Captain Sensible
12 April 2025 380 comments
Hibbo Hibbo
Share:

Fantasy Premier League (FPL) managers have, on paper, a straightforward captain choice ahead of Double Gameweek 32.

Newcastle United’s Alexander Isak (£9.5m) is the undisputed armband favourite ahead of Newcastle United’s home double-header.

Nevertheless, data can identify potential chinks in the Swede’s armoury and suggest alternative, differential options.

As usual, Captain Sensible highlights which assets have the best chance of delivering a big haul.

First, we will assess the fallout of the captain poll before analysing the best options, Rate My Team (RMT), and the Premier Fantasy Tools ratings ahead of Saturday’s 11:00 BST deadline.

THE CAPTAIN POLL

Alexander Isak‘s fitness dominates the rumour-mill narrative, with Newcastle’s marksman starting and blanking as the Magpies dismantled a sorry Leicester City side 3-0.

When Eddie Howe’s team sheet dropped, those backing Isak were in a buoyant mood, and Newcastle’s accumulated 3.25 expected goals (xG) justified his selection.

The data, however, told a different story. In 70 minutes, the forward mustered three shots – two from inside the box – but failed to test an otherwise busy goalkeeper. 0.16 xG was poor.

Still, our electorate is undeterred. The 25-year-old is backed by over two-thirds of the captain poll vote ahead of Newcastle’s two outings.

It was team-mate Jacob Murphy (£5.2m) who stole the Monday Night Football plaudits, netting twice to record a 16-point haul and send his owners into delirium.

The midfielder produced the league’s second-highest non-penalty expected goals (NPxG, 1.57) tally but remains very much the bridesmaid here, backed by a minority 6.76% of voters.

Jean-Philippe Mateta (£7.8m) is third, closely followed by Mohamed Salah (£13.8m) and Daniel Muñoz (£5.2m).

THE PLAYER STATISTICS – LAST SIX MATCHES

FPL team previews – Liverpool: Best players, predicted XI + more

Hibbo Author of Captain Sensible. I write Fantasy Premier League articles, focusing on stats and strategy. Four top 10k finishes. 22/23 Rank - 6123.  Follow them on Twitter

380 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. Sho-kun
    • 8 Years
    7 months, 27 days ago

    Right bench order? Saliba or Konsa?

    Sels
    Saliba/Munoz/Livra
    Salah/Rogers/Sarr/Murphy Isak/Mateta/Marmoush

    Raya/Saka/Konsa/Gvardiol

    1. waltzingmatildas
      • 15 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      Looks good

    2. Miguel Sanchez
      • 9 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      I’d play Gvardiol over Saliba for goal threat

    3. dwattsy21
      • 4 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      I'm playing saka over Marmoush

      1. Punned It
          7 months, 27 days ago

          I've been wanting to. How are your minutes concerns?

          1. dwattsy21
            • 4 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            I think he needs game time so will get over 60

            1. For Beto or Wirtz!
              • 1 Year
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I pray your right. I'm going Saka, ML Opponent going Rogers

    4. jacktaylor
      • 12 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      Play Raya or Martinez?

      1. gomez123
        • 12 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Raya

      2. Mufc202020
        • 6 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Martinez

      3. Miguel Sanchez
        • 9 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Martinez

    5. Jatz10
      • 11 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      Start Saka or Savinho?

      1. stumanchuu
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 14 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Not sure, same here currently on Savinho but feels like whoever I start will be the wrong person ha…same with Gvadiol vs Saliba

        1. Jatz10
          • 11 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Same issue on my side. But I think Palace can beat City, and will score for sure.

      2. Mufc202020
        • 6 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Sav

      3. Miguel Sanchez
        • 9 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Sav if we get news he starts

      4. waltzingmatildas
        • 15 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        I sold Savinho and am benching Saka. But I'd probably start Savinho

    6. Mufc202020
      • 6 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      Top of my mini league doesn’t have Murphy. About 75 points infront.

      Would you triple captain Murphy to try and gain as much as possible?

      A) Yes
      B) No

      1. Miguel Sanchez
        • 9 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        A - think you need to take some gambles on hope that Isak flops this week. Think this is likely the make or break week for you. Good luck!

