Selection
18 October 2017 3086 comments
davidwardale davidwardale
Share:

It is almost inevitable that Manchester City should dominate the hearts and minds of the Scout Picks selection panel this week.

The relentless tide of goals from Pep Guardiola’s men is difficult to ignore, so they haven’t. However, that won’t stop the debate from raging, with the foursome split on the chosen striker. Friday will be heated.

Elsewhere, there are shoo-ins and tactical votes to review, while after a Gameweek 8 drubbing for the panel, we reveal the latest community member to take on our pundits.

Paul Jonty Mark Peter
Goalkeepers Rob Elliot Joe Hart Joe Hart David de Gae
Lukasz Fabianski Jack Butland Jack Butland Joe Hart
Joe Hart Fraser Forster Rob Elliot Lukasz Fabianski
Defenders Marcos Alonso Phil Jones Phil Jones Nicolas Otamendi
Kyle Walker Cesar Azpilicueta Marcos Alonso Phil Jones
Phil Jones Ben Davies Aaron Cresswell Aaron Cresswell
Aaron Cresswell Aaron Cresswell Nicolas Otamendi Ryan Bertand
Cedric Soares Cedric Soares Virgil van Dijk Kyle Naughton
Midfielders Raheem Sterling Raheem Sterling Raheem Sterling Raheem Sterling
David Silva David Silva Eric Choupo-Moting Christian Eriksen
Eden Hazard Christian Eriksen David Silva Mohamed Salah
Eric Choupo-Moting Wilfried Zaha Mohamed Salah Wilfried Zaha
Michail Antonio Eric Choupo-Moting Henrikh Mkhitaryan Matt Ritchie
Forwards Sergio Aguero Romelu Lukaku Sergio Aguero Romelu Lukaku
Alvaro Morata Alvaro Morata Romelu Lukaku Gabriel Jesus
Harry Kane Gabriel Jesus Harry Kane Harry Kane
Romelu Lukaku Tammy Abraham Alvaro Morata Tammy Abraham
Tammy Abraham Jamie Vardy Tammy Abraham Manolo Gabbiadini

Paul says…

Starting at the back, I’m endorsing the West Ham defence to claim a clean sheet at home to Brighton on Friday night, with Aaron Cresswell’s steady supply of crosses down the left earning him my nomination.

Only Spurs and Arsenal produced more shut-outs at home last season than Slaven Bilic’s side (eight). This term, they’ve kept out their opponents twice in three at the London Stadium, with only Spurs finding the net against them.

Having opened his account for the season last week, Michail Antonio – who fired more shots on target than any player in Gameweek 8 – offers a differential option, with less than 1% ownership.

A double-up on the Man City midfield looks viable, with Raheem Sterling’s goal threat and David Silva’s creativity making a very persuasive case.

Yet having been benched for the last two in all competitions, Sergio Aguero is my top forward pick – he looks likely to earn a recall as he goes in search of their all-time scoring record at home to Burnley.

Elsewhere, Stoke’s Eric Choupo-Moting and Swansea striker Tammy Abraham boast strong home fixtures and will both set you back under 6.0.

Choupo-Moting has fired more shots inside the box than any midfielder at home ahead of a visit from Bournemouth. He’s already bagged a brace against Man United at the bet365.

And Abraham has served up 21 points in his last two at the Liberty, courtesy of three goals and six bonus. The youngster has played a part in 80% of his side’s goals and hosts a Leicester City side in freefall and disrupted by the sacking of Craig Shakespeare.

Jonty says…

A key factor in our heavy defeat to Gameweek 8 community champion Mine n Tatties was our hesitation in investing in Manchester City attackers ahead of their 7-2 hammering of Stoke at the Etihad. While he went for three – Leroy Sane, Raheem Sterling and Gabriel Jesus – we cautiously only opted for the England winger.

I advocated doubling up on the City midfield last week with both David Silva and Sterling, and I’m doing the same again this time around. Following early substitutions against Napoli in the Champions League, this pair look among the surest starters and racked up a total of 22 points last week alone.

I’m not stopping there though in my adoration of Guardiola’s troops, as I’d also like to see Gabriel Jesus, who has scored six in the league, involved. For me, he still looks a better bet for a start over Sergio Aguero, who has been recovering from a rib injury and was an unused substitute for City’s last two games.

There should be enough in the bank to afford this attacking City trio should I win the argument that Harry Kane can be swerved for Liverpool’s visit.

The Spurs striker has yet to score in the league at Wembley, with team after team managing to shackle him on its expansive surface. Will Jurgen Klopp bring a Kane-halting bus, to follow the lead of Swansea, Burnley and Bournemouth?

The German certainly has bus driving form, with the London side failing to score more than one goal in any of their five Liverpool clashes since he took charge in October 2015.

