Community
27 October 2017 3405 comments
J0E J0E
Share:

Second guessing Pep Guardiola’s starting XI dominates much of the discussion this week as the Spaniard continues to torment us with his teamsheet tinkering. Our Hot Topic posters also find time to discuss whether to hitch a ride on Jose Mourinho’s bus and mull over Harry Kane solutions, while our community scribes analyse the different ways teams build their attacks.

We also welcome back one of last season’s most popular community article series, sift through the best defensive statistics and find out who has got the measure of the Manchester City line-up at the top of our community leagues.

The Community Articles

This week saw the welcome return of YMA’s look at how form and fixture data can help pick the best captain for the next set of fixtures, with Sergio Aguero among the key players to consider for the armband according to his Gameweek 10 preview.

Manchester City assets are also under scrutiny in André94PT’s analysis of the different ways Premier League teams attack, and in Hutch_James’ latest crowd predictions.

Meanwhile, Sky Blues rotation produced mixed results in Gameweek 9 for the Career Hall of Fame top five being tracked by Top Marx.

Elsewhere, Niemi dropped by with the latest news on team form in the Norwegian top flight, as Fantasy Eliteserien nears its nail-biting conclusion.

Don’t forget, if you’ve got some analysis, scout reports or features brewing, be sure to visit our community section to submit your article.

The Hottest Topics

While City’s excellence in attack is not in dispute, what is troubling our community is how much pitch-time their assets will be given.

As our Gameweek 9 rough with the smooth round up of your highs and lows revealed, many were caught out by some surprise omissions from Pep Guardiola’s starting XI last weekend.

We canvassed your views on how you plan to deal with the heavy threat of rotation that looms over City assets, while Ktk Interista attempted to find some method in their manager’s team tinkering. In addition, Ludo’s analysis of Pep’s team sheets left us in no doubt that the Spaniard simply doesn’t care about our Fantasy teams.

The community feels they have a better steer on how City’s rivals Manchester United will set up ahead of the visit of Spurs this Saturday and a trip to Chelsea the following weekend.

Eden Wizard has strong reason to believe Jose Mourinho will be eschewing attack and is  preparing the biggest bus he can find to stop Spurs, although following today’s revelation of Harry Kane’s absence, maybe even Jose will consider changing tact.

But even if the Red Devils may take a more defensive approach, The Twelfth Man believes that Romelu Lukaku owners should keep hold of him, particularly with Kane injured, while unlike City options, the Belgian is at least guaranteed to start.

Among the teams to see an upturn in fortunes from Gameweek 10 is Watford, which has prompted considerable interest in their Brazilian sensation Richarlison, who has scored three times and assisted a further four this season. But while he earned considerable praise on our latest Scoutcast, we asked whether you think he is the real deal.

The young winger also earns a mention in VK’s discussion on the perfect midfield and Pukka–Geoff’s Hot Topic on the increasing competition for midfield places in our Fantasy line-ups.

We also found time to discuss Kane’s dazzling display against Liverpool in Gameweek 9, when he broke his league hoodoo at Wembley by scoring twice. With strong underlying statistics over his barren ‘home’ run, we asked whether Sunday’s turnaround was a victory for number crunching analysis.

But, of course, Kane will sit out Gameweek 10 which today sparked much discussion on possible solutions. First our Hot Topic asked for your plans in light of his absence. Then chatter turned to the Free Hit chip as a possible solution. Tears for Fers turned up to clarify the rules, while Musicholic offered an example of how the chip can impact squad value and budget while active.

Finally, our Live Hall of Fame has been updated to take into account Gameweek 9’s scores, and it revealed that a former number one is staging a dramatic march back to the top.

To view all our discussions please visit our Hot Topics page.

The Members’ Tables

Had enough of Ben Davies failing to make the first XI? Electrue understands your pain and has been taking a look at some replacements to consider.

But those shopping for an alternative to the Spurs defender are urged to steer clear of those highlighted in dingo 1982’s dreadful defences table.

