FPL
24 December 2025 119 comments
Rocky7 Rocky7
Share:

Fantasy Premier League (FPL) managers looking to invest in defenders should take a good look at the options presented by Everton’s backline.

Our Fixture Ticker says the Toffees have the second-best schedule over the next six Gameweeks.

With key attackers injured, away on international duty or simply misfiring, their defenders are the top Fantasy targets for this run.

As you might expect from a David Moyes team, the Everton backline is performing well, keeping four clean sheets over their last seven outings.

The question is, which defender is the better buy: Michael Keane (£4.7m) or James Tarkowski (£5.5m)?

Very little separates these two pillars in terms of points, with Keane the joint-sixth-best FPL defender over the season. He boasts 81 points, and Tarkowski is close behind on 77.

Keane or Tarkowski: who should FPL managers buy?

AVAILABILITY

It’s been quite the season for Keane, who almost certainly wouldn’t have been a starter were it not for a hamstring surgery that has kept Jarrad Branthwaite (£5.3m) completely absent.

Though on the road to recovery, Branthwaite will not be back in action for another few weeks, so Keane’s short-term availability looks secure. Further helping is that he’s playing so well.

“Jarrad is getting closer to getting back on the grass now, and we’re hoping to get him there by the end of the month, but it could be longer than that.

“He’s not due to integrate back in for two-to-three weeks, maybe more, so it’s not like I’m getting him back quickly. I’m just saying It’s beginning to look better than it was, and we’re getting closer to the point of that [returning to training].

“But I think my bigger worry is he’s missed so much of the season, [it’s] to get back into the swing of it quickly. But we need him back.” – David Moyes on Jarrad Branthwaite’s return, speaking on Tuesday

YELLOW CARD KLAXON

­­­FPL Gameweek 22 differentials: Gibbs-White, Wilson + Tarkowski 1

Keane has missed only one match this season, when a calf injury kept him out of Gameweek 14’s victory over Bournemouth.

Meanwhile, Tarkowski has been an ever-present, meaning he edges fitness reliability.

However, Keane has managed to avoid receiving any yellow cards so far, as Tarkowski still walks the four-booking tightrope. There are still two more matches to get through before he’s in the clear.

GOAL THREAT

 

 1



The rest of this article below is completely free to read but requires a Fantasy Football Scout user account for access – you can get yours at no cost here

 1


price change predictions
119 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. redsforlife
      4 hours, 24 mins ago

      hello, happy Christmas Eve
      Sanchez
      mukiele keane timber
      foden rogers saka wilson
      haaland ekitike thiago

      dubravka enzo ruben richards
      0.4 itb 0ft

      bench boost active but not sure if Wilson or Richards are going to play due to injury.

      1. leave it and hope injuries are fine (still play bb)
      2. wait till next week with worse fixtures but players will be fit and I can use a transfer or 2
      3. take a hit on richards now and play bb

      1. tbos83
        • 5 Years
        4 hours, 10 mins ago

        1, but if you get clearer info that Richards is out make a change on 26th

      2. Miguel Sanchez
        • 9 Years
        3 hours, 56 mins ago

        2

    • Qaiss
      • 9 Years
      4 hours, 21 mins ago

      Merry Christmas all, hope you all have a lovely time, tuck in to some nice food and do some FPL tinkering

      Tis a pleasure to share this forum with you all

      1. Miguel Sanchez
        • 9 Years
        3 hours, 30 mins ago

        Same to you mate, have a good one!

      2. Punned It
          3 hours, 14 mins ago

          Likewise! Proper stuffed, kids asleep, time to tinker on my FH19.

        • bso
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 10 Years
          2 hours, 18 mins ago

          Merry Christmas to you and all you footy mates! Enjoy!

        • x.jim.x
          • 11 Years
          2 hours, 4 mins ago

          All the best, big softie x

        • IN SANE IN DE BRUYNE
          • 9 Years
          1 hour, 31 mins ago

          Merry Christmas, mate!

      3. Jet5605
        • 11 Years
        4 hours, 16 mins ago

        Merry Christmas fellow FFS'ers.

