Captain Sensible
8 November 2019 1114 comments
DavidMunday815 DavidMunday815
Share:

Liverpool and Manchester City’s Sunday afternoon clash has complicated the Gameweek 12 captaincy debate.

Fantasy Premier League managers are largely steering clear of their table-topping premium options this weekend, with a greater focus on the cheaper assets in their teams.

Leicester, Chelsea and Wolves appear to be three sides at the heart of the discussion according to the polls.

As ever, we’re here to assess each candidate on both their own merits over the last four Gameweeks as well as their opponents’ defensive form.

As this article uses extensive data from the Fantasy Football Scout Members Area, only those who have signed up for the 2019/20 season can access it in full.

Captain Poll

It’s been tough keeping this to ourselves and making no comment at all, especially when some of the results have been leaked. Now we know for certain which player has won the captain poll.

We have saved and screenshotted the results which clearly show just one player has emerged as the winner.

It’s ………Jamie Vardy (£9.4m).

The results of this week’s captain poll

The Leicester City forward has been in exceptional form this season and currently sits top of the Golden Boot race with 10 goals.

Seven of those have come since Gameweek 7, where his form has really raced into life from a Fantasy perspective.

Since that 5-0 win over Newcastle, Vardy has averaged 9.6 points per game.

In Gameweek 12 he goes up against an Arsenal defence that has conceded an average of 1.4 goals per away game this season.

Furthermore, Vardy has scored eight times in as many Premier League starts against the Gunners.

All of that has contributed to 39.7% of voters in our poll selecting him as the best captain option for Gameweek 12.

Abraham is the second-most-popular option in the Gameweek 12 captain poll

Tammy Abraham (£7.9m) has his hands on second place with 23.4% of the vote.

This weekend, Chelsea host Crystal Palace in a match that could finally see their number one centre-forward even out the balance between his home and away form.

In the last four Gameweeks, Abraham has four attacking returns although all of those have come on the road.

Will some Fantasy managers be put off by the fact that just two of his 11 attacking returns in 2019/20 have come at Stamford Bridge? Perhaps. We recently did an analysis of this subject in a Members article.

Jiménez (left) is on course for a bronze medal in this captain poll

A long way off in third-place in the captain poll was Raúl Jiménez (£7.2m) who pulled in the support of 5.9% before hosting Aston Villa.

This Midlands rivalry contest could see plenty of goals, especially considering that Dean Smith’s men have conceded an average of 2.2 goals per away match this season.

Meanwhile, Jiménez is enjoying something of a Fantasy renaissance of late with four attacking returns (two goals, two assists), since Gameweek 8.

Despite going six league matches in a row without a goal, Teemu Pukki (£6.8m) is currently fourth in our captain poll with 3.3% of the vote.

That support is probably almost entirely influenced by the fact that Watford have conceded 23 goals this season – the third-worst.

However, it must be highlighted that Quique Sanchez Flores has been slowly improving the Hornets’ back-line recently.

In the last four matches, they have kept two clean sheets and went close to a third against Spurs.

Mané is the most fashionable asset for the captaincy from Liverpool’s next fixture

Sadio Mané (£12.0m) is the most popular asset from Liverpool and Manchester City’s encounter as far as captaincy is concerned.

2.9% of our voters have backed him for the armband and, on closer inspection, it hardly seems a strange decision to do so.

You have to go back to Gameweek 3 for the last time that Mané failed to register attacking returns in a home game.

Since then he scored 15 points against Newcastle, notched up a 12-point haul when Leicester came to Anfield and earned a penalty against Spurs in Gameweek 10 for five points.

Meanwhile, Manchester City’s defence has raised some eyebrows of late and they could also be without goalkeeper Ederson (£6.1m) on Sunday afternoon after he picked up an injury midweek.

There isn’t much backing for other cast members for this potentially title-deciding clash. 1.7% have voted for Sergio Aguero (£12.0m), 1.3% for Raheem Sterling (£12.1m), 1.1% for Mohamed Salah (£12.3m) and 0.9% for Kevin de Bruyne (£10.2m).

Harry Kane (£10.8m), Anthony Martial (£7.6m), Christian Pulisic (£7.3m), Todd Cantwell (£4.7m), John Lundstram (£4.8m), Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang (£11.0m) and Marcus Rashford (£8.5m) are the other options on more than 1% support.

