[sbu_large_image] Members
7 October 2015 1907 comments
Paul Paul
Share:

Our first members article of the international break arrives this afternoon. Assessing the players by classification across the last four Gameweeks, we look at the impact made by Southampton and City’s new centre-halves, Newcastle’s raiding right-back and Palace’s big Norwegian as Alan Pardew’s defence starts to tighten up.

Paul Is certain he won't make the same mistakes next season. Follow them on Twitter

1,907 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. jimbobmij
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Currently on a -8 (Had to to get KDB in who I see as essential.

    If I were to wildcard I'd only really make two more changes (Francis and Huth to Simpson and Dawson, which would let me stop rotating the terrible Bournemouth and Leicester defenses and just play West Brom instead).

    Do I wildcard or just stick with the -8?

    1. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Stick

      1. In Like Flynn.
        • Has Moderation Rights
        11 years, 16 days ago

        This ^^^

    2. Gashead9
      11 years, 16 days ago

      WBA fixtures GW12 onwards :- mun, ARS,whm, TOT, liv

      I dont fancy many CS from that lot myself, SAVE!

      1. Mark-O
        11 years, 16 days ago

        WBA might be able to shut down WHM as WHM is pretty unstable. Myhill is just enough if a WBA defender is needed. The save points can help to cover the points for goals conceded which ain't too bad.

  2. FPL Maldini
    11 years, 16 days ago

    If Ayew is injured is transferring him for Siggy a decent move?

    1. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      very good differential

    2. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      No. He is still in UK and resting according to the news. It's a minor knock so he's expected to be ok for the Stoke game from what I read.

  3. Forever In Our Shadow
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    UEFA regulations: Article 16 Group formation – final tournament
    16.01 By means of a draw, the UEFA administration allocates the 24 teams that qualify
    for the final tournament into six groups (A, B, C, D, E, F) of four teams each.
    16.02 The six groups are formed as follows:
    Group A Group B Group C Group D Group E Group F
    A1 B1 C1 D1 E1 F1
    A2 B2 C2 D2 E2 F2
    A3 B3 C3 D3 E3 F3
    A4 B4 C4 D4 E4 F4

    Basically Sepp phones Michel and says I'll pay you €20m to put England in a Sh1t group. 😉

    1. Paul Psychic Octopus
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'm not sure that Sepp and Michel talk to one another.

      Although they could always catch up in the prison courtyard, as they empty soil from their pockets…..

  4. Ginkapo FPL
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Well played Wenger, well played

    1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Transparent.

    2. Boris Bodega
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      ?

  5. Eames
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Martial >> Pelle/Vardy for -4 hit?? Already have Mane & Mahrez

    1. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      No. You have Mane which is okay.

    2. Paul Psychic Octopus
      11 years, 16 days ago

      The Mane man is back in town. Still sitting on a -1 loss, but I see him as one of the more essential midfielders for the season (only Sanchez and De Bruyne higher at the moment).

  6. Hibbo
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    The reality is there is nothing different now to when Sanchez was subbed off.

    Just the addition of a flag.

  7. Southampton defensive options
    Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Southampton defence. Something which we have all enjoyed over the last 2 seasons. With Fonte being the only member of the current back line who was ever present 2 seasons ago, many doubt whether they can pull off similar defensive feats to the ones which we were so familiar with back in yonder year.

    I have decided to skim over the numbers and take a look at how they have been performing so far this season as well as the wealth of options their backline has to offer.

    The first interesting stat I came across is the number of shots they concede in the box. So far this season, the Saints have conceded a total of 41 goal attempts from within the box, a number fewer than any other team. This averages out to 5.125 per game, which is fewer than the 6.1 which they conceded, on average, last season.

    The next interesting stat I stumbled across is the number of chances they have conceded down the right hand side. With only 17 chances conceded (down the right) being fewer than any other team, it looks like Cedric might not be as much as a liability at the back as we had once presumed. They also boast a mere 18 chances conceded through the middle, which is bettered only by Manchester City and Manchester United, who managed 11 and 17 respectively. Similarly, down the left they have conceded 19 chances which is bettered only by Bournemouth (15) and Chelsea (15). Both surprising to see given their current defensive form, I know.

    Another quick scout shows they have lost a total of 53 challenges. This is, again, better than any other team, with only Tottenham coming close with 63. This differs greatly from last season when they were ranked 7th for challenges lost. Their average this season, 6.625 trumps that of 8.8 last season, showing they have been significantly more formidable at the back this season.
    It is also important to note that Bertrand’s recent return should mean they will solidify even more and I would expect performances to improve greatly once the 4 get more used to playing alongside one another.

    So, the stats look great for them right now. It looks to me that clean sheets are imminent, especially given they have a kind run upcoming which has only a few games which could prove to be tough throughout.

    Maarten Stekelenburg (5.0)

    The joint cheapest route into their back line and arguably the most nailed on. With it looking like there is slim pickings among the keepers right now, Stekelenburg could prove to be a good, solid option for the mid to long run.

    The obvious downfall here is you will miss out on the wealth of points which the rest of their defenders can offer. They all boast excellent attacking potential and BAPS returns, so Stekelenburg might not be the wisest investment of a Southampton slot, more than anything. He doesn't make many saves either, as Southampton don't concede many chances.