        What's the feeling on Semenyo?

        A - Hold and play (Andersen first sub)
        B - Sell along with Bruno G for Cunha & Potts for -4

        1. George James
          • 11 Years
          4 hours, 6 mins ago

          A

          Thoughts below?

        2. Miguel Sanchez
          • 9 Years
          3 hours, 57 mins ago

          I’m holding and starting - I think (hope) he’ll remain professional until he has signed elsewhere. Once this GW has passed I will see if I need to sell as his fixtures with Bournemouth do turn

          1. Jet5605
            • 11 Years
            3 hours, 55 mins ago

            Think I'm doing the same. I think it may get leaked if he's not going to feature. Palace continued playing Guehi while he was talking to Liverpool.

      4. George James
        • 11 Years
        4 hours, 10 mins ago

        Pick one Def and one Mid

        A) Dorgu
        B) Mukiele

        1) Mount
        2) Wilson
        3) Paqueta

        1. Jet5605
          • 11 Years
          3 hours, 52 mins ago

          B3

        2. Miguel Sanchez
          • 9 Years
          3 hours, 46 mins ago

          B3

        3. Punned It
            3 hours, 31 mins ago

            B2, unless there's news on Wilson I've missed?

          • Big Mike
            • 3 Years
            3 mins ago

            B2

        4. Eightball
          • 5 Years
          3 hours, 59 mins ago

          Thoughts on Ekitike vs Haaland captain? I'm massively chasing at this stage and its quite tempting to go against the robot.

          1. Punned It
              3 hours, 29 mins ago

              It's only GW18. I've made zero gains going against him, only from differentials and being ahead of the curve.

            • Big Mike
              • 3 Years
              2 mins ago

              Nooooooo, don't do it! Captain the Norwegian at all costs.

          2. philc
            • 14 Years
            3 hours, 54 mins ago

            Is Frimpong a good buy right now? Should get 60+ mins and plenty of upside attacking potential.

            1. FPL Sanky
              • 2 Years
              3 hours, 34 mins ago

              He won't play RW if Bradley is out (which seems more likely)

            2. The Knights Template
              • 12 Years
              3 hours, 34 mins ago

              He’s a great punt.

          3. g40steve
            • 7 Years
            3 hours, 38 mins ago

            Mbeumo A

          4. Buck The Trent
            • 14 Years
            3 hours, 35 mins ago

            BB In tatters and used all FT. Will wait for further news but would you ?

            A Sell Richards (-4)
            B. Sell Hincapie (-4)
            C. Sell both (-8)

            1. Miguel Sanchez
              • 9 Years
              3 hours, 16 mins ago

              Hold off on the BB and try again next week

          5. Netters2018
            • 7 Years
            3 hours, 33 mins ago

            Is the downgrade of Saka to Rice worth it to bring in Bowen? Saka not great value for money atm, Rice is fairly similar in terms of pts output.

            1. Punned It
                3 hours, 11 mins ago

                Worth doing regardless of Bowen.

              • Miguel Sanchez
                • 9 Years
                3 hours, 10 mins ago

                Agreed Rice is better value if you need the funds

              • Big Mike
                • 3 Years
                just now

                Can you get both? I wouldn't sell Saka unless you don't already have Foden.

            2. BlzE_94
              • 11 Years
              3 hours, 31 mins ago

              Play Chalobah vs AVL(H) or Guehi vs TOT(H)?

              1. Miguel Sanchez
                • 9 Years
                3 hours, 13 mins ago

                My dilemma (with H.Wilson too) - think I’m playing Chalobah before Guehi as Palace look a bit knackered and Sanchez is pretty decent at saving shots from distance if that’s what Villa resort to.

                1. Miguel Sanchez
                  • 9 Years
                  2 hours, 10 mins ago

                  Palace haven’t got the best home record and Spurs been pretty decent on the road too.

              2. yakirh
                • 9 Years
                3 hours, 11 mins ago

                Same dillema, currently playing Guehi because it should be low scoring game.
                The odds are similar (2.75 for Chelsea and 3.00 for Palace)

              3. Haa-lala-land
                • 5 Years
                3 hours, 5 mins ago

                Chalobah by some margin.
                Spurs, as poor as they've been, to put a few past Palace, who look there for the taking.

