Community
16 September 2025 221 comments
Greyhead Greyhead
Share:

Fantasy Football Scout community writer Greyhead is back with his The Great and The Good series, analysing the Gameweek 4 transfers and strategies of some well-known Fantasy Premier League (FPL) managers

The Great and The Good this season are the FPL Godfather Mark Sutherns, the BlackBox pair of Az and Andy North, Scouts FPL GeneralJoe and Tom, the FPL Wire trio of PrasLateriser and Zophar, FPL celebrities FPL HarryMartin BakerPingreenFPL Frasier and Luke Williams, Hall of Famers Ben CrellinFabio Borges and Tom Dollimore, and last year’s mini-league winner Huss E.


“Back to Black”

Is it just me, or do the international breaks seem to be getting longer?

There was very little to distract us apart from every man and his dog pointing out that Alexander Isak (£10.4m) was unlikely to start. He didn’t.

Whether it was boredom or one of the FPL algorithmic model influencers, a few also used the time to smash and like the Wildcard button. Expect the Bench Boost and Free Hit to follow in an orderly fashion over Gameweeks 5 and 6.

Fabio Borges was one to make the move.

OVERALL PERFORMANCE


Fabio Wildcarded into the highest score this week, thanks to Antoine Semenyo (£7.5m) and his DefCon magnets Virgil Van Dijk (£6.1m), Joachim Andersen (£4.5m) and Maxence Lacroix (£5.0m).

In fact, it appears that the trick this week, for non-Haaland owners at least, was the combination of Andersen and Semenyo, as Martin Baker and Zophar were the other managers in the seventies.

As noted, Fabio followed his Free Hit last week with a Wildcard, which suggests it wasn’t the pre-season plan but an adjustment in tactics influenced by injuries to some of his key players, such as Bukayo Saka (£9.8m), Ismaila Sarr (£6.5m) and Jorgen Strand Larsen (£6.4m).

He has moved to three strikers with Jean-Phillipe Mateta (£7.6m), Viktor Gyokeres (£9.0m) and Evanilson (£7.0m). The Bournemouth striker is part of a triple-up on the Cherries.

Elsewhere, Fabio has stuck with the double up of cheap-ish midfielders, with Lucas Paqueta (£5.9m) joined by Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall (£5.0m). It looks like the plan will be to rotate them with the budget defenders of Andersen and Marcos Sensei (£4.6m).

Finally, he has invested in David Raya (£5.5m) and van Dijk as the bedrocks of his backline. It’s interesting to note that he has no Manchester City players and no Free Hit, so I wonder how he will navigate that juicy-looking Gameweek 6 fixture against Burnley.

TRANSFERS

Sometimes the best approach is to keep it simple when it comes to transfers, and so it transpired with six of The Great and The Good going for Semenyo. I fully expect his price to rise further as he delivered his second double-digit haul of the season.

Elsewhere, the moves were focused on a trip to the Crystal Palace defence, with a split between whether to prioritise DefCon points in Lacroix or the attacking flair of Daniel Munoz (£5.6m).

It’s worth noting that Pras has now jumped on the Gyokeres bandwagon for a hit. He’s just under 50% owned in The Great and The Good, with fixtures about to turn.

TEMPLATE

There is a lot of uncertainty in the template, with only Mohamed Salah (£14.5m), Martin Dubravka (£4.0m) and Pedro Porro (£5.6m) over 80% owned. It’s perhaps a reflection of a season that has been tricky to predict so far.

Semenyo comes in as you would expect for an injured Matheus Cunha (£8.0m), whilst Cristian Romero (£5.0m) is unlucky to be moved on for Chris Richards (£4.5m). Luke Williams was one of his sellers in a week when he delivered a 12-point return.

Still, no one owns Erling Haaland (£14.1m)!

The template and % ownership amongst these managers is:

Dubravka (88.9), Sels (50.0)
Porro (88.9), Andersen (72.2), Esteve (50.0), Murillo (50.0), Richards (33.3)
Salah (94.4), Reijnders (66.7), Fernandes (61.1), Wirtz (61.1), Semenyo (50.0)
Watkins (66.7), J Pedro (55.6), Gyokeres (44.4)

BIG AT THE BACK

­­­FPL Gameweek 22 differentials: Gibbs-White, Wilson + Tarkowski 1

With the growing influence of DefCon points, there is a whisper in the wind that big at the back is back!

It’s worth noting that four out of the top 10 FPL points scorers are defenders, and there is even a goalkeeper – Guglielmo Vicario (£5.1m) – in there.

The most used formations this season are below.

  • 3-4-3 (10)
  • 3-5-2 (41)
  • 4-3-3 (3)
  • 4-4-2 (16)
  • 5-3-2 (2)

Have we seen a shift in the formations used by The Great and The Good? Well, not yet, with 3-5-2 dominating with the managers preferring Salah, a couple of £8-9m midfielders and then the likes of Tijjani Reijnders (£5.7m), Elliot Anderson (£5.5m) or Dewsbury-Hall.

