Hot Topics

Below are the Hot Topics currently being discussed, with access to all past discussions.

To create a Hot Topic you have to post and interact with the community in the comments section under articles. Moderators read these comments and will and promote some important comments to Hot Topics as the conversations develop.

You should use the flag option to alert mods to posts and discussions that you feel should be promoted to Hot Topic status. Write ‘Potential Hot Topic?’ in the box that pops up after ticking the flag.

And don’t forget to use your voting powers: upvote posts that positively contribute to important discussions. These posts are seen more often by the moderating team!

AuthorHot TopicDateReplies

Krionos
Budget defender options

I've been looking at defenders and especially trying to pick out a few good cheap options. I've mainly picked out some stats from the distribution and goal threat tables to see which defenders r…

7 years, 9 months ago15

Whattheheck!
Improved statistics vs the eye test

I've been thinking about the "eye test". Is it a meaningful tool for analysing FPL players? I would say yes and no. Why can't they just be replaced with hard statistics? For me the reason why th…

7 years, 9 months ago48

Ramboros
LIverpool & the big six league

There's one myth that's being perpetuated on here about Liverpool that's getting rather annoying, and is a classic example of FPL managers carrying on conclusions from seasons past. Last season'…

7 years, 9 months ago37

Rossi3254
Premium midfielder analysis

Was just thinking about how many of the premium mids (8M plus) are actually worth getting right now with upcoming fixtures in mind so here is my analysis on them starting off with a look at all the…

7 years, 9 months ago43

Geoff
Arsenal assets

Fantasy Football Scout Daily Hot Topic What are you looking at doing with Arsenal assets, and why? With quite a few options to choose from across the side, Emery has already surprised us by rest…

7 years, 9 months ago45

Shawcus
Form over Fixtures?

Haven’t commented much on here lately but having seen people talking about fixtures and teams having a run of great matches, I thought I would add my thoughts. Firstly I decided in the summer th…

7 years, 9 months ago25

Geoff
Members Area improvement suggestions

I'm going to be putting some time into getting fixes/tweaks done to the Members Area tools and tables started next week, or at the very least planned. What would you like to see? Feel free to be …

7 years, 9 months ago167

Ëð
Will Son get Moura fewer games?

I posted this a few pages back but it bottomed out... could be useful and would like to hear some thoughts. 'Will Son replace Moura following the IB?' Seen this question floating around a lot ove…

7 years, 9 months ago106

Smurf
No way, Jose?

Holebas - No Way Jose I like many, have looked at getting in Jose Holebas. I’m on my wildcard so it’s pretty easy to fit him in. However looking more into the fixtures I think he’s a lot les…

7 years, 9 months ago40

Geoff
Feedback on Scout Notes articles

Fantasy Football Scout Daily Hot Topic After speaking with David yesterday today’s Hot Topic is about some articles the writers would like feedback on, specifically the Scout Notes and the Lineu…

7 years, 9 months ago103

IRBOX ⚽
All or Nothing

Just finished watching the 8 part mini series, Man City: All or Nothing. For those of you who haven’t seen it I would highly recommend. Even if you aren’t a city fan (as most of us here would n…

7 years, 9 months ago51

Geoff
Interest in Internationals

Fantasy Football Scout Daily Hot Topic What is your interest level in the international games? Will you be watching some? Which games are you interested in? Will you watch for the games themsel…

7 years, 9 months ago28

Geoff
Site update

The Injuries and Bans tab, labelled Injuries at the top of the site, now can be sorted by whichever column you choose. If that isn't working for anyone please let me know

7 years, 9 months ago9

Jafooli
Captain choices and heavy hitters

For those on WC’s, here’s an idea to help build your team. Excluding punty captains (Alonso, Mendy, Mane, Eriksen etc), how many genuine grade A week in week out captain choices are there in t…

7 years, 9 months ago43

Geoff
Gameweek 4 Rough with the Smooth

Gameweek 4 Rough with the Smooth Feel free to post your tales of joy and woe from Gameweek 4 here:

7 years, 9 months ago59

Legomané
Can you carry a cameo-Kamara?

It is becoming very clear this season that we have now entered into a post-security era in relation to secured starting berths for players in the 'top' teams. Even promoted sides like Wolves and F…

7 years, 9 months ago42

Geoff
International Break Transfer Plans

Fantasy Football Scout Daily Hot Topic With the first International Break now underway what's your transfer strategy, and why? Will you make transfers early, trying to catch price rises and knowi…

7 years, 9 months ago68

Rhinos
Mo Salah or No Salah?