    Jose Fonte (5.4)

    The BAPS magnet of the Southampton defence. The master of the 0-0s. Fonte has provided countless 9 pointers over the last couple of seasons, coupled with the odd attacking return. After returning 16 and 21 bonus in his last 2 seasons, once would expect him to score similarly again this season.

    He has however, only managed 3 BAPS which all came in one game. With a mediocre baseline BAPS score of 15.25 it seems the bonus points system this season might not favour him, so I’d advise looking elsewhere until he can show signs of raking in more bonus.

    Virgil van Dijk (5.5)

    The newest addition to the Southampton defence, who has already shown his attacking threat by providing a goal. Last season, in the league, he managed 4 goals and 6 assists in 35 league games, which is mighty impressive for a centre back. You can argue that the league was not to the same standard as the Premier league, however the numbers look promising.

    His baseline BAPS score of 14.75 is marginally lower than Fonte’s, but his attacking threat, for me, makes him a better option. He is the most expensive of the Southampton backline however, with cheaper options coming in 0.5m less than the Dutchman. It is worth noting that over his 4 games, he has registered a total of 12 touches in the box, which is bettered only by Richards (17).

    Ryan Bertrand (5.3)

    A very popular option last season, managing 140 points. He offers both attacking potential, with 2 goals and 3 assists last season, as well as the chance for BAPS, charting 13 bonus last season.

    However, his baseline BAPS this season lie at merge 11 which I expect to improve.
    There isn’t much to look into stats wise with Bertrand, since he has only played 2 games after returning to injury. His price looks a bargain right now, lower than the likes of van Dijk and Fonte who all began the season at 5.5. He looks a great differential and a real option over Southampton’s fixtures.

    Cedric Soares (5.0)

    The popular option in pre-season given his bargain price of 5.0m. Cedric has shown his fantastic attacking potential over the course of this season, already picking up an assist. He was dubbed a yellow card magnet in pre-season and after picking up one in what was an erratic display GW1, many decided to jump off the wagon.

    He has since calmed down and has looked better defensively. The issue lies with him not being totally nailed on. Koeman opted to drop him in favour of Yoshida against United, which could show he might get rotated against the tougher sides. However, Yoshida wasn’t great in that game and they conceded a total of 3 goals.

    Cedric also boasts an impressive baseline BAPS score of 17.95, which is reasonably better than any of the other Southampton defensive assets. If he does continue to start regularly, which he probably will in my opinion, he looks the best option. If he is rested against the stronger opposition, it doesn’t matter as he is cheap enough that you won’t mind benching him, which you may have already done given the fixture. It’s tougher benching a 5.5m priced player. He may also have a Demel like tendency to come off early whilst the clean sheet is banked, as he has done on 2 occasions this season.

    Conclusion

    Southampton’s defence looks well worth the investment for me. Given most will want Mane and Pelle, it seems there is just one space up for grabs. It’s a tough choice between the lot of them, with all having pros and cons.

    I have placed them in order for several attributes based on my own opinions:

    Value:

    Cedric
    Bertrand
    Stekelenburg
    van Dijk
    Fonte

    BAPS Potential:

    Cedric
    van Dijk
    Fonte
    Bertrand
    Stekelenburg

    Attacking Potential:

    van Dijk
    Cedric
    Bertrand
    Fonte
    Stekelenburg
    .

    The order of these is based on my own opinions, and they could be swapped around somewhat. I have no doubt that they will change throughout the season.

    They all seem like good picks in one way or another. Cedric looks the best bet to me, right now, if he continues to get regular starts. Bertrand looks like a safe pick with good attacking returns and decent BAPS potential. van Dijk is an unexplored resource of points, who could prove to be a great asset this season with his outstanding attacking potential. Fonte is somewhat of a veteran in their backline and offers BAPS potential, although this may have diminished with the new ways of calculating the points (favouring full backs). Stekelenburg seems a bit of a waste of a spot, but is a decent pick for someone needing a long term goalkeeper.

    1. Polaris - The Mortal Coil
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Whoa.

    2. Paulie Walnuts
      11 years, 16 days ago

      +1 for the effort alone... nice post!

      1. Paulie Walnuts
        11 years, 16 days ago

        very informative especially for someone like myself looking at bringing in a Southampton defender

    3. The 12th Man
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Nice write up.
      I've had Cedric since wk1 and keeping.

    4. Slam
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Fonte for a 15 points this week.
      Bookmark this.

      1. Slam
        11 years, 16 days ago

        pointer*

    5. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      cheers. good info

    6. Paul Psychic Octopus
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Their main problem with their defence is the defensive midfielder. Schneiderlin was a big loss, and Wanyama is unsettled.

      1. Mark-O
        11 years, 16 days ago

        And they missed Forster too!

      2. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Clasie's return should help to shore things up somewhat. They have hardly been leaky at the back.

    7. Forever In Our Shadow
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Nice work.

    8. andy85wsm
      • Has Moderation Rights
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Good stuff Rodallegabomb

      I'll take a proper look later but should make for interesting reading - a Southampton defender is next on my list.