There is further rearguard analysis in Montafly’s comparison of Liverpool and Burnley assets, with both teams having a raft of budget defenders to consider.

Jurgen Klopp’s troops also come under the gaze of Dexter4king, who is in search of their best midfield options.

If you’re a member and are yet to get to grips with the custom statistics tables, you can view this movie for an explanation of how they work. Also, remember to tag them so that people can find the tables with ease.

The Community Tournaments

Fabio Borges has regained the lead in Red Lightning’s Top 10k Any Season league, as well as the summit in the FFS Members League, while Damir TeNay still leads the main FFS league and is seventh in the overall standings.

In TorresMagic’s Last Man Standing, the safety score was 39, which saw 202 players depart and over 2,600 remain.

FC Lackless retains top spot in QPR Utd’s FFS Frequent Summer Posters league, and in the FFS Old Farts Club league, PDM has a commanding 21-point lead over second-placed Ross Graham.

Uwais Ahmed remains first in the FFScout Moderators and Contributors league, with Stilicho’s ghost ship team docked in second.

In Heels Over Head’s R U Smarter than 10K Club, for those who have never finished so high, Bargain Hunters is in the lead. Heels Over Head also issued a plea for community members to take part in his expanded draft competition.

If you are running a community tournament and would like the latest scores included in future Community Round-Ups, please email us summary of the current leaders and a link to your league, spreadsheet or head-to-head competition, at jonty@fantasyfootballscout.co.uk.

3,405 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. arndff_
    9 years, 13 days ago

    A bit frustrated with Kane injury, but sticking with that team. G2G?

    Elliot
    Otamendi Monreal Jones
    Eriksen Salah(C) DSilva Richarlison(VC)
    Kane* Morata Abraham

    DDG Tarroll Naughton Long

    1. ⚽️ Dingo ⚽️
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Gtg Bro, or Kane to Kun for a bit of a punt.

      1. arndff_
        9 years, 13 days ago

        No free transfers left.
        Have faith that Kane'll return for Palace game.

  2. ⚽️ Dingo ⚽️
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Gtg?

    Who to captain?

    Elliott
    Cedric / Otamendi / Mee
    Salah / Richarlison / Sterling / Ritchie
    Kun / Morata / Lacazettte

    Hart / Carroll / Naughton / Long

    1. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Salah or Lacazette as (C) for me

      Richarlison as (VC)

      G2G.

    2. Holmes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      😮

      WC or Free Hit?

      1. ⚽️ Dingo ⚽️
        9 years, 13 days ago

        -4

        1. arndff_
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Nice!

      2. arndff_
        9 years, 13 days ago

        It has to be WC imo. 🙂

        1. ⚽️ Dingo ⚽️
          9 years, 13 days ago

          I should WC?

    3. La Roja
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Salah(c)

  3. La Roja
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Rate my free losers team;

    Mig
    Gomez Ota Kola Maguire
    San(c)hez Sane Richarlison Salah(VC)
    Jesus Laca

    Elliot Mariappa Surman 4.5

    1. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      G2G

    2. ⚽️ Dingo ⚽️
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Solid

    3. Jafooli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      No Kane 😮

    4. fedolefan
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Is this a free hit team? Really good. I'd want a Burnley keeper over Mig. Maguire, I'm not convinced about too.

  4. JasonG123
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Why is Salah so favoured over Morata for the captaincy this week? Morata is more explosive and Salah may get less oportunities without Mane and Coutinho.

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Morata poor performance last week and coming back from injury and you argue salah has more potential to be explosive

    2. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Salah could shine even without Cout & Mane,
      as he did for Egypt lately.

      Morata has just came off an injury. He needs to hit form again.

  5. ragsyboys
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Coutinho to Sane ?