Gonna wade in on the Salah debate; The pros of keeping: 1) There is nothing to suggest Salah will significantly regress from last season's superhuman efforts, stats are all in his favour 2) No p…

7 years, 9 months ago55

J0E
Breakfast Club launches 11:15am - link now live

Live Breakfast Club - 11:15 https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKxYKQ8pgJ7V8wwh4hLsSXQ/live @FFScout_Joe @DavidMunday815 and @FFScout_Granny discuss: Our GWK 4 sides Granville's wildcard Reaction t…

7 years, 9 months ago5

@ocprodigy
Scout Picks Challenge - GW 4

SCOUT PICKS CHALLENGE - GAMEWEEK 4 Lets bring it on! Onside 9 - if you see this, please feel free to get in touch somehow! I'd love to learn about automating the process. GW3 results: https://www…

7 years, 9 months ago30

J0E
New Video - Gameweek 4 press conference round up

New Video - Gameweek 4 Conference Call I'm joined by Skonta Rigga to look over the key points from GWK 4's press conferences Klopp rotation tease Man Utd defensive worries Ings' blistering for…

7 years, 9 months ago9

Reckoner.
Best 4.5m midfielders

4.5m Midfielders, who we all going for? Stephens - Guarentees starts, not going to get any attacking points but maybe the odd CS point Westwood - As above but maybe at risk when Defour returns M…

7 years, 9 months ago51

Geoff
GW4 breakout players

Fantasy Football Scout Daily Hot Topic Who do you think will step up in GW4 and be a popular transfer in for GW5, and why? Do you think it will be an already-established name in our sides or some…

7 years, 9 months ago47

Geoff
What to do with Ings

For those with Danny Ings, what are you doing this week? 'Mark Hughes reveals that Danny Ings has a "bad blister" on his foot, but has trained today and will be monitored ahead of the weekend.' I…

7 years, 9 months ago49

Rainer
Tough Liverpool Fixtures

Liverpool's fixtures between the two international breaks, GW5-8: Sat: Spurs (A) - Prem Tue: PSG (H) - UCL Sat: Southampton (H) - Prem Tue: Chelsea (H) - EFL Sat: Chelsea (a) - Prem Wed: Napoli (a…

7 years, 9 months ago52

Geoff
Members Only - Live HOF update

The Live HOF has been updated for the first time this season! Where do you rank? Surprised to see some of the names at the top?

7 years, 9 months ago33

Benster
Scoutcast Feedback

Sorry to say this but the Scoutcast is not nearly as good as it used to be. It used to be the FPL highlight of my week but now other pods have easily overtaken. Jonty is a great asset but he's not…

7 years, 9 months ago247

G-Whizz
GW4 DS, Fixture and clean sheet odds

GW4 DS, Fixture and clean sheet odds Last week the top DS Liverpool (645DS) only beat Brighton 1-0 while Arsenal (537DS) beat fellow Londoners West Ham 3-1. Man City (435DS) could only draw 1-1 wi…

7 years, 9 months ago21

Jekori
Fulham and West Ham rotation

Just noticed fulham and west ham rotation-heaven, never against a top6 side: (WOL, EVE, WAT, eve, bri, car, BOU, BUR, hud, STH, new, CAR, CPA, W-H, WAT, WOL, HUD, BRI, bur, bou, BRI, cpa, cpa, FUL,…

7 years, 9 months ago24

tambourineman
GW4 Referees Confirmed

Referee appointments for GW4, figures in brackets are penalties per match for last season plus GW1-3. Leicester City v Liverpool - Paul Tierney (0.11) Brighton & Hove Albion v Fulham - Lee Probert…

7 years, 9 months ago20

RedLightning
Early Chips

Tony Coppen, the new world #1, has already used three of his chips (Bench Boost, Wildcard and Free Hit). I wouldn't be surprised if he plays his Triple Captain chip in GW4. His chips have turned o…

7 years, 9 months ago32

Geoff
A goodbye, an addition, and a Hot Topic update

Updates 1. Niemi let me know last week that he hasn't had the time online and onsite that he thought he would, as other things are taking up more time than he expected. He is stepping down as a mo…

7 years, 9 months ago21

J0E
New Video - Gameweek 4 Captaincy

New Video David and I discuss the best captaincy picks for GWK 4 Aguero's record v New Hazards's v Bou J-Lingz bombshell dropped Watch here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OU65X5tIbW4

7 years, 9 months ago12

Legomané
Time to reduce the impact of price falls?

