringing up the previous season it's the current one that counts. Over the 21 games they have played together they have outscored each other equally on a game by game basis.

                    I made the point that in some of those Aguero had limited minutes and is part of the reason I would always go with him over Silva for captaincy.

                    Nonetheless there is 'merit' in captaining Silva.

                    1. Carlos Kickaball
                      • 9 Years
                      9 years, 25 days ago

                      I also keep bringing up the background numbers from this season, as just like the points score per minute, they show Agüero to be superior.

                      Last season matters, because it is still important in how we rate the players. If someone has a good season in the Premier League, we don't just discount what has gone before, it forms an important part of our appraisals of players.

                      In FPL sometimes a player has a good season, and next season people will label him a one season wonder, by the logic of discounting anything more than 8-9 months ago, your saying all of this talk is ridiculous.

                      If someone started watching the EPL this year, having previously only watched Italian football, and they told you that Cissé is a much more dangerous striker than Van Persie, you would suggest they look at previous seasons and think it rather dismissive of them if they then said, oh who cares about previous seasons.

                      1. Tommy J
                        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                        • 14 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        But the only purpose of this summary was to see whether there is merit in captaining Silva and based on the points scored per game in the current season in the way that Pellegrini sets up the team there is 'merit' in captaining Silva.

                        All that said Aguero is more likely to be the first goal scorer and get the bigger points but he has not been totally in form.

                      2. Carlos Kickaball
                        • 9 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        I don't know what you mean by merit here. Your conclusion seems to be that Agüero is the better of the choice between the two, but you feel there is 'merit' in making a worse decision. 😕

                      3. Tommy J
                        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                        • 14 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        Your last paragraph makes no sense to me-RVP had one excellent season for MU. If people had captained him the following season they would have scored very few points.They would have made a judgement in the second season not to captain him as his form was poor.

                      4. Carlos Kickaball
                        • 9 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        Not only that, but you falsely present it as a 50:50! I find this genuinely misleading, and was why my initial response was worded as strongly as it was.

                      5. Tommy J
                        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                        • 14 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        The Guy asked the question whether there was merit-I said yes based on the summary but I personally was choosing Aguero.

                      6. Carlos Kickaball
                        • 9 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        The point is that you can't just base your rating of a player on their last 2000 or so minutes and discard everything before it.

                        Otherwise people would be making conclusions like Cissé is a better goalscorer than Robin Van Persie.

                      7. Tommy J
                        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                        • 14 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        p.s. It was a fact that in the 21 games played together it was 50:50 which one would outscore the other,that is all I meant.

                    2. Carlos Kickaball
                      • 9 Years
                      9 years, 25 days ago

                      When you say Pellegrini is playing 1 striker at the moment, that isn't true either. He played 1 striker against United, but has played 2 in the previous 6 PL games.

                      1. Tommy J
                        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                        • 14 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        OK lets not push this any further we're not really getting anywhere....and we'd both captain Aguero!

                      2. Carlos Kickaball
                        • 9 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        Exactly, we're both in agreement that Agüero is the better captain.

                        That is why I think a hulked post that suggests it's a 50:50 between Agüero and Silva is misleading, it was nothing personal against you. 😀

                        Sorry If I've caused you any offence, but also apologies to those that thought I was overly harsh, as it wasn't my intention to be personal only to offer a strong opinion.

                      3. Tommy J
                        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                        • 14 Years
                        9 years, 25 days ago

                        He's more likely to outscore Silva-only just and in some games he wont.

                        No offence taken.

                2. Carlos Kickaball
                  • 9 Years
                  9 years, 25 days ago

                  PS 973 vs 54 votes in the captain poll... and you think it's a coin toss?

        2. Carlos Kickaball
          • 9 Years
          9 years, 21 days ago

          I hope you captained Silva in your righteous indignation.

          One up vote for useless information, 10 up votes for righteous indignation. 🙄

          1. Carlos Kickaball
            • 9 Years
            9 years, 21 days ago

            Haha Useful information even. 😆

      2. 32chickens
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 13 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        carlos-go kick a ball instead.....
        the site is for serious fantassists (sic) who enjoy this stuff

        1. Carlos Kickaball
          • 9 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          I do too, in fact I love the stuff.

          I just don't need this type of analysis to tell me who is likely to score more points out of Silva and Agüero, and would go as far as to say making out that it is a close decision and using the data the way it has been used is genuinely misleading.