    1. Lone Wolf
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Cou injured so..

    2. JonSnow
      9 years, 13 days ago

      For free yes

  6. Lone Wolf
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Fabianski, Elliot
    Otamendi, Jones, Ward, Dunk, Rangel
    Cou*, Hazard, Richarlison, Choupo, Carrick
    Firmino, Jesus, Vardy

    0FT, 5.3 ITB. (Will make Vardy > Kane when he is fit)

    a) Cou > Sane/Silva
    b) Cou > Eriksen
    c) Cou > Sanchez (no Kane back in 1 FT)
    d) no hit, play Jones

    1. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      If you wanna make a hit, then C) imo.

    2. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      D

  7. Winners900
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Firmino or Lacazette

    Next two? Assume I can take Lacazette(C) this round.
    If not Salah(C) if I pick Firmino

    Thoughts?

    1. Lone Wolf
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Firmino

    2. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I'd choose La(c)a.

    3. JonSnow
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Firmino will likely be playing on the wing in place of coutinho with sturridge up top, go laca

    4. Joggers Nipple
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Lacca

  8. bigbudgie
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Draft game:

    Pope
    Stones Davies VVD Cedric
    Pedro Alli Richarlison Stanislas
    Lacazette Joselu

    I've got Bailly and I want to play him if he's fit so who to drop?
    A) Stanislas
    B) Davies
    C) joselu

    1. Lone Wolf
      9 years, 13 days ago

      B

  9. Jafooli
    9 years, 13 days ago

    How does this look as a FH chip team:

    Elliott
    Monreal - Duffy - Dunk
    Sanchez (c) - Silva - Sane - Salah
    Morata - Firmino - Vardy

    4.0 - 4.5 - 4.0 - 4.0

    Is there a FHC template going about for this GW?

    1. Lone Wolf
      9 years, 13 days ago

      FH only for Blank/DGW imo but it looks nice

      1. Jafooli
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Yeah that's what I was thinking, but current team looks like it could bomb massively this GW....

    2. the snazzy viking
      9 years, 13 days ago

      awful

      1. Jafooli
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Ah cheers Snazzy....

    3. La Roja
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Looking very good except Firm

      1. Jafooli
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Who better Roja?

        1. La Roja
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Nobody at that price. Laca if you could

    4. Holmes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Need more Ozil and Lacazette and KDB

    5. FootballFanatic365
      9 years, 13 days ago

      SAVE

  10. D_R_S_PORT_S
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Swansea:,3 cleansheet from 4 is in away along with spurs ...so m I good to play naughton over Carroll in replace of Kane ???
    Naughton - Carroll - Francis are the options !!!

    1. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Swansea will concede. I'm going with Tarroll because he could make an assist to Tammy.

      In the worst scenario, both Naughton and Tarroll will record 2 points.

  11. machickenz
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Is it worth holding onto Kane for a week or trade?
    I need a player to field..
    a) trade Clark > Ward
    b) trade Kane + Sterling (20.9) > Aguero + Mid (9.1)?

    1. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Keep

    2. JonSnow
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Keep if you can field 11, I had to transfer. Too much uncertainty with bavies, kun, sterling, lejeune and rlc

  12. tvz32
    9 years, 13 days ago

    I have Kane at 12.5 and his price now is 12.7. When i try to sell him i see my selling price is still 12.5. Shouldnt it be 12.6 instead?

    1. machickenz
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Depends on when you got him. I've got him valued at 12.6. I've had him from the start of the season

    2. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      He should but are you sure that you bought him at 12.5?

      1. tvz32
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Yes i am sure. He is listed as 12.5 on my team page

        1. Red Dagger ✪
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          9 years, 13 days ago

          That's very odd then.

    3. Red Dagger ✪
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 13 days ago

      He should. Use list view to check what you bought him at.

  13. TheSteel
    9 years, 13 days ago

    I need to bench one of these and im havinv a hard time picking.
    Monreal(SWA)
    Moreno(HUD)
    Stones(wba)
    Ward(NEW)
    Jones(TOT)

    1. the snazzy viking
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I’d bench Moreno. Liverpool can’t defend against the smaller teams

    2. FootballFanatic365
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Moreno

    3. fedolefan
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I'd bench Jones. Lower points ceiling than any of the other. His value is in his consistency of points over time.

