Captain Sensible
1 November 2019 741 comments
DavidMunday815 DavidMunday815
Share:

The moment Southampton conceded nine goals to Leicester last Friday, Manchester City players were locked in as Gameweek 11 captains.

Not surprisingly, their headline attackers have dominated the discussion for the armband ahead of this weekend’s fixtures.

However, there still remains some debate over which of them to trust with the captaincy, which is what we’re here to analyse in the latest Captain Sensible article.

As this piece uses data from the Fantasy Football Scout Members Area, only those who have signed up for the 2019/20 season can access it in full.

Captain Poll

Captain Poll results as of Thursday lunch-time

Raheem Sterling (£12.1m) has taken the Gameweek 11 captain poll by storm ahead of that meeting with the Saints.

41.9% of our voters have handed their backing to the England international, almost certainly influenced by his night-off from midweek EFL Cup action.

Sterling was not in the matchday squad as a large number of his colleagues were tasked with pariticipating in a dry-run of Saturday afternoon’s Etihad Stadium clash.

Prior to Gameweek 10, Sterling had just one league goal between Gameweeks 4 and 9 but in his last five matches in all competitions for club and country he has rediscovered the golden touch.

Since England’s 2-1 defeat to the Czech Republic on October 11, Sterling has scored six times.

As already mentioned, the main thing hanging over Sterling had been how secure his place in the starting eleven, but that has all been cleared up after Tuesday night.

De Bruyne also had the night off as Man City beat Southampton in the EFL Cup

Also getting the night off in the EFL Cup, admittedly still on the bench, was Kevin de Bruyne (£10.2m).

He currently sits in a distant second place on the captain poll with 15.9% backing from the voters.

Those supporting the Belgian may be influenced by his reliable rate of returns in 2019/20, especially at home.

Not only does de Bruyne have more double-figures than Sterling this season (three to two), he is yet to blank at the Etihad Stadium.

In four starts there, he has scored a total of 47 points, from two goals and six assists, averaging at 11.8 points per game. That may be hard to turn down for his owners this weekend.

Aguero has stung his captainers in recent weeks but could reward them on Saturday

Sergio Aguero (£12.1m) completes the trio of Manchester City options art the top end of the captain poll this week.

9.9% of voters are doubling-down on the Argentinian after his disappointing one-point cameo against Aston Villa last time out.

There is certainly enough evidence to suggest that Aguero will be back in the side to face Southampton though. He has had plenty of rest in Gameweeks 9 and 10 while Gabriel Jesus (£9.5m) has started both of those matches, also registering 88 minutes midweek too.

While Pep Guardiola’s rotation policy is not an exact science, there are some signs pointing towards a benching for the Brazilian this weekend, allowing Aguero to come in after already scoring twice against Southampton this week.

Salah and Liverpool have an appealing trip to Aston Villa in Gameweek 11

Mohamed Salah (£12.4m), Sadio Mané (£11.9m) and Roberto Firmino (£9.5m) head up the best of the rest on 3.6%, 3.5% and 3.4% backing respectively.

While Liverpool won’t be treated to a meeting with Southampton’s atrocious defence, they are still facing a relatively obliging one at Aston Villa.

In all their clashes with top-six sides this season, the Villans have conceded three times.

However, Salah does remain goalless away from home this season, contributing just two assists in five road trips thus far.

Meanwhile, Mané has been the slightly more reliable option outside of Anfield, with a goal and two assists so far. That said, the Senegalese international is yet to register a single Premier League attacking return away from home since Gameweek 4, blanking at Chelsea, Sheffield United and Manchester United since.

However, with both Salah and Mané, it must be said that Villa’s defence is unlikely to present as much of a test of those last three opponents on the road.

Vardy registered a 20-point haul for Leicester in Gameweek 10

Jamie Vardy’s (£9.3m) Gameweek 10 hat-trick at Southampton has kept him in the captaincy debate for this weekend but not in a particularly big way.

Not surprisingly, most Fantasy managers have assessed an away trip to Crystal Palace to be a much harder challenge than Southampton.

