[sbu_large_image] Opinion
19 October 2015 852 comments
Paul Paul
Share:

Eden Hazard’s security of starts is now under threat. City’s attack flourish without Sergio Aguero, Anthony Martial’s versatility is a problem, whilst Arsene Wenger’s reluctance to rotate is benefitting Fantasy managers. Here’s the lessons learned from this weekend’s matches…

Hazard’s season goes from bad to worse…
Saturday’s team sheet at home to Villa sent shockwaves through the Fantasy community after the Belgian was benched for the first time in a league match under Jose Mourinho. A goal and two assists in his previous three had persuaded Hazard’s owners to hold in the hope that his sluggish start to the season would soon be a thing of the past but with his minutes now in question, the exodus is picking up pace. A spot on the bench against Dynamo Kiev in midweek may well be the final straw.

We’ve woken up to Wijnaldum…
The Dutchman’s stunning four-goal haul kick-started Newcastle’s kind run of matches in style as they grabbed a much-needed first win of the season. Wijnaldum’s display against Norwich means he’s now notched 20 times since August 2014 – that’s more than any midfielder in Europe over that period. The Dutchman looks essential to Steve McClaren’s chances of steering his side to safety and, at 6.8, has emphatically announced himself as a viable option for our five-man midfields.

City have more than enough without Aguero…
A 5-1 thrashing of Bournemouth dispelled any theories that the league leaders would struggle without Sergio Aguero on board. With David Silva also missing, Manuel Pellegrini’s decision to move to 4-4-2 paid off as front pair Raheem Sterling and Wilfried Bony ran riot against the beleaguered Cherries. City look full of goals right now and the Chilean’s penchant for playing with the handbrake off will keep their main men in contention, regardless of Aguero’s availability.

The Vardy bandwagon isn’t slowing…
A late brace at St Mary’s broke Southampton’s hearts and rescued another point for Claudio Ranieri’s never-say-die Leicester. At some point, the returns are bound to dry up for Vardy but, for now, his output is actually improving – he’s brought home his three highest hauls of the season in the last three Gameweeks. Having blanked in just one of nine appearances, that 35% ownership looks set to soar again, with the Foxes striker front of the queue for transfers in once more this week.

Mahrez has made his point….
Omitted from the first XI for the second match in succession, Mahrez’ half-time introduction was pivotal in inspiring his side’s comeback against the Saints. Having laid on three chances and provided the assist for Vardy’s last-gasp equaliser, the Algerian’s display will surely have given Claudio Ranieri food for thought as the Foxes prepare for the weekend visit of Palace. Despite their weekend showing, the Foxes have just one win in four now and Mahrez has surely done enough to earn a recall at home to the Eagles.

Martial’s versatility is a problem…
Shifted onto the left flank as Wayne Rooney was handed the lone striker role, the United youngster failed to find the net for the third successive Gameweek in a 3-0 win at Goodison. The third most popular striker in FPL, with an ownership of 30%, Martial’s ability to offer options on the flank is now proving detrimental to his Fantasy prospects and with Ander Herrera staking a claim for the role in “the hole” with a weekend goal and assist, Louis van Gaal isn’t short of options. With Memphis Depay benched and Juan Mata hauled off at the break, the United attack is becoming increasingly difficult to predict as Van Gaal looks for a winning formula.

Wenger’s suddenly not keen on rotation…
Despite the upcoming Champions League encounter with Bayern, the Gunners manager was reluctant to tinker with a winning line-up away to Watford. Wenger chose not to rest the likes of Nacho Monreal and Hector Bellerin at the back, whilst Theo Walcott yet again kept ahead of Olivier Giroud up top against the Hornets. In a weekend where Chelsea and United’s teamsheets raised an eyebrow, Wenger’s consistency of selection is proving reassuring for Fantasy managers.

