[sbu_large_image] Community
31 October 2014 3053 comments
J0E J0E
Share:

Stick or twist? The dilemma of whether to hold key players dominated much of the discussion within the Fantasy Football Scout community this week, as stubborn and risk-taking Fantasy mangers prepared to do battle in Gameweek 10.

Whether you’re looking to ditch or keep your main assets, there was a feast of information to gorge on throughout the week, with our hot topics, articles and members tables helping to finalise those last-minute transfer plans. We look back on all that activity and, as ever, find time to catch up on the latest ups and downs in our community competitions.

The Community Articles

The Puntmaster has been assessing potential replacements for Gylfi Sigurdsson after taking a look at the Swansea man’s declining attacking threat and poor upcoming fixtures. Our regular scribe was back later in the week with his regular trio of punts, including another potential midfield replacement for the Icelandic international, for those who fancy taking a chance on a differential.

The Sarjeant also turned up with his popular regular, offering up further analysis of current form throughout the Premier League. Meanwhile, Sticky Mockwell provided his report on the effectiveness of goalkeeper rotation over the opening nine Gameweeks. It provided a timely reminder on the merits of a pair of active, alternating stoppers.

Don’t forget, if you’ve got some analysis, scout reports or features brewing, be sure to visit our community section to submit your article.

The Hottest Topics

There are a multitude of factors to ponder ahead of Gameweek 10: the choice of options in midfield being a major consideration. Right now, there are a handful of premium midfielders vying for our attention, whilst a slump in output amongst some popular Fantasy picks, allied with the ongoing uncertainty over Diego Costa’s minutes, suggests that the forthcoming set of fixtures could shake-up mini leagues.

On one side of the battle lines there are the “Twisters” who are ditching the likes of Gylfi Sigurdsson, Costa and Raheem Sterling without a second thought. In the other corner there are the “Stickers”, resolutely clinging on to their fading stars in hope that class is permanent and a revival is on the way. In our discussion on which camp will prevail this weekend, Jafalad was among those who believe Costa ditchers will be left disappointed.

Later in the week we pondered whether we should welcome this apparent break up of the template team . Baines on Toast was among those who joined the discussion, stating that, with so many good expensive midfield options and just five slots, it’s impossible to “catch ‘em all”.

Such is the tension surrounding this week’s transfer decisions, there was even talk that Sergio Aguero may falter due to Manchester City’s poor form and midweek injury concerns around David Silva and Yaya Toure. Demi sparked this discussion to gather the community’s derby day predictions. Meanwhile, Beavis proclaimed that, even without Silva, Aguero has the form to shine. His excellent number crunching certainly puts forward a compelling case for captaining the Argentine hit man, with or without Silva’s craft providing the ammunition.

Chelsea have arguably one of the best fixtures of the week as they entertain QPR at Stamford Bridge. However, with Jose Mourinho continuing to be vague over Costa’s minutes earlier in the week, Rickardinho was eyeing up other Chelsea options and urged the community to consider Oscar’s excellent recent form and his high points tallies against “lesser” sides.

Over on the other side of London, Agbonlahorse has been looking into Arsenal striker Danny Welbeck’s potential. He’s far from impressed and wonders whether cheap strikers at big clubs, such as Welbeck and Everton’s Steven Naismith, are duping us into thinking they will perform beyond their price tag.

In contrast, Everton’s defence may be expensive but is worth every penny, according to MOTR in his run down of the pros and cons of doubling up on the Toffees backline.

Wakey’s Falling Stars team regularly reveals others that are making a mockery of their price tag. Each week he builds an XI comprised of those that have suffered price falls below their initial valuation. Gameweek 9 was another success story for Wakey’s ensemble, with the likes of Alexis Sanchez and Swansea’s Wilfried Bony performing well. Valuation was also being discussed by Milanista, who issued another call to FPL to disclose the secret calculations behind their price changes.

Price is something the community’s weekly Scout Pick champions need to keep a close eye on as they take on the Scouts with just a 83.5m budget. Saniul brought some much needed credibility back to the title of Scout Pick Community Champion last week by beating Paul’s total. This week’s champion, Magerost, will be hoping to do even better with his election winning set of picks. Just a reminder that our search for a community champion now takes place in its own community article, published the Monday before each Gameweek at 10am.