      1. TheSteel
        9 years, 13 days ago

        I like this answer. Thank you

    4. Red Dagger ✪
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Jones of those. Moreno is nailed to score and clean sheet this week.... Said the Liverpool supporter.....

  14. Hymie
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    9 years, 13 days ago

    My point exactly. Had 2FTs, Kane wasn't going to do much this weekend and a lack of quality replacements. Already plan to ship Jesus (cars) next week and have Ward and Lascelles on the pine, so Ward now plays. Used both trades to go Alli to Salah (vc) and downgrade Cedric to Dunk.

    1. Hymie
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Jesus (c)

  15. Jafooli
    9 years, 13 days ago

    That moment when you reset your Free Hit draft and all the dross comes flooding back in 😥 😥

  16. FootballFanatic365
    9 years, 13 days ago

    aguerro or Jesus ?

    lets play "second guess pep"

    1. Positive vibes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Kun for me

    2. JonSnow
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Jesus this week

  17. Ravager
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Captain:

    A) Salah
    B) Vardy
    C) Morata

    1. FootballFanatic365
      9 years, 13 days ago

      c

    2. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A

    3. La Roja
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A

    4. arndff_
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Salah the safest one

      1. Ravager
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Thanks guys. Not worried that Pool struggles to break them down?

    5. fedolefan
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Hard. I'm never confident in Salah as a captain given his low bonus. Vardy is the opposite. 1 shot all match, 1 goal, 3 bonus. Bournemouth are decent at home, and Morata is not captain material yet given he's just come back. I'd pick Salah given how negative Puel was at Southampton.

      1. Ravager
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Nice analysis. Plus Salah is so wasteful to be honest. Needs a few chances to bury one.

    6. Positive vibes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I'm between A or C.

    7. Jafooli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A

  18. fedolefan
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Well, done with my WC. Couple of starter dilemmas.

    Pick one to start from each pair, please:

    A) Gross (SOU)
    B) Diouf (wat)

    1) Lascelles (bur)
    2) Jones (TOT)

    1. Ravager
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A1

    2. Holmes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A2

    3. Positive vibes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A1

    4. fedolefan
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Everyone picking Gross. That's helpful.

    5. We Will Klopp you
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A1

  19. ROSSI_7
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Davies or Trippier?

    1. Mauricios Cappuccino
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I have them both, need to transfer one out! Aurier got rested midweek while all other spurs fullbacks played 90mins (with Bavies playing on left of back 3). So aurier looks set to come in... so you would think he would play RWB in place of trippier. Though last week he did play LWB to combat pace of Salah... Ive juut rambled on, conclusion, I dont know.

  20. Positive vibes
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Hope Kun have decent playing time and scores.

    1. We Will Klopp you
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Same

  21. mcrayeps
    9 years, 13 days ago

    my WC Team :

    Elliot / Ryan
    Otamendi / Jones / Daniels / Naughton / Moreno
    Salah / Eriksen / Silva / Richarlison / Caroll
    Aguero / Morata / Diouf
    2.2 itb

    A) Rate it please, and Any suggestions?
    B) im sort of 0.2 to get Kane for Morata next week (if he fit).. Any idea who to drop and for who?

    1. Positive vibes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A. Decent balance team
      B. Downgrade one of Naughton or Moreno
      Who is your C this week?
      Semoga sukses:)

      1. mcrayeps
        9 years, 13 days ago

        thank you 🙂
        maybe Salah with Aguero as a VC
        still fixing the wc squad

        Sama2 dan semoga sukses 😉

  22. Mets
    9 years, 13 days ago

    On WC, current team looks like

    Elliott - Speroni
    Kolasinac - Mee - Rangel - Otamendi - Lascelles
    Salah - Sane - Romeu - Sanchez - Richarlison
    Lacazette - Aguero - Diouf

    0.0 ITB.

    Thoughts/suggestions please?

  23. ROSSI_7
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Aguero for (C) I can see kun scoring a hat-trick against West Brom!