Giroud isn’t going to allow us or Wenger to settle on Walcott…
Afforded yet another cameo off the bench, the Frenchman took his tally to three strikes in the last five Gameweeks – despite playing a mere 86 minutes over that period. Giroud may be playing second fiddle to Theo Walcott for the lone striker role right now but is still proving more prolific, with the England international notching just twice over that period by comparison. Wenger has now started Walcott in the last six league matches but Giroud is clearly not giving up without a fight.

Ozil’s consistency can make the difference…
With Alexis Sanchez running riot in recent weeks and Walcott’s out of position role also catching the eye, the German has remained under most Fantasy radars. Two assists against the Hornets, allied with maximum bonus, saw Ozil serve up back-to-back double-figure hauls as he rose to seventh amongst midfielders. At just 8.4 and owned by only 9%, it’s perhaps time we pay him a little more attention.

The promoted sides are being found out…
Bournemouth, Norwich and Watford all started the season relatively sprightly after arriving from the Championship but their early form is starting to wane. Shipping 14 goals between them in Gameweek 9, the promoted clubs have now picked up just one point apiece over the last three rounds of fixtures, with the former two now conceding 20 and 17 goals already. Whilst Watford have shipped just ten goals, a lack of impact in the final third has seen them net just six times – the worst record in the top-flight. With the honeymoon period now over, all three have plenty of work to do to stop a slide into the drop zone.

Norwich always need to start Redmond….
Handed a recall for the trip to St James’ the Canaries winger bagged a fourth goal of the season to take his tally to 44 points in FPL. With Wes Hoolahan dropping to the bench, Redmond’s threat down the right flank once again came to the fore to offer Alex Neil a crumb of comfort in the wake of Sunday’s 6-2 humbling. Given his side’s woes in defence, Redmond – one of only two players to score more than a single goal for Norwich this season – surely needs to start from now on if Neil’s men are to have a chance of beating the drop.

Paul Is certain he won't make the same mistakes next season. Follow them on Twitter

852 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. internal error
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Hazards defensive work isn't that much worse than last season

    1. Big Col
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Think Jose tried this with Hazard the season before last, I'm sure its his way of trying to motivate him.

      As a Chelsea fan I cant see us hitting the heights without Hazard, so don't expect him to be on the bench for long.

      I bought Hazard in on WC last week over Costa, although I expected Costa to do well, I see no reason to change at this stage.

      1. mambo
        11 years, 10 days ago

        I went Haz over Costa on my WC too. Gutted but I'll give the kid a few weeks before shipping.

      2. internal error
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 10 days ago

        he is clearly trying to get a positive reaction out him. The win against Villa was an easy one and winning without Hazard doesn't prove anything

        1. Big Col
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Yes, exactly!

        2. Somalion
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Agreed

    2. ​
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Nope, its opened the door for Real to tempt him though lol.

      1. internal error
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 10 days ago

        and Liverpool

        1. Somalion
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Best mates with Mata though, welcome to MUFC 😎

          1. internal error
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            11 years, 10 days ago

            Hazard went to primary school with Mignolet's cousin and he's bff's with Benteke. #donedeal

            1. ​
              11 years, 10 days ago

              😆 Somehow you'll end up with Thorgan instead of Eden

              1. internal error
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                11 years, 10 days ago

                he did ok last season. 7 assists in the Bundesliga

            2. Somalion
              11 years, 10 days ago

              Apparently fell out with Tekkers because he told him that he didn't like his neck hair.

              Mata, however, appreciates all attempts at beards.

    3. Piggs Boson
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Jose loves a scapegoat.

      1. internal error
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 10 days ago

        he loves scapegoats. A new one every week. Rui Faria up next

      2. ​
        11 years, 10 days ago

        which does him absolutely no favours if he's trying to build a dynasty

        1. Irish Madridista ⭐
          11 years, 10 days ago

          He's definitely not trying to build a dynasty.. Unless you mean the Mourinho FC dynasty consisting of countless short stints at teams around the globe.

  2. calsinc
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Need a new striker so if I had to pick one, do I get Martial or Lukaku?