              4. Big Mike
                • 3 Years
                just now

                I'd play Guehi as he's likely to get more minutes than Chalobah. Plus they play Sunday which is five days worth of rest.

            3. panda07
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 13 Years
              3 hours, 27 mins ago

              Does the absence of Gueye weaken the Everton defence much? I'm looking at bringing in one of the defenders mentioned above next week.

              1. Tonyawesome69
                • 7 Years
                3 hours, 5 mins ago

                Have a look at the defensive stats for the 4 PL games he's missed

                1. panda07
                  • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                  • 13 Years
                  2 hours, 26 mins ago

                  XGC was low for Forest and Bournemouth but it's a small sample size. The other matches were Arsenal and Newcastle which doesn't represent the standard of opposition they will face over the medium term.

                  I haven't watched their last few games, unfortunately, so I'm a bit unsure. The last time I watched them was when he was sent off vs United.

            4. Miguel Sanchez
              • 9 Years
              3 hours, 15 mins ago

              Play one:

              A) Guehi (TOT)
              B) Wilson (whu)

              1. Big Mike
                • 3 Years
                just now

                A

            5. Haa-lala-land
              • 5 Years
              3 hours, 15 mins ago

              I really think the popular Thiago to Ekitike move will end in tears this week. Bournemouth without Adams, should concede a few to Brentford who are quite strong at home

              1. Yes Ndidi
                • 6 Years
                2 hours, 51 mins ago

                They may well concede a few to Brentford, but Thiago couldn't find the net against the mighty defences of Leeds on the road & Wolves. If he does score against Bournemouth, with or without Adams, it'll be an outlier on current form.
                I'd struggle to back him to score against Bournemouth without a keeper.

                1. The Knights Template
                  • 12 Years
                  2 hours, 20 mins ago

                  Thiago is a lummox and deserves all the vituperation one can throw at him! Penalty merchant! Unless of course he moves to Liverpool, in which case I’ve always loved him!

              2. mookie
                • 12 Years
                2 hours, 37 mins ago

                I think playing 2 forwards was a mistake. A long sunk cost fallacy cycle we just can't get out of.
                Nothing special Tarkowski with 6 CS and 1 A is outscoring all forwards except the robot and the Thiago the pen merchant.
                We've wasted transfers on Watkins > Pedro > Gyokeres > Thiago > Ekitike, when bang on average Tarkowski would've done the same job.

                Thiago - 11 goals = 84 points
                Tarkowski - 6 CS + 1 A = 77 points

                Who do you think will keep that up?
                I wouldn't bet a cent on Thiago.

                1. mookie
                  • 12 Years
                  2 hours, 36 mins ago

                  Btw Tarkowski is the 9th highest scoring defender.

                2. panda07
                  • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                  • 13 Years
                  2 hours, 13 mins ago

                  Good points and this is why I'm beefing up my defence and playing the fixtures with 4/5 at the back over the next while. Selling Saka to fund this.

                  1. panda07
                    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                    • 13 Years
                    2 hours, 8 mins ago

                    One drawback is that timing attacking players right can be very lucrative.

                3. Brosstan
                  • 11 Years
                  2 hours, 10 mins ago

                  Playing 3 forwards is objectively worse than 2 forwards

                  1. Brosstan
                    • 11 Years
                    2 hours, 8 mins ago

                    Maybe 1 forward is the play but I think I prefer rotating 2nd forward based on fixtures

                    1. Haa-lala-land
                      • 5 Years
                      1 hour, 27 mins ago

                      2 or 3 forwards is still the correct strategy. So long as you use your Frees to chase the upside in mid and forwards only. Dont make any defender transfers since they are all the same, and defender points are too hard to predict, compared to forwards and mids. Targeting a transfer on an Ekitike or Cunha at home to Wolves is still more likely to get you points than a defender transfer any given game week. Just leave your defenders alone.

