Scout Picks
9 November 2018 4194 comments
DavidMunday815 DavidMunday815
Share:

Double investment in Liverpool’s midfield is advised in Gameweek 12’s edition of the Scout Picks.

We have painstakingly gone over the squad of players chosen by our panel of Paul, Joe, Az and Peter earlier this week to find a final XI.

After making some tough choices we have a side that comes in at £81.70m, with some room to spare within our budget of £83m.

Goalkeeper

Mat Ryan (£4.5m) gets the goalkeeper jersey this week after being tipped by three of our pundits. Peter was the only one not to name-check the Brighton shot-stopper. Ryan was only chosen as the best option by Az, with Lukasz Fabianski actually receiving the highest number of top picks, but we’ve decided to cover the West Ham defence elsewhere.

Defenders

Andrew Robertson was selected as the best defender by three of our panel this week, with Az opting for Joe Gomez instead of the Scot. However, with reports in the media suggesting that Robertson has been training on his own and not with the main group we’ve decided to go for a Liverpool defender more assured of a start in Virgil van Dijk (£5.9m). The Reds have conceded just one goal at Anfield all season and this week they face a Fulham attack that has found the net just twice in their last four away matches.

Ben Chilwell (£5.1m) gets the nod ahead of Leicester’s big home match against Burnley. It is the Foxes’ first at the King Power Stadium since the tragic passing of chairman Vichai Srivaddhanaprabha last month. Only Manchester City and Liverpool have allowed fewer chances than Leicester in home matches so far this season while Burnley rank bottom of the league for shots on target in the last four Gameweeks. Furthermore, Chilwell has some exciting offensive potential with two assists in his last three matches.

Fabian Balbuena (£4.4m) is chosen as the West Ham cover this week as Manuel Pellegrini’s men travel to face goal shy Huddersfield Town. The Terriers have scored just one home goal all season and still have none from open play in front of their supporters. Meanwhile, Balbuena himself ranks third best among defenders for shots in the box so far this season so carries some goal threat.

Kiko Femenia (£4.2m) goes into our Scout Picks XI primarily to save us the money for particularly lavish spending in the attacking areas. However, Watford defence was still well-represented amongst our pundits with three of them selecting Ben Foster and two choosing Jose Holebas for their squads. The Hornets travel to a Southampton side with just one goal in their last six Premier League matches.

Midfielders

Mohamed Salah (£13.0m) was unanimously chosen as the best midfield option by our panel this week. It’s easy to see why as Liverpool host Fulham on Sunday, the side with the division’s worst defence so far this season. The Egyptian is streaks ahead on our current captain poll for Gameweek 12, having averaged 8.4 points per game at Anfield in 2018/19.

Alongside Salah is his colleague Sadio Mané (£9.8m) as our Scout Squad panel encouraged double Liverpool offensive coverage. Such is their faith in the Fulham defence which has conceded more goals than any other side season (29), having allowed more shots on target than every Premier League club apart from Burnley in the first 11 matches. Meanwhile, Mané may have struggled of late but is still averaging eight points per game at Anfield.

Eden Hazard (£11.3m) should be back in the starting line-up for Chelsea this weekend after getting a 62-minute run-around in the Europa League on Thursday night. Even though he has featured as a substitute twice at Stamford Bridge this season, Hazard has attacking returns in all but one of his displays in front of his own set of fans in 2018/19. For that reason, we are backing him to deliver once again, especially considering that Everton are averaging 1.8 goals conceded per away match so far.

David Brooks (£5.1m) was not actually mentioned by our Scout Squad panel but he has been selected by his namesake as an enabler. With so many premium assets squeezed into the squad, we needed a cheap midfield option with decent form and a fixture to boot. Brooks fits that bill quite nicely with three goals in his last five appearances and a trip to Newcastle in Gameweek 12, who have allowed the third worst number of big chances in home matches so far this season. Also, with Josh King still a doubt for Bournemouth, there’s every chance the Welshman could feature up front again.

Forwards

Such is the quality of Sergio Aguero (£11.4m) that he has made it into the Scout Picks XI despite facing a fixture that might look tougher on paper than it may prove in reality. For starters, the Manchester City forward is yet to blank at home this season and has seven goals in his last eight Premier League meetings with Manchester United. Aguero should get the full 90 minutes in this match after completing the 6-1 win over Southampton, and he is going up against a United defence with just one clean sheet this season. That’s why he got the top pick from Az and Peter while being tipped as the second-best choice by Joe.