    1. Sharkytect
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Lukaku.

  3. Sharkytect
    11 years, 10 days ago

    I see nothing wrong with getting wijnaldum. Fixtures look good for the short term, price will rise, great finishing, decent stats. I'm all over it. Bye bye Hoolahan!

    1. Up the tics
      11 years, 10 days ago

      i thought this before the deadline for gw9 😉

  4. INDIANPUNDIT
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Best 3 Everton picks please for their dream run of fixtures --

    (Repost,need more answers)

    1. Numb
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Lukaku
      Barkley
      Coleman

      In that order

    2. money face bandwagon
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Lukaku
      Coleman
      Baines

      1. INDIANPUNDIT
        11 years, 10 days ago

        When would baines be fit ?

        1. money face bandwagon
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Soon in a few gw time.

    3. FF Dirtbag
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Lukaku and Coleman is enough.

      1. FF Dirtbag
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Personally think Barkley takes up that midfield place that you cannot give away at the moment with all the better quality midfielders out there.

    4. Jpowell
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Lukaku, Barkley, Coleman

    5. Sharkytect
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Lukaku, Barkley, Coleman

  5. calsinc
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Going to play my wildcard.
    What are your thoughts?

    Butland Gomes
    Dawson Bellerin Van Dijk Janmaat Alderweireld
    Wijnaldum Payet Cabaye De Bruyne Sanchez
    Pelle Vardy Lukaku

    1. Big Col
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Is this you old team or a WC team?

      If its your old team cant see any reason to change what you have.

      1. calsinc
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Sorry forgot to specify, this would be my WC team

        1. Big Col
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Who are you benching? looks like a weekly headache.

          Had that myself at the being of the season with Mahrez & Wilson, benched the wrong one every time, so good luck with that.

          1. calsinc
            11 years, 10 days ago

            Very true I guess i'll bench depending on who plays who and just hope for the best

    2. Sharkytect
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Looks very very good. Man united have some good fixtures coming up - any room for Mata?

      1. calsinc
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Very difficult unless I downgrade Lukaku or Pelle to Ighalo and upgrade Cabaye or Wijnaldum

  6. Whats the Huth
    11 years, 10 days ago

    What to do with Kolv?

    A/ Get Everton Defender (Jags or Coleman)
    B/ Spurs defender (Toby)
    C/ Saints (Berty)
    D/ Keep and ride the price fall (BUT will he play vs Norwich - or will Clinchy be back)

    1. Paulie Walnuts
      11 years, 10 days ago

      B

    2. BbBb
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I just sold him and brought in Rojo.
      Utd have great fixtures after GW10 and I feel that Rojo will cement a left back starting role in Shaw's absence after his solid performance and an assist in GW9

  7. 1966 was a great year for E…
    11 years, 10 days ago

    I don't know if this has been posted, but Yaya having a moan again:

    http://www.express.co.uk/sport/football/613013/Yaya-Toure-unhappy-Manchester-City-exit-transfer-talk-Premier-League

    Just concentrate on scoring me some points, you whinging &*^%!

    1. 1966 was a great year for E…
      11 years, 10 days ago

      He says absolutely nothing about leaving City, though, despite the headline.

    2. Raddy
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I think Yaya is a little nuts tbh

      This is my favorite line:

      "Many people, beasts, I must say, have laughed at me when I said that. They wondered what I, Yaya Toure, could do to change City. And then you saw what happened next? We almost won everything"

      "beasts" 😉

  8. DannyBoy....
    11 years, 10 days ago

    If Jones starts alongside Smalling in the Derby game, is it safe to assume he is first choice / nailed on?

    1. Big Sum
      11 years, 10 days ago

      he is first choice, but he is not nailed on

    2. Kurtinho
      11 years, 10 days ago

      5.2m, good spot! One to monitor.

    3. BbBb
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I prefer Rojo as above, think he'll be Utd's new first choice left back now that he's made up with LVG and after his solid performance in GW9.
      I can see Jones being rotated with Blind as he's a Van Gaal favourite.