                    2. Haa-lala-land
                      • 5 Years
                      1 hour, 26 mins ago

                      Sorry, I basically said the same as you, but mine was much more long winded

                      1. Brosstan
                        • 11 Years
                        1 hour, 25 mins ago

                        🙂 all good

                  2. DBry
                      1 hour, 14 mins ago

                      Bowen, Ekitike and Haaland?

              3. Nightf0x
                • 10 Years
                3 hours, 9 mins ago

                alison (dub)
                richards cala mukiele (oriely clyne)
                Saka rice foden neto (king)
                Haland tiago ekitke

                Which, 3fts?

                a) tiago neto king to bowen gordon deveny
                b) tiago neto alison to bowen gordon pope (was going to do alison to pope gw20 anyway, gw19 FH)
                c) tiago neto to bowen/wolte rogers.

                1. Big Mike
                  • 3 Years
                  1 min ago

                  Neto > Rogers

              4. Tonyawesome69
                • 7 Years
                3 hours, 7 mins ago

                "That said, between Gameweeks 11 and 17, only one point separates the pair, but with a £0.8m price difference."

                What's the reason for highlighting this point?

                Keane and Tarkowski has started 16/17 and 17/17 games this season respectively.

                1. Tonyawesome69
                  • 7 Years
                  2 hours, 23 mins ago

                  I can change the narrative...

                  "In the last 5GWs (12-17) Tarkowski has outscored Keane by 10 points"

                  1. Tonyawesome69
                    • 7 Years
                    2 hours, 22 mins ago

                    13-17*

                    1. Tonyawesome69
                      • 7 Years
                      2 hours, 14 mins ago

                      “Keane has scored 4 more points than Tarkowski this season, despite starting one fewer game and costing £0.8m less.”

                2. Dank Squid
                  • 7 Years
                  2 hours, 21 mins ago

                  Fallacies. Exploit, win.

                  I thought "you should write articles" but then realized, "everyone would know, back to square zero."

              5. BR510
                  2 hours, 49 mins ago

                  So stuck on this one! 343 with Bowen/Woltemade or 352 with Rogers/Gordon. This is pretty long term as takes 2ft to fix. Thanks guys!

                  1. The Knights Template
                    • 12 Years
                    2 hours, 29 mins ago

                    343

                  2. Brosstan
                    • 11 Years
                    2 hours, 6 mins ago

                    352

                  3. Big Mike
                    • 3 Years
                    just now

                    3-5-2 as that way you get Newcastle's penalty taker.

                • AD105
                  • 9 Years
                  2 hours, 35 mins ago

                  Bruno/Saka/Thiago > Cunha/Rice/Ekitike worth a -4?

                  1. The Knights Template
                    • 12 Years
                    2 hours, 25 mins ago

                    One doesn’t play, one hands out his penalties like trick or treat lollies, and one is a lummox. Yes from me!

                  2. IN SANE IN DE BRUYNE
                    • 9 Years
                    1 hour, 45 mins ago

                    Yes

                  3. Big Mike
                    • 3 Years
                    just now

                    No. Just do Bruno + Thiago > Cunha + Ekitike.

                    1. Big Mike
                      • 3 Years
                      just now

                      Keep Saka

                • Yes Ndidi
                  • 6 Years
                  2 hours, 12 mins ago

                  Last piece in the jigsaw

                  play Van Den Berg (BOU, 433) or Gordon (mun, 343) please?

                  Raya
                  VVD O'Reilly Keane
                  Wilson Foden Cunha
                  Haaland Ekitike Bowen

                  Dub Van Hecke KDH

                  TY

                  1. g40steve
                    • 7 Years
                    1 hour, 35 mins ago

                    Gordon

                    1. Yes Ndidi
                      • 6 Years
                      1 hour, 30 mins ago

                      Logical to play the attacker, but vdB will play 90 & may get defcon, so it's not clearcut for we.

                • g40steve
                  • 7 Years
                  2 hours, 11 mins ago

                  Who to bench from,

                  Wilson
                  Semenyo
                  DCL

                  1. Yes Ndidi
                    • 6 Years
                    2 hours, 2 mins ago

                    Any other options? DCL probably.

