FPL Rate My Team surgery with five-time top 1k finisher Tom Freeman

FPL GW17 Scout Picks

Kelleher

O’Reilly
Senesi
van Hecke
Hincapie

Saka
Semenyo
Foden
Schade

Haaland
Ekitiké

Dubravka
Andersen
Miley
Kroupi

GW17 Captain Poll

Price Change Predictions

Risers

Fallers

Player	Team	Price	Progress	Tonight
Semenyo	BOU	7.6m	137.5%	Very Likely
Bowen	WHU	7.5m	103.1%	Very Likely
Marc Guiu	CHE	4.2m	98.3%	Likely
Haaland	MCI	15.0m	86.3%	Likely
B.Fernandes	MUN	9.3m	56.9%	Likely
Truffert	BOU	4.5m	88.7%	Maybe
Verbruggen	BHA	4.4m	82.4%	Maybe
Rogers	AVL	7.1m	42.4%	Unlikely
Keane	EVE	4.6m	81.5%	Unlikely
Guéhi	CRY	5.3m	50.9%	Unlikely
Evanilson	BOU	7.0m	50.2%	Unlikely
Watkins	AVL	8.5m	83.5%	Unlikely
Ballard	SUN	4.6m	75.8%	Unlikely
Wilson	FUL	5.7m	13.4%	Unlikely
Cherki	MCI	6.5m	51.6%	Unlikely
Andersen	FUL	4.6m	72.5%	Unlikely
Senesi	BOU	4.9m	13.7%	Unlikely
Petrović	BOU	4.5m	66.5%	Unlikely
Calvert-Lewin	LEE	5.7m	24.0%	Unlikely
O'Reilly	MCI	5.3m	31.4%	Unlikely
Cunha	MUN	7.9m	54.4%	Unlikely
Dalot	MUN	4.4m	66.4%	Unlikely
Mitchell	CRY	5.0m	70.4%	Unlikely
Chalobah	CHE	5.5m	30.2%	Unlikely
Raya	ARS	6.0m	64.3%	Unlikely
Tete	FUL	4.5m	62.4%	Unlikely
L.Miley	NEW	4.4m	49.6%	Unlikely
Van den Berg	BRE	4.5m	54.9%	Unlikely
Dúbravka	BUR	4.0m	56.5%	Unlikely
Igor Jesus	NFO	5.8m	51.9%	Unlikely
Cullen	BUR	5.0m	55.4%	Unlikely
Tavernier	BOU	5.6m	13.4%	Unlikely
Foden	MCI	8.9m	8.9%	Unlikely
Ekitiké	LIV	8.7m	8.9%	Unlikely
Flemming	BUR	5.3m	47.9%	Unlikely
Mukiele	SUN	4.2m	32.3%	Unlikely
Cash	AVL	4.9m	49.2%	Unlikely
Kroupi.Jr	BOU	4.6m	28.0%	Unlikely
Mount	MUN	5.9m	42.9%	Unlikely
Richards	CRY	4.6m	35.8%	Unlikely

Connecting to LiveFPL...