If any Spurs player is likely to break down the Reds resistance, it is more likely to be another of my midfield picks, Christian Eriksen, whose guile in the final third ensured he got the better of the Cherries’ defensive resolve at the weekend.

I’m also backing Chelsea striker Alvaro Morata to earn his fourth double-digit haul when Watford drop by Stamford Bridge. He looks a far better prospect than Kane this week, and substantially cheaper, too.

Elsewhere, Swansea’s Tammy Abraham, who earned 13 points last week, is among my top value picks, particularly as Liberty Stadium visitors, manager-less Leicester, have only claimed one shut-out in their last four.

Another budget selection I’d like to see in our final XI is Crystal Palace’s Wilfried Zaha, who travels to a Newcastle side that last kept a clean sheet in Gameweek 4.

Peter says…

At the time of writing, a lack of cast-iron insight on FPL’s top performing asset – Sergio Aguero – means that we have to speculate even more than usual.

City, of course, continue to dominate everyone’s thoughts, with that 7-2 pummelling of Stoke fresh in our minds as a very open Burnley side, missing its first choice keeper, rolls up at the Etihad. Only Pep dictates his players’ game-time, so I am in no position to criticise anyone’s speculations or choices for City players, just so long as our squads are maxed out on Sky Blues. I’ve gone for Sterling and Jesus once again and resisted the powerful temptation to triple up on their attack by slotting Nicolas Otamendi in.

The other half of Manchester also looks likely to get back on the scoring trail against a struggling Huddersfield Town side with just one goal from their last six games. I love a defensive double up, so David De Gea and Phil Jones join Romelu Lukaku as Manchester devours my notional budget.

The team which struggles to score at home (three goals in four games) takes on the team which can’t keep a clean sheet away from home (eleven goals conceded in four games) when Spurs host Liverpool on Sunday. The only time my loyalties strayed from Harry Kane he paid me back with a brace, so this time I am backing him, the in-form Christian Eriksen and the Reds’ Mohamed Salah to profit from a high-scoring game at Wembley.

Elsewhere, Newcastle looked a shoo-in at home to Crystal Palace before the Eagles’ rose up against Chelsea last weekend to claim their first win. This is a tough one to call, but two mid-price midfielders could well get among the points in the form of Matt Ritchie and the talismanic Wilfried Zaha.

In truth, that means I need to scour some of the less fashionable teams in order to afford such a rich spine, and I’ll be forced to go into hiding when Chelsea host Watford in the lunchtime kick-off on Saturday.

Mark Says…

The headline news is that I’m backing Aguero.

I love to speculate and theorise and, unlike some who see Guardiola’s decision to keep Aguero benched in the last two as indication of a new pecking order, I see it as the City boss keeping the striker under wraps specifically for Burnley’s visit.

Aguero needs a single goal to break the club’s scoring record. Guardiola has previously stated that he wants to celebrate such an event and he’ll surely want the goal to arrive the Etihad.

With City sharing the goal pie all season, I see Aguero starting with the star-studded supporting cast determined to hand the Argentine the opportunity to reach his milestone.

Elsewhere Raheem Sterling and David Silva are in the mix, though I’ve strategically promoted Stoke City’s Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting up my ranks in order to reinforce his Scout Picks credentials. I like his home form and Bournemouth, as we’ve seen, can prove obliging opponents. Unless you’re Spurs at Wembley, of course.

The Community Champion

Representing the Community against the Scout Picks in Gameweek will be Oddjobleff, who is in his fifth campaign, with last season’s impressive finish of 398 his best to date.

The community champion who has the best lead over the Scouts during 2017/18 will win a £100 Amazon voucher (currently we can only offer Amazon.co.uk or Amazon.com vouchers).

Gameweek 8’s champion Mince n Tatties, beat the Scouts 56 to 39, however, the champion to beat remains Gregor, who achieved victory over the Scouts by a 33-point margin in Gameweek 5.

3,086 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. Transferred Out
    9 years, 22 days ago

    I have doubts for both Bavies and Luiz and don't have Jones in my team. Which would you transfer out if any?

    1. Demel
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Jones didn't start yesterday. I would hold bringing him in if I didn't own him until next week.

      1. J T
        9 years, 22 days ago

        He hasn't played any CL this season he will play the weekend

    2. Whats the Mata?
      9 years, 22 days ago

      ‘After the first half the doctor told me David Luiz had a pain in his calf, and the same for Bakayoko in his groin. It was a good decision to try to protect him. In this moment it’s very important to protect the players.

      ‘We must realise we had three important players out, Kante, Drinkwater and Moses, and this gives us problems, but I am not looking for excuses now. I tried an extra defender to protect more the team, but in terms of the style and system I want to see, it must always be the same.’

