Scout Notes
4 November 2016 777 comments
davidwardale davidwardale
Share:

Undiluted woe for United, unbridled joy for Southampton – Thursday’s Europa League matches were a study in contrast. Here’s how the two ties panned out.

Fenerbahce 2 Manchester United 1

Injuries, goal droughts and a manager publicly shaming his players; dropping to third in their Europa League group was the least of Manchester United’s worries following a dreadful performance in Turkey.

Even Wayne Rooney (8.6) scoring for only the second time in 14 matches this season did little to lift the gloom on a night of unremitting negativity for the Red Devils.

Paul Pogba (8.2) limped off with a thigh injury that makes him a doubt for Sunday’s trip to Swansea. Zlatan Ibrahimovic (11.2) replaced him and again failed to score – he now has just one goal from his last 11 matches – while the team as a whole enjoyed 70% possession but did precious little with it.

A makeshift defence missing Eric Bailly (5.4), Antonio Valencia (5.5) and Chris Smalling (5.9) conceded a goal within two minutes and never recovered. Only the latter, who has a knock, is a short-term injury worry and the pair drafted in as centre-halves in Turkey, Daley Blind (5.8) and Marcos Rojo (5.2), looked uneasy all night.

Coach Jose Mourinho started Ander Herrera (6.3), who is suspended domestically, and Morgan Schneiderlin (4.6) in midfield in a bid to give Juan Mata (7.4) a rest. But the pair produced so little that the Spaniard was brought on at half-time.

By then, the die had been cast, as Mourinho was quick to point out post-match.

“A team that concedes after two minutes is a team that is not ready, not mentally prepared, not focused, not concentrated.”

Summer signing Henrikh Mkhitaryan (8.9) replaced the ineffectual Marcus Rashford (6.9) for the final half hour but had little impact, with Mourinho talking down his immediate prospects.

“He has to do more. That is as simple as that. We have big expectations in the club and lots of players for these positions. He has to play better than Mata and Lingard and Martial, and it’s a simple as that.”

After such a night to forget, the same could be said of the whole side.

Swansea City will suddenly fancy their chances of a Gameweek 11 “upset”, with United’s squad currently looking bereft of assets to tempt even a cursory glance from us Fantasy managers.

Manchester United XI: de Gea, Darmian, Blind, Rojo, Shaw, Herrera, Schneiderlin (Mata 45), Pogba (Ibrahimovic 30), Rashford (Mkhitaryan 61), Rooney, Martial.
Subs not used: Romero, Jones, Young, Fellaini.

Southampton 2 Internazionale 1

The Saints exorcised any demons left over from their unfortunate loss in the San Siro by grabbing a glorious win against their Italian opponents in the reverse fixture.

Inter had pinched victory against the run of play in Italy and threatened to repeat the trick when they scored from their first shot of the match at St Mary’s.

But a Virgil van Dijk (5.4) equaliser, after Oriol Romeu (4.5) had hit the bar, and then a Yuto Nagatomo own goal from a Dusan Tadic (7.2) cross turned everything round in a blistering second-half performance.

Tadic had blown a chance to level the match just before the break when he had a penalty saved. Charlie Austin (6.7), who was not on the pitch at the time, should remain the club’s spot-kick man if Tadic’s weak effort is anything to go by.

Austin came on in the second half, replacing Jay Rodriguez (6.3), one of five changes coach Claude Puel had made from the side that lost to Chelsea on Sunday.

In came Maya Yoshida (4.3), Sam McQueen (4.5) James Ward-Prowse (5.1) and Pierre-Emile Højbjerg (4.3).

Puel has generally juggled his resources well, but the workload for two of his attacking stars, Tadic and Nathan Redmond (6.0), has been high. Record signing Sofiane Boufal (6.8) was again on the bench, but played no part. Whether that suggests he will figure in Sunday’s trip to Hull remains to be seen.

The 12.8%-owned Austin, however, looks almost nailed-on for a start at the weekend.

Southampton XI: Forster, Martina, Yoshida, van Dijk, McQueen, Romeu, Ward-Prowse, Højbjerg, Redmond, Tadic (Davis 76), Rodriguez (Austin 58).
Subs not used: Lewis, Clasie, Fonte, Boufal, Bertrand.