                    1. g40steve
                      • 7 Years
                      1 hour, 28 mins ago

                      Palmer, Rice, Ekitike, Robot, Foden

                      1. Yes Ndidi
                        • 6 Years
                        1 hour, 26 mins ago

                        Yeah, I see.
                        Still DCL I think.

                        It'll be the wrong one

                        1. g40steve
                          • 7 Years
                          1 hour, 23 mins ago

                          Yep, benched 13 points last week

                          Was considering Wilson?

                          1. Yes Ndidi
                            • 6 Years
                            1 hour, 15 mins ago

                            They could both blank (easily), but they could both return 8 or 9 points.

                            Stick a pin time, but I just think Sunderland at home are tighter at the back than WH at home.

                            1. g40steve
                              • 7 Years
                              1 hour, 1 min ago

                              True

                  2. Big Mike
                    • 3 Years
                    just now

                    Tough call but I'd bench DCL.

                • ⭐ Bemba_Da ⭐
                  • 15 Years
                  2 hours, 7 mins ago

                  anyone have wc and free hit left? if so, which order are you using?

                  1. Bigbars
                    • 15 Years
                    1 hour, 52 mins ago

                    me, free hit this week, WC next to set me up for the new year

                  2. Bigbars
                    • 15 Years
                    1 hour, 50 mins ago

                    doing this order, allows me to go rogue this week, and any punts that may work i can confirm next, also gives me another week to work on a WC squad before the deadline

                    1. ⭐ Bemba_Da ⭐
                      • 15 Years
                      1 hour, 41 mins ago

                      I am considering this, my only concern is losing on price rises this way and rotation midweek - free hit allows for some out of the ordinary punts midweek potentially

                      1. Bigbars
                        • 15 Years
                        1 hour, 35 mins ago

                        i'm gonna swallow any price rises, no different to me doing last minute transfers against those beating the rises and doing it early. the extra week, is another week of data and you never know it could swing the other way and planned changes may be blown out of the water with injuries or suspensions from this GW. For me, a bit of patience i hope helps, rather than panic transfers then spending a few gw's rectifying it,

                        1. fedolefan
                          • 11 Years
                          just now

                          How are you doing this season? Talking out of my a**, but feel the WC dictates the mindset for the season. The longer you hesitate to play it, the more risk averse you end up playing since you're constantly fire fighting and fire fighting can get quite tedious after a while. Of course if you're flying, then there's probably no need to play it. Think rolling up to 4 especially banking 3 in the first 5 GWs, can potentially offset an early WC but that does require you to have been quite good and lucky with your GW1 team.

                  3. g40steve
                    • 7 Years
                    1 hour, 48 mins ago

                    Got FH & using next week, with quick turn round & everyone using the 5ft any injuries this week not so easily covered.

                    1. Bigbars
                      • 15 Years
                      19 mins ago

                      ditto. gonna bank those 5ft for next year to repair any post WC discrepancies in the new year

                    2. Bigbars
                      • 15 Years
                      18 mins ago

                      Amazing TV by the way.. impressive !

                      1. g40steve
                        • 7 Years
                        13 mins ago

                        Not chased it but had an amazing run that’s faltered last couple of weeks 🙁

                        1. Bigbars
                          • 15 Years
                          11 mins ago

                          but gives you more wiggle room to absorb price changes. well done ... ride that wave.

                          1. g40steve
                            • 7 Years
                            4 mins ago

                            Next move is either keeper or Palmer, Palmer gives benching headache?

                • AD105
                  • 9 Years
                  2 hours, 7 mins ago

                  Thiago > Ekitike and Bruno to a 7.3 MID - which one?

                  Raya
                  Timber VVD Alderete
                  Cherki Saka Bruno* Foden Wilson
                  Haaland Thiago

                  Dubravka Andersen Richards* Guiu

                  1. Miguel Sanchez
                    • 9 Years
                    1 hour, 52 mins ago

                    Gordon

                  2. Yes Ndidi
                    • 6 Years
                    1 hour, 48 mins ago

                    Rice would be the obvious one, but you can't

                    Rogers long term, but don't expect much this week or next
                    Gordon, but it'll be a rollercoaster (owner)
                    Mount if you want to keep a bit of Man U

                    Other than that, there isn't much to get excited about.
                    When's Gakpo back?