  9. Hooky
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Any ideas of what to do with my FT this week? Have nearly 8m itb and don't want Vardy. Thinking of maybe shipping Targett but not sure who to get in.

    Myhill, Hennessey
    Kolarov, Toby, Bartrand, Huth, Targett
    Hazard, Sanchez, Ayew, Mahrez, Surman
    Pelle, Ighalo, Berahino

    1. Big Sum
      11 years, 10 days ago

      You need better strikers imo

      1. Hooky
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Don't like Vardy or Costa so I guess Bony would be the best option to bring in?

        1. money face bandwagon
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Haha u dont like point scoring forwards?

          1. Hooky
            11 years, 10 days ago

            Vardy is a racist and Costa is just a horrible, dirty player. If not having them means me scoring less points then I can live with that.

            1. Bibelnissen
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              11 years, 10 days ago

              Then I don't understand why you're paying for membership priviliges on here tbh.

              1. Hooky
                11 years, 10 days ago

                I don't see why having principles should stop me from being a member?! I can just take the next player down on the list if I don't like one of them that is at or near the top.

                1. ILOVEBAPS
                  11 years, 10 days ago

                  Very true. Glad you are a member and on this site.

            2. Fitzy.
              11 years, 10 days ago

              Guess you never had Suarez in your team in previous seasons?

        2. Bibelnissen
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Don't like Vardy? What's the reasoning behind this?

        3. Total Foot 5
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Vardy racist, what did he do or say??

            1. Total Foot 5
              11 years, 10 days ago

              mercy. this is bad. Leicester’s Thai owners, the Srivaddhanaprabha family, are Buddhists and are known to place a high value on decency and manners. Vardy’s behaviour at the casino was reported to the club by a member of the public
              will the owners do something? challenging for them

    2. RustyBz
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I'd bring in KDB

      1. Hooky
        11 years, 10 days ago

        For Surman?

        1. RustyBz
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Yeah

  10. Numb
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Sometimes I wish I could play like a normal person - guy in my ML took a 12 point hit that more than paid for itself (including bringing in Costa and Bony) even though he only had a couple of injuries.

    Spoke to him this morning, he's like "obviously I brought in Wijnaldum last night, will have to bring in Sterling as well I think"

    He's actually doing well as well!

    1. ​
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Hey dont let us stop you from getting Wijy

      1. Numb
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Thing is, although he's doing very well he always seems to have at least one dodgy player that is a no brainer to swap to the likes of Wij. My team is too good (on paper!) to accommodate these bandwagons!!

        1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
          11 years, 10 days ago

          This is my problem too. I think Wijnaldum is worth a punt, or even just a place in my team, but how can I take out Mane, or Mahrez, or Payet? Mahrez is a possible candidate, if his starts keep looking dodgy, but that could so backfire.

    2. Sharkytect
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Are you not a normal person?

  11. RustyBz
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Myhill;

    Bellerin, B Davies, Azpilicueta;

    KDB, Sanchez(C), Ayew, Mahrez(VC);

    Pelle, Costa, Ighalo;

    Hennessey, Mané, Moreno, Hangeland

    1) Save this week? Would then use 2FT for GW11 on Costa + Ayew/B Davies -> Lukaku + Sterling/City DEF

    2) Who to bench this week: Ighalo or Mane?

    1. Jazz!
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Mané from them 2 I'd say. And save this week

    2. Russell
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I'm benching Pelle instead of Mane, got same problem.

  12. BucketHead
    11 years, 10 days ago

    So would ha take out Redmond (who I've wanted to move on fora while now) for wijlnadum??

  13. calsinc
    11 years, 10 days ago

    What is the better pair?

    A) Lukaku and Wijnaldum
    B) Ighalo and Mata

    1. RustyBz
      11 years, 10 days ago

      A, they have great fixtures.

      1. Bibelnissen
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 10 days ago

        So does B.

    2. Amsterhammer
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Think A. Both are guaranteed starters. Mata was subbed at half time and I gotta feeling we will see more of this. Ighalo I can see scoring well but not as well as Lukaku.