    9. The Pep Revolution
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Great post, thanks for taking the time to write that.

      Great to see my choice of picking Cedric last weekend could be a good call. Did it mainly to get in KDB but good to see that part of the transfer may also be beneficial.

    10. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Lovely. Very helpful, thanks.

    11. Concrete
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Nice one, cheers for this. I'm looking at Soton defenders at the moment and this helps

    12. A.T
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Great post. I think I'm opting for Berty myself, mainly due to price and nailedonness. Van Diyk has been impressive but I think I'll need that extra bit of cash.

    13. Bored Bear
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Yoshida it is then

    14. copps
      11 years, 16 days ago

      where are chelsea at in goals conceded on the right? (ivanovic). must be winning by a country mile!

      1. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
        11 years, 16 days ago

        38. Only Sunderland are worse with 40.

    15. John t penguin
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Another excellent post by yourself my good man
      Was debating the burger man in for mignolet but may now reconsider this

    16. Gashead9
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Great article & timing, looking to switch WBA to SOT myself from GW11 & this helped greatly.
      Personally I will be going Bertrand, i'm sure his bps will increase considerably as he gains in match fitness. I just think he'll be a steal at 5.3 with his attacking potential & Southampton's underlying defensive stats so far that you kindly shared (which are impressive!)

    17. RubeRx
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Great insight here, I sincerely appreciate it.

      I'd like to point out one stat.

      17 chances conceded from the right flank is best in the league, however, did you check out crosses conceded from Cedric's right side?

      Southampton have conceded 89 crosses from the right flank (4th worst in the league).

      Only WAT, LEI and SUN have conceded more.

      Managers also have access to the same OPTA stats that members do.
      That may or may not be reason Koeman has dropped him several times this season already.

      While its great he is bombing forward and supporting the attack, he is also leaving huge holes in doing so. This has been exploited by several teams already.

      http://members.fantasyfootballscout.co.uk/my-stats-tables/view/10071/

      1. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Interesting find. Strange that he has conceded so few 'chances' but has conceded so many crosses.

        Perhaps one of the centre backs is coming to help in the defence? That way the attacker would be forced to cross the ball rather than try to cut inside or take a chances vs 2 players.

        1. RubeRx
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 16 days ago

          I'm assuming most the crosses are not leading to shots on goal.

          Tough to explain, but your analysis may be right.

          Perhaps it reveals Fonte's ability to win those 50/50 balls.

      2. Ryan
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • Has Moderation Rights
        11 years, 16 days ago

        'Koeman has dropped him several times this season already'

        He was dropped once 😕

    18. Backup Dancer
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Thoughts on a double up? Already got cedric (and pelle) with no room in my team for mane.

      1. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
        11 years, 16 days ago

        I think it's a great idea, but you may end up wanting Mane at some point.

        I doubled up on City earlier in the season which has made it tough getting KDB in midfield.

        1. Backup Dancer
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Yeah good point, a lot of surgery would be required if he did become 'essential'.

    19. Jay_
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Great post !

    20. Juventino4life
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Great article!!!

      I was debating between Bertrand and Cedric. Your article answered this question and more.

      Best article I have seen on this site!

    21. Nickofoz
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Cheers mate! Had Cedric since the start and have lately been considering a switch to Bertrand on my WC, in GW13 hopefully, but I'm not yet sure whether he is worth the extra 0.3 as you say

    22. Sharkytect
      11 years, 15 days ago

      Great post. Thanks, Rodallegabomb. I need to find the 0.1 for Evans > cedric

    23. Prøphet
      11 years, 15 days ago

      Beast information. Didnt help me much since i was debating between Berty and Van Dijk, but now you threw Cedric into the mix! 🙂

      Thank tho, really appreciate it. Return of Classie should help even more.

    24. HVT
      11 years, 15 days ago

      Thanks very much RB, a very well written and informative article.
      9.5/10

    25. tomandrews123
      11 years, 15 days ago

      Fantastic post - it's going to be Berty for me.

    26. Return Of Chamakh
      11 years, 15 days ago

      Great post thanks! Been thinking abut bringing in a Saints defender this week and this sums it all up nicely 😀

    27. Lanley Staurel
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 15 days ago

      Van Dijk takes free kicks..... Used to score them for Celtic and took one against Chelsea I recall.

      1. JK - Cønt ⭐
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 15 days ago

        But VVD is competing with Tadic and JWP for them at Saints

    28. ​
      11 years, 15 days ago

      Jesus christ this needs to be a members article not a comment.

    29. JK - Cønt ⭐
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 15 days ago

      great post

      Had Cedric from the off and am considering a switch to Berty who actually has had better attacking stats in the last 2 GWs

      Worth monitoring over the next 2 and then make a call

    30. J0E
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      11 years, 15 days ago

      I think for any future analysis like this that uses lots of Members stats could you submit as a community article. That way I can make it a Members only community article.

      1. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
        11 years, 15 days ago

        Ah okay, my bad. I meant to get this out last week so just wanted to get it out ASAP. Plus I didn't actually anticipate how lengthly it would be; I thought it wouldn't be of the standard for an article.