777 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. pokern1nja09
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Coutinho firmino or mane? Currently leaning towards coutinho

    1. Numb
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Firmino or Coutinho is a 50/50 thing

      1. OzilFozzil
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Yep Ive doubled on Firm and Cout

    2. Moose™
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Cout. On set-pieces. And more influential player.

    3. Ronny Hotdog
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Both.

    4. Atimis
      10 years, 17 days ago

      imho Coutinho can be a season keeper

      1. Cevap
        10 years, 17 days ago

        the same can be said about Firm

        1. Atimis
          10 years, 17 days ago

          Have 2 but Coutinho is more explosive + set pieces

    5. superfrank
      10 years, 17 days ago

      I keep meaning to do a calculation from the last 6-8 fixtures as to what the total points would have been for each double up pairing?

      mane- Firmino
      mane - cout
      cout - Firm

      I doubled with mane and firmino. have sold mane and left firmino. Everyone else has Cout so I have either a differential or an obvious mistake. time will tell

      1. OzilFozzil
        10 years, 17 days ago

        imo bit of a risk, Cout seems to be the one bringing home the bacon...

    6. teki0s
      10 years, 17 days ago

      I always had Firmino, even last season and served me well. However you cant ignore Coutinho's season now, so i got both. Never thought about Mane, mainly because of the price.

    7. Football Weekender
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Coutinho & Firmino could be a bit of a risk in the short term as it's very likely one or both will be rested after the international break due to the travel involved.

  2. Moose™
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Kosc + Rose season keeper? Or need to ditch at least one of em?

    1. El-Kloppico
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Rose i ditch-able.. will be a rotation risk at some point.

      1. Cevap
        10 years, 17 days ago

        he won't be if they don't advance in CL

    2. chr12345
      10 years, 17 days ago

      I've got Kosc but tempted to free up a few funds by going to Van Dijk and keeping him for the season instead

    3. Hy liverpool
      10 years, 17 days ago

      rose when plays probably the best but he is an injury prone and poch always rotate him with davies

  3. Jafooli
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Foster - Heaton
    Vertonghen - Clyne - Evans - Kone - Amat
    Sanchez - Sterling - Firmino - Allen - Capoue
    Aguero - Costa - Defoe

    1 x FT, 0.0m ITB

    All ideas very welcome....

    1. Numb
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Give us some options!

    2. Hy liverpool
      10 years, 17 days ago

      defoe to austin or save

    3. Pochecinno
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Defoe to Austin

    4. Moose™
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Pretty balanced team. Might do Defoe for Austin. But not for a FT imo. Save.

    5. Slam
      10 years, 17 days ago

      I'de WC 😉

      Defoe -> Deeney imo

      1. Hy liverpool
        10 years, 17 days ago

        i'd do deeney to austin for a hit

    6. teki0s
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Defo get Austin 😛

    7. Jafooli
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Cheers all....

    8. Cevap
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Defoe to Austin? i would look to downgrade Capoue and get Cout/Haz in the coming weeks

    9. Adam West - Team Serbia for…
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Hi Jaf Jarvish is doing an fpl tournament . I am captaining one of the teams any interest ?

    10. Billy Gilmore
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Delete your team 🙁

  4. chr12345
    10 years, 17 days ago

    How about this for a WC?

    Heaton, Pickford

    Alonso, Evans, Francis, Lovren, Amat

    Sanchez, Coutinho, Hazard, Allen, Fletcher

    Aguero, Lukaku, Austin

    1. pokern1nja09
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Looks solid for a wildcard. Would like a stronger defence but that's the price you pay

    2. Moose™
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Pretty good. Bit light in def. No Fuchs given?

    3. OzilFozzil
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Needs more Fuchs

  5. Pochecinno
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Anyone have the referees list for this weekend?

      1. Pochecinno
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Cheers Karan. Top man

        1. Karan_G14
          10 years, 17 days ago

          Always welcome mate!
          They always post it on Tuesday or Wednesday on this same site.

    1. devils advocate
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Someone posted it in another recent article.

      I think the BOU vs SUN and CHE vs EVE matches had the pen happy refs.

      1. Pochecinno
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Cheers DA.

    2. Sess!
      10 years, 17 days ago

      What ref is doing a game is the most pointless exercise ever.