      Luiz should be good for the weekend imo

  2. Saïss Doesn't Mat…
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Fernandez or Naughton or a coin throw??

  3. Ask Yourself
    9 years, 22 days ago

    What’s this jones injury about? He’ll be back the weekend surely

    1. Sims
      9 years, 22 days ago

      usual mourinho nonsense. not even concerned as an owner

    2. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Mourinho rubbish. Could well not start but he was on the bench so can’t have been that bad.

    3. Lazaretti
      9 years, 22 days ago

      I think Mourinho told before UCL game that it is not difficult to predict ManU line up in UCL game.

  4. HD7
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Do you think I should play Fab and Simpson in the same match and hope they finish 0:0 or just play Elliot?

    1. Demel
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Play the keeper you think will score the most points regardless of the rest of your squad.

    2. GoonerByron
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Wouldn’t play Elliot over Fabianski regardless of Simpson...

    3. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Palace seem to have that buzz back. Leicester were woeful and lacked any creativity against a defensive West Brom. I’m doubling on swans due to mini league rivals. Back Fab

  5. kime67
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Firmino best captain pick for gw 10?

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 22 days ago

      No salah is

    2. Costa Nostra
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Lol!

    3. Over Midwicket
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Never again

  6. SouthCoastSaint
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Own Davies, jones, RLC and Bony

    Bony to Abraham a no brainer? And hope mourinho is messing around with jones again.

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Sounds good

  7. GoonerByron
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Already own Sterling, Sane or Silva for the double up? (mkhi out)

    1. Zareos
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Silva more nailed, Sane more explosive. Depends on how safe you like to play things.

    2. Whats the Mata?
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Silva

    3. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 22 days ago

      I'm personally going sane if anyone but silva is the smart choice

    4. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Sane shown he can deliver on lack of minutes. Be a rogue

    5. agueroooooney
      9 years, 22 days ago

      I have Sane but after him playing 90 in CL I am not confident about husband minutes this week, Silva much safer

  8. Zareos
    9 years, 22 days ago

    What would you do this week?

    A. Davies to Otamendi,
    B. Mooy to Richarilson,
    C. Davies and Mooy to Suttner and Sterling (-4), or
    D. Save (and hope that one of Davies and Mooy starts this week).

    1. agueroooooney
      9 years, 22 days ago

      A

    2. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 22 days ago

      B

  9. Foozeball
    9 years, 22 days ago

    What's the deal with Jones being listed as injured even though he was apparently well enough to be on the bench yesterday? >.>

  10. bigbudgie
    9 years, 22 days ago

    KDB still not in any teams around here
    Owned by 18.3% of teams though...
    No one considering?

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Terrific player not good fantasy asset at 10M

    2. Sims
      9 years, 22 days ago

      owned mostly be dead teams

    3. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Best player in the league this season. But for 10m doesnt deliver the explosive returns Sterling and sane have been delivering at much cheaper prices

    4. Over Midwicket
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Awful value

  11. agueroooooney
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Predicted minutes for Morata and Aguero this week?

    60 and 20?

    1. Sims
      9 years, 22 days ago

      20 each depending on the score. don't expect either to start

      1. StayoutheSpiceZone
        9 years, 22 days ago

        Morata will start 100%

    2. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      60, 60

    3. Over Midwicket
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Morata will 100% start. Chelsea have looked awful without him

    4. Tufe
      9 years, 22 days ago

      80, 90.
      At least Morata starts, just remember how well it went last time with Batsuayi.

    5. J T
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Morata Will 100% start.

  12. C'mon the Fylde
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Would you captain Sterling or Jesus for this weekend?

    1. Whats the Mata?
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Kun could start too.

      1. C'mon the Fylde
        9 years, 22 days ago

        I've left him out this week. I have Kane, Chicharito and Jesus up front.

        1. Whats the Mata?
          9 years, 22 days ago

          I meant Jesus could be benched for Kun

    2. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      With guardiolas rotation id be nervous captaining either

    3. 1 Flew Over Lukakus Nest
      9 years, 22 days ago

      sterling for sure, jesus more at risk of coming off on 60. Sterling usually gets longer pitch time, and just take a look at his recent hauls, great pick

  13. LD
    9 years, 22 days ago

    I've got Bellerin in my team, but a bit skeptical of Arsenal's defense. Think they can keep a clean sheet against Everton? and keep him.

    1. AttackAttackAttack
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Same thinking with kola. Everton have been poor and Swansea next. Get rid for gameweek 11 against citeh.