    3. BbBb
      11 years, 10 days ago

      C if you have a spare 0.8m - Lukaku & Hererra - if he can nail down the number 10 spot he will outscore Mata

  14. INDIANPUNDIT
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Best united defender for points ?

    1. RustyBz
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Smalling

    2. Nickofoz
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Smalling

  15. Jazz!
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Would you rather have Van Dijk/Bertrand or Coleman from GW11 onwards?

    1. Up the tics
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Coleman

  16. Up the tics
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Beat the bandwagon! Dont be afraid to take hits in order to beat the first on the bandwagon! And you know what they say, if you cant beat them, join them!!!

  17. KOLASINA(C)
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Just realised that I have just doubled on Arsenal's and WBA'S defence. Oh dear.

    1. Jazz!
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Double WBA has been working a treat for me 🙂

      1. Sjaugen
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Dawson power

        1. Jazz!
          11 years, 10 days ago

          And Myhill 🙂 Best keeper in FPL, gets bonuses every clean sheet!

          1. Sjaugen
            11 years, 10 days ago

            Just checked the BAPs. Dawson was 2 points from 2 BAPS. Oh well.

            1. Bibelnissen
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              11 years, 10 days ago

              That yellow card... 🙁

              1. Sjaugen
                11 years, 10 days ago

                That's -3 right? fekk

      2. KOLASINA(C)
        11 years, 10 days ago

        For me too, but who knows what time will tell in the future...

    2. Return Of Chamakh
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Not the worst shout to be honest!

  18. Sjaugen
    11 years, 10 days ago

    I had Kolarov, Dawson, Williams, Ward, Richards
    I bought Kolarov at 5.5, and I did Kolarov >> Bellerin yesterday

    My reasoning was that I want a cheap defense with 2x 4.5
    Dawson or Williams might become a Bertrand if I got spare FTs

    Could I get you chaps to rate my stupidity from 1 (good move) to 4?

    1. Amsterhammer
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Solid 3. Just don't take any hits jigging defenders about.

      1. Alittude
        11 years, 10 days ago

        i did kolarov to bellerin for a hit, paid off handsomely.

  19. internal error
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Ancelotti has said today that he never spoke with Liverpool about replacing Rodgers. Shove that up your pipe and smoke it, Harry

  20. Dynamic Duos
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Alli ft in mind, but not yet made for Surman.

    Gwk10 would be, G2G?

    Myhill
    Janmaat Richards Monreal
    Mata Alli Payet Sanchez
    Lukaku Costa (c) Vardy (v)

    McCarthy Mane Cedric Gomez

    1. Big Sum
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Save and paly mane

      1. Big Sum
        11 years, 10 days ago

        play*

    2. Jazz!
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Do not captain Costa. Chelsea were horrific yet again, (C)osta's got lucky. I'm doing Mahrez (c) but I'd suggest you captain Vardy.

      1. Dynamic Duos
        11 years, 10 days ago

        I'm still confident

    3. ​
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Don't get Dele Alli, he's gonna be a potential bench candidate in coming risks, also I'd (C) Sanchez or Vardy.

      Happy birthday by the way :mrgreen:

      1. Dynamic Duos
        11 years, 10 days ago

        OK Balders, I really take time to consider my options anyway.

        Thanks for birthday wishes.

    4. Sess!
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Benching mane, playing Ali? Err, what?!

  21. Manani
    11 years, 10 days ago

    assuming gomis blanks,

    should i shift out pedro or gomis?

    5m in bank, 1FT

    1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 10 days ago

      He won't blank, so it's academic. Pedro.

      In truth, the answer must depend on whom you would bring in.

      1. Manani
        11 years, 10 days ago

        costa/vardy for gomis,
        payet for pedro

  22. Sharkytect
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Everyone making transfers before the midweek matches? Are you sure?

    1. Dynamic Duos
      11 years, 10 days ago

      No wait.