                  3. Big Mike
                    • 3 Years
                    just now

                    Morgan Rogers

                • George James
                  • 11 Years
                  2 hours, 3 mins ago

                  Any one with Nick Pope hoping he will play this GW, what are the chances do we think?

                • Dank Squid
                  • 7 Years
                  1 hour, 54 mins ago

                  Long season.

                  Early GWs, 4.0 defenders/promoted teams racking up CS, scoring some goals (Jaidon Anthony etc.). Now? Goals conceded, Leeds/DCL often.

                  Aston Villa, West Ham, easy CS points. Rogers, Watkins, Bowen - times change.

                  Invest in attack or defense? Defensive contributions, a nice addition to the game.

                  1. Pep's Money Laundry
                    • 10 Years
                    1 hour, 1 min ago

                    I played 442 for the vast majority of the season, it served me really well. I'll be going back to that formation really soon

                • DBry
                    1 hour, 31 mins ago

                    -8 With this team. Wouldn’t be able to afford it with the price rises since the weekend now.

                    Or free hit out of it?

                    Raya
                    Timber,VvD,Keane,nunes
                    Rice,cunha,Foden
                    Bowen,Ekitike,haaland

                    BrunoG,Anderson,Rodon,Dub

                    1. If you have your free hit left may as well use it, you’ll get another in next GW

                    2. might as well free hit unless your set on the midweek gameweek?

                  • Captain Robert Hatch
                    • 14 Years
                    1 hour, 14 mins ago

                    Forced to boost that bench this GW.

                    Shall I replace Wilson and or Esteve?

                    Cheerio

                    1. Big Mike
                      • 3 Years
                      just now

                      I wouldn't, both are likely to play. Esteve has trained this week and Silva has already played down Wilson's injury concerns.

                  • DARE TO BISCAN
                    • 7 Years
                    58 mins ago

                    Feliz Navidad, muchachos. Do I:

                    a) Bruno > Rice/maybe Wirtz (-4)
                    b) play Senesi, bin Bruno next week

                    1. Big Mike
                      • 3 Years
                      just now

                      Bruno > Cunha

                  • FPLMACKEM
                    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                    • 5 Years
                    42 mins ago

                    Raya
                    Virgil, Andersen, Timber, Richards
                    Bruno, Wilson, Foden, Saka
                    Thiago, Haaland

                    Dubravka, Anderson, Rodon, Guiu

                    3ft 1.4 itb

                    A Richards to Keane
                    B Roll (hope Richards starts, if not Rodon/Anderson off bench)

                    1. Flynny
                      • 10 Years
                      5 mins ago

                      B

                  • RalphieFPL
                    • 3 Years
                    33 mins ago

                    Thoughts on this W/C? Thanks
                    Sanchez
                    VVD, Timber, O’Reilly
                    Rice, Cunha, Foden, Rogers
                    Haaland, Ekitike, Bowen

                    Dubravka, Bijol, Alderete, L.Miley

                    Thanks and Merry Christmas!

                  • hazza44
                    • 13 Years
                    29 mins ago

                    Hi all,
                    Which mid to replace Bruno, up to £10.6, current mids are:
                    Foden Cunha Rice Minteh

                    1. Freshy
                      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                      • 15 Years
                      25 mins ago

                      Foden

                    2. Pep's Money Laundry
                      • 10 Years
                      25 mins ago

                      Gordon or Rogers

                    3. ⭐ Bemba_Da ⭐
                      • 15 Years
                      24 mins ago

                      wirtz

                    4. Big Mike
                      • 3 Years
                      2 mins ago

                      Saka

                  • Pep Roulette
                    • 8 Years
                    24 mins ago

                    Who's on pens for Sunderland?

                    1. ELF

                    2. FPLMACKEM
                      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                      • 5 Years
                      2 mins ago

                      Enzo Le Fee