        1. Mufc202020
          • 6 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Thanks!

      2. waltzingmatildas
        • 15 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        You are in front or they are?

        1. Mufc202020
          • 6 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          They are

          1. waltzingmatildas
            • 15 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Yeah, I'd probably go for it then

            1. Mufc202020
              • 6 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Thanks

              1. Tommy Template
                • 11 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                Does he have TC left? Because you could still make a reasonable gain with TC Isak and owning Murphy if they can only cap Isak.

                1. Mufc202020
                  • 6 Years
                  7 months, 27 days ago

                  No they are on AM

                  1. Tommy Template
                    • 11 Years
                    7 months, 27 days ago

                    Its a question of how risky you want to go then I guess. I think theres a bit of recency bias with Murphy who I do own and hes good for his price but
                    I fully expect Newcastles main striker and penalty taker to outscore him in a double. Good luck whatever you do

                    1. For Beto or Wirtz!
                      • 1 Year
                      7 months, 27 days ago

                      I have both and exactly what Jimmy is saying.

    7. Miguel Sanchez
      • 9 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      Play Bruno this week or bring in Rogers a week ahead of the DGW on a free when he could be a rotation risk (note he has started every PL and UCL game he has been available for)

      A) Rogers (sou)
      B) Bruno (new)

      1. waltzingmatildas
        • 15 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        I think I'd just play Bruno

      2. Gamst - Up (?) the Rovers
        • 15 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        I fear Rogers will be rested. I brought in Watkins and Asensio on a WC since none of them started in Paris.

      3. Mufc202020
        • 6 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        B

    8. waltzingmatildas
      • 15 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      GTG?
      Sels
      Munoz Livra Williams
      Salah Eze Murphy Rogers
      Isak Marmoush Evanilson
      (Raya Saka Gvardiol Gabriel)
      AM Glasner

    9. Wet Bandits
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 10 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      Thoughts? Currently on A with the team below.

      A) TC - Isak
      B) BB - Raya, Saliba, Saka, Konsa

      Martinez
      Gvardiol, Munoz*, Livra*
      Salah, Eze*, Sarr*, Murphy*
      Isak(c), Watkins, Marmoush

      1. waltzingmatildas
        • 15 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        When else would you BB?

        1. Wet Bandits
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 10 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Next GW.. or perhaps later in the season?

          They are only single GW players, of which some (perhaps just Saka) are at risk of playing .

    10. MGMT
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 12 Years
      7 months, 27 days ago

      Would you start Saka, Elanga or Robinson?

      1. Leo14CFC
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Got same and staring Elanga

      2. phil_whites11
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 15 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        A Pope (x2)
        B Raya (BRENTFORD)

        C Munoz (x2)
        D Trippier (x2)
        E Saliba (BRENTFORD)
        F Konsa (southampton)
        G Gvardiol (PALACE)

        H Eze (x2)
        I Sarr (x2)
        JSalah (WEST HAM)
        K Saka (BRENTFORD)
        L Rogers (southampton)

        M Isak (x2)
        N Marmoush (PALACE)
        O Evanilson (FULHAM)

        Who to bench…?

        I’m currently thinking: B, G, F, L

        Thoughts please?

      3. Jullepuu
        • 6 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Any Brighton fans here? You reckon that Minteh starts?

      4. DL
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 6 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Do any Villa fans - or indeed anyone - have a sense of which of their Defenders is most likely to play all three matches in GW 32–33? (Apart from Martinez in GK, obviously.)

        Thanks!

        1. Tommy Template
          • 11 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Not a Villa fan but I'd be expecting none of them potentially. Crazy schedule coming up over the next fortnight for them and Palace

      5. waterboy
        • 13 Years
        7 months, 27 days ago

        Who would you play out of Saliba and Gvardiol?
        The rest of the team picks itself.

        1. Miguel Sanchez
          • 9 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Gvardiol for goal threat

        2. The Big Fella
          • 9 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Similar situation to me - Gvardiol or Konate. So many benching headaches post-WC

          1. Kdobienufc
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I'm also thinking of konate over gvardiol. Everyone has gvardiol in mini league no one has konate and gvardiol attacking has dropped off, better chance clean sheet for liverpool perhaps.