    2. ​
      11 years, 10 days ago

      What could go wrong?

      1. Sjaugen
        11 years, 10 days ago

        It's a good thing I don't make a living off this. I did the Ayew >> Mane kneejerk two Saturdays ago.

      2. Sharkytect
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Haha. Yeah it's not like we have to think back a long way for a precedent!

    3. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I'm not, even though it's going to kill me watching Toby go up tonight.

    4. Sess!
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Learnt my lesson hard during international break. Stuff price rises. Waiting until Fri.

    5. The Gambler.
      11 years, 10 days ago

      the chances are a lot slimmer this week.

      a player only has 1 game in europe rather than 2 internationals.

      #justsaying

      1. Sharkytect
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Valid point. Last week's catastrophe is less likely, plus many players we are considering are not in the champions league.

  23. Jazz!
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Who do we think will get more points?

    A) Lukaku vs Sunderland (H)
    B) Bony vs Norwich (H)

    1. Big Sum
      11 years, 10 days ago

      B) Bony vs Norwich (H)

    2. Dynamic Duos
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Close but I already have Lukaku, so hopefully him.

    3. Bibelnissen
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      B).

      Don't trust Lukaku and will be hesitant to bringing him in.

    4. Sess!
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Bony. Lukaku seems to prefer the tougher games.

  24. AK ⭐
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Well, Fuzzy made it to 101goals.com at least..

    http://uncova.com/fpl-manager-writes-to-pl-over-when-southamptons-cedric-was-substituted

    1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Well, good for him. I think he totally misses the point, but we're all a little over the top here, so more power to him.

      1. Sess!
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Yeah, he didn't play 60 mins. Whether it was by 15 mins or 15 secs. End of.

        1. Piggs Boson
          11 years, 10 days ago

          He's not asking for a CS, he's asking for consistency.

      2. AK ⭐
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Using another player's minutes (Yoshida) to support your own player's argument (Cedric) was never going to work. I don't know why it's difficult to accept a simple fact that the player did not complete full 60. We have all been there, it's not something that happens very rarely.

      3. Billy Gilmore
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Yeah, there are 2 situations where the minutes played matter, 30 mins and 60 mins. In those situations it will always be 59 and 31 (albeit slightly incorrect, correct in practice) Every other situation is immaterial.

        1. Sharkytect
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Actually, I think you'll find that if a player comes off ar the 30 minute mark (lets say 30:42) then they will be awarded 30 and the player coming on 60 by FPL.

          So fuzzy does have a point.

          1. AK ⭐
            11 years, 10 days ago

            Has that actually ever happened though?

            1. Sharkytect
              11 years, 10 days ago

              I'm not gonna go through every single player's history to find one who has come on/off on the 30 minute mark, but based on the minutes awarded by FPL for every substitution I have ever seen, i am gonna assume that yes, yes it has actually happened.

              1. AK ⭐
                11 years, 10 days ago

                So you don't know if it has actually happened, but you are sure on the basis of your assumptions that it has actually happened?

                1. Sharkytect
                  11 years, 10 days ago

                  On the opening day of the season Cattermole came off with 29 FPL minutes under his belt, and Fletcher came on with 61. Annoyingly, not the exact evidence you're looking for.

                  If a player comes off a minute later, they will get 30 minutes, and the player coming on will get 60 minutes. No examples given, but given that every single substitution is calculated in this way by FPL, it is highly likely that this has happened some point in the many years of FPL, when a player has been subbed during the 31st minute.

          2. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
            11 years, 10 days ago

            No he really doesn't. His entire argument is based on consistency, but he offers no reason why consistency is required in this situation. There is no rule principle, or any other interest that calls for FPL to be consistent as to the the situations Fuzzy is talking about. FPL is not in the business of accurately describing the Universe, and creating an elegant model that adequately accounts for all of the minutes in a game. Instead, they are in the business of defining the cirucmstances under which points are earned. The did that: a defender earns 4 points if the play at least 60 minutes without conceding a goal.