Marko Arnautovic (£7.1m) rounds off our starting XI by earning himself a second consecutive appearance. He rewarded our faith last week with a 12-point haul in the win over Burnley and we feel he will be on the scoresheet when West Ham travel to Huddersfield on Saturday afternoon. Alvaro Morata is the only player to have recorded more shots on target than the Austrian in the last four Gameweeks. Furthermore, on his last visit to the John Smith’s Stadium, Arnautovic came away with a goal and two assists.

Substitutes

Kieran Trippier (£6.3m) nearly made an appearance in the Scout Picks selection after receiving backing from all four of our pundits. The Tottenham right-back has shown great consistency this season, recording one of either defensive or attacking returns in seven of his 10 Premier League appearances since Gameweek 2. This week Spurs travel to face a Crystal Palace side with just two goals in five home matches so far. However, he was a little too expensive to fit in and we worry a little about the Spurs defence after a shaky finish at Molineux in Gameweek 11.

Johann Berg Gudmundsson (£6.0m) has three goal involvements in as many away matches for Burnley and seems the most likely to do well for them in Gameweek 12. His set-piece responsibilities underpin his appeal and his style of play means he does well for bonus too, collecting five in his last five matches.

Joe’s man Danny Ings (£5.5m) rounds off our list of substitutes given his impressive individual figures over recent weeks. The Southampton man has actually had more shots in the box and efforts on target than Salah and is the only Saint to have actually scored in the last six Gameweeks. A home match against a Watford side with just one away clean sheet thus far seems the perfect opportunity for Ings to continue his run.

Community Champion

Representing the community against the Scout Picks in Gameweek 12 is Sam Goddard aka Boleyn Boy. He has opted for a 3-4-3 formation of Schmeichel; Bellerin, Rudiger, Mendy; J. Murphy (Cardiff), Salah, Ozil, Anderson; Ings, Kane, Firmino.

The community member who beats our picks by the biggest margin over the campaign will win a £100 Amazon Voucher and a place in our Contributors and Moderators League for the following season.

The Scouts have won seven and lost four so far, with Mince n Tatties losing out 50-37 in Gameweek 11.

fclackless‘s winning margin of 33 points (77-44) in Gameweek 10 is the current target to beat.

Become a Member and access our data

Memberships for the 2018/19 campaign are now available for the price of just £15.

Join now to get the following:

  • Plot your transfer strategies using the fully interactive Season Ticker.
  • Get projections for every Premier League player provided by the Rate My Team statistical model.
  • Use Rate My Team throughout the season to guide your selections and transfers.
  • Get access to over 130+ exclusive members articles over the season.
  • Analyse our OPTA-powered statistic tables specifically tailored for Fantasy Football Managers.
  • Use our exclusive tool to build custom stats tables from over 100 OPTA player and team stats.
  • View heatmaps and expected goals data for every player.
  • Use our powerful comparison tool to analyse players head-to-head.

CLICK HERE TO BECOME A FANTASY FOOTBALL SCOUT MEMBER

  1. Cuchu
    • 8 Years
    7 years, 3 months ago

    Which option to choose?
    a) Maddison-->Pereyra/Anderson/Lamela (-4)
    b) Play Schurrle
    c) AWB-->van Dijk (-4) and play with 4-3-3

    1. Bagheri Arce
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 10 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      A or C but depends on your team which and also whether the hit will pay off longer term

    2. Stinglikeabee
      • 10 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      Go for Lamela.

    3. Cuchu
      • 8 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      Many thanks!

  2. La vida FPL
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 12 Years
    7 years, 3 months ago

    Start fabinski or foster?

    1. Rage Against The Raheem
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 7 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      Fabs

    2. BIGREDDOG
      • 8 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      fab

  3. Stimps
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 12 Years
    7 years, 3 months ago

    Evening all, good to go? Bench OK? Play Diangana or Richarlison?

    Ryan
    Alonso Robertson Mendy
    Hazard Salah (c) Fraser Diangana
    Kun Wilson Ings

    Hamer Richarlison Bennett AWB

    1. Bielsa's Bucket
      • 14 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      I'd put AWB before Bennett just for potential attacking returns

  4. jonnymo
    • 14 Years
    7 years, 3 months ago

    free hitting this week - thoughts?