  8. The 12th Man
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Has anyone else hit the 105 mark in TV?

      1. BlzE_94
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Dayuum, and i thought my104.4 was good

      2. The 12th Man
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Nice, but look at all those hits.

    1. Ginkapo FPL
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Whats your selling value?

      1. The 12th Man
        11 years, 16 days ago

        102.7 m last time I looked.

        1. Ginkapo FPL
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Ah good to hear. My buying and selling values are 101.7 so am not far behind really. 😀

          Good job though, thats impressive.

    2. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      wow you only required only one hit to get there. good job

      1. The 12th Man
        11 years, 16 days ago

        WC in wk 2 was the secret.

    3. Paulie Walnuts
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Not yet but i am on 104.4 or something

      1. The 12th Man
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Nice

    4. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 16 days ago

      104.9/102.3 here

      1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Hard not to conclude I was singled out for no reply. 🙁

        1. Black Knights
          11 years, 15 days ago

          You're the champ, champ!

    5. Jøssy ⭐
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Nope! A lowly 104.5 😉

      1. The 12th Man
        11 years, 16 days ago

        That's good

        1. Jøssy ⭐
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Yeah, I know. 🙂

          Just feigning modesty 😉

          1. copps
            11 years, 16 days ago

            I wasn't buying it

            1. Jøssy ⭐
              11 years, 16 days ago

              Not much getting past you! 😆

              1. copps
                11 years, 16 days ago

                😀

  9. Gerci
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Schmeichel Butland
    Bellerin Kolarov Cedric Prödl Gomez
    Payet Redmond Mahrez De Bruyne Pedro
    Agüero Gomis Vardy

    1 FT. 0.9 ITB

    Sanchez + Ighalo for Pedro + Gomis for a hit?

    1. Lovren an elevator
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'd say worth the hit. You're team would look very nice then. Still don't like the gk rotation personally. But other than that, great team

  10. boombaba
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Huth, Morgan or Cook as a 4.4m defender ?

    Any 4.3m defenders nailed ?

    1. FPL Blow-In
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      O'shea is 4.3 I think

    2. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Morgan is the captain so he is the most nailed on. No nailed 4.3 defender that I can find..

    3. Harper_
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Hangeland potentially

      1. Mark-O
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Not nailed on.

  11. I Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Sanchez being injured would be too good to be true. Terrified of him not owning him.

    1. FPL Blow-In
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Leave now. 😉

    2. Slam
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Why wouldn't he own himself?

      1. Meinhoff
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Lol

      2. Cheeseoid
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Maybe he is a slave?

      3. I Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        haha my bad

  12. The Pep Revolution
    11 years, 16 days ago

    The rest of the season will be interesting regarding the Premier League. City are title favourites and if Silva, Sterling, KDB and Aguero all click it could be hard to see past them. However both Arsenal and United will be well up there and could challenge. It will be interesting to see what effect Klopp will have on Liverpool, top 4, maybe even title contenders? Can Chelsea turn their season around? Surely not challenge for the title now but surely top 4? And if not what will the fallout be? Can other teams like Southampton or Everton take advantage of the other teams not performing and push for top 4?

    Should be an interesting and entertaining season. Seems better than last year where Chelsea just dominated.

    1. Parm
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Completely against the grain but City, Arsenal/United, Spurs. Top 4.

      1. The Pep Revolution
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Spurs top 4, that would be interesting. They could well achieve that though. Looked impressive against City in the 2nd half.

        1. Mark-O
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Spurs for a 4th is possible if Chelsea sank too deep and could only rise as high as up to 5th/6th only. There is an article from the PL website that says no other teams in that measly number of points have managed to reach beyond 5th at the end of the PL season.

          1. The Pep Revolution
            11 years, 16 days ago

            I wouldn't rule it out anyway. What damage would that do to Chelsea is the question.

            1. Somalion
              11 years, 16 days ago

              Given the PL team performances in the CL, I think it won't do too much. Any player with real aspirations of going far in the competition will probably look at a number of other clubs before they consider a PL team, at least that's the way it is going in my view.

      2. Burning Plastic
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Spurs? I would give this Liverpool team a better chance (I may be a bit biased).

        1. Tomeister
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Why? They usually finishvbelow Spurs, and are about to have a transitional season...

    2. Tomeister
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Are you deliberately missing spurs out there? Better than Liverpool, Everton and Southampton...

  13. Piggs Boson
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Have fixtures played a part in Leicester's impressive scoring record?

    When do you think their form will drop? (Or are they getting 5th?)

    .
    I ask because Leicester played Bournemouth, Villa, Stoke, Arsenal, Norwich in their last 5, and Swansea now have the exact opponents in the next 5. Their turn now?

    1. Slam
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Possibly.
      I'm eyeing up a switch of Mahrez -> Ayew soon.

    2. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Exactly why I'm keeping faith in Gomis through his drops.

    3. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Since i bought Ayew got me 3 blanks in a row before i sold him for KDB last gw.

      Not sure i can trust swansea attackers again.

      1. Mark-O
        11 years, 16 days ago

        I would trust Ayew over Gomis.