            1. AK ⭐
              11 years, 10 days ago

              This.

            2. Sharkytect
              11 years, 10 days ago

              "they are in the business of defining the circumstances under which points are earned. The did that: a defender earns 4 points if the play at least 60 minutes without conceding a goal."

              In that case, in the example stated above, the player coming on in the 31st minute (say, 30:42) should not be awarded clean sheet points because they should not technically be awarded 60 minutes of game-time, having come on to the pitch half way through the 31st minute and not completing 60 full minutes of football.

              Not asking for FPL to delve into any rules beyond the realm of fantasy football. I don't even care if we think they should change some of their rules (for instance, 6 points for a keeper coring a goal? Surely they should award more than that). All I am saying is that they should get their own rules correct.

              1. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
                11 years, 10 days ago

                First of all, what is with me constantly writing "the" when I mean "they"? 🙂

                Second, IF it is true that they would give the whole 60 to the player who comes on at 30:42, that would be inconsistent and silly, but I have no reason to believe it is true.

                1. Sharkytect
                  11 years, 10 days ago

                  Haha, I could have edited the quote for you, but this is a forum of rapid-fire replies. Typos are to be expected (all my comments have them).

                  You DO have reason to believe this is true, because FPL awarded Yoshida 30 minutes for coming on at 60:42. This is the whole point of Fuzzy's argument.

                  They awarded Fletcher 61 minutes when he came on at 29 minutes (and something) in gameweek 1 (see my response to AK Top 10 above), so we can assume they would award 60 minutes to someone coming on during the 31st minute.

                  (I don't even have Cedric, why am I arguing!?)

    2. THE Wild Rover
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I think he has lost the plot

      1. ​
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Lost his Warbles you might say

      2. Irish Madridista ⭐
        11 years, 10 days ago

        5 points the price of a good plot these days..

    3. DeadStarComing
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Yeah I'm a little confused with this one. It clearly states on the rules page a player must complete 60 mins to get the clean sheet. Yet a new shot/pass ruling out a previous assist isn't mentioned. To be clear (before the abuse starts) I know Pelle didn't earn an assist, but I'm standing by the fact it's not actually written on the FPL rule page why.

      Good luck to him though,

      1. THE Wild Rover
        11 years, 10 days ago

        *sigh* It IS in the rules but you are the only person who can't see it. You think they can describe every possible scenario?

        1. DeadStarComing
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Copy and paste me the bit I'm missing then. I'm honestly not trying to be annoying or anything. I honestly can't see it. I do understand the reason why it's not an assist.

      2. AK ⭐
        11 years, 10 days ago

        I think the same happened with a Pienaar assist 2 seasons back. I had him and I think he assisted Mirallas. Mirallas hit the cross bar but the rebound fell to him and he scored again. I do remember Pienaar not getting the assist on that day, but I think he might have got an assist later when it was reviewed.

        1. DeadStarComing
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 10 days ago

          Look this is my best way of putting it...

          Yeah they are basically saying that when a player shoots at goal and it is either saved, blocked or hits the woodwork then the opportunity of an assist being awarded is gone. It's basically a new phase in play.

          The way they word their rules though suggests that the final pass to a goal scorer is an assist. They neglect to mention that if the goal scorer doesn't score first time then an assist is not awarded.

          1. AK ⭐
            11 years, 10 days ago

            I do have a bit sympathy for you. The rules on this particular regard (player hitting the post and then scoring) isn't really clear, but as I pointed out in the Pienaar-case 2-3 seasons back, it has happened before.

            Very unlucky in all fairness not to get that assist, Virgil should have just scored from the initial shot. 😉

            PS. Not a Pelle owner.

          2. Gamoriola of the Galaxy (Eu…
            11 years, 10 days ago

            What they do mention, however, is that when a player hits the post, and it rebounds and is then shot in for a goal, the first player gets an assist. In other words, it defines what Van Dijk did first--hitting the post and rebounding back to him--as the relevant assist for the goal that followed. Therefore, Pelle cannot have made an assist, because Van Dijk did. It is clearly stated in the rules that what Van Dijk did was THE assist for that goal.