    Leno(Lossl)
    Alonso VVD Fernandez(Femenia Peltier)
    Salah Mane Hazard Ozil Murphy
    Arnautovic Morata(Success)

    1. Hotdogs for Tea
      • 10 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      Madness - keep your free hit for a double or blank game week

    2. IAWC ( It's a Wonderfu…
      • 8 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      Free hitting in sgw is madness.Nearly did in gw8 ,luckily didn't and could have got really hurt.It needs a lot of luck to be successful.U can easily profit 30 more points but at the same time u can lose 30 points in a sgw.Its a lottery

      1. jonnymo
        • 14 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        we shall see. there's more than one way to use the chips. this week i'd already used my f/t, didn't have Salah or Mane, then Maddison got injured, and then Richarlison and Robertson are both doubts to play, as well as my bench being rubbish for the week. I try not to second guess when i'll use the chips, it just seems right to play free hit this week. I hope it works out for me

        1. IAWC ( It's a Wonderfu…
          • 8 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Then it's OK .Free hit is a chip where the efficiency of its use is found by subtracting free hit team - original team points.This team looks good on paper tho .Play kiko over Fernandez

  5. manu4life99
    • 16 Years
    7 years, 3 months ago

    Someone talk me out of Maddison to Anderson (-4)?

    I own Arny too but so do most ML rivals and so exposure is limited to Anderson only

    Leading by 40pts

    Fab
    Mendy Laporte Duffy
    Haz Salah(C) Richarlison Maddison
    Arny Kun Wilson

    Subs: Yedlin,Doherty,Bacuna

    1. Flynny
      • 10 Years
      7 years, 3 months ago

      Do it

    2. MTPockets
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Fancy playing both next week vs mci?

        1. Fernando Torres
          • 14 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          They will score vs city.

          1. MTPockets
              7 years, 3 months ago

              I hope so, but not confident.

          2. manu4life99
            • 16 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Would bench vs city and play this 11 (plus FT if needed):

            Fab
            Mendy Yedlin Duffy Doherty
            Haz Salah Rich
            Kun Arny Wilson

            Subs: Anderson,Laporte,Bacuna

        2. My Name Is Pepu
          • 9 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Do it

      • Flynny
        • 10 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Any advice here please 0ft...0.3itb

        Pat (hamer)
        Robbo mendy Alonso (awb peltier)
        Salah hazard richarlison deulofeu (stephens)
        Kun arnie wilson

        A.....stick

        B...Stephens to diagana - 4 to stiffen up bench if richarlison doesn't play

        Thanks

        1. My Name Is Pepu
          • 9 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Stick

      • Pique and De Bruyne
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 9 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Which looks best going forward after this game week?

        A) Salah / Richarlison / Hazard / Fraser / Gudmundsson

        B) Salah / Richarlison / Sterling / Fraser / Pereyra

        C) Hazard / Sterling / Mané / Fraser / Diangana

        1. Rage Against The Raheem
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 7 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          C

        2. FPL_DON
          • 11 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          c imo

          1. Pique and De Bruyne
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Cheers guys.

      • pundit of punts
        • 13 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Bottomed.

        Patricio
        Alonso - Trippier - TAA - AWB
        Salah - Sterling - Richarlison
        Aguero - Vardy - Arnautovic

        Hamer - Bennett - Ward - Schneiderlin

        1 FT and 0.2m in the bank.

        Save FT?

        1. Rage Against The Raheem
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 7 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Yeah looks good for this week, save then you will have 2FT over IB.

          1. pundit of punts
            • 13 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Cheers

      • StayoutheSpiceZone
        • 8 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Hart
        Yed VVD Doherty
        Ozil mane salah (c) haz rich
        Arnie vardy

        Button, jim, awb, Bennett

        Gtg or any changes?
        Thanks -

        1. Rage Against The Raheem
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 7 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Looks ok to me, GTG

          1. StayoutheSpiceZone
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Cheers mate

        2. Monkey Hanger
          • 12 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Is this a free hit team? Not too far off what I would of played on a free hit this week.

