Captain Sensible
21 November 2025 531 comments
FFScout Tom FFScout Tom
Share:

Erling Haaland (£14.9m) scored yet again for the millions of Fantasy Premier League (FPL) managers who handed him the armband in Gameweek 11, although a missed penalty limited him to just four points.

The captaincy decision might not be quite so straightforward in Gameweek 12, however, with Manchester City travelling to fellow Champions League side Newcastle United.

In Captain Sensible, we consider if there is a case to look beyond the Norwegian this week, especially with Arsenal and Manchester United playing at home and Chelsea facing Burnley in a plum fixture.

First, we will assess the on-site captaincy poll. We will then analyse player and team statisticsRate My Team (RMT) and the Premier Fantasy Tools ratings to determine the best captain for Gameweek 12 ahead of Saturday’s 11am GMT deadline.


Captaincy Poll

As is customary, Haaland leads the Fantasy Football Scout captaincy poll. Just over 39% of site users believe the Norwegian, who has scored 14 goals in 11 league starts, is the best option for Gameweek 12.

Joao Pedro (£7.5m) is the only other player to boast at least 10% of the vote, ahead of an appealing fixture on Saturday for Chelsea against Burnley.

Elsewhere, there is little to separate the likes of Jean-Philippe Mateta (£8.1m), Antoine Semenyo (£8.1m) and Bukayo Saka (£10.1m) in what is a very crowded field, Haaland aside.


Player Stats – Last Six Gameweeks

FFScout Tom <p>Deputy General Manager. Forever chasing the top 10K. Chelsea fan.&nbsp;</p>

531 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. Tsparkes10
    • 7 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Start one..
    A) Woltemade
    B) James

    1. SalahFingers
      • 8 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      A

    2. Mr. O'Connell
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Nothing else to bench?

      B baby

    3. Sun Jihai
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      A
      Feel like there's a decent chance James gets saved for Barca + Arsenal

  2. FDMS All Starz
    • 10 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Bottomed

    Bench one, first to 3 wins:

    A) Ndiaye (mun A)
    B) Andersen (sun H)
    C) Semenyo (whu H)
    D) Welbeck (bre H)

    1. Mr. O'Connell
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      B

  3. SalahFingers
    • 8 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Gabriel -> Timber OR Chalobah?

    1. Mr. O'Connell
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Neither

      1. Casual Player
        • 5 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Either

    2. jacob1989
      • 4 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Timber

  4. andymck
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 10 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Semenyo > Mbeumo - worth a hit? Reijnders on the bench if Semenyo doesn’t play

  5. Mr. O'Connell
    • 14 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Just bought Guiu. Bargain.

  6. TochanMama
    • 13 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Who'd you start?
    A) Caicedo vs Burnley
    B) Alderete vs Fulham
    C) Start both and bench Semenyo

    1. Mr. O'Connell
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      A. Sunderland lose to Fulham

    2. Lav
      • 9 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      A

  7. jacob1989
    • 4 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    C Mateta anyone?

    1. Lav
      • 9 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Great shout as a differential

  8. boroie
    • 7 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    A - Senesi (have Petrovic in nets)
    B - O’Reilly

    1. Lav
      • 9 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      A

    2. Casual Player
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      B

  9. Lav
    • 9 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    2 FT, looks like I need to take a -4 at least? Could also FH.

    Pope
    Gabriel* Calafiori* Munoz Truffert Rodon
    Semenyo Eze Ndiaye Minteh King
    Haaland JP Woltemade

  10. Saka White Rice
    • 11 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Goodnight sleep tight guys x

  11. boroie
    • 7 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    On WC… gtg?

    Petrovic
    Timber VVD Senesi
    Saka(VC) Mbeumo Semenyo Minteh
    Haaland(C) Mateta Thiago

    Dubravka; Richards King Esteve

  12. shredder
    • 15 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Lost on last page
    Evening all,
    Stuck on a defender decision, who to buy.
    Have 5m
    1. De Ligt
    2. Lacroix
    3. Anderson
    4. Richards
    What do ye think ?
    Cheers

  13. Purefection
    • 11 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    I have Semenyo, Kroupi and King and no FT. Do I roll or do I transfer one of them out? Two of the three will be in my starting line up

    1. Casual Player
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      You have to make a transfer maybe only 1/3 plays?