That’s because before hosting Manchester City in their last home match, the Eagles had conceded just once in four Premier League matches at Selhurst Park this season. Even when Guardiola’s men did turn up, Palace still managed to make them work very hard for a 2-0 win.

Therefore, Vardy has been backed by just 3.4% for the captaincy this time around.

Anthony Martial (£7.6m), Mason Mount (£6.9m), Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang (£11.1m), Callum Wilson (£8.0m), Marcus Rashford (£8.4m), Tammy Abraham (£7.8m) and Harry Kane (£10.8m) are the only other options above 1% support in the poll.

Player statistics – Last four matches

741 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. FPL Maldini
    7 years, 19 days ago

    My two rivals are 20 points behind me if I take no hits but they both own Vardy / Kane which scares the living hell out of me despite the fact Auba potentially has a better fixture in paper than either

    The fact that Vardy and Kane play Sunday makes things more torturous

    Any advice from someone who has more sense?

    1. badgerboy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      If it was the last week of the season or maybe a couple of weeks before the end of the season covering up on players that a rival owns isn't a bad idea but it's way to early to think about it imo.

    2. St Pauli Walnuts
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Could go your way, could go theirs. The question is, do you feel lucky? Well, do you punk?

      Hope that helps.

    3. International Richard
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I would be a touch concerned based on form & data.

      Auba is not getting involved ... at all. No chances, 1 touch in the box last 2 game weeks.

      Vardy is quite the opposite. No exact science & anything can happen, but yeah. I would be looking to switch

  2. Roy Rovers
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Hi everyone....have I got this right?

    Pope
    VVD Tomori Lundstram
    Salah KDB (VC) Mount McGinn
    Kun (C) Vardy Tammy

    Button Cantwell Rico Mings.

    1. No Professionals
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I'll tell you on sunday

      1. Roy Rovers
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Leave it until Monday...got Vardy!!

        1. No Professionals
          7 years, 19 days ago

          Who plays Sunday

          1. Roy Rovers
            7 years, 19 days ago

            Depends where you live!!!

    2. QUEN
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Would rather play Cantwell over mcgin but other than that looks good.

      1. Roy Rovers
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Cheers will have a look at that....

      2. dunas_dog
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        7 years, 19 days ago

        This or even Rico who might get attacking return

        1. Roy Rovers
          7 years, 19 days ago

          Cheers but not a fan of 4 at the back....especially against a fast improving Man Utd!

    3. n14mul
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Good team

      1. Roy Rovers
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Thanks....could do with a green arrow after 4 weeks of red with this team.

  3. QUEN
    7 years, 19 days ago

    RMT WC please

    Gazzaniga
    TAA Tomori lund
    KDB mane son martial mount
    Laca vardy

    Button Rico greenwood Reid

    1. SH
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Like the differential pick of Laca. Not so sure about Son. I would definitely upgrade the bench

      1. QUEN
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Thanks pal, yeah son and laca worry me slightly but not sure what I would do instead of son.

        Not too fussed on the bench, hopefully shouldnt need it. Then again going into the Christmas period could be risky, hopefully I can use a transfer later down to fix if needed

    2. International Richard
      7 years, 19 days ago

      It would be template but Auba to Abraham & Son to Sterling?

      1. QUEN
        7 years, 19 days ago

        I could if it wasn’t laca 🙂

  4. HurriKane
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Norwich have failed to score in their last 4 away games.

    Is Starting Dunk (NOR) over CHO (wat) no brainer assuming there is big chance CHO comes off bench?

    1. QUEN
      7 years, 19 days ago

      If cho starts I would rather him no question

      Difficult call with his minutes but would always bench the defender. Lampard will have to start him sooner or later or risk losing him. But then again he played 90 mins mid week so maybe dunk is better

      Sorry to confuse you further

      1. HurriKane
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Yh but will lampard drop willian and pulisic after fine performance last gw?
        Dont think so.

