Pro Pundit Teams

Why doing nothing is so difficult for FPL managers

After consecutive red arrows and at least a couple of my players having apparently outstayed their welcome, it feels like action is needed with my team and, yet, I’m doing my best to try and do nothing.

Doing nothing should be a perfectly acceptable strategy in Fantasy Premier League, in fact, doing nothing can offer all sorts of advantages, so why is doing nothing so difficult?

One answer might be found in an appropriately-themed study of goalkeepers and penalties conducted by Israeli psychologist Michael Bar-Eli.

Bar-Eli studied hundreds of penalties faced by elite goalkeepers and found that, in attempting to save the penalty, goalkeepers tend to dive left or right about 94% of the time.

Deciding how to make transfers is somewhat similar to goalkeepers having to save penalties

However, crunching the data, Bar-Eli also discovered that about 60% of penalties actually go down the centre of the goal, meaning that, if goalkeepers just remained central instead of diving they would, on average, save more penalties.

Most surprising, however, was the finding that, even after these elite goalkeepers were made aware of these stats, they still continued to dive left or right when facing penalties.

Bar-Eli concluded that this was a manifestation of ‘Action Bias’; a cognitive bias describing an impulse to take action in order to feel ‘in control’ of a situation or problem.

Sometimes, as the goalkeeper study suggests, we prefer to take action even when we know the best strategy is to do nothing and this compulsion is particularly strong when the ‘norm’ or expectation is that we should take action.

In other words; it’s easier to justify action than inaction, and taking action makes us feel better than doing nothing.

Haller has been frustrating to own but I still fancy West Ham’s Gameweek 11 fixture

It’s not hard to see how this bias can manifest itself among Fantasy managers, particularly after a poor Gameweek.

In some respects, it is the psychological basis for ‘knee-jerking’ or transferring players out based on emotion.

Looking at my team, it’s harder to justify keeping the likes of Bournemouth’s Callum Wilson (£8.0m) and West Ham’s Sébastian Haller (£7.4m) after several blanks each than it would be to switch either out for somebody who seems to be in better form, and the compulsion is to do exactly that.

Of course, the flipside to this is that, around this time last week, owners of Leicester’s Ayoze Pérez (£6.1m) would have looked at their teams and thought exactly the same thing.

Now, by no means is Perez scoring a hat-trick conclusive evidence of the benefits of doing nothing but it does offer a timely illustration that doing nothing can really pay off.

I’d say this is more likely to occur if the player in question has a good fixture and, with Wilson hosting a Manchester United team without a clean sheet in five matches and Haller at home to 17th-place Newcastle, hat-tricks might not be on the cards but I wouldn’t bet against them scoring either.

Perhaps more general are the benefits of banking an extra transfer and I’m a big believer in two transfers being exponentially better than one.

Here is how I line up for Gameweek 11

This week, with only one transfer currently available, I have limited forward options to replace Wilson or Haller, none of whom have very compelling fixtures either this week and/or in upcoming Gameweeks, or taking a hit.

If I wait until next week, I get the benefit of my players’ decent fixtures this Gameweek and practically unlimited options for their replacement(s), meaning I can get the player(s) I want, with the fixtures to deliver.

If I’m really lucky, Wilson and Haller hit form, I get some points and I end up with a transfer headache next week.

Ultimately, while too much inertia can be as damaging as too much action, judiciously doing nothing with a view to it paying off over several Gameweeks can be a very viable strategy if you can fight the short term instinct to knee-jerk.

So, this Gameweek, I’m standing still, fingers crossed, hoping that the FPL gods aren’t aiming left or right.

Become a Member and access our data

Memberships for the 2019/20 campaign are now available for the price of £17.50.

Join now to get the following:

  • Plot your transfer strategies using the fully interactive Season Ticker.
  • Get projections for every Premier League player provided by the Rate My Team statistical model.
  • Use Rate My Team throughout the season to guide your selections and transfers.
  • Get access to over 150+ exclusive members articles over the season.
  • Analyse our OPTA-powered statistic tables specifically tailored for Fantasy Football Managers.
  • Use our exclusive tool to build custom stats tables from over 100 OPTA player and team stats.
  • Enjoy our brand NEW Flat-Track Bully feature which introduces an opposition filter to your tables.
  • View heatmaps and expected goals data for every player.
  • Use our powerful comparison tool to analyse players head-to-head.

ALREADY A USER? CLICK HERE TO UPGRADE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT

NEW TO SCOUT? CLICK HERE TO START A MEMBERSHIP ACCOUNT

575 Comments Post a Comment
  1. Wizard of Ozil
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 6 Years
    13 days, 4 hours ago

    How true is this article. sums up FPL perfectly. More often than not, if i forget the transfer deadline, i tend to do better than if i had got rid of players to chase the points elsewhere. Some one needs to chop my fingers off or hide my computer come saturday morning....

  2. JDs123
    • 1 Year
    13 days, 4 hours ago

    Ryan
    Lund-Soyuncu-Tomori
    Sterling-Mane-KDB-Mount
    Vardy-Tammy-Wilson

    Subs: Pope-Rico-Chambers-Saka

    I have 2 FH

    A) Wilson-Saka to TAA-Connolly
    B) Wilson-Saka to Martial-Connolly
    C) Chambers to Lacacells and save 1 transfer
    Any comments?

    1. Devo-McDuff
      • 1 Year
      13 days, 2 hours ago

      I like the look of A, but how would it work? Different positions.

      1. JDs123
        • 1 Year
        12 days, 22 hours ago

        I would do Chambers to TAA and Wilson to Connolly

  3. dylano21
    • 2 Years
    13 days, 1 hour ago

    Which combi would get more points ?

    A. Pukki, Willian, Dsilva
    B. Lundstram, Rashford, Dsilva
    C. Mahrez, Hudson, Pukki
    D. Other combi of these Players

  4. Yoshioka
    • 1 Year
    12 days, 2 hours ago

    Pulisic could be a great FPL option not in 'captain hindsight' or chasing last week's points fashion, but more because he just seems brilliantly greedy.