Finally, Nighthiker took a look back at some of the pre-season bandwagon flops the community optimistically drafted in for Gameweek 1. Meanwhile, Evs embarked on a more jolly stroll down memory lane in his discussion about the season’s best players and moments so far.

The Members Tables

Liverpool’s poor form in front of goal was a key issue covered in this week’s members tables. In my assist imminent table Liverpool midfielders dominate, showing just how badly they need Daniel Sturridge back to convert the many chances they are still creating.

The Fantasy Freak specifically took a look at Raheem Sterling to see just how he compares to one of this week’s most popular transfers Alexis Sanchez. Liverpool’s Mario Balotelli rides high in Erlando’s table looking at trigger happy players who are notching up a prolific number of goal attempts. His poor goal scoring form is clearly not for the want of trying.

The Community Tournaments

The Tinkerman increased his lead in the Fantasy Football Scout moderators and contributors league over second placed Mark.

Rasping Drive continues to top The Puffinboy Memorial Cup, for our veteran posters as well as the FFS Old Farts Club and the FFS Deadzone leagues.

In TorresMagic‘s Last Man Standing competition, Mr Rabbit hit the top score in Gameweek 9 with 74. There are now 997 teams left after 57 were eliminated after the safety score was set at 30.

The FFS UEFA Hockey World Cup reaches the semi-final stage in Gameweek 10. Here’s the latest from ENR looking back at the group stages and ahead to the weekend’s fixtures.

3,053 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. RubeRx
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Somebody posted this last night and thought I would share again. Please admire Berahino's finishing skills.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-B-6BqEBvg

    If you don't want to watch all 3 mins, just fast forward to 2:39

    1. Lawrø
      12 years, 3 days ago

      1:03 is pretty tasty too!

      12 years, 3 days ago

      Not even close to being the best goal in the whole vid... 😆

  2. Kip
    12 years, 3 days ago

    RMT tells me to play Moore(WBA) over Wisdom(lei). Can't see WBA blanking though

    1. TorresMagic™
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Play Wisdom then.

  3. Puyol Pants Up
    12 years, 3 days ago

    What to do?

    Foster/4.0
    Baines/Cahill/Clyne/Duff/Dummett
    ADM/Sterling/Downing/Siggy/Marney
    Aguero/Costa/Pelle

    A. Siggy ----> Chadli
    B. Sterling & Cahill -> Sanchez & Chambers (-4)
    C. ADM -> Hazard/Fabregas
    D. Save

    Leaning towards D..

    1. Lawrø
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I like B), D) is an option too.

      1. Puyol Pants Up
        12 years, 3 days ago

        I was thinking B. Until I realised..

        - Marney is back for Burnley (Solid defensive mid that has missed the last 3-5 games)
        - Sterling and Cahill have good fixtures
        - Not worth -4
        - Danny Ings is back for Burnley and could easily score against a fragile Arsenal defence.

        1. Lawrø
          12 years, 3 days ago

          Sounds like your mind's made up.

    12 years, 3 days ago

    Literally no idea what to do........... 😕

    Costa in feels like a must. But going without makes a better overall team. 1 FT, £1m itb...

    Begovic
    Ivanovic Bertrand Baines
    Sterling Sigurdsson Di María Chadli
    Pellè Agüero Welbeck

    1. Kip
      12 years, 3 days ago

      no Chelsea attacking cover at all? ouch.

      Di Maria => Hazard?

        12 years, 3 days ago

        I know, but no way am I selling ADM.

  4. Lawrø
    12 years, 3 days ago

    How many transfers have you used so far this season?

    My plan was to be Gung-ho at the start of the season to boost my team value but as the price rises have been somewhat unpredictable I feel like I've been fairly middle of the road! 9 transfers so far.