          Anytime goalscorer from Paddy Power

          Agüero 4/9
          Silva 13/10

          FFS points predictions

          Agüero 6.2
          Silva 5.0

          It's not a close call. There are random elements so Silva could outscore Agüero, but out of the two Silva is a poor choice.

          1. Tommy J
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 14 Years
            9 years, 25 days ago

            I was merely responding to an earlier post as to whether there is merit in captaining Silva.

            I do actually think there is merit in captaining him(which is supported by the FPL points system analysis which reflects the actual goals assists and bp's) however I think Aguero tips the scale for me but it is not as black and white as you suggest.

            Cheers

            1. Carlos Kickaball
              • 9 Years
              9 years, 25 days ago

              Good job, I'll be pleased for you if you end up settling on Agüero, as I think it will give you the best chance of some serious points.

              Just hope it won't backfire. 😀

          2. The Enlightener
            • 10 Years
            9 years, 25 days ago

            *searching in vain (unfortunately) for that downvote button*

            1. Carlos Kickaball
              • 9 Years
              9 years, 25 days ago

              Oh I find this offensive. 😉

              1. The Enlightener
                • 10 Years
                9 years, 25 days ago

                Have some! 🙂 I ain't tryin' to be a jerk, by the way. Just thought I would try to put some perspective on it.

                1. Carlos Kickaball
                  • 9 Years
                  9 years, 25 days ago

                  😆 - I don't mind.

                  You know paid up members can down vote. 😉

          3. Tommy J
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 14 Years
            9 years, 25 days ago

            All I have done is analysed the FPL points scored(which is what we are playing for in this game) on a game by game basis and in half of the games they played together(not including those they matched points) one outscored the other.

            I'm not sure why you feel that is mis-leading other than as I pointed out in one or two games Aguero had limited minutes.

            All I would say is 'past performance' is not an indicator of future outcomes but it does indicate that Silva is not a bad shout.

    6. 32chickens
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      interesting that the facts back up my feeling that they are about even
      i think hammers are there for the taking big style and further fixtures to come.
      form would suggest KUN but i am sticking with silva because on value -points per price he is miles ahead and gives me more squad flexibility

      1. AleksanderVN
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 12 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        I might have missunderstood you, but value is irrelevant when it comes to captain pick.

        But if you dont have Kun in your team, I see your point.

        1. 32chickens
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 13 Years
          9 years, 25 days ago

          yes as you suspected i dont have kun in my team-sorry i did not make this clear.
          I was weighing up getting him in for citeh's run coming up-i want more citeh 'cover' as i like their fixtures/differential but beyond silva and the expensive kun its a bit of a fantasy wasteland-due to the tactical incompetence of the curent manager and the paucity of yoof players given a chance with the galacticos
          yes i'm a citeh fan .....

    7. andy85wsm
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Aguero! 🙂

    8. Forza
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 9 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Good analysis, it's pretty close, but when in doubt go with the penalty taker.

      1. Tommy J
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 14 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Yaya?

  19. Sushant
    • 9 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Getting 8 players for a DGW for a -12 hit worth it or not???

    These are the 8 i am planning :

    MIGNOLET/COURTOIS

    IVANOVIC,BRUCE,SCHLUPP

    HAZARD,STERLING,HENDERSON,Silva

    Aguero,Murray,VARDY/REMY/STURRIDGE

    1. Rafabio
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      You'll at least break even if the player gets 60 in both games of the double.

      Just a matter of will they make ground for you in your league overall based on who your rivals have, lead they have etc.

      Not convinced by Sturridge or Schlupp for a hit though.

      1. boogle
        • 10 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        You dont at least break even if you take a hit to get an extra dgw player in...

        You lose 4 points from the transfer and 2 from the player you took out and you gain. 4. So it's a -2 for every extra player you take a hit for.

      2. Sushant
        • 9 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Since i can only field 10 players this GW..i am thinking of bring in Schlupp for Naughton which as a result would give me 2 extra games frm that player....& as for Sturridge it all depends on how Remy & Vardy perform this GW

    2. Corkyote FFS CWC Champion 2…
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      Would fun but almost certainly won't work out. Forget Bruce, Schupp and why do you need two dgw keepers?