    4. Parm
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      There are too many options. Please help.

    5. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Given the fact that Leicester can score against Arsenal, we know that Leicester will not sit back regardless how difficult the match is.

      One note to know is that Ranieri promised to tighten their defence, which he really kept to his promise, but at the expense of Mahrez which was totally unexpected. 🙁

      1. Parm
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Balance.

    6. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Don't fancy their attackers to be honest. There's a lot of players I like, too many to fit in. I'd rather just accept that I'll be foregoing them and that's that.

      I'll be keeping Williams over those fixtures and praying that he actually scores some points.

      1. Mark-O
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Williams is good for the BAPS which I really fancy!

        1. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Indeed he is, but he is useless if they don't keep clean sheets!

  14. Cheeseoid
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    So what would you guys do to this team:

    Myhill
    Janmaat - Dawson - Souare
    Payet - Sanchez - KDB - Mahrez - Mata
    Aguero - Vardy
    Subs - Hennessey - Ighalo - Cedric - Davies

    1FT and 0 ITB.

    I think I know what I will do but just curious what others think

    Thanks

    1. Slam
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Delete it.
      I need to move up in the ranks somehow...

      1. Cheeseoid
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Sorry. Maybe next season!

    2. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Save

    3. Slam
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Would bench Mahrez, play Ighalo. Run the defensive stats (comparison tool) for Southampton and Arsenal. Looks good otherwise.
      What are you thinking of doing?

      1. Cheeseoid
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Either save or Mata to Mane. I am erring towards the transfer at the moment

      2. Jazz!
        11 years, 16 days ago

        So you'd play Vardy over Mahrez? Reasoning?

        1. Slam
          11 years, 16 days ago

          I would.
          Both don't have much of a chance at scoring against SOT tbh. Vardy at least is 100% to start...

          1. Jazz!
            11 years, 16 days ago

            Leicester can score against anyone this season. They are an all out attack team, and Mahrez will start next game. Provided if you know that Mahrez and Vardy will both start, who would you play?

            1. Slam
              11 years, 16 days ago

              Flip of a coin really.
              Sorry if that's not helpful 😐

              1. Jazz!
                11 years, 16 days ago

                It's fine. I know it's an extremely hard decision.

            2. Cheeseoid
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              11 years, 16 days ago

              It would spread the risk I guess. I am a fan of spreading risk

      3. Ziegler1988
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Arsenal 4 clean sheets v Southampton 3 clean sheets. Southampton have also conceded more goals at home than Arsenal have away. Finally for me, Mahrez is penalty taker and Ighalo isn't

        1. Slam
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Can't agree with this by any means.
          Run Arsenal in away matches and Southampton in Home matches (comparison tool). Look at the defending stats… clear winner if you're looking at which team is stronger defensively...

          1. Ziegler1988
            11 years, 16 days ago

            Well one of those matches is 45 minutes down a man and another is in an all out attack match against Leicester. I may be biased but I think Arsenal defence is better than Southampton defence. And Leicester attack is much better than Watford attack

            1. Ziegler1988
              11 years, 16 days ago

              Also Newcastle away, up a man for 75 minutes so not great for analyzing either

            2. Slam
              11 years, 16 days ago

              Good point.
              I guess there is no edge then 😐

    4. Ziegler1988
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Mata to Mane or Save FT

      1. HurriKane
        11 years, 16 days ago

        would be preferable to go with mane or pelle for their fixtures. both in great form

        but then again selling mata might not be the best of options

        1. Cheeseoid
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 16 days ago

          I should have gone Mane last week. It was a daft decision in hindsight.

    5. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Good to go!

    6. Cheeseoid
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Thanks. You clearly agree with the 2 options I am pondering. They will probably all be injued by next week anyway.

  15. omryry
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    A) Kolarov + Gabriel
    B) Bertrand + Bellerin
    ?

    1. Meinhoff
      11 years, 16 days ago

      B

    2. BlzE_94
      11 years, 16 days ago

      A

    3. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      B

      neither one in A is nailed

    4. A.T
      11 years, 16 days ago

      B

  16. FISSH
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Sanchez is out wwwhhhaatt?

    1. Slam
      11 years, 16 days ago

      A trusted source is telling me he's dead.

      1. Epic Fail
        11 years, 16 days ago

        he*

      2. The 12th Man
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Was it the same source that reported Francis Jeffers passing?

    2. BlzE_94
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Quick get rid off him! He's fine

    3. Ziegler1988
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Sell for a hit to Hazard

    4. Cheeseoid
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I heard he had a yachting accident

  17. Jøssy ⭐
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Question... There's an awful lot of love on here for Janmaat, due the his treating attacking stats, albeit he plays for the defensively frail Newcastle.

    If we can see beyond Newcastle's potential for clean sheets, why is there not a similar attraction to Moreno who also has some great attacking stats and is cheaper?

    1. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      one argument is newcastle looked solid for most part of chelsea game and one half of city game.

      their defense have improved they are bound for cs against easier teams

    2. Fanta sea
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'd say you're better off with Ben Davies in a side that will prob keep more clean sheets than Liverpool and Newcastle.

      And he's cheaper. It's a steal right now.