    1. thischarmingman
      12 years, 3 days ago

      9 here as well

    2. TorresMagic™
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      12 years, 3 days ago

      10

    3. NLB
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      only 7. always been against hits (except in special circumstances) and usually works out in the long run

    4. Kip
      12 years, 3 days ago

      11

      took a few hits in the opening GW's

    5. Tatty Bojangles
      12 years, 3 days ago

      6

    6. RSe
      12 years, 3 days ago

      6.

    7. Calm
      12 years, 3 days ago

      11 currently, but going to be 12 when I draft in Chambers for Naylor in a bit.
      Haven't played my WC though.

  5. dynamike
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Stoned, but............

    Forster
    Bertrand, Chambers, Wisdom
    Sanchez(c), ADM, Faby(vc), Jedinak
    Costa,Augero, Wellbeck

    (Heaton, Cork, Duff, Hutton)

  6. applebonkers
    • Has Moderation Rights
    12 years, 3 days ago

    anyway, good luck all.
    (hope you all have good luck but still score badly)

    1. TorresMagic™
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • Has Moderation Rights
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Good luck Mac.

  7. thischarmingman
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Would you change anything in this midfield before tomorrow?

    ADM Sterling Eriksen Siggy (James)

    Only got 1FT and .1 in the bank.

    1. Puyol Pants Up
      12 years, 3 days ago

      James Rodriguez?

      1. thischarmingman
        12 years, 3 days ago

        Matthew "4.4" James, I like to call him

        1. Puyol Pants Up
          12 years, 3 days ago

          Never heard of him. What team does he play for? I assume he has had 0 points all season?

          1. thischarmingman
            12 years, 3 days ago

            He's on a sweet 6 point total, plays now and then. Plays for Leicester (I had to go check..:)

  8. Les Bleus
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Who else is going without Costa this GW?

    1. Declan
      12 years, 3 days ago

      o/

    2. Twisted Saltergater
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      o/

    3. Sponge-worthy
      12 years, 3 days ago

      o

    4. laGan1n1
      12 years, 3 days ago

      me

  9. Mesh
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Play Bertrand or Chester?

    1. Declan
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Bertie

    2. Park the bus
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Bertrand

    3. NLB
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Bertrand

  10. Doar1986
    12 years, 3 days ago

    When is Walcott back, will he start / play this weekend

    Not much love for Barkley on here, surely a ideal replacement for Siggy after this GW ?

    1. Park the bus
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Possibly a few mins off the bench for Theo.

      Barkley needs to show us something first, also the concern over rotation is putting a lot of people off.

  11. Demí
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Not sure if this affects anyone, but seems Coutinho starts tomorrow. Maybe Lallana owners?

    1. Gunner77-
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I was tempted by Coutinho, then I bought Chadli...

    2. Mesh
      12 years, 3 days ago

      You got a link to any bib theory pics Demi?

      1. Demí
        12 years, 3 days ago

        Nah man, sorry

        1. Mesh
          12 years, 3 days ago

          No worries, cant seem to find the pics anywhere

    3. Fantasy Gold
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Borini and the baby up top?

    4. pundit of punts
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Sterling-------Coutinho-----Borini
      ---------------Balotelli----------------

      Sterling out wide then.

    5. DRY PEANUT
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Coutinho has looked good when coming on, defo deserves it.

      1. Demí
        12 years, 3 days ago

        agree

  12. Optimus.
    12 years, 3 days ago

    If someone had the enviable choice to start 1 of these..

    1) Dummett(LIV)?

    or

    a) Bruce(SOT)?

    1. Declan
      12 years, 3 days ago

      1

    2. Parm
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Brucey.

    3. Mílanista
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I'd sooner turn the volume up to full and click on the girl link 😉

      1) I suppose

      1. Optimus.
        12 years, 3 days ago

        Ah so I caught yourself?..That will teach you for lurking then 😉

        1. Mílanista
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          12 years, 3 days ago

          No I saw you talking about it afterwards when I came on, went to your recent comments and followed it. Clicked mute before I clicked a link 😀

          1. Optimus.
            12 years, 3 days ago

            I had linked it after posting "anyone with Costa (c) now worried after reading this" 😆

            1. Mílanista
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              12 years, 3 days ago

              😆 😆

              I only saw when you relinked after moaning about it being deleted. Knew what was coming with the Haloween comments

    4. the axolotl
      12 years, 3 days ago

      dumbo

    5. Optimus.
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Cheers all 🙂

    6. Puyol Pants Up
      12 years, 3 days ago

      1

      Dummett has the attacking potential

  13. V-2 Schneiderlin
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Who should I get in Hazard or Sanchez? (Have Cesc but no Costa)

    1. V-2 Schneiderlin
      12 years, 3 days ago

      that settles it, going for Sanchez!