    1. Holmes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Will be tough to do that in 10mins 😮

  24. LD
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Gtg?

    Elliot
    Cedric - Mee - Cresswell - Jones
    Sterling - Eriksen - D. Silva - Richarlison
    Kaku - Calvert-Lewin

    DDG (3.9) Carroll Kane
    Any ideas on who to captain?
    Thanks 🙂

  25. Jimmy Boy
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Captain Aguero or Lacazette?

    1. ROSSI_7
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Aguero!

      1. smix
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Aguero too much of a risk !

    2. Holmes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Lac

  26. smix
    9 years, 13 days ago

    After multiple hits ! GTG?

    Elliot
    Jones Ward Duffy
    Sanchez(c) Salah Silva Sterling
    Jesus Vardy Diuof
    Fab Davies Lascelles Surman

    1. We Will Klopp you
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Yes

  27. We Will Klopp you
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Who gets most points? I'll give my reservations of each pick although they all tempt me.

    A) Laca - doesn't get full 90 mins
    B) Salah - no Coutinho/Mane
    C) Aguero - playing time
    D) Sane - will he start?

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      If everyone plays 90 than
      1.aguero
      2 laca
      3. Salah
      4. Sane
      I don't think everyone will play 90 so I reckon salah will be on top.whats your team looking like
      this saw you took a 32 point hit 😮

      1. We Will Klopp you
        9 years, 13 days ago

        I went crazy tbh, but reckon I could break even, if not then I'll take it on the chin, things just went to pants so thought I'd try to fix it with a bit of crazy

        Elliott (Fabianski)
        Azpilicueta Ward Duffy (Jones Rosenoir)
        Salah Silva Sane Choupo Richarlison
        Aguero Lacazetter (Abraham)

        1. Pranav Santhosh
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Are you looking to bring in either lukaku or Kane in the coming weeks or sticking with lacazette aguero up top?

          1. We Will Klopp you
            9 years, 13 days ago

            2.1m itb so will do Laca to Kane when he's back with Abraham/Choupo being downgraded, wasn't sure which at the time so thought I'd get them both in and see who does better, downgrade the other

            1. We Will Klopp you
              9 years, 13 days ago

              Kun is a better option than Kaku imo

            2. Pranav Santhosh
              9 years, 13 days ago

              Sounds like a plan good luck for this werk could go well considering kaku and Kane can't punish

              1. We Will Klopp you
                9 years, 13 days ago

                Hope so mate and good luck to you too. If ever there was a week to do something crazy it's this one 😉

  28. melvinmbabazi
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Is selling Kane worth -8?

    1. We Will Klopp you
      9 years, 13 days ago

      What would your moves be?

      1. melvinmbabazi
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Am on -4 Would bring Morata for -8

        1. We Will Klopp you
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Hmm, he's injured so think of it as only a -2, I think it's worth it

          1. melvinmbabazi
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            9 years, 13 days ago

            But its minor so could be back soon

            1. We Will Klopp you
              9 years, 13 days ago

              If you have cover you can bench him if it would be difficult to get him back for you but Poch has lied about the extent of injuries in the past and wouldn't be keen on having a 12.7m player on my bench personally

    2. Holmes
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Depends on replacement

      Thats only -4pts

  29. L'Aeroplanino
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Richarlison Sterling Silva Eriksen
    Kane Lukaku Joselu

    I want Salah but can only do it by getting rid Eriksen or Sterling (-4)....Save and (c) Silva?

    cheers

    1. We Will Klopp you
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sterling to salah imo

      1. L'Aeroplanino
        9 years, 13 days ago

        even if its a -4?

        1. We Will Klopp you
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Yeah, worth it if you'll captain him imo

          1. L'Aeroplanino
            9 years, 13 days ago

            Thanks Jurgen

    2. L'Aeroplanino
      9 years, 13 days ago

      1ft

  30. Who Am I?
    9 years, 13 days ago

    (C) Sanchez or Salah?

    1. We Will Klopp you
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Has to be Sanchez if you have him