      1. HurriKane
        11 years, 16 days ago

        is he nailed on though.with danny rose lurking around

        1. Jøssy ⭐
          11 years, 16 days ago

          This is my fear with Ben Davies

  18. Fanta sea
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Have a feeling Sanchez will not be playing against Watford. In comes Ighalo

    1. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      That is if Wenger wants to use him very badly to defeat Bayern!

    2. Slam
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Don't bench Ighalo…

      1. Fanta sea
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Sanchez, Mahrez, Ayew, KDB, Payet

        Aguero, Martial Ighalo

        Ighalo seems the only one to bench right now.

        1. Slam
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Alright, if you believe that Mahrez will deliver.
          Fair enough

        2. Mark-O
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Even if Sanchez does not play, surely Walcott has to score.

          Even if Sanchez and Walcott does not play, surely Giroud has to score.

          Even if Sanchez and Walcott does not play, and Giroud fails to score, surely Ozil has to score.

          Even if Sanchez and Walcott does not play, and Giroud and Ozil fail to score, then 0-0 is coming. 🙁

          1. Fanta sea
            11 years, 16 days ago

            Good thing I have Monreal. Clean sheet 🙂

    3. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      There's a possibility with crucial Bayern game in midweek

      Alexis would want to play if fit but Wenger wouldnt want to take the risk imo

    4. I Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Could see Wenger resting Sanchez and Walcott for Bayern, especially if Sanchez is coming off a slight groin problem.

      1. HurriKane
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Yeap. Giroud and Ox could start

      2. Fanta sea
        11 years, 16 days ago

        If I were Wenger, I'd rest him for both Watford and Bayern. Concede the champions league and focus on the league.

        1. Slam
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Good thing you're not him then 🙂

          1. Fanta sea
            11 years, 16 days ago

            If I were, I'd have the league by now 😉

        2. Forever In Our Shadow
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 16 days ago

          You sound like Henry on Super Sunday

          1. Fanta sea
            11 years, 16 days ago

            Doesn't it make sense though? Why bother with the champions league when you can focus on the league alone?

            Arsenal suffer many injuries during the year and if a reduced playing time helps with that, then I'd take it. Arsenal don't need to worry about the money since they're already sucking their fans dry

            1. Slam
              11 years, 16 days ago

              😆
              You have a unique logic

  19. callanderlg
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Thoughts appreciated !

    A) hazard > Sanchez
    B) martial > Pelé
    C) Sterling > ayew/cabaye/ozil
    D) save ft

    Cheers lads !

    1. BlzE_94
      11 years, 16 days ago

      A, would have said C but mane/payet weren't options.

    2. Fanta sea
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'd lose Sterling first and then move onto getting Sanchez from hazard. You may have to take one hit this week with A and C being your priorities.

    3. Meinhoff
      11 years, 16 days ago

      B

    4. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      A looks good. but not this week since hazard has villa

      I did B

    5. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      E. Wait if you wanna do A. 🙂

      For now is a D but C (Ozil or Ayew) looks more important than A.

    6. In Like Flynn.
      • Has Moderation Rights
      11 years, 16 days ago

      A)
      Martial has a couple of tricky games then a great run, can't help thinking you'll just want him almost straight back in,
      Sterling out for a hit or next transfer.

      1. callanderlg
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Nice one. Thanks. If you were to choose from Pelle or mane , who would you go ?

  20. Piggs Boson
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Does anyone prefer David Silva to KDB?

    He's just returned from injury and immediately provided 2 assists. That makes 6 assists in 5 EPL appearances.

    1. Fanta sea
      11 years, 16 days ago

      problem is KDB is scoring and that's a biggie in terms of Baps

      1. Piggs Boson
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Will he keep scoring so many?

        Silva got 12 goals last season, surely he'll grab a few too?

    2. Jazz!
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I do simply because I've had him since the start

    3. Forever In Our Shadow
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Maybe long term. I only signed KDB as his replacement but the next few games will tell me whether it is prudent to switch back

    4. In Like Flynn.
      • Has Moderation Rights
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'm concerned he'll do well for 3 or 4 then get injured again. I'll stick with KDB unless Silva really takes off points wise and is stopping KDB getting them.

    5. SYLVIAN
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I have Silva so I'm hoping he takes the reigns again, and pushes KdB out wide! (and grabs a few goals)

      1. Piggs Boson
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Goals will be key. He certainly showed he was capable of scoring last season...

    6. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      No chance, but maybe the double up.

    7. Ziegler1988
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Had Silva GW1 and held for the first injury. Got frustrated with the warm up injury and will stick with KDB now

    8. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Silva was my proffered choice in city mids before KDB signed

      KDB looks the real deal. think he has more goals in him then silva

    9. A.T
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Not at the moment. KdB looks to have more goals in him so I'll stick for now. And then there's his injury recorded to consider too. I'm really looking forward to watching them play though.

    10. Swanremainsthesame
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Silva is looking good to be same as last season, but KDB is promising top performance too.
      I'm so unsure so I got both!

    11. FISSH
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Silva's glass ankles sway me to KDB

  21. Back on the horse
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Is there a scoutcast this week?

    1. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      No

      1. Back on the horse
        11 years, 16 days ago

        not even Parm's "Legends" podcast? 😉

        1. Epic Fail
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Cancelled because I'm busy. 🙁

          1. Parm
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            11 years, 16 days ago

            He said legends.

