Scout Reports
14 January 2026 162 comments
FPL Marc FPL Marc
Share:

Stuck in the relegation zone, seven points away from safety, West Ham United desperately need new forwards Valentín ‘Taty’ Castellanos (£5.5m) and Pablo Felipe (£5.5m) to succeed.

They arrived in the first five days of January, costing a combined £46 million, suggesting that the Hammers’ board will keep backing Nuno Espirito Santo, despite being winless in 10 and having the league’s leakiest defence.

So can these forwards settle quickly, and what impact will they have in Fantasy Premier League (FPL)?

We’ll attempt to answer those questions below.


WHO IS TATY?

FPL new signings: Is Taty or Pablo the best West Ham forward pick?

Born in Argentina, for whom he has two international caps, Castellanos’ early clubs were based in Chile and Uruguay.

He then moved to America as a late teen, winning both an MLS Eastern Conference and MLS Cup title with New York City FC. In 2021, he won the Golden Boot.

SeasonTeamDivisionStarts (subs)GoalsAssists
2025/26LazioSerie A8 (3)23
2024/25LazioSerie A28 (1)105
2023/24LazioSerie A16 (19)43
2022/23Girona (loan)La Liga33 (2)131
2022New York City FCMajor League Soccer17 (0)132
2021New York City FCMajor League Soccer32 (0)198
2020New York City FCMajor League Soccer11 (8)62
2019New York City FCMajor League Soccer23 (7)118

A new challenge then took him to Europe, specifically Girona. Undoubtedly, the highlight of this loan spell was scoring four times in a match against Real Madrid, which helped impress Lazio scouts ahead of a summer 2023 transfer.

Throughout 2024/25, Taty netted 14 times across Serie A and Europa League matches, though this latest half-season has been restricted by a month-long hamstring problem.

As for playing style, the 27-year-old is a deep-lying forward, capable of both linking play and scoring goals. He has enough energy to relentlessly hunt the ball, yet also won 53.1% of last season’s aerial duels.

In context, Erling Haaland (£15.1m) and Brian Brobbey (£5.5m) are this term’s only regularly-playing forwards to exceed such a proportion (see below). He’s not even six feet tall!

So, think of him as being similar to Nick Woltemade (£7.3m) (ie not a goal-hanger), just without the height.

WHO IS PABLO?

FPL new signings: Is Taty or Pablo the best West Ham forward pick? 1

Naturally, there’s less to say about 22-year-old Pablo.

Brazilian but born in Braga, he developed at Famalicao and Pacos Ferreira, before grabbing attention last April when on loan at Gil Vicente. The striker scored a 10-minute hat-trick away at Boavista.

SeasonTeamDivisionStarts (subs)GoalsAssists
2025/26Gil VicenteLiga Portugal12 (1)101
2024/25Gil Vicente (loan)Liga Portugal8 (12)50
2023/24Pacos Ferreira (loan)Liga Portugal 25 (10)11
2023/24FamalicaoLiga Portugal2 (6)00

Soon established as a leading forward, Pablo’s rapid 2025/26 progression has brought 10 goals over a few months, placing his team fourth heading into the winter break.

Furthermore, starting at just €5.5m in Fantasy Liga Portugal – a game we cover – he was its fifth-best forward by the end of Gameweek 16, accumulating 71 points.

More of a poacher inside the box than Taty, Pablo boasts a physical presence that can effectively hold up the ball, whilst also being up for an occasional take-on. This could prove handy for West Ham’s direct, counter-attacking style.

However, FBref says he’s Liga Portugal’s biggest expected goals (xG) overachiever (+4.30), having netted 10 times from a mere 20 shots and 11 on target.

HOW DO THEY FIT IN AT WEST HAM?

FPL new signings: Is Taty or Pablo the best West Ham forward pick? 2

Above: Player overviews from WhoScored

Nuno has been switching systems during his few months in East London. He mostly uses a four-man defence, but is open to a wing-back formation, like in the FA Cup clash versus Queens Park Rangers.

Castellanos seems to currently have the centre-forward shirt, playing all 90 minutes of Gameweek 21 and most of Sunday’s two hours. Two of three shots against Nottingham Forest were Opta-defined big chances, then his bullet header defeated QPR in extra time.

Meanwhile, Pablo’s league cameo meant they played together for a period. And perhaps that’s the plan for these crucial months – especially if Lucas Paqueta (£5.9m) leaves the club. Taty in the 10, Pablo in the 9 is one possibility.