              I'm 36 points behind in second but it's a winner takes all league lol so have to make some moves sometime lol

              Would have BB verbruggen/gvardiol/timber/kluivert but not sure either of the last 2 start so thinking of just putting raya on bench and pick verb, again going against the masses. Will either work well or be a disaster lol

        3. Al Pacho
          • 4 Years
          7 months, 27 days ago

          Raya
          Muñoz Saliba Livramento
          Saka Eze Salah Murphy
          Isak Marmoush Mateta

          Bench : Verbruggen Rogers Milenkovic Gvardiol ( 0.3 ITB 1 FT left)

          I need help guys,
          Should I make any changes to my squad ?
          Worth to Bench boost or TC or save my chips for other GW.

          1. Leo14CFC
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I’ve Benched Saka as he won’t start

              1. Count of Monte Hristo
                • 12 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                This is the correct answer.

          2. TyroneGAA
            • 8 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Raya

            Gvardiol Muñoz burn

            Sarr saka salah Murphy

            Isak TC Marmoush Mateta

            Areola Enzo Saliba Konate

            Doesn’t feel right having this bench but all look ok and triple captain isak is the best time to use? Will BB next week and FH in the blank

            1. Wet Bandits
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 10 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I'm in a similar situation;

              A) TC - Isak
              B) BB - Raya, Saliba, Saka, Konsa

              Martinez
              Gvardiol, Munoz*, Livra*
              Salah, Eze*, Sarr*, Murphy*
              Isak(c), Watkins, Marmoush

              1. TyroneGAA
                • 8 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                I am more inclined to TC as I’m not sure saka gets going this week

          3. Dollyems15
            • 3 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            If you were chasing in your mini league would you captain Murphy over isak? We all have tc and bb left. I think they are geared up for bb this week like myself. 60 points behind, it paid off last week captaining Murphy, is it too much to ask 2 weeks in a row haha

            1. Dollyems15
              • 3 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              My team is
              Sels
              Gvardiol, munoz, livra
              Salah, Palmer, Murphy, Eze.
              Isak, mateta, Evanilson
              Raya, murillo, mgw, huijsen

              1. The Big Fella
                • 9 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                I am also playing Sels over Raya this week. Re. your original question, anything is possible but I also think there is a reason Murphy is 5 point something million so it is not probable you get another haul

            2. Dollyems15
              • 3 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I am using my bb this week. Guess play safe and go isak, so don't lose too much ground, then free hit next week and save tc for later on and hope to get another double for it

          4. Bruno Commando
            • 11 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Team and bench order correct? TC activated...

            Raya
            Konsa Munoz Livramento
            Salah Palmer Sarr Murphy
            Mateta Marmoush (I)sak

            Areola Gvardiol Saliba Foden

          5. dwattsy21
            • 4 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Thoughts please? Main decision is Saka over Marmoush? No chips left, saving transfers for wk 34

            Sels
            Cucurella / Munoz / Livramento
            Murphy / Sarr / Salah / Saka / Rogers
            Isak(c) / Mateta

            Ederson / Marmoush / Milnkovoc / Kerkez

          6. Elijah's Wood
            • 11 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Start one:

            A) Saka (BRE)
            B) Szoboszlai (WHA)

            1. Fodderx4
              • 8 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I'd play Saka if I had him

              1. Elijah's Wood
                • 11 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                Thanks, even with minutes risk?

                1. Fodderx4
                  • 8 Years
                  7 months, 27 days ago

                  Yeah, but i like a risk! I'm not bringing him in this week as already have a benching headache.

          7. Fodderx4
            • 8 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Morning all, 2 Free transfers 0 ITB

            Raya
            Livra Munoz Gvardiol
            Palmer Mo Sarr Murphy (VC)
            Mateta Isak (C) Marmoush

            Areola Bruno Fernandes WBS Gabriel
            GTG? benching Bruno seems wrong, going with Palmer due to the fixture.

          8. The Big Fella
            • 9 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            I am debating TCing Wood for his double and not Isak for this week, as I had planned for weeks. Any thoughts?

            1. The 12th Man
              • 12 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Forest might not get a double gameweek.