  14. Rash
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Can I get away with saving my transfer?

    Elliot
    Davies Jones naughton hegazi
    Eriksen sané richarlison
    Kaku Kane morata

    Lössl tcarroll mbemba RLC

    1ft 1.5itb cheers

    1. The Wizard of Ozil
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Yes.

    2. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Yep

    3. Dreaming of glory
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Yea but hegazi to someone who might keep a clean sheet would be nice unless u have something else planned u need a double up for next week

  15. Danstoke82
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Morning all, current team:

    Elliot (Foster)
    Alonso Bavies Naughton
    Eriksen Salah Silva Carroll
    Kane Jesus (c) Joselu

    subs: Foster Mee Rosenior Chalobah

    £1.1ITB 1FT

    Stuck on the following

    a) Jesus > Aguero or Morata
    b) Eriksen or Salah > Hazard
    c) Save FT

    Many thanks in advance

    1. agueroooooney
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Hazard a definite gamble to pick

    2. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Save

  16. J T
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Anyone know what's up with Rashford? Mourinho say anything?

    1. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Knee injury. No news yet

  17. HD7
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Should I play Simpson or Tarroll this week?

    1. SouthCoastSaint
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Tarroll

    2. Over Midwicket
      9 years, 22 days ago

      TC

  18. balint84
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Who should I buy?

    A) Jones (ok vs Hudders but not ok later)
    B) Hazard (was ok in CL, but not sure in PL)
    C) David Luiz (cheapest Chelsea def)
    D) KDB (have Sterling and Jesus but he's good for many assists)

    1. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Hazard

    2. nkhoughton
      9 years, 22 days ago

      A & B both great options

  19. Foozeball
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Who is expected to play in Duffy's place for Brighton? Hunemeier?

  20. Kevtheotter
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Hey guys

    Would love some help on the below.

    Elliot
    Alonso Jones Cresswell
    Eriksen Sterling Ritchie Brady
    Lukaku Kane Vardy

    Foster Carroll Naughton Mbemba 1FT 0.4 ITB

    A) Kane to Aguero/Morata
    B) Brady to Choupo
    C) Save

    Cheers!

    1. jg7u
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 22 days ago

      B

    2. agueroooooney
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Looking at A potentially myself, very hard to call

    3. nkhoughton
      9 years, 22 days ago

      B

  21. Beatle
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Alli & Vardy to Sterling and Morata for a -4?

    1. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Just the first one

      1. Beatle
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        9 years, 22 days ago

        Why not Morata?

        1. Kevtheotter
          9 years, 22 days ago

          Not worth the hit for Vardy. If it’s for free ok but not -4.

  22. Tmel
    9 years, 22 days ago

    How would you rank the following for the next few weeks?

    1. Daniels
    2. Sakho
    3. Mee
    4. Fernandez
    5. Dunk
    6. Wimmer

    1. Balance
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Daniels first Wimmer last

      Everyone else no difference

  23. Flynny
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Anyone captaining hazard?

    Between hazard Jesus and Kane for me...

    And there should be goals in the Chelsea Watford match.....

    Worried about Jesus minutes and kane home form...

    1. nkhoughton
      9 years, 22 days ago

      o/

  24. MAVER!CK
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Bavies Alonso VVD Ward Mbemba
    Choupo Ritchie Eriksen Sterling Chalobah
    Lukaku Kane Vardy
    1FT 0.0ITB
    Thinking of taking Alonso out for Ota, they've been drinking goals like Heineken lately. Or should I hold? Any other glaring errors?

    1. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 22 days ago

      I think you can save

  25. ponsio22
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Which one?

    Gross
    Max Chupo
    Knockheart
    Shaqiri

    1. Distinctly Average
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Gross

  26. smix
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Will aguero play 90 mins against Burnley ?

    1. Eze Really?
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Ask Pep

    2. Squashed
      9 years, 22 days ago

      common sense says no.
      30-20min cameo will likely see him start the next gw.
      no cameo no evidence

      1. tokara
        9 years, 22 days ago

        this

  27. Captain Kakaroto (I blame R…
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Where is the guy that tell which time the presser's?

    1. nkhoughton
      9 years, 22 days ago

      Usually a hot topic if there is

  28. Blanka
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Kane to Aguero?

    Bit reluctant, but it will also allow Chalobah to be upgraded to Zaha. Does this make it worth it?

    1. tokara
      9 years, 22 days ago

      no

      1. Blanka
        9 years, 22 days ago

        So Aguero and Zaha will not score more than Kane alone?

  29. HD7
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Newcastle vs Palace
    Swansea vs Leicester

    Play:
    A) Fab, Tarroll
    B) Elliot, Simpson
    C) Fab, Simpson and hope for 0:0

  30. OzilFozzil
    9 years, 22 days ago

    Is Davies > Otamendi a good move?

    Yay or Nay?