If FPL changed the impact of price falls occurring below a players Purchase Price, to match the algorithm for value gained – so that for every 0.2 that a players value dropped below the original …

7 years, 9 months ago25

Geoff
Liverpool fixtures and transfer plans

Fantasy Football Scout Daily Hot Topic Salah, Mane, Robertson, and TAA have all performed well so far, as have some other Liverpool assets, and many of us have tripled up for the opening fixtures.…

7 years, 9 months ago50

COYS Down Under
Past Stats Predict Waning Fortunes for Defence-Heavy Teams

Does anybody else think that a back heavy team is only going to be viable short term? Having 3 6m+ and a 5+ is almost the norm and it probably won't be long until we have all of Trip, Alonso, Mendy…

7 years, 9 months ago31

J0E
Live Scoutcast Tonight at 9pm - Leave your questions here

Live Scoutcast tonight (9pm) Joining me on tonight's show will be David, Andy and FPL General Leave your questions for us here Also make sure you subscribe to our Youtube channel to ensure you …

7 years, 9 months ago114

Geoff
Gameweek 3 Rough with the Smooth

Gameweek 3 Rough with the Smooth Feel free to post your tales of joy and woe from Gameweek 3 here:

7 years, 9 months ago58

Geoff
Scout Pick Community Champion Lottery – Gameweek 4

Scout Pick Community Champion Lottery – Gameweek 4 Once again this year, we will have a champion representing the community to take on the Scout Picks every week with a chance to win a prize at …

7 years, 9 months ago0

flaming_iles
RMT performance

I've posted a few times about my approach this year - I've written a program that selects the best possible team & transfers from the RMT tool. So far, I've got 237 pts (79, 78, 80) with no chips …

7 years, 9 months ago31

Gregor
Short term absences, keep or sell?

Credit to Licious Lizard for this one; Do you think there is any merit in holding players with short term bans/injuries or do they need shipping straight away? Does anyone plan on keeping Richa…

7 years, 9 months ago56

Gregor
The New Suspension Rules

New suspension rules; ‘This season, any cautions players receive will be specific to the competition they were playing in at the time. So, a yellow card in an FA Cup game, for instance, wouldn'…

7 years, 9 months ago16

Celt Abroad
Richarlison Replacements

So the question on many manager’s minds today: who to replace richarlison with? Here’s 5 possibilities: 1. Mkhitaryan- need to find a bit of money to upgrade, but excellent fixtures, in an a…

7 years, 9 months ago96

@ocprodigy
Scout Picks Challenge GW3

SCOUT PICKS CHALLENGE - GAMEWEEK 3 Sorry, on holiday with my family but GW2 results will be available tomorrow! For this week, let's go...! ****** WHAT IS IT? ****** For those of you who haven'…

7 years, 9 months ago39

Ghost Ship
How to work out if a story in the media is reliable

Scout cast had a great idea about a guide to reliable journaslism in the wake of the Guardian’s Aguero nonsense. I was a jouro (not football) for 10 years so thought I’d offer my ten cents on w…

7 years, 9 months ago28

Geoff
Eliteserien GW20 plans

What are you looking to do with your FTs this week? Who is your captain? Now in the final third of the season, how have your goals changed? Are you now looking for differentials? How does your te…

7 years, 9 months ago30

J0E
Breakfast Club launches Sat am

Breakfast Club 11:15am tomorrow. @FPLGeneral , @DavidMunday815 and @FFScout_Joe reveal their GWK 3 line ups and react to the Man City team sheet. Watch the stream via our Youtube channel - https:…

7 years, 9 months ago18

RMT's Professor
RMT model upgrade and HOF

We've spent a bit of time this week working behind the scenes on the code behind the RMT numbers. There are 3 components to the RMT model: the team numbers, the playing probabilities and the play…

7 years, 9 months ago11

J0E
Mark's Wildcard Team Revealed

New Video Mark reveals his Wildcard team https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9JP3gKAVxA

7 years, 9 months ago37

Pierce34
The early template, part 3

A few more thoughts on the idea of templates: of course it was covered a lot more extensively on the earlier hot topic, but another reason people say (complain?) that we already have a small pool o…

7 years, 9 months ago41