      • The Red Devil
        • 10 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Ryan button
        Alonso Robertson Mendy Doherty AWB
        Hazard maddison Salah Brooks hojberg
        Aguero Jimenez Arnie

        0.4ITB 1 FT

        A-maddison to lamela
        B- Maddison to Anderson
        C-Save

        Thanks

      • Garlana
        • 11 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Correct bench order?

        Hennessy
        Alonso, Robertson, Mendy, Duffy
        Hazard, Salah, Fraser, richarlison
        Aguero, Arnie

        Patricio, Success, Doherty, billing

        1. Rage Against The Raheem
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 7 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Looks good to me, but I would probably put Doherty as first sub myself.

          1. Garlana
            • 11 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Thanks

      • Eden Wizard
        • 7 Years
        7 years, 3 months ago

        Mane to rise tonight please
        #Knob

        1. StayoutheSpiceZone
          • 8 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Yes I think so

        2. MTPockets
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Looks like it

          • Rainer
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            His knob to rise?

        3. Woody01
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 9 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Have 11.3m ITB to transfer out Maddison...WHO comes in?

          Forster
          Alonso / Holebas / Robertson (VC)
          Mane (C) / Hazard / Maddison / Richarlison / Barkley
          Murray / Arnie

          (Patricio / Mitrovic / Doherty / AWB)

          1. Gizzachance
            • 11 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            11.3 ! any one you want !
            on a serious note maybe shaq?

          2. diesel001
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Sterling

          3. jtreble
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            :). Show us the math.

          4. g40steve
            • 7 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            You may be short if Robo, Richy, Maddy & Bark get benched.
            Why still got Mitro, spend some money?

        4. Bleach †
          • 9 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Quick question

          Chilwell better pick than Pereira?

          1. Rainer
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Much!

          2. Bielsa's Bucket
            • 14 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Chilwell - his stats don't represent his points, but he's doing everything right

          3. 1zverGGadeM
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Chilwell is more consistent

        5. 1zverGGadeM
          • 8 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Ok, guys. Very seriuos que$tion!!!
          Who is scoring more this gw only?
          A) Aguero+Morata
          B) Aubameyang+Vardy

          Thanks!

          1. Lav
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            B

          2. Rage Against The Raheem
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 7 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            B

        6. AandyzZ
          • 8 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Doherty or wan-bissaka first bench?

          1. Lav
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Doherty

          2. Rage Against The Raheem
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 7 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Doherty for attacking threat

        7. Jonny HOW SON?
          • 11 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Oh my God. Seems like I will end up with Mitro, Cairney and AWB playing...
          Happy days

          1. CRO KLOPP
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Doherty, Hojbjerg and AWB here if TAA and Richarlison don't play

            1. Jonny HOW SON?
              • 11 Years
              7 years, 3 months ago

              Ah I shouldn't forget Doherty too

          2. grumpyman
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Obiang and Bennett here.

        8. Mind över Mata
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 14 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Who to play gents - already playing Patricio:

          A) Hojbjerg (WAT)
          B) Doherty (ars)

          Currently on B, bigger upside. Right call?

          1. Lav
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            B

        9. Lav
          • 9 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Save FT?

          Pat (Henn)
          Alonso Robbo Mendy (Doherty AWB)
          Salah Haz Rich* Murphy (Billing)
          Kun Arnie Wilson

          1. Mind över Mata
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 14 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Yes

        10. SFC Fan 123
          • 9 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Begovic Fabianski 
          Alonso Bednarek B Mendy Duffy Wan-Bissaka
          Hazard Salah Richarlison N Mendy Hojbjerg
          Mitrovic Aguero Arnautovic

          Still have WC but tempted by:
          B Mendy and Mitro -> Gomez and Morata for a -4 hit.
          Thoughts?

          1. Chucky
            • 12 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            morata and that too for -4? never

        11. TorresMagic™
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • Has Moderation Rights
          • 16 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          What would you do with this bunch?

          Patricio Fabianski
          Alonso Robbo Doherty Yedlin AWB
          Salah Hazard Richo Fraser Hoj
          Aguero Arnie Mitro

          1 FT, 0.6m in bank.

          Cheers

          1. CRO KLOPP
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Mitrović to anyone or save

          2. Eddie
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 13 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Rage quit.