  14. Voice of the Mysterons
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Is Stevan Taylor fit for this weekends game?

    1. Declan
      12 years, 3 days ago

      A good chance he starts

  15. NLB
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    12 years, 3 days ago

    DDG
    Baines Bertrand N.Taylor
    Haz (vc) Tadic Lamela Hendo
    Costa (c) Pelle Welbeck
    Subs: Hamer Moore Dummett Marney
    2 FTs, +4.2 in the bank

    about to pull trigger on:
    DDG, Hendo to Adrian, Sanchez

    thanks for help on last page. looking good to go?

    1. Parm
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Good to go mate. Good luck.

  16. Park the bus
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Subs order : wisdom Boyd coloccini?

    1. Mesh
      12 years, 3 days ago

      WCB

    2. Mílanista
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Looks right

    3. the axolotl
      12 years, 3 days ago

      subs order questions should be banned 🙂
      your's are probably right though

  17. boyler
    12 years, 3 days ago

    2fts should I do A,B or C ?
    A sterling+ulloa to sanchez+naismith captain sanchez
    B sterling+chester to sanchez+4.0 captain sanchez
    C chester to chambers captain ageuro

    1. Park the bus
      12 years, 3 days ago

      C

  18. OptimusBlack
    12 years, 3 days ago

    I know it reposted few Times but i need help

    Which is the best for next 10 / 11 / 12 GWS ?

    A- Eriksen
    B- Chadli
    C- Tadic
    D - Mane
    E- Ramsey

    i hope it's easier now

    1. Fantasy Gold
      12 years, 3 days ago

      B

    2. nedfoo
      12 years, 3 days ago

      E perhaps

    3. thischarmingman
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I got Eriksen over Chadli, but seeing all the teams on here, I fear he does not warrant the extra cost.

    4. GREENDREAMS11
      12 years, 3 days ago

      i would discard Tadic and Mane purely on Saints longer term fixtures, Spurs and Arsenal fixtures are similar so I would go the better player for the better team, Ramsey imo. the issue is how long before he is back to his usual self.

  19. Recoba
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Which looks better:
    A) Costa Tadic
    B) Pelle Haz

    1. Declan
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I have B, so A.

    2. Mile Plankton - Myth and Ch…
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I have A and Pelle 🙂

      Got to say Costa wins it.

    3. Pea Soup
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Costa Tadic & Pelle

    4. NLB
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I've gone for all 4 but I'd say A if I had to choose.

    5. Recoba
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Thanks for playing all, but the answer was B. Best of luck next next time!

  20. Optimus.
    12 years, 3 days ago

    I have Speroni as my only starting keeper..

    Was he concussed or was it just a knock to the head,anyone know?

  21. DIegoCosta19
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Can someone explain bib theory??

    1. Declan
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Nope, all guess work

    2. Pea Soup
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Yes, in two words.

      Nonsensical garbage.

    3. the axolotl
      12 years, 3 days ago

      in training teams wear bibs in a mini practice match (captured with photos). it's assumed it's starters vs non-starters. proven time and time again to be nonsense yet people persist with it, based on fact that sometimes it's right.

  22. Bigo1
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Would you do:
    Sterling to Hazard
    Balo to Costa

    ???

    1. Elwood
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Balo to Costa

    2. Mesh
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Depends on the rest of your team but get Balo out

    3. nedfoo
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Balo to Costa

    4. Royal5
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Yes

  23. MJ6987
    12 years, 3 days ago

    I always think this game is all about getting the bargains. This then enables you to get more of the "big obvious" ones like Costa, Aguero and Fabregas.

    I have identified two such bargains that I don't have currently.