  14. Jasoooooooo
    • 9 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Transfer Gabriel to:
    A. Munoz
    B. VVD

    Have no Liverpool or Palace defence right now. Leaning towards Munoz.

    1. Casual Player
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      A

  15. Letsgo!
    • 9 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Gab to vvd/konate for -4?

    1. Herger
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 4 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      You need to deal with Rice first

  16. RICICLE
    • 3 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    No replies so just trying once more hehe

    Raya
    Gabriel* - Chalobah - Munoz
    Saka - Semenyo* - Enzo - Ndiaye
    Mateta - Haaland - Woltemade
    _______________________________
    Dubravka: Senesi: Gudmundsson: Stach

    2FT, 0.2 ITB

    A) Gabriel + Semenyo > VVD + Cunha
    B) Gabriel + Semenyo > Konate + Mbeumo
    C) Semenyo + Woltemade > Mbeumo + Thiago (Play Senesi & have to keep Gab)
    D) Gabriel + Semenyo + Woltemade > VVD + Thiago for -4
    E) Gabriel + Ndiaye + Woltemade > Konate + Mbeumo + Thiago -4

    Any help welcome, thanks gents!

    1. RICICLE
      • 3 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Actually thinking now to just do Gab + Wolt > VVD + Thiago and have Senesi for cover if Semenyo doesn’t play and bring in a UTD player in 14 as I’ll likely be FH’ing in 13.

      1. Count Olaf
        • 1 Year
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Do you need Thiago if you FH 13? Welbeck could be an alternative

        1. RICICLE
          • 3 Years
          7 months, 20 days ago

          Fair point actually, I wouldn’t need Thiago in now if FH’ing in 13, hadn’t even considered Welbeck ya knows good shout bud!
          Reckon Wolt is worth keeping for City?

          1. Count Olaf
            • 1 Year
            7 months, 20 days ago

            Wolt has two good home games in 14 and 15, so might be worth keeping all the way

            1. RICICLE
              • 3 Years
              7 months, 20 days ago

              True, ah to hell with it then, I’m gonna keep Wolt as I have a sneaky feeling he could do something against City anyway, confidence should be good after a Germany brace anyway

    2. PartyTime
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      B. FH 14 is better imo. Play the fixtures

      1. RICICLE
        • 3 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Cheers bud, unfortunately I’ve already brought in VVD now, as I wa stair certain I wanted him over Konate, now my decision just lies with holding Wolt or not as I’ve decided to forego United players this GW

      2. RICICLE
        • 3 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        I can definitely afford any United mid now if I move wilt out next GW, that’s an IF though.

        Really didn’t think I’d use just the 1FT this GW haha!

  17. ball c
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 5 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Is it 2:30am price rises / drops?

    1. Count Olaf
      • 1 Year
      7 months, 20 days ago

      In roughly 10 minutes

  18. Letsgo!
    • 9 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Rjames gonna bench again?

  19. Count Olaf
    • 1 Year
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Gabriel to
    A) Munoz
    B) Van Dijk
    No other defender from either team

    1. ball c
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      B

      1. Count Olaf
        • 1 Year
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Thanks

    2. Casual Player
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      A

    3. RICICLE
      • 3 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      I like A there bud

    4. Jimjams
      7 months, 20 days ago

      B

  20. ball c
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 5 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Which move before prices change:
    Haven’t taken a hit yet all season.