Do their arrivals boost or weaken Jarrod Bowen (£7.7m) as an FPL asset? Well, it’s not like three goals from the latest 15 matches allow much room for doing worse.

FPL new signings: Is Taty or Pablo the best West Ham forward pick? 5

The forward has mostly been used on the right flank, which isn’t ideal, but sits third overall for attempts (53), shots inside the box (41). He’s just lacking big chances (six) and shot quality (0.09 xG per shot). Improve the quality around him, and maybe he’ll produce more.

COULD THEY TAKE OVER PENALTIES?

­­­FPL Gameweek 4 differentials: Elliott, Truffert + Paqueta 4

With Paqueta supposedly wantaway, penalty-taking duties could soon pass over to a teammate.

Bowen took one in 2024/25 and is a contender but the Hammers’ two new forwards do have some experience from 12 yards.

Taty, indeed, has the best record of the lot:

Success rate
Taty15 out of 18 (83.3%)
Pablo3 out of 4 (75%)
Bowen7 out of 10 (70%)

ARE EITHER WORTH BUYING IN FPL?

Not right now.

After all, this is a club famous for its history of poor striker signings. These two also come with mixed reputations, with plenty to prove.

Yes, West Ham’s next six outings rank fourth on our Fixture Ticker – but they’ve recently gifted Wolverhampton Wanderers their first win of the season, also losing at home to Forest and Fulham.

Many FPL managers are completely avoiding the Hammers, and it’s easy to see why.

Taty is the one to monitor over the next few weeks, as he seems to have the game-time advantage. In a landscape where so few forwards have appeal, there’s potential in downgrading someone to this cheap price point, as it raises money for other positions.

With Dominic Calvert-Lewin (£6.0m) rising in price, there are few sub-£6.0m forwards boasting guaranteed starts.

For the time being, the likes of Mateus Mane (£4.5m) and Eli Kroupi (£4.6m) are the go-to forwards for FPL bosses stripping money from their frontline and moving to a 4-4-2/3-5-2. They also save owners around a million compared to Taty.

But should pricier forwards further fall out of fashion – for example, managers moving to a 4-5-1 in Gameweek 24 to accommodate the likes of Cole Palmer (£10.4m) and Bruno Fernandes (£9.1m) – then it’s always worth keeping an eye out for regular starters in the budget striker pool.


price change predictions

FPL Marc Broadcaster, writer and overthinker. Hoping that ‘differential potential’ will catch on.

162 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. FPL Sanky
    • 2 Years
    7 mins ago

    Trollard as a differential over Rice?

    1. The Bandit
      • 15 Years
      5 mins ago

      No way. Trossard is far from nailed.

      1. FPL Sanky
        • 2 Years
        just now

        Arteta prefers him over Martinelli...think he is nailed...the only problem is he has a history of trolling FPL managers

  2. The Bandit
    • 15 Years
    6 mins ago

    Guiu saved for the weekend. Well done owners..

  3. JBG
    • 7 Years
    5 mins ago

    You know your defence is bad when Gyokeres scores...

  4. The 12th Man
    • 12 Years
    4 mins ago

    Hi,
    Just Cunha > Rice and roll the 2nd FT?

    Petrovic
    Gabriel,Senesi,VVD
    Cunha,Saka,Foden,Cherki,Wilson
    Haaland,Ekitike

    Dubravka,Dalot,Guiu,Keane 0.3m itb 2FT’s

  5. SomeoneKnows
    • 9 Years
    3 mins ago

    A) Roll
    B) Cunha > Wilson
    C) Keane > Cash
    D) Other ideas

    Roefs
    Gabriel, Lacroix, Andersen
    Saka, Rice, BrunoG, Foden, Cunha
    Haaland, Eketike

    (Dubravka, Gudmundsson, Keane*, Guiu)

  6. The Bandit
    • 15 Years
    2 mins ago

    Nacho goal

  7. patricio33
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 7 Years
    1 min ago

    For some strange reason, comments were disabled in the previous post about having four City players. But, I have a question about it:

    If I were to "decide to roll for a few weeks and enjoy the City foursome," would I still accumulate one free transfer for each week that I went without a transfer, or would I remain stuck on one without any accumulation?

    1. Baps Hunter
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 8 Years
      just now

      Until you have 5

    2. The Bandit
      • 15 Years
      just now

      You will accumulate. The rules say you have to sell a City player when you make a transfer, not that you have to make a transfer.

  8. F4L
    • 11 Years
    just now

    think chelsea look abit more gung ho under rosenior tbf, although only 1 match and a bit so far