Player statistics – Last four Gameweeks

1,114 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. JELLYFISH
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Still deliberating over who to swap Otamendi out for.

    My other back 4 is the familiar quartet of TAA, Lindy, Rico, Soy....and even without Ota deciding who to play/bench from these 4 has been a bit of a mare in recent GW's. (for example, I've missed both Soy hauls from the last 2 GW's having benched him). So, adding a 5th option (i.e. Tomori) is only going to add to the selection dilemma!

    So, my thinking is...go with these 4 defenders and swap Ota out for a cheap as chips defender. Allows strengthening in other key areas.

    Thoughts?

    1. GoonerByron
      7 years, 12 days ago

      I done that exact thing, Ota -> 4.0 (Could even do 3.9!)

    2. A19
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Yep, that's what I did and brought in Reid. It burns a spot on the bench but realistically how often do we have to use the 3 bench players?

      1. JELLYFISH
        7 years, 12 days ago

        I was looking at Reid as a 3.9 option too.

    3. Gregor
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Maybe get a Villa fullback, very benchable and cheap, but have a good fixture when Liverpool blank.

      1. JELLYFISH
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Guilberts an option at 4.4, but 4.3 was my ceiling (strategic, to enable a way in for Son > KDB if needed)

        1. Gregor
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • Has Moderation Rights
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Janmaat looks a great price if that’s your ceiling.

    4. Maximus Bonimus Pointimus
      7 years, 12 days ago

      I couldn't bring myself to swap Ota to a cheapie (Lascelles or Saissrotation looked good) to pave the way for Lundy starting every week - I went for Chilwell as the extra ~1.5m just wasn't buying me anything extra across my front 7 - I still have another 0.5 surplus even with below XI & bench FFS

      Pope
      TAA, Robbo, Chilwell
      Salah, KDB, Martial, Mount, Maddison
      Vardy, Tammy
      (Button, Lundy, Conolly, Rico)

      Might eventually buy a backup keeper with the extra 0.5, or upgrade Popey for GW15

      1. JELLYFISH
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Nice team

    5. MikeRyko
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Agree, although I'd try to find a playing defender in case they are ever needed off the bench (esp with one eye on TAA blank in a few weeks).

      There's plenty of 4.4 options that look fine to me or maybe even a 4.3 from Watford.

      1. JELLYFISH
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Thanks all for your thoughts. Was looking a Janmaat as a playing option at 4.3

  2. Weasel Boy
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Pool v Ciyy Result?

    1-2 to city.

    Pools defence is too leaky this season unfortunately and I'm a Liverpool fan.

    1. Begbie.
      7 years, 12 days ago

      draw

    2. Bavarian
      7 years, 12 days ago

      0-0

      1. FPL Daniel
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Sterling brace

    3. ElliotJHP
      7 years, 12 days ago

      2-1, who to I am unsure

    4. Lukey27
      7 years, 12 days ago

      4-2

    5. redsallstars
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      2-0

    6. Pipermaru
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      3-1

  3. Zimo
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Why isn't Trossard starting? He's been back for 3 gameweeks.

    1. HamezMace
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Form of Connolly I guess

  4. IN SANE IN DE BRUYNE
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Good to go here?

    Gazzaniga
    Trent Robbo Rico Lord
    Salah(VC) Sterling KDB Tielemans
    Vardy(C) Abraham

    (4.0 Soyuncu Cantwell Greenwood)

    1. Come on you Kante
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Same mid and attack as me think they will score well this week like the defence not sure what the pool city game will bring

  5. GoonerByron
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Good luck to any fellow Martial (C)!

    1. Bruce Lee
      7 years, 12 days ago

      check the statistycs

      1. GoonerByron
        7 years, 12 days ago

        He’s second in the RMT Tool listings above?

  6. Maximus Bonimus Pointimus
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Salah (c) is tempting me
    Vardy (c) is tempting me
    Martial (c) is tempting me
    Lundstram bench is tempting me

    Love having these type of selection dilemmas 🙂

    1. IN SANE IN DE BRUYNE
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Triple captain

      1. Maximus Bonimus Pointimus
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Imagine the Triple captain chip allowed you to captain 3 players instead of trebling one player's score

        1. IN SANE IN DE BRUYNE
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Yeah that would be something!

        2. YEAH PITCH!
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Cool idea

        3. Warby84
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Eliteserien do the Attack Attack chip where all 3 strikers are Cpt.. That would be fun

    2. n-doggg
      7 years, 12 days ago

      I’m on salah. Although I wouldn’t hold much in that as I’ve only got the C pick right twice all season...