            1. THE Wild Rover
              11 years, 10 days ago

              This. You can't assist yourself and Pele assisted the effort that hit the post. Simples

            2. DeadStarComing
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              11 years, 10 days ago

              They could simply add the line "When a player shoots at goal more than once the previous pass/shot does not result in an assist".

              1. DeadStarComing
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                11 years, 10 days ago

                Ironically, everyone has said the obvious - you can't assist yourself. So shouldn't they change the rules on this so that the last player to play the ball does get an assist? That's would be the most consistent/fair thing to do. I know this may result in a lucky assist being given but at least it would be consistent.

  25. Pringle
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Who do you prefer? Moreno or Dawson?

    1. AlCapwnUK
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Moreno

    2. kelsek
      11 years, 10 days ago

      moreno, wba had a load of defensive injuries couple of weeks back and have looked weak in D since

      1. Sess!
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        11 years, 10 days ago

        West brom are rubbish. They'll get found out soon.

    3. Sess!
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Alberto

    4. Nickofoz
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Moreno. For West Brom it's Myhill or nobody IMO. The boy gets BAPS for every clean sheet (Dawson owner here).

    5. Alittude
      11 years, 10 days ago

      suprised at the answers wow. dawson for me

    6. Sharkytect
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Dawson.

  26. turboLuck
    11 years, 10 days ago

    if you can only have 3 spots (1 def,1 mid and 1 fwd) between EVE and SOU what would your picks be?

    1. ​
      11 years, 10 days ago

      VvD, Mane, Lukaku

      1. turboLuck
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Thnx! Might need to do a little sideways switching over the next 2 weeks.

    2. Sess!
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      Van Djk
      Mane
      Pelle

      Maybe coleman over van Djk if don't want to triple up.

      1. turboLuck
        11 years, 10 days ago

        Currently have Bert, Barkley, Pelle.
        Was thinking Bert, Mane, Lukaku?

        1. Sess!
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          11 years, 10 days ago

          I got Bert last week. If I'd have waited would have def got van djk

    3. Irish Madridista ⭐
      11 years, 10 days ago

      VvD / Coleman

      Mane / Mane (and Mane again for good measure.)

      Pelle / Lukaku

      1. turboLuck
        11 years, 10 days ago

        You're making me want to switch my Barkley for Mane and Pelle for Lukaku :]

        1. Irish Madridista ⭐
          11 years, 10 days ago

          I'd prefer to have Mane + Lukaku over Barkley + Pelle, but I have Pelle and I probably unfairly rate Barkley as shite.

          1. turboLuck
            11 years, 10 days ago

            Haha ok lets see. Thnx mate.

  27. Pringle
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Two dilemmas:

    1. Start Huth or Moreno next weekend?
    2. Start Ighalo or Pelle next weekend?

  28. Dezrar
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Butland
    Nyom Richards Francis (Kolarov & Reid)
    Mahrez KDB Alexis Payet Wijnaldum
    Bony Vardy (Martial)

    Toss up between Mahrez & Martial but leaning towards Mahrez??? There's even that mysterious All Out Attack chip...? But then I guess thats too much of a risk atm as Mahrez is no longer nailed & I suspect Martial will become the same?

  29. Alittude
    11 years, 10 days ago

    Is the old saying never take a hit for defender just hearsay?

    I just did kolarov to bellerin for a hit last week and it paid off handsomely, so obviously the rule isn't NEVER to take a hit for a defender.

    (You always double down on 11.)

    1. Sess!
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      11 years, 10 days ago

      I got Bert and Gabriel in for a hit. Total of -8pts.

  30. FPL Daniel
    11 years, 10 days ago

    City are baking amateurs really. Just make tons and tons of cakes for Yoyo, how difficult is that. Now he is moaning something again...

    1. Alittude
      11 years, 10 days ago

      he needs cake like aguero needs eva caneiro