We can't connect to LiveFPL right now, check back shortly

Player	Team	Price	Progress	Tonight
Burn	NEW	5.2m	117.3%	Very Likely
Welbeck	BHA	6.5m	96.1%	Likely
Sels	NFO	4.7m	106.3%	Very Likely
Munetsi	WOL	5.4m	98.4%	Likely
Mbeumo	MUN	8.2m	83.0%	Likely
Nallo	LIV	3.8m	102.9%	Very Likely
Iwobi	FUL	6.4m	80.7%	Likely
Elanga	NEW	6.6m	102.1%	Very Likely
Dunk	BHA	4.5m	86.6%	Likely
Rodon	LEE	4.1m	101.2%	Very Likely
Mosquera	ARS	5.4m	90.0%	Likely
Jordan	BUR	4.0m	99.9%	Likely
Estêvão	CHE	6.5m	67.1%	Maybe
Bentley	WOL	4.0m	95.7%	Maybe
Balcombe	BRE	4.0m	96.1%	Maybe
Szoboszlai	LIV	6.7m	63.3%	Maybe
Johnstone	WOL	4.5m	75.3%	Maybe
Nørgaard	ARS	5.2m	91.1%	Maybe
McKenna	BOU	4.0m	96.1%	Maybe
Danso	TOT	4.3m	92.0%	Maybe
Diouf	WHU	4.1m	66.0%	Maybe
Broggio	AVL	4.5m	92.7%	Unlikely
Piroe	LEE	5.0m	93.5%	Unlikely
Okafor	LEE	5.5m	94.3%	Unlikely
Worrall	BUR	3.9m	92.4%	Unlikely
Neave	NEW	4.4m	95.2%	Unlikely
Tzimas	BHA	5.3m	87.2%	Unlikely
Benitez	CRY	4.0m	88.2%	Unlikely
Tasker	BHA	3.9m	91.4%	Unlikely
Coleman	EVE	4.3m	88.9%	Unlikely
Colwill	CHE	4.8m	91.8%	Unlikely
Acheampong	CHE	3.9m	75.3%	Unlikely
Kulusevski	TOT	6.4m	90.1%	Unlikely
Pedro Porro	TOT	5.3m	67.6%	Unlikely
Aina	NFO	4.7m	86.1%	Unlikely
Robertson	LIV	5.8m	84.7%	Unlikely
Bevan	BOU	3.9m	85.5%	Unlikely
Barnes	BUR	4.3m	90.8%	Unlikely
Strand Larsen	WOL	6.2m	83.4%	Unlikely
Hannibal	BUR	4.8m	82.2%	Unlikely

Connecting to LiveFPL...

We can't connect to LiveFPL right now, check back shortly

FPL Fixture Ticker

Watchlists

	Player	Club	Factors
No Change	Raya Martin	ARS	C
No Change	Alisson	LIV	B, Vs
No Change	Donnarumma	MCI	B, Vs, Sus
No Change	Kelleher	BRE	C, Vs
No Change	Dubravka	BUR	C, £

Last updated: 20 Dec, 2025 12:40am

	Player	Club	Factors
No Change	van Dijk	LIV	B, Vs
No Change	Jurriën Timber	ARS	C
No Change	O’Reilly	MCI	B, Vs
No Change	Andersen	FUL	C
No Change	Marc Guehi	CRY	A
No Change	van den Berg	BRE	C, Vs
No Change	Thiaw	NEW	B
No Change	Milenkovic	NFO	B
No Change	van Hecke	BHA	A
No Change	Mukiele	SUN	C, £

Last updated: 20 Dec, 2025 12:42am

	Player	Club	Factors
No Change	Saka	ARS	A
No Change	Bruno Fernandes	MUN	A
No Change	Foden	MCI	A, Vs
No Change	Semenyo	BOU	C
No Change	Szoboszlai	LIV	B, Vs, Inj, Sus
No Change	Minteh	BHA	C
No Change	Bruno Guimarães	NEW	B, Sus
No Change	Schade	BRE	C, Vs
No Change	Anderson	NFO	B, £

Last updated: 20 Dec, 2025 12:49am

	Player	Club	Factors
No Change	Haaland	MCI	B, Vs
No Change	Thiago	BRE	B, Vs, Inj
Up	Ekitiké	LIV	A, Vs
Up	Bowen	WHU	A
Down	Mateta	CRY	C
Down	Woltemade	NEW	B, Rest

Last updated: 20 Dec, 2025 12:51am

GW17 Chip Poll

Rate My Team

30 December 2022 175 comments

avfc82

With Gameweek 18 of Fantasy Premier League (FPL) nearing, five-time top 1k finisher Tom Freeman is here to help with your pre-deadline dilemmas for the next hour.

Whether it’s questions on Reece James (£5.8m) replacements, differentials or anything in between, Scout’s Deputy Editor will tackle whatever’s thrown at him.

Tom will be on hand to first reply to requests from Premium Members in the Hot Topic below the line of this piece and will get through as many as he can until the next article goes up.

If there’s time, Tom will also turn his attention to other requests in the comments section.

You can, as ever, chip in with your own opinions on the RMT requests filtering through – and naturally, you’re free to ignore the article subject matter and talk about any other wider FPL topics that you’d normally be musing on.

Don’t forget that, if it’s an algorithmic answer you’re after rather than an opinion-based one, we also have a ‘Rate My Team’ tool available in the Premium Members Area.

SIGN UP HERE FOR ALL THE TOOLS YOU NEED TO WIN AT FPL!