4-4-2 has been the second most selected formation, and more may choose this path with DefCon monsters James Tarkowski (£5.5m) and Lacroix performing well. We also have the Arsenal defence repeating their form from last year, with fixtures looking good from Gameweek 7. They could easily be swapped in for the aforementioned £5-5.5m midfielders.

Others like Fabio have shifted to a 3-4-3 with Gyokeres now in play, safe in the knowledge that a couple of the £4.5m defenders can be rotated and are providing real value, such as Andersen.

Will the DefCon revolution gain more followers with the next surge of Wildcards?

CONCLUSION

The FPL season still seems to be finding its feet. The pre-season template appears to have led us astray, plus a tumultuous transfer window and now the European rotations will no doubt mean at least a few weeks more of uncertainty.

A good time to hold our nerves then, or we could say sod it and Wildcard to bring in Haaland, Salah and a bunch of DefCon hungry defenders!

Anyway, that’s all from me for now, and remember, don’t have FPL nightmares. 

For those affected by any of the topics raised above, you can find me here on Twitter or here on BlueSky.

221 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. Bigbars
    • 14 Years
    2 months, 19 days ago

    Anyone enjoying the defcon jeapordy mixing up fpl ?

    1. Moon Dog
        2 months, 19 days ago

        Yeah I am. I was sceptical at first, but it adds an extra layer to watching games. I like that they eventually added the DefCons from last season on the FPL page, makes it more of a level playing field for everyone, and not pay-to-win, which was my initial worry. Fun addition!

        1. Bigbars
          • 14 Years
          2 months, 19 days ago

          encourages you into thinking of changing usual fpl strategy and trying to get in a few defcon magnets to supplement goals and clean sheets which are sparse at the moment, i'm thinking of getting in more defcon cheapies as i think a couple of those will cover loss of clean sheets if i go budget defenders, then clean sheets would be a bonus

          1. Moon Dog
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Yep, it rewards those who are maths savvy. Which is something that got me addicted to this game in the first place. Back when the game was very basic, and played with pen and paper, I would calculate player value to make my decisions. It always starts with pts/£... that's how it gets you...

            • Moon Dog
                2 months, 19 days ago

                I'm with you on the cheapie defence approach. My defence is Lacroix - Senesi - Anderson - Tosin - Rodon, and I think a rotation between them will match a defence with the likes of Gabriel and Cucurella, while saving a ton of money. DefCons are a lot stronger than many are giving it credit. It lifts the floor massively of some players, which dampens the value of the 6.0m Arsenal defs. It's all relative. VORP is important.

                I think the money is better spent in attack because of this, and I think people are sleeping on the likes of Bruno and Mbeumo. Just sort the players by xGI and see how strong they are, especially given they've played Arsenal & City. I'm happy with my WC, even a week after I made it, which is a rare feeling!

          2. tutankamun
            • 16 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            Big opportunity this season for sure due to some of their low prices. Won’t be the same next season once their prices go up.

            1. Bigbars
              • 14 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              i agree defo. some low value players could swing it for us in our mini leagues just by getting 2 extra points. miss the old paper and pen days, when fantasy was just basic. only reason id get the times on a monday in those days

          3. White Pony
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 7 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            Yeah I like the addition.

          4. Casual Player
            • 5 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            makes every player relevant, good change IMO

        2. The Knights Template
          • 12 Years
          2 months, 19 days ago

          Conclusion: they’re all rubbish! Poor management!

          Huzzah!

          1. g40steve
            • 7 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            FLOL

          2. RedLightning
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • Has Moderation Rights
            • 15 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            There seems to be a groupthink among them about owning and captaining Salah, and it is amazing that none of them own Haaland.
            My Gameweek 4 Mini-League article will highlight the fact that nearly all the featured mini-league leaders now own Haaland, but that none of the top nine in the Live Hall of Fame do.

        3. The Bandit
          • 15 Years
          2 months, 19 days ago

          Yikes, what a woeful start. Not a single Haaland captain. Baaaaaaaaa

          1. Miguel Sanchez
            • 9 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            It’s all a bit safety in numbers

            1. The Bandit
              • 15 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Or the opposite. They don’t even pretend to make their own decisions, clearly it’s all groupthink.

          2. Brosstan
            • 11 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            Peak sheep moment.

          3. Bggz
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 15 Years
            2 months, 19 days ago

            They always do the same thing, use the same models, pick variations on the same players.
            The models and their spreadsheets are inaccurate at the start due to the variance, but unfortunately they become more accurate through the season and they end well.

        4. Moon Dog
            2 months, 19 days ago

            The Borges / Dollimore cream is slowly rising....

            1. Moon Dog
                2 months, 19 days ago

                That sounded way more dirty than I intended...

                1. FPL Blow-In
                  • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                  • 13 Years
                  2 months, 19 days ago

                  It didn’t until now actually 😳

            2. Mother Farke
              • 1 Year
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Dortmund pen.

              1. The Son-dance Kid
                • 7 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                Talk about jam!
                Vlahovic comes on in the 60th minute...2 goals, 1 assist, and likely MoTM bonus

            3. FPL Blow-In
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 13 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Madrid pen

            4. The Knights Template
              • 12 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Ball pen

            5. The Knights Template
              • 12 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Bull pen

            6. Feanor
              • 16 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              It's crazy that no one in the G&G had Haaland and captained him against a desperately poor United team. Are they all looking at the same bad model?