        And watford are no pushovers of late with 3 consecutive cs's

        1. QUEN
          7 years, 19 days ago

          That’s the thing prob not. Hoping for a Chelsea win though otherwise I’m out of my LMS tournament

    2. Bragazeti
      7 years, 19 days ago

      It is worth considering. Their defense stats aren't the best though

  5. n14mul
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Morning,

    Best to go for a 1 week punt or think more long term?

    A. King to Maupay (punt)
    B. Ota to Chilwell (long term)

    Thank you

    1. Bragazeti
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Get Maupay then consider Ota's replacements after the GW

    2. dunas_dog
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      A

  6. Captain_Shirokov
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Pope
    TAA - Ota - Lund
    Sterling - Mane - Mount - Yarmo
    Auba - Tammy - Maupay

    (Montoya, Soy, Dendoncker)

    2 fts, 1.1 in the bank. Thoughts?

    1. n14mul
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Have to think about getting rid of Ota long term.

  7. dunas_dog
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 19 days ago

    To avoid burning transfer worth doing one of following ( no cash in bank so Greenwood to Connolly not poss- but still have WC)

    A Cantwell to Dendoncker
    B Otamendi to Cancelo
    C Any other move you would make?

    Pope
    TAA Otamendi Söyüncü Diop
    Salah Sterling (c) KDB Mount
    Abraham Vardy

    McGovern Rico Cantwell Greenwood

    1. badgerboy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Otamendi to a cheaper defender and then use the cash to upgrade Cantwell next week.

    2. St Pauli Walnuts
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      A especially if you’ll still have 2 FT next week. I’m probably doing that with my one FT. Greenwood to Connolly another good option but I’ve not checked prices so maybe you can’t.

    3. Ze_Austin
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Otamendi to Lundstram

  8. Ritchies Magic Hat
    7 years, 19 days ago

    My only decisions this week: Ryan or Pope?
    Rico or Lunds?
    Anyone else feel it could be a scrappy 0-0 at Bramall Lane?

    1. kysersosa
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Definitely. Especially Burnley are struggling to field Barnes/Woods. 0-0 thriller on the cards.

      1. Ritchies Magic Hat
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Cheers - definitely leaning towards playing Pope and Lunds atm

  9. kysersosa
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Any point in keeping Otamendi for this week? Can FT in anyone (4.2 ITB). Current set up -

    Ota, Diop, Soy, Tomori, Lundstram

    Obviously TAA is the one to bring in, but could do for Diop and hope Ota starts.

    Thoughts?

    1. badgerboy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      You'll end up getting rid of Otamendi eventually anyway so you might as well get it over and done with.

    2. Ritchies Magic Hat
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I’d say West Ham have as good a chance of a clean sheet as City

    3. andres
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I would sell Ota if you have the transfer to do it. Why not get Mendy instead?

      1. andres
        7 years, 19 days ago

        ah sorry just saw that you don't have TAA nor Robbo. I would go for one of them now as you will need to do it at some point anyway.

      2. kysersosa
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Have considered this. I think he will outscore TAA this week, but then TAA will outscore over the next 5. I think I’ll end up transferring Mendy out in 3 weeks.

    4. St Pauli Walnuts
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Yes do TAA, you’re gonna need him with the upcoming fixtures. Ota pretty unlikely to start.

  10. andres
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Pope
    TAA Soy Lund
    Mane KDB Mount Madds*
    Abraham Vardy Wilson*

    Cantwell, Kelly, Pieters. 3.3 ITB. 1 FT

    A madds to dilva ( and gives up 10.7 for wilson replacement)
    B wilson, madds => sterling, connolly (-4) (gives 1.7 to upgrade cantwell to perez next GW)
    C wilson, madds => sterling, maupay (-4) (no cash, playing maupay every week)

    1. kysersosa
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Reply fail... I think they are short term transfers. Leicester have some great fixtures coming up and he is on set pieces.