    A) Reijnders & Muniz to Mbuemo & Thiago for -4

    B) Gabriel & Reijnders to Ballard & Mbuemo for -4

    C) Reijnders to Schade
    D) Muniz to Thiago

    Raya
    
Virgil - Munoz - Senesi
    
Reijnders - Semenyo - Sarr - Bruno - Minteh

    Haaland - Mateta 



    Dubravka - Gabriel - Andersen - Muniz


    1. Count Olaf
      • 1 Year
      7 months, 20 days ago

      I like A the most

      1. ball c
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 5 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Ta

  21. ball c
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 5 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Is double Man Utd mid too much?
    I already have Bruno but looking to bring in Mbuemo too

    1. Count Olaf
      • 1 Year
      7 months, 20 days ago

      I have them both and I think it's worth it.

    2. Dannyb
      • 9 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      I have both now, just got Bruno in.

    3. Casual Player
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Look anytime you can spend 17m on 2 players from a team that finished bottom half last season you have to do it

  22. Richm
    • 4 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Start Sarr or Thiago? Have Mateta

    1. Casual Player
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Sarr but surely you have someone else to bench?

      1. Richm
        • 4 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Not really have minteh , Semenyo , Enzo , Saka , Haaland. Hoping Semenyo gets a rest

  23. PartyTime
    • 5 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Already own Saka & capping this GW but is Eze to Mbeumo worth a -4 hit ?

    1. PartyTime
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Interesting stuff. Apparently, Eze hasn’t blanked in home games this season. Think that’s enough for me to avoid a hit.

    2. Jimjams
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Hold.

      1. PartyTime
        • 5 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Having a change of mind ar the moment. No better time to get Mbeumo with his surging ownership.

  24. rainy
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • Has Moderation Rights
    • 10 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Price changes 22nd November

    Rises:
    Mbeumo 8.6
    Thiago 6.4
    Cherki 6.4
    Minteh 6.1
    Virgil 6.0

    Falls:
    Gyökeres 8.8
    Semenyo 8.0
    Grealish 6.7
    Johnson 6.6
    Gabriel 6.5
    Mitoma 6.1
    Ndoye 5.6
    Reijnders 5.4
    Schär 5.3
    Burn 5.1
    Sels 4.7
    Chirewa 4.3

    1. Casual Player
      • 5 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      I sold Thiago on WC8 and he’s had 4 rises since. I get fantasy

      Thanks for the update

    2. Sun Jihai
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Thanks Rainy
      Mbeumo now the 4th highest owned player in the game

    3. Jimjams
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Cheers.

    4. Yank Revolution
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      1 up, 2 down 🙁

      1. JohnnyCroat
        • 10 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Same

    5. GreennRed
      • 14 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Cheers Rainy.

  25. Jimjams
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Bench one:

    A) Senesi
    B) Guehi
    C) Ndiaye

    1. mixology
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 13 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Too close to call. Go with your gut

  26. ⭐ Bemba_Da ⭐
    • 16 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Not much difference in Konate and vvd, why not just go konate?

    1. RICICLE
      • 3 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Just feels more comfortable going with VVD imo

    2. Feanor
      • 17 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      Virgil plays more and scores more

  27. HellasLEAF
    • 16 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    What's the general feeling on Semenyo starting at this stage. Might go with someone else over 23 minutes of Semenyo.

    1. Feanor
      • 17 Years
      7 months, 20 days ago

      My bench is Tarkowski, Porro and Gordon so Semenyo starts

  28. Puuli
    7 months, 20 days ago

    A)Bowen or¨
    B)Ndiaye

  29. GROBARI
    • 5 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Was late on price changes (tough) but it is what it is
    Gabi to?
    A) Saliba
    B) Van Dijk

    1. Puuli
      7 months, 20 days ago

      B
      Bowen or Ndiaye?

      1. GROBARI
        • 5 Years
        7 months, 20 days ago

        Ndiaye

  30. SpaceCadet
    • 12 Years
    7 months, 20 days ago

    Best option here? 1 ft, 0.3m itb.

    A. Gabriel > vvd
    B. Gabriel semenyo > konate mbeumo -4
    C. Gabriel semenyo > vvd gakpo -4

    Sanchez
    Gabriel senesi Munoz
    Saka semenyo Sarr Enzo
    Haaland mateta wolte

    Dubravka vdv Anderson gudmundsson