      1. Sushant
        • 9 Years
        9 years, 25 days ago

        Not 2 keepers its either of them..still not decided!!

  20. Lucy.
    • 10 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Quick Poll:

    Fabianski, Krul
    Terry, Clyne, Lescott, PVA*, Bellerin*
    Silva, Hazard, Puncheon, Eriksen, Mané
    Remy, Kane, Aguero

    2 FT, 4.0m ITB.

    A) Cut my losses on Remy and go for Remy and Mané/Eriksen -> Vardy and Fabregas
    B) Or keep the faith with Remy and prepare for DGW with Mané/Eriksen -> Sterling
    C) Make a defensive switch for DGW - Bellerin or Krul out.

    1. FortunesAlwaysHiding
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 10 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      B I think

  21. Somalion
    • 14 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Another less likely but possible move is

    Ancelotti -> City
    Klopp -> Real

    Not as likely but then again, Klopp is massively rated.

  22. NEW ARTICLE POSTED
    1. Demí
      • 13 Years
      9 years, 25 days ago

      cheers

  23. Cheshire Duck
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 9 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    For GW33 and prepare upcoming GW34 with the doubles

    Fabianski
    Jones - Rose - Alderweireld
    Boyd - KiSungYueng - Hazard - Eriksen
    Aguero(c) - Kane - Remy

    Subs: Hammer - Downing - Moreno - Jenkinson -

    6,7£ in the bank.

    1FT and considering a -4

    Would you :
    A) Downing or Boyd to Aaron Lennon
    B) Downing or Boyd to Fabregas (to prepare double GW)
    C) Save FT
    D) Jenkinson for Jagielka

    Any other idea ?

  24. HNI
    • 11 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Guys was pondering...is it really worth going for Liv defender considering they have relegation dwellers WBA and HULL fighting for their lives and that too both AWAY?!

  25. Ten Season Wonder
    • 10 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Me V's Opponent in ML Cup Semi: [We've got very similar teams]:

    I've 2FT ---> He has 1.

    GK: I have Krul ----> He has no active GK
    **(prompts me to think he might use his transfer for this? Thoughts??)**

    DEF: (belive it or not) Both defences are the same!!!

    MIDS: Both have a trio of mids the same - (Haz, Silva & Eriksen)
    **diffs: I have Walters (but he probably will be sub (& Alexis is going to free up funds) ---> He has 'Fellaini & Boyd'**

    ATTACK: (Both have Kun & Kane)
    **I have Agbonlahor (who is going) ----> His 3rd striker spot is 'Loic Remy'.**

    what are your thoughts on how to play this people? this cup comp is cash payout.

  26. Ten Season Wonder
    • 10 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    Trying to decipher what 2 players to get in my team AND who my ML opponent is going to go for...

    1). MY TEAM:

    [2 FTs; Mid & Att: budget of £17.4m]

    ..............Krul
    ....Clyne / JT / C.Dawson
    Haz / Eriksen / Silva / ______
    ....Kane / Kun / _______
    I
    I
    I
    V

    2). OPPONENT'S TEAM:
    (1FT: £3.9m itb)

    ...........------------------------------------------------->(2x non playing GK)
    .....Berty / Ivan / C.Dawson -------------------->(2x non playing defs)
    Haz / Eriksen / Silva / Fellaini / Boyd------->(1 will be benched prob Boyd)
    .......Kane / Kun / Remy

    please help guys. Thanks 🙂

  27. Cousin Greg
    • 9 Years
    9 years, 25 days ago

    SInce it's that time of the year
    Mourinho = Tywin
    Stannis = Matic.
    Little Finger = Super Alan Pardew.
    Diego Costa = Khal Drogo.
    Giroud = Loras Tyrell
    Fellani = Hodor
    Harry Kane = Robb Stark.
    David Moyes = Jorah Mormont - an exiled northern lord
    Wenger = ?
    LVG = ?

    1. Donkey_Sanctuary
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 11 Years
      9 years, 24 days ago

      Comparing Mourinho to one of the most cold hearted and evil characters is a bit harsh! I don't think anyone in football can be likened to Tywin Lannister.

      Fellani, Kane and Moyes are good though! LVG Robert Baratheon maybe

  28. eder123
    • 13 Years
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Nugent or Vardy guys?.. kun,silva or vardy cap? Tempted by silva or vardy to chase