      1. andres
        7 years, 19 days ago

        in B I could get a thhird leiecester player in for catnwell next GW. ALready have Vardy and Soy.
        Would add tielemans or perez

      2. andres
        7 years, 19 days ago

        could also do mount to dilva but I think mount will still deliver

  11. Azathoth
    7 years, 19 days ago

    I want to (K)un but because of Pep i'm gonna (K)DB......

    1. Roy Rovers
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I’m doing the opposite....

    2. Kay317
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I've got the armband on Kun at the mo, but very worried about him being benched. I'm falling behind more and more coz of my poor captain choices.

    3. Bobby_Baggio
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Sterling. Out of your two KDB

  12. kysersosa
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 19 days ago

    I think they are short term transfers. Leicester have some great fixtures coming up and he is on set pieces.

    1. Roy Rovers
      7 years, 19 days ago

      ?

      1. Sir Edo
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Maddison most likely!

  13. mookie
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Fun fact
    Leicester lost the last 4 games against Palace, scoring 1 goal(Evans) and conceding 13.

    1. Don Kloppeone
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Good luck to all those Chilwell and Soy owners 😉

  14. The Mantis
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 19 days ago

    I have gone with Sterling as my captain this week so that means Sterling is not the best captain pick this week

    1. Roy Rovers
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I hope you are right!!…non owner.

      1. Don Kloppeone
        7 years, 19 days ago

        ^This

  15. Bobby_Baggio
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Morning all. 2FT and 0m ITB. Prefer to only use 1FT but happy to use both. Suggestions most welcome. Thanks all.

    Pope
    Ota - Robbo - Lund
    KDB - Sterling - Mount - James
    Kane - Abraham - Vardy

    McGovern - Soy - Rico - Nakamba

    1. Miniboss
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I think you’re well set. Maybe Ota to a more nailed city defender?

      1. Bobby_Baggio
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Cancelo?

        1. Roy Rovers
          7 years, 19 days ago

          Mendy

  16. Kay317
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Two dilemmas this week that I could do with your help on....
    Captain:
    1) Aguero
    2) KDB
    Start:
    A) CHO
    B) Connolly
    Your advice would be much appreciated. Currently on 1/B.

    1. Klein
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I see kdb starting more than kun so 2 for me.a/b is roll of dice.

      1. Kay317
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Agree about A/B - both could be benched or start. CHO is better but played 90 mid week and pulisic got an early sub off. Plus he scored a hatrick last week so can't see him being benched. Whatever I chose will be wrong I'm sure. Thats my luck this season. Thanks

    2. Bobby_Baggio
      7 years, 19 days ago

      2B

  17. Roy Rovers
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Is this crazy?

    Salah > Sterling & VVD > TAA

    Pope
    VVD Tomori Lundstram
    Salah KDB (VC) Mount McGinn
    Kun (C) Vardy Tammy

    Button Cantwell Rico Mings.

    1. Aleksei
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Could work out

    2. Kay317
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Don't think id lose Liverpool attack to be honest. Vvd to TAA yes.
      Maybe aguero downgrade then upgrade other mid to sterling. Cantwell maybe then go 352

      1. Roy Rovers
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Yeah thinking that after this weekend....Kun gets this week.

        1. Kay317
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          7 years, 19 days ago

          Defo armand on Kun too? I'm going for it. Trouble is if he scores a hatrick I won't want to sell him!

          1. Indpush
            7 years, 19 days ago

            Good headache to have haha

  18. Yoshioka
    7 years, 19 days ago

    I have 2ft.

    Auba + Maddi > Maupay + Sterling(c)?

  19. Miniboss
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Hi all!

    What would you do? All help appreciated 🙂

    2ft, 0.2itb

    Heaton Button
    Robbo TAA Otamendi Tomori
    Salah Sterling KdB CHO
    Pukki Abraham

    Button Lundstraem Dendoncker Greenwood

  20. EgyptianKing
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Mates which duo you think will score more this GW?

    A) Martial Auba

    B) Vardy Rash

    Cheers!