            1. TorresMagic™
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • Has Moderation Rights
              • 16 Years
              7 years, 3 months ago

              It's practically your team, you go 1st 😛

              1. Eddie
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                • 13 Years
                7 years, 3 months ago

                🙂

          3. diesel001
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Mitro too Wilson

          4. Chucky
            • 12 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Mitro to Murray or Demarai G.

          5. Gizzachance
            • 11 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            mitro out, like most of us this week.
            wilson in ? ars an city after this week though
            murray has got some decent fixtures though

          6. TorresMagic™
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • Has Moderation Rights
            • 16 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Cheers all.

          7. Bielsa's Bucket
            • 14 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Probably downgrade Mitro and upgrade a singular defender (Jimenez, Ings etc).
            I took the risk and downgraded Alonso for a nice tidy profit and brought in Rudi to make it more of an even spread in my upgrades for def / mid.
            But depends how risky you want to be

          8. 1zverGGadeM
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Hoj > Murphy
            and bench Mitro?

        12. Martnnn
          • 7 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Maddison to :
          A: Pereyra
          B: Lamela
          C: Brooks or Fraser

          1. 1zverGGadeM
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Fraser

          2. Chucky
            • 12 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Fraser

          3. Garlana
            • 11 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            I went for Fraser which I know alot are getting rid of, however I don't think for attacking returns that all the fixtures are bad and he's nailed.

        13. Goonermeister
          • 8 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Which midfielder under 8.0? Pogba? Gudmunddson? Brooks?

          1. 1zverGGadeM
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Siggy?

        14. davies
          • 11 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Thoughts on Silva as an option?

        15. Teahupo'o
          • 14 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          How is she looking.. G2G?

          Begovic
          Robertson Mendy Alonso
          Salah Anderson Richarlison Hazard
          Aguero Arnautovic Success

          (Patrício, Femenia AWB Stephens)
          0FT 0.1ITB

        16. PURPLE-RONNIE
          • 10 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Best replacement for Maddison lads up to 7.8, thinking martial but not seeing much love for him here. After Man City they've got a good run, or is Felipe Anderson the better pick even if I have Arnie?

          1. FC Hakkebøf
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Should be a hot topic on this. Im in the same pick. Debating either Diangana (frees up a lot of cash) or Anderson

          2. IAWC ( It's a Wonderfu…
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Siggy

        17. tiger
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 14 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Chances of Sterling being rested against Man Utd?

          1. Eat my goal!
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 7 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            60/40

            1. jtreble
              • 9 Years
              7 years, 3 months ago

              ‘bout right.

          2. SAKA AND EMILE SMITH ROWE
            • 9 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Slim, in brilliant form and just signed a new contract. You never know with Pep but I’m 90% sure he’ll start

          3. Legomané
            • Has Moderation Rights
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Think last season he tended to get a run of 4-5 games then rested just as you started to feel comfortable with him!

            1. tiger
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 14 Years
              7 years, 3 months ago

              He's had the last 2 league games, and played the full 90 in the CL in midweek. Just wondering if he might be benched. But hard to tell with Pep.

        18. Hazardous1983
          • 15 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Best 4.5m.keeper on free hit.

          1. Chucky
            • 12 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Ryan

          2. Legomané
            • Has Moderation Rights
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Etheridge and hope Groß is on pens

        19. FC Hakkebøf
          • 9 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Need some advice. I'm in a pickle right now.

          1 ft 0.2 itb

          Hennesey*
          Alonso Mendy Trippier
          Salah (C) Hazard Rich Maddi*
          Aguero Arnie Jimenez

          Subs: Hamer Doherty Obiang Peltier

          A) Hennesey -> Fabianski
          B) Maddi -> Anderson
          C) Obiang -> Diangana
          D) Maddi -> Diangana
          E) Save ft

          Cheers

          1. Chucky
            • 12 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            B

          2. Legomané
            • Has Moderation Rights
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            B looks tempting, but it's a lot of Ham you'll need to munch on every week..

        20. Wings Fan
          • 12 Years
          7 years, 3 months ago

          Thoughts on Maddison > Milner?

          Have Salah + Robbo, and Richarlison

          1. Legomané
            • Has Moderation Rights
            • 8 Years
            7 years, 3 months ago

            Actually similar thoughts on a Barkles switch - see below - feels like a 1wk stab in the dark though!