175 Comments Login to Post a Comment

Previous
First
…
1
2
…
Last
» Next

Warby84
2 years, 11 months ago
Kepa - Ward
Robertson Trippier Cancelo - Gabriel Bueno
Martinelli Salah (c) Almiron Rashford - Andreas
Haaland Martial Darwin
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
1. Warby84
  2 years, 11 months ago
  Gtg?
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
  1. OptimusBlack
    2 years, 11 months ago
    Yes but Haaland C
    Open Controls
    Permalink
    Login To Reply
Nate(U)dog(ie)
2 years, 11 months ago
What are people expecting from Brighton v Arsenal? It's looking like I'll have to play White if Dalot is still unavailable but I'm expecting it'll be a tough game and that Brighton will score. 11 goals in their last 4 and they tend to play well against the top sides. Thinking of chancing playing Cash instead
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
1. Warby84
  2 years, 11 months ago
  I bought In Robertson as I think Liverpool should batter Lei, I think Brighton will score so in the same thinking boat..
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
2. Conners
  2 years, 11 months ago
  More chance of an attacking return from Cash, but slimmer chance of a CS.
  
  I think I'd play White.
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
3. The Mentaculus
  2 years, 11 months ago
  Most likely I do think Brighton will nab 1, but I'd still give White a much higher CS % than Cash (maybe sth like 30% / 15%). Think Villa will concede 2+ so you'll really need an attacking return. I would go with White
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
BantasyFootball
2 years, 11 months ago
Start:
A) Shaw or White
B) Martinelli or Pereira
?
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
1. Warby84
  2 years, 11 months ago
  Shaw/Martinelli
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
Buck The Trent
2 years, 11 months ago
James to ? (Have Kepa)

A Azpi
B Botman
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
1. DARE TO BISCAN
  2 years, 11 months ago
  Probably B. I'm more tempted by Ream, than Azpi (as a GW19 punt)
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
Olof Mellberg
2 years, 11 months ago
I did the restart with 1.2m ITB. James replacements:

A. Robbo (Tsimi worries me, can't afford Trent)
B. Botman
C. VVD (more ITB no rotation risk)
D. Cucurella (rotation risk)

Current Squad:

Ederson
Trips - White - *James*
Rashford - KDB - Almiron - Salah - Martinelli
Haaland - Nketiah
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
andre_c
2 years, 11 months ago
Start Andreas OR replace James for someone $6.1m max and start them?
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
DARE TO BISCAN
2 years, 11 months ago
Afternoon all
GTG? Roll James transfer?

Kepa
Trippier, Gabriel, Shaw
Martinelli, Almiron, KDB, Rashford
Darwin, Haaland, Kane

(Ward, Andreas, Bueno, James) 0.4 ITB
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
OptimusBlack
2 years, 11 months ago
GTG ?
Ramsdale
Cucu - Shaw - Trippier
Rashford - KDB - Almiron - Ødegaard
Kane - Darwin - Haaland
0FT it worth -4 for any transfer ?
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
1. DARE TO BISCAN
  2 years, 11 months ago
  GTG. Did you do James > Cucu?
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
  1. OptimusBlack
    2 years, 11 months ago
    Yaaay
    Open Controls
    Permalink
    Login To Reply
AL23
2 years, 11 months ago
Who to bench out of the following:

a) Foden
b) Andreas
c) Nunez
d) Rashford
e) Odegaard

Andreas underlyings and fixture is causing a headache.
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
PatrickLee
2 years, 11 months ago
Ramsdale (Smith)
James, Cancelo, Shaw, Trippier, Bueno
Odegard, KdB, Rashy, Andreas, Almiron
Darwin, Halaand, Wilson.

James and Wilson are the questions.
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
ValterPereira
2 years, 11 months ago
Is Adams -> Mitrovic worth a hit, particularly if that implies moving Andreas Pereira to the bench?
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
Ligdon
2 years, 11 months ago
Is trossard to almiron for free a good move ?
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
MannionUK
2 years, 11 months ago
Wilson to Mitrovic for a -4?
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
1. Jordan.
  2 years, 11 months ago
  whos the pic? glorious
  Open Controls
  - Permalink
  Login To Reply
Fenty
2 years, 11 months ago
Sanchez
Trippier Shaw Cucurella
Martinelli Rashford Almiron Salah
Darwin Kane Haaland (c)
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply
alibi
2 years, 11 months ago
Hi tom would you keep Wilson and play or bench ? Thinking mitrovic as replacement if sell?
Open Controls
- Permalink
Login To Reply