            1. Epic Fail
              11 years, 16 days ago

              Ahhh plural. True. I'm only one person 😎

    2. In Like Flynn.
      • Has Moderation Rights
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Next week.

  22. vardys party
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Hart (Mccarthy)
    Martin Kolarov Cresswell Kolorov Darmian
    Hazard Bolasie Moses Mane Mahrez
    Bojan Sturridge Remy

    Was banking on Chelsea coming good and the big guns elswhere faltering. Didn't work.

    £4m in the bank. What are my best options?

    a) Remy to Pelle and Mahrez to Walcott (-4)
    b) Sturridge to Aguero
    c) Hazard to Silva and Remy to Pelle
    d) other

    1. Forever In Our Shadow
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      B all day long. A team without Aguero is not a team. 😉

      1. vardys party
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Thanks. Was hoping to have a good Sturridge differential, but Aguero seems the way to go

    2. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      E. Remy to Aguero

      1. Mark-O
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Oops my bad on the math. Then it's a B.

      2. vardys party
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Would love to but can't afford it.

  23. Iceball
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Best max 5.0 defender?

    1. Ziegler1988
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Dawson or Gabriel

    2. vardys party
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Dawson, Cedric

    3. Piggs Boson
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Williams
      Dawson
      Walker

      Glen Johnson got 8.5 PpG over the last 2 😉

    4. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Cedric, Dawson, Williams.

    5. Swanremainsthesame
      11 years, 16 days ago

      In terms of nailed on, recent team form for CSs, it looks like
      Alderweireld, Cedric, Dawson, Cathcart(home games only).
      Blue moon goal scorers there is a handful of recent hitters, but not on CS teams, less Palace turn their last two games into a run, somehow doubt that.

    6. Rödallegabomb ᴿᴮ
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Cedric

  24. Parm
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Martial, Lukaku, Pellé.

    Gomis, Rondón, Sakho, Vardy, Diouf, Berahino.

    Ighalo.

    How do we sort this out then? Aguero plus two of those.

    1. Forever In Our Shadow
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Fight fight fight.

      1. Forever In Our Shadow
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Personally I would want Lukaku Pelle & Kun

    2. Piggs Boson
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'd remove Rondon, Sakho, Diouf and Berahino personally.

      1. Parm
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Some people have these players(I sadly have Sakho)

    3. Back on the horse
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'm current;y on Aguero, Vardy, Pelle.

      I have eyes on Lukaku, Sakho, Gomis in that order

      1. Parm
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        hmmmm

    4. A.T
      11 years, 16 days ago

      One from the top and one from the middle and forget Ighalo 😀

      Vardy has to be the middle one and you can give a good argument for any of the top.

      I'd go Lukaku, Martial, Pelle

      1. Parm
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        No Kun 😯

        1. A.T
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Soz. I meant in order of goodness from the top 3

      2. A.T
        11 years, 16 days ago

        So it'd be Aguero Vardy Lukaku.

        1. Parm
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Fair enough.

      3. Jøssy ⭐
        11 years, 16 days ago

        ...and three small ones please Carol.

    5. Swanremainsthesame
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Top goal scoring teams are MCI,LEI,WHU & Song due back soon
      suggests Vardy+Sakho
      Tho Sou are coming back to form so Pelle.

      Depends on midfield, as Ive gone double MCI & LEI, + Payet & Pelle
      Preferred that to Mane+Sakho
      I wouldn't double anyone except mci & lei right now.

  25. gtf
    11 years, 16 days ago

    How can I improve this lot

    Myhill McCarthy
    Ivanovic Kolarov VVD Williams Oxford
    Sanchez Mane Payet Mahrez Westwood
    Aguero Martial Murray

    0.2 itb
    1 FT

    1. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Save

    2. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Do you still trust Ivanovic?

    3. Shiner
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Lose ivana. Too much money tied up in him with little to no returns.

      1. Epic Fail
        11 years, 16 days ago

        You can't transfer him out vs Villa, at home.

    4. Forever In Our Shadow
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Ivan not good IMO. Otherwise ok

    5. vardys party
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Ivanovic to Nyom and Murray to Pelle

    6. Swanremainsthesame
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Ivan has slumped to some of the worst stats in the BPL, awful 1st touch, getting crucified by any winger with pace & an U8s stepover, just f awful.
      & on a team that's forgotten what a CS is.

      Put Coates+2mn there & then think what you would do is best I think.
      Since you have 3 good def there already it could be wait to see no IB injuries and then swap out for a cheapie to upgrade Murray or Westwood week after.

  26. d1sable
    • Has Moderation Rights
    11 years, 16 days ago

    So do we think Sanchez and Ayew are 'international injuries' and will be fine for BPL?

    1. Shiner
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Defo

    2. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Ayew is still in UK and resting so he will be fine according to the reports.

      Sanchez will be fine but Bayern is Arsenal's next match so it depends on whether Wenger plays him (or shorten his time if he starts) against Watford.