  6. MartialMatas
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Play Holebas against Liverpool who are weak vs set pieces or Pieters?

    1. teki0s
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Close, but i would go for Pieters. WHU are very bad, and the CS chances of WAT even though they are recently very tight are low.

  7. Slam
    10 years, 17 days ago

    How much of a chance does Alonso have of loosing his place in the near future?
    I don't want to be buying a player who will be rotated in a few weeks time.

    1. Hy liverpool
      10 years, 17 days ago

      0%

    2. Ronny Hotdog
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Very little chance in my uninformed opinion. He looks good, no?

      1. Slam
        10 years, 17 days ago

        He does indeed.

        1. Ronny Hotdog
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          10 years, 17 days ago

          His stats hold up as well, good final third and penalty area touches since he was a regular. Plus the obvious Chelski of old clean sheets.

    3. makaveli123
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Low chance imo. A player that Conte rates highly.

    4. pompeyfan
      10 years, 17 days ago

      pretty low I reckon. 10%?

      He's also an option as one of the three in the centre.

    5. teki0s
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Conte brought him and likes him. And he loves playing with 3 in the back (im a juve fan and i know 😛 ), especially now that it works for him. I would say he is nailed.

    6. Dedalus1
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Chelsea don't have Champs League or cup so nothing to rotate for

  8. Cesc Pistols
    10 years, 17 days ago

    A) Valencia ➡ Fuchs
    B) Walker ➡ Alonso
    C) Save FT

    Team is as follows:

    Foster, Valdes
    Valencia, Walker, Lovren, Friend, Pieters
    Sanchez, Firmino, Mane, Capoue, Fletcher
    Aguero, Lukaku, Wilson

    1. Hy liverpool
      10 years, 17 days ago

      a

      1. Cesc Pistols
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Cheers, matey! 🙂

    2. Moose™
      10 years, 17 days ago

      A. No brainer. Tony V is injured.

      1. Cesc Pistols
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Thought he'd be back soon, but it seems I was wrong, yes? Cheers anyway!

    3. Ravager
      10 years, 17 days ago

      A

      1. Cesc Pistols
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Thanks, Pipes!

    4. Pork Pie Sausage Roll
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Valencia has to go.

      1. Cesc Pistols
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Ta, PPSR! 🙂

    5. Cevap
      10 years, 17 days ago

      A

      1. Cesc Pistols
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Thank you, mate!

  9. nadman89
    10 years, 17 days ago

    mandanda

    kelly - pieters - francis

    alexis - payet - firmino - redmond

    aguero(C) benteke lukaku

    pickford - capoue - evans - amat

    future surgery need thinking of saving transfer and doing 3 after the international break . opinions ?

    1. RoysCallerAnne
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      10 years, 17 days ago

      I think you can save. -4 mini WC after an international break is always nice 🙂

  10. RoysCallerAnne
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Bellerin, Lovren, Holebas, Amat, Kingsley. 2.9m itb, 0FT

    Kingsley -> Fuchs for a hit? Cheers

    1. Jebiga
      10 years, 17 days ago

      why not stones ?

      1. RoysCallerAnne
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        10 years, 17 days ago

        I'm a bit worried about Kompany being fit. Do you reckon Stones is undroppable?

    2. Hy liverpool
      10 years, 17 days ago

      that will be expensive defense ..

      1. RoysCallerAnne
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Yeah, a little I suppose. But I did get Lovren at 4.9 and Holebas at 4.5

        1. Hy liverpool
          10 years, 17 days ago

          amat to pieters after this week .. play holebas this and hope for any attacking return .

          1. RoysCallerAnne
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            10 years, 17 days ago

            Yep, I think not taking a defender hit is wise. Thanks again

    3. Moose™
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Kingsley to Pieters. Rotate accordingly.

      1. RoysCallerAnne
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        10 years, 17 days ago

        This is a good idea too, thanks.

    4. Cevap
      10 years, 17 days ago

      not for me. how about a BOU defender? would prefer to bank the money and keep for upgrades in front 8 later

      1. Cevap
        10 years, 17 days ago

        and i did not mean a BOU defender for a hit. maybe wait until IB

        1. RoysCallerAnne
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          10 years, 17 days ago

          Thanks Cevap.