              1. Feanor
                • 16 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                A Salah pen miss would have wiped the lot of the out!

              2. Brosstan
                • 11 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                They are all in the same discord channel group thinking

              3. Bggz
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                • 15 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                Same every year. Boring.

            7. Brosstan
              • 11 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Juve - Dortmund absolute cracker of a game. Best Ive seen in a long time. And the first half was boring lol

            8. F4L
              • 10 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              8 second half goals in juve dortmund 😯

            9. F4L
              • 10 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              milwall equalise late on

            10. The Bandit
              • 15 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Juventus score in the 95th and 97th minutes to draw level 😯

            11. Mumchumba
              • 5 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              I captained him, but I'm neither Great or Good

            12. RICICLE
              • 3 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Has anyone got a link to the mods and cons league? I tend to just have a nosy now and then, but can’t seem to find it.

              Cheers for any help 😉

                1. The Bandit
                  • 15 Years
                  2 months, 19 days ago

                  Wondered why I hadn’t seen Sam on Sky Sports recently 😆

            13. F4L
              • 10 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              watkins scores his pen but mcginn took first. mcginn on pen duties?

            14. White Pony
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 7 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              I celebrated the second Haaland goal like I scored it.

            15. g40steve
              • 7 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Villa out

              1. tutankamun
                • 16 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                At least Watkins finally scored (a pen)

            16. Glasner Ball
              • 13 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Probably our worse performance for some time (even with the many changes), but 5 nice pens (and 2 good Benitez saves) to knock Millwall out.

            17. Sting
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 13 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              not a single Haaland pick amongst any of the so called elite managers.

              the groupthink is amazing. i suspect also stubbornness to prove that picks were correct. and biased towards a set of players favoured by prediction models.

              you can make huge gains on these managers by a) watching real football; b) applying interpretations gained by watching

              1. riot
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                • 14 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                it's genuinely so sad, Luke gets a pass because he plays creatively but I really don't see how playing like a sheep is enjoyable for some of these guys

            18. jayzico
              • 14 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              I'm at around 200,000 after some high scoring weeks and still dont get this DEFCON thing. Sounds like button for the end of the world. Must be doing something right though

            19. theshazly
              • 2 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Sels ( Dub )
              Guehi Porro Diouf (Guddmnssn / DeCuyper)
              Salah Wirtz KDH Reijnders Kudus
              JP Watkins Gyokeres

              1 FT / 2.1 ITB

              Do what ?

              A ) roll this week then do Wirtz, Watkins >> King, Haaland with 2 FT before GW6

              B ) WC

            20. Casp123
              • 10 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              What's the one midfielder you'd purchase at the moment? With the next few weeks in mind. I have Salah and Reijnders already.
              Really not bothered about any of them, maybe Semenyo.

              1. tutankamun
                • 16 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                Definitely Semenyo if you don’t already have him.

              1. ᶠᶦˡᵗʰʸLucre $$$
                • 10 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                I'd be surprised if they start dicking around with PL fixtures to accommodate a League Cup quarter final. I suspect they will just play the QF in semi first leg midweek and slot the semi in somewhere after.

            21. TheSteel
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 13 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Looks like Brennan Johnson lost his place at Spurs.

            22. Iceball
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 11 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              BB this? Dubravka KDH Esteve Diouf
              Yes or No?

              1. Mighty Duck
                • 1 Year
                2 months, 19 days ago

                Crackin' yes

            23. Pep Roulette
              • 8 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Will these players be rotated this weekend?

              1. Munoz
              2. Kudus

              1. tutankamun
                • 16 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                Why would Munoz be rotated?

                1. Pep Roulette
                  • 8 Years
                  2 months, 19 days ago

                  Has played a lot of games lately

                  1. tutankamun
                    • 16 Years
                    2 months, 19 days ago

                    Has he? More than most?

                    Season’s just started and he’s a beast of a player. Can’t see him being rotated v West Ham away.

            24. pundit of punts
              • 12 Years
              2 months, 19 days ago

              Thoughts? Any changes on the bench and first XI?

              Raya
              VdV - Cash - Gudmundsson
              Salah - Semenyo - Kudus - Reijnders
              Haaland - Gyokeres - Wood

              Dubravka - Reinildo - King - Dorgu

              Last GW without Pedro. Have 0.4m in the bank for Wood ➡ Pedro next gw. 🙂

              1. BigDan1995
                  2 months, 19 days ago

                  I have a similar lineup but starting Reinaldo over Reijdneers vs Arsenal I think

              2. Letsgo!
                • 9 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                Will u start damsgaard or tavernier?

              3. FPL Sanky
                • 2 Years
                2 months, 19 days ago

                Which one would you pick on a WC?
                A) Tarkow
                B) Munoz

                1. Letsgo!
                  • 9 Years
                  2 months, 19 days ago

                  Tarko