      1. Camzy
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Maybe picks like this is why...

        Salah is a pretty poor pick this week imo. Not only did he have a dismal record vs other top 6 teams last season, he's in poor form.

        1. Maximus Bonimus Pointimus
          7 years, 12 days ago

          I'm not sure city will have it in them to park a bus at anfield - with a 35 year old DM at centreback, partnered by either a shaky stones or an even shakier Ota - and especially when their flanked by fullbacks who don't know if they're even going to be playing from one week to the next i could see goals coming - Penalties sweeten the deal.

          If Ederson is out its a go i think

          But yeah its not a form pick at all

          1. Pep Pig
            7 years, 12 days ago

            Are you not put off how he didn't take him off during the week? Before that game Klopp had said Salah can't do more than 65 mins with the ankle. Maybe he was proving his fitness more than anything, but I was hoping he'd get subbed late on. I captained him last week 🙁

          2. Bennerman
            7 years, 12 days ago

            They're

            It's

            I wouldn't normally bother bit you've been such a know-it-all in the past.

            1. Bennerman
              7 years, 12 days ago

              For Boner btw

              1. Maximus Bonimus Pointimus
                7 years, 12 days ago

                Take the apostrophes up with Kondraske & Feinson & the other predictive text trailblazers 🙂

                I think the majority are in the right place though?

                [* = correct usage ** = angry email from Bennerman??]

                I'm* not sure city will have it in them to park a bus at anfield - with a 35 year old DM at centreback, partnered by either a shaky stones or an even shakier Ota - and especially when their flanked by fullbacks who don't* know if they're* even going to be playing from one week to the next i could see goals coming - Penalties sweeten the deal.

                If Ederson is out its** a go i think

                But yeah its not a form pick at all

        2. Corgz Dark side of the Loon
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Agree with this..……..not convinced his ankle is 100% and was surprised to see him play midweek.

          1. FPL Daniel
            7 years, 12 days ago

            Triple captain should definitely be captaining 3 players.

            Also we need all attack chip when all attacking returns will be counted twice, all defense chip when all CS pts (mids included) will be doubled such as the park the bus chip.

            We need changes

            1. Warby84
              7 years, 12 days ago

              I think Park the bus was too powerful, I think attack attack chip (front 3 only) and 2 cap chip are very good..

  7. Letsgo!
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Guys out of cantwell willian mount,

    Which two should i start?

    Will mount or willian start?

    1. IN SANE IN DE BRUYNE
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Willian Mount

  8. simong1
    7 years, 12 days ago

    A or B with a FT?

    A) Wilson (new) > Jimenez (AVL)
    B) Mount (CRY) > Martial (BHA) (already have Tammy)

  9. The Chosen One...
    7 years, 12 days ago

    are people benching the highest scoring defender this week?

    1. ⭐ Bemba_Da ⭐
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Yes, need to adapt to situations and play him at the right time

    2. Gregor
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      7 years, 12 days ago

      I am.

    3. Holmes
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Dont even have him 😎

    4. HamezMace
      7 years, 12 days ago

      SHU are 19th in the bookies clean sheet odds this week.
      If people are playing him it’s probably more on hope of more attacking returns, which of course is possible.

      1. JohnnyCroat
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Being the only reason also to own *any* Liverpool defenders... But a lot of critics of lower placed teams tend to gloss over defensive failings at the top because 2-1 to go 7 clear is perfectly fine and doesn't at all flag possible problems within the team's overall approach to game day.

        TAA, Rico, Lordstram my back 3 this weekend... One clean sheet expected, 3 goals 😛

        1. HamezMace
          7 years, 12 days ago

          it’s true.
          None of the ‘big’ teams are filling me with confidence about their defensive abilities.

          I suppose Allison was out for a few weeks, and City have problems with injuries at centre back too, but I was never keen on big at the back anyway.

