Breaking into the top 10,000 in the Fantasy Premier League this season is seemingly tougher than ever. But has this always been the case or is this season an exception? This analysis will look in detail at this elite group and find out whether joining their ranks really is getting harder.
To help look back at the top 10,000 in FPL I have used the excellent analysis from Smarty Pants’ FPL Discovery website and have been inspired by the research from the FFScout community, for example this analysis by Balders into the cost of the top 10,000 template.
Starting two seasons ago I’ve broken down the research into two marking periods each season. This enables midseason to midseason comparisons as well as end of year comparisons.
The Top 10,000 (2013-2015)
Midseason, 2013-14
End of year top 10k currently there at mid season : 35%
End of year top 10k there at least once by mid season: 49%
Midseason Rank achieved by hitting top 10k average each week: ~22k*
*data starts from gw12 and assumes 10k from that starting point
Points Gap from 10k to 1k/100/1: 44/79/143
End of season, 2013-14
Experience: 90+% played before, ranging pretty evenly from 1-7+ years of prior experience
Previous Top 10k: ~20%, ~7% more than once
Previous Top 1k: ~4%
Seasonal average weekly turnover in top 10k : ~17%
Seasonal average brand new teams per week to top 10k: ~9%
Average team value: 108m, 2.1m itb
End of season Rank achieved by hitting top 10k average each week: 30.3k*
*data starts from gw12 and assumes 10k from that starting point
Points Gap from 10k to 1k/100/1: 74/132/234
Midseason, 2014-15
End of year top 10k currently there at mid season : 51%
End of year top 10k there at least once by mid season: 66%
Average team value: 103.7m, 1.2m itb
Midseason Rank achieved by hitting top 10k average each week: 98.8 points behind top 10k (can’t figure out exact rank)
Points Gap from 10k to 1k/100/1: 54/93/178
End of season, 2014-15
Experience: 96%, still quite even from 1-8 years of prior experience
Previous Top 10k: ~36%, with ~21% more than once
Previous Top 1k: ~8%
Seasonal average weekly turnover in top 10k: ~14%
Seasonal average brand new teams per week to top 10k: ~6%
Average team value: 103.5, 1.3m itb (very confusing to me)
End of season Rank achieved by hitting top 10k average each week: 71.1k
Points Gap from 10k to 1k/100/1: 96/159/273
Mid year, 2015-16
Experience: 80%, with ~25% at 5+ years
Previous Top 10k: ~4%
Previous Top 1k: <1% (1 player w 4 top 1k finishes!)
Average team value: 104m, 2.4m itb
Midseason Rank achieved by hitting top 10k average each week: 117 pts behind
Points Gap from 10k to 1k/100/1: 44/77/148
Analysis
While many Fantasy managers are looking at this 2015-16 season as a marked change from the past, that is not necessarily the case.
If you look at the change from 13/14 to 14/15, we might be in the midst of a larger transition in FPL difficulty, not at its beginning or in the midst of some outlier. As FPL Discovery illustrates (see links below), it became markedly more difficult to break into the top 10k last year than the year before, and the gaps from the top 10k to the truly elite top 1k and even the challengers for the overall crown at season’s end became much wider. In actuality, the gaps this year from 10k to the overall top are shorter, and historically more like 2013/14 so far.
Another big change so far from last season is a change in average transfer value (TV) among the midseason top 10k. Ironically, in this season of the value attacker, those teams have almost 2m more in team value than in the past. As Balders pointed out in his post, this could be a significant factor in the potential lack of movement at the top, since if everyone is richer but there aren’t many premium players worth owning, it is hard to use budget constraints to differentiate yourself from others. This could also be connected to the change in Wild Card (WC) rules, as many more managers used theirs early to get on bandwagons and develop TV; it will be interesting to see the season long impact of the new WC chips over the full season.
One of the key changes this season is the experience level of the top 10,000 managers. A massive 20% of the managers are new to the game, with less than 5% being previous top 10,000 ranked managers. This is one of the main criticisms of this season and is sometimes used as evidence that this season is a bizarre campaign being run by “casuals.” However, that might be a bit self-serving, and perhaps an odd revision of our own past seasons. The amount of posts lamenting the lack of differentials or risks paying off has created a narrative that makes it seem as if players from past seasons could leap over the masses with the strike of a single flair captaincy, but doesn’t it stand to reason that most players when first getting serious used this site to follow a template and get in the best players?
Another factor is the wealth of knowledge now available and rise in popularity of FFScout. More people now have more knowledge about strategy, underlying statistics and fixtures. It stands to reason that more people will be vying for a top 10,000 berth and what’s more are equipped with the skills to get there.
Looking at the above research it is clear that this explosion is not sudden. Sometimes the hardest thing to understand about change is that it is not always a gradual shift but rather a series of inconsistent transitions that can catch us off guard. This season Leicester’s incredible rise to the summit of the Premier League is an example of those sorts of surprising changes that perhaps less experienced Fantasy managers have been quicker to react to than the veterans this season.
Finally my own experience as a Fantasy manager over the last three seasons is indicative of how often single decisions in one Gameweek or drafting in just one player can be the difference between a top 10,000 finish or mediocrity. In the 12/13 season Romelu Lukaku’s hat trick, while on loan at West Brom against Manchester United propelled me into the top 5,000. The next season I avoided Aaron Ramsey and Yaya Toure, which ensured I struggled to break the top 100,000. Last year Sergio Aguero’s masterclass against Tottenham in Gameweek 8 set me up for the rest of the season. And this year chasing differentials has cost me dearly. FPL is not broken, there is just a transformation going on that experience managers need to adapt quicker to.
I would love to hear others’ thoughts on this raw data and any more information for the past, since I couldn’t find too much from seasons before 2013/14.
Useful links
https://fpldiscovery.wordpress.com/2014/05/31/season-1314-and-fpl-history/
https://fpldiscovery.wordpress.com/2014/05/20/final-top-10000-teams/
https://fpldiscovery.wordpress.com/2015/06/09/season-1415-final-top-10000/