  11. Parm
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Hull away might be a good chance for Puel to triple up on Tadic, Redmond & Boufal. I know 3 AMs is not in his philosophy but for one game maybe?

    1. TeddiPonza
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Think he might with two of Clasie Romeu and Davis behind them. Maybe I'm just being wishful as I'm a Redmond owner

    2. Karan_G14
      10 years, 17 days ago

      I just hope Redmond starts. Otherwise my AOA will be a waste.
      But agree he could try those 3 together with Austin. I think all 4 were on the pitch last match for 15-20 mins.

      1. Ronny Hotdog
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        10 years, 17 days ago

        That's a good point. If you play AOA and one of your attackers doesn't play, does it auto sub a defender in? Guess you lose your AOA chip as well?

        1. John t penguin
          10 years, 17 days ago

          correct on both

          1. Ronny Hotdog
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            10 years, 17 days ago

            Cheers. Saving for Christmas rotation fun then.

    3. pompeyfan
      10 years, 17 days ago

      maybe not as it's away from home

      1. Parm
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Maybe as it's Hull.

  12. leonickroberts
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Help please! After a reasonable start to the season my team needs an overhaul. No FT. £1.1m ITB.

    Gomes (Pickford)
    Smith Mee Holebas Bellerin Walker
    Wally Firmino Allen Capoue Fletcher
    Aguero Kaku Costa

    Main consideration for this week is:
    Bellerin/Walker+Wally+Capoue > Stones+Coutinho+Redmond?

    Good plan!? Bad plan? Appalling plan!?

  13. Jebiga
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Thanks everyone on previous reply.

    Valencia to Stones for -4. Is Stones realy nailed for City ? Maybe some other option up to 5.6 mil ?

    I did last night Capoue and Son to Allen and Firmino. Rest of the team is:

    Foster, Pickford
    Valencia, Williams, PVA, Evans, Amat
    Coutinho, Ozil, Firmino, Allen, Mutch
    Aguero, Lukaku, Costa

    Thanks all

  14. columbo
    10 years, 17 days ago

    My differential to fund Aguero this week is Zaha. Dangerous v Liverpool and unlucky to not win a penalty. Is nailed, plays 90 minutes nearly every time, and has the close range to back up the stats as he sits just behind benteke. Any team who concedes 12 shots on target in Burnley are susceptible to a few goals, too. At 5.3, I really think he's going to return something this GW. Saying that, the fact it's Ibra I'm selling for Aguero might show how much I know.

    1. devils advocate
      10 years, 17 days ago

      I don't think either are great options personally, but if you wanted a cheap palace mid I'd punt on McArthur playing in the No.10 role.

      Fwiw, if I was going to take a punt on a cheap mid and already had Allen, I'd be tempted by Drinkwater.

      Leicester have the fixtures so I think Drinkwater will chime in with a few assists and possible goals over the next few.

  15. Give Me the Mane
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Good to go?

    Pickford

    Lowton Williams McAuley

    Sterling Walcott Sanchez Coutinho

    Aguero(C) Austin Costa

    Jaku Amat Smith Maloney

    1. Moose™
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Nice front 7. Like it

    2. Ablazer
      10 years, 17 days ago

      really great front 7!

  16. Krul Runnings
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Mike Dean on the Bournemouth v Sunderland match this weekend.

    Guaranteed PK there then. Nice for Defoe and Wilson owners.

    1. Karan_G14
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Lets hope he awards one to Bournemouth this weekend.

  17. Lav
    10 years, 17 days ago

    On mobile phone and cant fins the league code. Can someone post it please?

    1. Lav
      10 years, 17 days ago

      *find

      1. John t penguin
        10 years, 17 days ago

        3000-1538

        1. Lav
          10 years, 17 days ago

          Cheers

  18. TeddiPonza
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Play Pick or Grant?

  19. Russell
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Have we had a Chelsea Presser recently? Any important news?

  20. El-Kloppico
    10 years, 17 days ago

    GTG?