          1. JohnnyCroat
            7 years, 12 days ago

            I had Robbo and VVD last season. This year I went wide and it's Robbo and TAA. Lordstram my 3rd. Rico and Mendy recently added. I've moved away from a defensive backline and now I have 5 players capable of regular attacking returns. I feel it's why I'm green arrows mostly.

      2. Eat Sleep FPL Repeat
        7 years, 12 days ago

        Where can you get clean sheet odds of all teams without going through each game one after the other?

      3. FPL Daniel
        7 years, 12 days ago

        He can score

        1. HamezMace
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Isn’t that what I said?

  10. Atimis
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Have following question regarding my team, all thoughts appreciated 😉

    1) Mount to Pulisic for free or keep FT?
    2) Changes to bench and (c)?

    Pope
    TAA/Tomori/Rico
    Mane/KDB/Maddison/Mount*
    Auba/Vardy(c)/Tammy

    Button/Lund/Soy/Hayden

  11. FPL Mentor
    7 years, 12 days ago

    A or B for one week punt.

    A. Azpi & Maddi (already have Vardy, Pulisic, Abraham)
    B. Pereira & Richarlison (already have Vardy and Digne)

  12. Pep Roulette
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Need some suggestions!

    1 FT 1 ITB

    Gazza
    TAA Robbo Lundy Rico
    Salah Martial DSilva*
    Kun Abraham(C) Jiminez

    Button Yarmolenko* Dendo Reid

    1. HamezMace
      7 years, 12 days ago

      David Silva to a Leicester midfielder

  13. n-doggg
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Thoughts on the Sheffield double up in defence?

    Want to spend up to 4.8

    A. O’Connell
    B. Tomori
    C. Willems
    D. Janmat

    1. Gregor
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Seems sensible.

  14. Cilliant
    7 years, 12 days ago

    A) Dilva -> Son (-4)
    B) Dilva -> Martial (-4)
    C) Play Soy
    D) Any other advice

    Pope
    Robbo, Lund, Rico
    Mane, KDB, Maddie, Dilva*
    Vardy(c), Tammy, Jimi

    Button, Soy, Stephens, Kelly

    3.1M ITB

    1. IN SANE IN DE BRUYNE
      7 years, 12 days ago

      C

    2. redsallstars
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      A, think Son will haul this week

    3. Cilliant
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Thanks both!

  15. Dannywaz
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Pope
    Taa Robbo tomori
    Mount madds sterling mane
    Jim Tammy vardy
    Mcgovern Lund soy donks
    Gtg ?

    1. Noé Pamarot
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Yep, all good.

  16. n-doggg
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Any word on Mount?

    1. ⭐ Bemba_Da ⭐
      7 years, 12 days ago

      trained yesterday, fitness test today

    2. Gregor
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Trained I believe and in the England squad, Lampard press conference later today.

    3. Corgz Dark side of the Loon
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      I hope he plays but Frank takes him off after 70 mins and the ankle stops him playing for England and has a full rest over two weeks.....England don't need him as we only need one point in two games.

  17. SpaceCadet
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Anything worth a hit here? Maybe mount out for son/ martial/ pulisic?

    pope
    taa rico lund
    mane kdb Maddison mount
    vardy tammy jimmy

    button soy dunk dendo

    1. MikeRyko
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Only if Mount confirmed out - which seems unlikely at the moment.

  18. Lord Flashheart
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Bench one:

    A sir Lundy (tot)
    B chilwell (ARS)
    C Tomori (CPL)
    D TAA (MCI)

    1. Noé Pamarot
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Chilwell...but it's a tough one.

    2. firstade
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      I'm benching A out of those.

    3. A19
      7 years, 12 days ago

      A

    4. JohnBlack
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Tomori

    5. redsallstars
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      A

  19. Sj3451
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Auba + Douglas Luiz > Jimenez + Martial for a -4 worth it?

    1. Pep Roulette
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Yes

  20. FOO FIGHTER
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Mctom out for UTD? Probably their best midfielder.

    I just cannot see myself taking any chances on UTD assets.