    1. Aleksei
      7 years, 19 days ago

      A

      1. EgyptianKing
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Thank you mate

    2. Royal5
      7 years, 19 days ago

      B by a mile

      1. EgyptianKing
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Will be a difficult choice for me.

        I deduce you consider Leicester will score again lots of goals against Palace?

        1. Royal5
          7 years, 19 days ago

          Not necessarily, but Vardy and Rash are both in great form atm. Martial still a bit rusty and Auba is abysmal.

    3. sunzip14
      7 years, 19 days ago

      C) Vardy Martial

  21. No Professionals
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Is vardy worth a hit if it includes a connolly, and you have Otamendi?

    1. IRBOX ⚽
      7 years, 19 days ago

      No

  22. Jimbo-Jones
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Need to use a transfer and considering a GK move.

    Can only afford 4.6 in one move (Henderson?)
    Worth using 2ft to get Ryan/Pope?

    Heaton
    VVD TAA Soyuncu Tomori
    Salah Sterling KDB Mount
    Abraham Jimenez

    Lundstram Greenwood Cantwell

    1. badgerboy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Greenwood and Cantwell need sorting before thinking about a gk change.

      1. Bobby Digital
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Cantwell and Greenwood are benchfodder.

        1. badgerboy
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          7 years, 19 days ago

          They won't be in a few weeks when the fixtures start piling up. Greenwood barely getting any minutes and Cantwell is soon going to be displaced by Hernandez.

  23. 87jace
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Who would you dump and why?

    Tomori (full rise) 4.7 return
    or
    Soyoncu (half rise) 4.6 return

    1. GE
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Why dump any of them?

      1. 87jace
        7 years, 19 days ago

        I want to upgrade one of my defenders to Mendy

    2. Roy Rovers
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Out of those 2...Soy

  24. 87jace
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Also...

    Who would you choose and why?

    Tielemans (6.5)
    or
    Ayoze (6.1)

    1. Fuddled FC
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Tielemans if you have the cash, far better average returns

    2. GE
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Tielemans, more nailed

    3. Roy Rovers
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Tielemans...nailed and form

  25. Legohair
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Play one

    A. Souyncu
    B. Lascelles
    C. Cantwell

    1. GE
      7 years, 19 days ago

      A

  26. GE
    7 years, 19 days ago

    TC Sterling this GW the right time?

    1. Bobby Digital
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Could be.

    2. Fuddled FC
      7 years, 19 days ago

      I'm deliberating the same thing.

      I guess sensible answer is always wait until the double gw

      However experience has taught us that sometimes an excellent sgw came reap better rewards

      1. GE
        7 years, 19 days ago

        Yes, and the advantage of using it in a SGW is that you avoid the difficult task of choosing to FH, BB or TC later in DGW

  27. Bobby Digital
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Looking good for the GW?

    Ederson
    TAA VVD Lundstram
    Salah Sterling(c) KDB Tielemans Jorginho
    Abraham Pukki

    Button Aurier Kelly Greenwood

    0ft 0itb

  28. andre_c
    7 years, 19 days ago

    GTG?

    Pope
    TAA, Lund, Soy
    Salah, KDB (VC), Yarmo, Mount
    Aguero (C), Tammy, Wilson

    Button, Cantwell, Rico, Janmaat
    0.0ITB, 1FT

    GW11: Hold

    GW12: Aguero > Vardy, Cantwell > Dilva/Martial/Tielamans (which one should I pick?)

    1. Bobby Digital
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Yup, gtg.

    2. Fuddled FC
      7 years, 19 days ago

      Tielmans

  29. IRBOX ⚽
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Better combo this week?

    Cancelo and Maddison
    Lundstram and Martial

    1. andre_c
      7 years, 19 days ago

      b

    2. Roy Rovers
      7 years, 19 days ago

      B

  30. Moves like Dejagah
    7 years, 19 days ago

    Any thoughts on this lot - I have 2 FTs and 0.0 in the bank.

    Pope (Button)

    Lundstram, Otamendi, Soyuncu (Kelly, Guilbert)

    Salah, Mount, Sterling, KDB

    Pukki, Wilson, Abraham