    1. Fantasy Gold
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Arfield and Ings yeah?

      1. MJ6987
        12 years, 3 days ago

        Something like that yeah.

        I am normally very open in my advice but I want to keep this to myself at the moment as I don't want to spark any bandwagons and bump the price up just yet.

        1. Fantasy Gold
          12 years, 3 days ago

          You rate your own opinion quite highly, then?

          1. MJ6987
            12 years, 3 days ago

            Lol, that was tongue in cheek tbh.

          2. MJ6987
            12 years, 3 days ago

            Lol @ sneaky upvoter! 🙂

    2. Elwood
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Bertrand and Sahko?

    3. pundit of punts
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Name names

      Mane's gotta be one.

      1. Fantasy Gold
        12 years, 3 days ago

        MJ talks in riddles. He won't reveal good info 😉

        1. MJ6987
          12 years, 3 days ago

          Gotta maintain an edge somehow 😉

      2. MJ6987
        12 years, 3 days ago

        I'll tell you next GW. Let's get this week out of the way first.

        1. Fantasy Gold
          12 years, 3 days ago

          Who says I wanna know...

          #justsayin

          1. MJ6987
            12 years, 3 days ago

            PM me.

            1. Fantasy Gold
              12 years, 3 days ago

              Haha 😉

        2. pundit of punts
          12 years, 3 days ago

          lol

    4. Optimus.
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Yun ftw

    5. Defcons are for Kinnear
      12 years, 3 days ago

      I think like this too

    6. Cpt Crunch Scott talent
      12 years, 3 days ago

      This is one way to lure the others into revealing their cheapies...... I salute you.

      1. MJ6987
        12 years, 3 days ago

        *takes notes furiously*

    7. Vardy Gras PBFC
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Fellaini & Ameobi?

      1. MJ6987
        12 years, 3 days ago

        😆

        1. Vardy Gras PBFC
          12 years, 3 days ago

          So I was right!

      2. Fantasy Gold
        12 years, 3 days ago

        Sammy?

        1. Vardy Gras PBFC
          12 years, 3 days ago

          Indeed. I haven't pulled the trigger on Boyd to Ameobi myself yet though.

    8. Dr Dream
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Downing and Ings next GW would be my best guess.

      1. Dr Dream
        12 years, 3 days ago

        Or Creswell and Trippier if they're defensive.

  24. Every Dog Has Its Day
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Please Help.

    RMT is it good to go?

    Adrian
    Baines Clyne Bertrand
    Chadili Sterling Fabregas Downing
    (C)Costa Pelle Aguero(V)

    Siggy Moore Duff

  25. Mile Plankton - Myth and Ch…
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Can I get a link to scout picks article. I can't log on to home page.

    1. Mile Plankton - Myth and Ch…
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Thanks both.

  26. nedfoo
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Wasting a transfer for the second week in a row, unless you can spot anything that I should do? 0.1m ITB. Thanks

    Forster / Hamer
    Baines / Bertrand / Chambers / Moore / Hutton
    Fabregas / Sterling / Tadic / Siggy / Boyd
    Costa / Aguero / Welbeck

    1. Sponge-worthy
      12 years, 3 days ago

      i have 9 of your players..maybe you're set..

    2. the axolotl
      12 years, 3 days ago

      other than sterling out (if you fancy it), you're fine. can't even see a vanity transfer there.

      1. nedfoo
        12 years, 3 days ago

        Thanks guys

  27. Back on the horse
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Start a) Chambers (BUR) or b) Wisdom (lei)?

    1. DRY PEANUT
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Come on dude

      1. Sponge-worthy
        12 years, 3 days ago

        🙂

    2. nedfoo
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Chambers

    3. Declan
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Wisdom.

      We wont keep a cleansheet

  28. DRY PEANUT
    12 years, 3 days ago

    UFPL

    Berahino or Siggy?

    1. nedfoo
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Berahino

  29. -KocH-
    12 years, 3 days ago

    Who to bench?
    Mane, downing, chadli, haz, siggy

    1. nedfoo
      12 years, 3 days ago

      Downing maybe?