    3. Forever In Our Shadow
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Not sure on ayew but I think if Sanchez has an injury going into them he will have it coming out. Which means he might be benched for Watford possibly? I hope not though !

    4. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Probably.

    5. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I'm pretty sure Sanchez is. He went down once the match was in the bag, waved straight to the bench. Then Wenger did histrionics about how Sanchez "would insist on playing for Chile". Then he shows up mildly injured. He's fine.

    6. Back on the horse
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Hopefully Sanchez is, although there clearly was a groin issue. I have already transferred him in to replace hazard, so I will look a bit stupid if he is out... and that's what's most important in FFS; how good your transfers look, not final ranking.

    7. A.T
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I do hope so Luke cause I've already done Hazard to Sanchez and if he really is injured I think I might cry 😥
      I'm not having any luck. Either that or I'm just playing badly. In truth, it's the latter.

    8. Optimus.
      11 years, 16 days ago

      "They are both(Sanchez,Vidal) in the same condition. I cannot confirm at this stage if either will be fit to face Brazil," the 55-year-old said in a news conference.
      "Of course, they are very valuable to us but I am confident that if they are not available we have the squad to be competitive against Brazil or Peru."

      Read more at http://www.fourfourtwo.com/news/alexis-and-vidal-doubts-face-brazil#87jLLtQKegy9BKEc.99

  27. gtf
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Ben Davies.

    Discuss.

    1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Not as high as Ben Nevis, but a lovely tarn on top. Worth a ramble.

    2. Mark-O
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Good steal given his price, but rotation is his enemy. Rose was stellar against Monaco.

    3. copps
      11 years, 16 days ago

      the rotation is inevitable

    4. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      learned my lessons and will never touch a def who's not nailed on

      been burnt by the likes of sagna gomez muniesa this season

      could recall being burnt by cameron and bendavies of last season too

  28. Frank Black
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Anyone believes the news about Guardiola?

    1. Optimus.
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Money talks so probably

      1. Frank Black
        11 years, 16 days ago

        I never trust spanish sources usually but i can't help but think there's something true about this.

    2. A.T
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Hes appearing in Corrie?

    3. Epic Fail
      11 years, 16 days ago

      What news?

      1. Frank Black
        11 years, 16 days ago

        He has agreed a deal with City for next season. Apparently he has rejected Bayern's offer of a new contract.

        1. copps
          11 years, 16 days ago

          Pellegrini is going to be inspired for the rest of this season

      2. Optimus.
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Pep > City in the Summer

      3. A.T
        11 years, 16 days ago

        He's taking over The Rovers 😯

    4. Parm
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I don't want to believe it.

    5. Kurtinho
      11 years, 16 days ago

      I can see it happening. He'll bring Thiago with him as Yaya replacement. Imagine Klopp, LvG, Guardiola, Mourinho, Wenger in the same league. Wow.

      1. Frank Black
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Even less chances of success for Wenger.

      2. Somalion
        11 years, 16 days ago

        And they still won't dominate in Europe 😛

        1. Frank Black
          11 years, 16 days ago

          In the last eight years three different spanish/La Liga teams have reached the CL final in four different seasons(Barca, Real and Atletico) with Barca winning three times(2008/2009, 2010/2011 and 2014/2015), Real winning once(2013/2014) and Atletico not winning anything since they lost to Real. In the same period of time two english/Premier League teams have reached the CL final three times in three different seasons with United winning once(2007/2008) and Chelsea winning once(2011/2012).

          Essentially, the ranking of the the last eight years of CL would be this:

          1 - La Liga/Spanish teams
          2- Premier League/English teams
          3- Bundesliga/German teams
          4 - Serie A/Italian teams

          With a very small gap between Spanish teams and English teams.

  29. gtf
    11 years, 16 days ago

    I kept faith in Sanchez and Aguero and it paid off. So I'm sticking with Ivanovic, surely Chelsea will come good.

    1. copps
      11 years, 16 days ago

      he's looked well off the pace though, not even close

      1. Epic Fail
        11 years, 16 days ago

        To be fair, Aguero hasn't looked brilliant before this GW.

    2. Forever In Our Shadow
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 16 days ago

      With respect Ivan is not Kun or Sanchez regardless of his historical efforts. If it was just his form that was a concern then you might be right. This is an entire championship winning Chelsea squad that had fallen of the cliff. I'd sell him and try and improve else where.

      1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
        11 years, 16 days ago

        This is right--Arsenal and City always looked effective while Sanchez and Aguero were blanking.

    3. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Could be dropped for baba next gw due to his poor performances

    4. Swanremainsthesame
      11 years, 16 days ago

      San & Kun had the stats just not the final result, waiting on luck to change was all.
      Ivan has been consistently utterly totally woeful.
      You'd do better with Coates or Yoshida.

  30. Parm
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 16 days ago

    Can anyone name the only Premier League side with more goals from outside the box than within it?

    1. HurriKane
      11 years, 16 days ago

      chelsea ?

      1. HurriKane
        11 years, 16 days ago

        remember pedro matic and couple of willian freekicks from outside the box

      2. Parm
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 16 days ago

        Aye.

    2. Ziegler1988
      11 years, 16 days ago

      Liverpool?