    Europa League nothing to go by compared to the EPL. That already points to staying clear 🙂

    1. ChelseaGuy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      He's been really good this season. Think that makes Martial less attractive (as an FPL option of course)

  21. MikeLowrey
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Thoughts on one of the below as a 1 week punt:

    A) Wickham & Salah to martial & Vardy (-4). WC next week

    Pope
    TAA VVD Tomori
    Sterling KDB Martial CHO
    Wilson Abraham Vardy
    (Button soyuncu lundstram Cantwell)

    B) Sterling & Wickham to Pulisic & Vardy (-4). WC next week

    Pope
    TAA VVD Tomori
    Salah KDB Pulisic CHO
    Wilson Abraham Vardy
    (Button Soyuncu Lundstram Cantwell)

    C) Move around the edges and save my WC for later

  22. Bavarian
    7 years, 12 days ago

    bench one:
    A-Soyuncu
    B-Lundstram
    C-Yarmolenko

    1. A19
      7 years, 12 days ago

      A

    2. Tonyawesome69
      7 years, 12 days ago

      A

    3. redsallstars
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      B

  23. PlayPercentage
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Salah 1% captaincy choice is interesting. He could be a massive differential if those figures are reflected amongst all FPL players.
    - Playing at Anfield, against the second-string City keeper and a makeshift back four.
    - Salah stats for shots per game are good.
    - On penalties.
    Could be worth a punt.

    1. Camzy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Poor form, poor record vs top 6 teams. Not for me.

      I'd rather go Mane if I want to punt on that game but it's not like we're short of decent options. Vardy and Abraham both look sharper and have better fixtures.

  24. The Train Driver
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Xhaka stripped of his (C), Auba new (C). Morale boost? Worried non owner...

  25. Tsparkes10
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Kane and son captainers... Brace yourselves, people tried it with Salah and then tried it with Aubam. Surely you've learnt by now 😉

    1. ElliotJHP
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Don't think there are many tbf mate!

    2. The Train Driver
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Shef Utd very solid, Spurs still far from their best and away game. Very stupid to C Spurs players, agree....

      1. ChelseaGuy
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        7 years, 12 days ago

        It's a home game?

        1. HamezMace
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Think it would be called off if it was in Sheffield this weekend

        2. The Train Driver
          7 years, 12 days ago

          Oh, my bad

  26. Jindaljain
    7 years, 12 days ago

    I have transferred in Dele Alli & transferred out Mount

    1. ElliotJHP
      7 years, 12 days ago

      ...I've made a huge mistake

      1. Jindaljain
        7 years, 12 days ago

        I m having a great intuition that Alli will score more points

    2. jtreble
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Ouch. Sorry mate.

    3. niko mate
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Might be a good move. I think about Mount > Pulisic

  27. BigBillyBass
    7 years, 12 days ago

    How's she looking? G2G?

    Pope
    TAA Lord Lundstram Soy
    Sterling KDB Mane Tielemans Mount*
    Vardy(c) Tammy

    Bench: Rico Tomori Connolly

    1. Tonyawesome69
      7 years, 12 days ago

      g2g

  28. A19
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Pondering this for GW13, thoughts?

    Sterling, Tomori -> Son, Robertson

    Would give me

    TAA Robbo Lund
    Mane KdB Son Martial Mount
    Tammy Vardy

    1. GreennRed
      7 years, 12 days ago

      I wouldn't be getting Robertson without an improvement in Liverpool clean sheets.

  29. Tonyawesome69
    7 years, 12 days ago

    g2g?

    1ft 0.6itb
    pope
    TAA lundy rico willem
    mane sterling KDB mount
    abraham vardy (c)

    ryan CHO dunk connolly

    1. ChelseaGuy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      If Lamp says Mount is fit then Yes, else play CHO

  30. UnitednationsXI
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    7 years, 12 days ago

    Stupidly brought in Martial over Maddison. The 0.2m could have been useful in a transfer I had in mind. Any suggestions on how to bring in mane and robbo in this team? got 0m itb

    Pope
    Taa Tomori Rico -- Lundy Lascelles
    Sterling Kdb Martial Mount -- Cantwell
    Tammy Vardy Rashford

    I am 0.2m short of Sterling + Lascelles + Rashford >> Mane + Robbo + Ings grrr

    1. Camzy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Just straight swap Sterling > Mane. Easy.

    2. MikeRyko
      7 years, 12 days ago

      Wouldn't bother with Liverpool defence double up - hasn't really worked this season I don't think.

      As above Sterling to Mane or maybe even Martial & Rashford to Mane and a cheapie.