    Cech
    Evans - Williams - Pieters
    Firmino - Bolasie - Coutinho - Redmond
    Kun(c) - Lukaku - Costa

    Bench: Pickford - Capoue - Holebas - BSmith

    1. Give Me the Mane
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Nice

      1. Give Me the Mane
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Williams over Holebas?

        1. El-Kloppico
          10 years, 17 days ago

          Yep.. Bargaining on Koeman experience of keeping Chelsea off..
          Holebas will concede 4! 😀

      2. El-Kloppico
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Can't see much point though.. 40 at most! 🙁

    2. Gazj11
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Looks good

  21. ryacoo
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Not sure what to do with my doubtful Arsenal assets:
    A) Bellerin + Walcott > Fuchs/Alonso + Coutinho (-4)
    B) Walcott + Capoue > Coutinho + Fletcher/4.3 mid (-4)
    C) Save FT

    I own Sanchez too by the way.

    1. Give Me the Mane
      10 years, 17 days ago

      C

    2. oispakaljaa
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      10 years, 17 days ago

      B

    3. leonickroberts
      10 years, 17 days ago

      In the same boat. Contemplating A but for Stones rather than Fuchs...

  22. Gazj11
    10 years, 17 days ago

    G2G?

    Foster
    Bellerin Kelly Pieters
    Allen Gundogan Firmino Payet Walcott
    Aguero Lukaku

    Pickford Deeney Amat Britos

  23. J0E
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • Has Moderation Rights
    10 years, 17 days ago

    New community article

    Here's YMA with his latest look at what the bookies, form and fixtures say about the best captain picks.

    With a 100% success rate this article has frightening soothsaying skills.

    http://www.fantasyfootballscout.co.uk/2016/11/04/what-the-bookies-form-and-fixtures-say-gameweek-11-captaincy/

    1. Numb
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Do you know when the Live HoF is updated each week? Thanks

    2. superfrank
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Cheers Jonty,

      I was on Aguero. Thi I think has convinced me to switch to Hazzard. 100% is 100% after all. Seems to make sense to go with it until it misses.

  24. United10
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Who would you captain if you had both?
    A) KDB
    B) Aguero

    1. Coaly
      10 years, 17 days ago

      B

    2. il Brutto
      10 years, 17 days ago

      B but it's close as KdB has the tendency to do well at home.

  25. aaaaaa
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Is Gundogan this years Mahrez?

    Priced at 5.5 too!

    1. Coaly
      10 years, 17 days ago

      No, but a good option for the next 3-4 weeks

    2. Ronny Hotdog
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      10 years, 17 days ago

      No.

    3. kumast
      10 years, 17 days ago

      5.7

    4. il Brutto
      10 years, 17 days ago

      No

  26. Ablazer
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Stones or Morgan?

    Fuchs is too expensive

    1. il Brutto
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Stones

  27. Jebiga
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Play foster or pickford ? have evans and pva as well

    1. Sauzée
      10 years, 17 days ago

      Foster.You are a brave man with double Sunderland defence!

  28. Old Wulfrunian
    10 years, 17 days ago

    where i can see post match press conf of the games? ty

  29. daviyb
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Special mention to Dundalk, very unlucky not to get a result. Incredible job that Steve Kenny has done there.

  30. Coaly
    10 years, 17 days ago

    Either of these worth a hit?

    a) Walcott to Haz
    b) Deeney to Austin

    After this week Deeney has two good fixtures (despite 0 form recently)

    1. Ablazer
      10 years, 17 days ago

      not convinced to both atm.
      Would wait one week to see Chelsea - Everton game

      1. Coaly
        10 years, 17 days ago

        But by then Hazard will have three tough games up next

        1. Ablazer
          10 years, 17 days ago

          aaa true. So a) is definitely bad imo

          1. Coaly
            10 years, 17 days ago

            He could do well against Everton and cause a rush to acquire him though

            My worry is Walcott has a tough game this week and next then a great little run so I'm reluctant to bin him although if there is any sign of rotation it may force my hand

    2. Sauzée
      10 years, 17 days ago

      A

    3. Olivier Bernards watch
      10 years, 17 days ago

      B

    4. Sess!
      10 years, 17 days ago

      B easy. Keep Walcott. Spurs are rubbish at moment.

      Deeney is a terrible FPL option.

      1. Coaly
        10 years, 17 days ago

        Thanks.

        Deeney has scored in 2 of Watfords last 3 home games and has two coming up after this week. Can see Liverpool conceding one and Deeney possibly will be extra motivated to try and get his 100th goal this week?

        Agree Austin is a better option though definitely