            2. Tommy Template
              • 11 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Yeah you might not get a Forest double and could only potentially if they beat City. The other thing is Wood's still injured until we've seen otherwise so I wouldn't be planning anything on a currently injured player

            3. Count of Monte Hristo
              • 12 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Wood is injured at the minute and doubtful he will be as sharp as before so soon. Seems an awful waste of the chip.

          9. Al Pacho
            • 4 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Raya
            Muñoz Saliba Livramento
            Saka Eze Salah Murphy
            Isak Marmoush Mateta

            Bench : Verbruggen Rogers Milenkovic Gvardiol ( 0.3 ITB 1 FT left)

            I need help guys,
            Should I make any changes to my squad ?
            Worth to Bench boost or TC or save my chips for other GW...

            1. jimbo_smells
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 12 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I think I have am identical team, except Enzo for Rogers. For what it's worth I'm currently thinking of BB as planned

          10. Steve Stiffler
            • 9 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Start two from this lot?

            A) Milinkovic
            B) Saliba
            C) Gvardiol
            D) Rogers
            E) Saka

            Also, TC Isak or save?

            Cheers all

            1. The Big Fella
              • 9 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Who would you TC instead if not Isak this week?

              1. Steve Stiffler
                • 9 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                Tbh I don’t see anyone else I’d put it on. Going to play BB next week with 12 doublers. Thinking of saving TC for possibly DGW on a city player. Would you bench boost - Sels, Saka, Gvardiol, Rogers?

                And is my bench order correct from the players in the question above

          11. Elijah's Wood
            • 11 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Bench 1 Def:

            A) Konate (WHA)
            B) Gvardiol (CPL)
            C) Milenkovic (EVE)

            Currently benching Gvuardiol. Leader in mini league has Gvaurdial and Milenkovic

          12. gellinmagellan
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 8 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Verbruggen [Raya]
            Gvardiol Burn Munoz [Gabriel O'Brien]
            Sarr Salah Murphy Saka [Savinho]
            Isak Mateta Manoush
            AM: Potter (who becomes Glassner with 1 FT)

            For player transfer, please help!
            A) Munoz > Bradley
            B) Munoz > Sessegnon
            C) Munoz > NWilliams
            D) Munoz > Ait Nouri
            E) Sarr > Rogers
            F) Sarr > ?!?!

            1. The 12th Man
              • 12 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Why would you remove 2 players with a double gameweek?

              1. gellinmagellan
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                • 8 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                Need to remove one of the three Palace to bring in Glassner for AM.

                1. The 12th Man
                  • 12 Years
                  7 months, 27 days ago

                  Personally, I wouldn’t do it.

                  But if that’s what you want to do,
                  I’d do Sarr to Rogers and play Savio over Rogers.

                2. The 12th Man
                  • 12 Years
                  7 months, 27 days ago

                  Or Saka

                3. Count of Monte Hristo
                  • 12 Years
                  7 months, 27 days ago

                  Counterintuitive and illogical imo.

                  1. gellinmagellan
                    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                    • 8 Years
                    7 months, 27 days ago

                    How? I have to use AM on Glasner which is only possible with one of Munoz or Sarr leaving..

                    1. FplmorelikeFml
                      • 1 Year
                      7 months, 27 days ago

                      If you really want Glasner, I would suggest keeping munoz. Sarr barely touched the ball the last game which doesn't really give confidence

          13. el polako
            • 8 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            I’m just not feeling Isak TC.
            Running out of time to use it.

            1. Tommy Template
              • 11 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I actually kind of prefer Marmoush and Saka's games next week but I dont think either of them start both games.

            2. Philosopher's Stones
              • 5 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Yeah. Not feeling it as well, but not many other options left. Though I felt Kane completely when he gave me that 1 pointer a few seasons back, so I may go with Isak even if I ain't feeling it.

          14. RamaJama
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 13 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Start

            1) Saka
            2) Savinho

            Start

            A) Gvardiol
            B) Kerkez

            1. STHH
              • Fantasy Football Scout Member
              • 11 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I was going to ask the same question about Saka v Savinho! I am leaning towards Savinho for the following reasons:
              - Saka could be benched or not play 90 mins.
              - It was Savinho’s birthday on Thursday and players tend to score on their birthday
              - Palace have a weakened defence with no Guehi.

              1. RamaJama
                • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                • 13 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                Cheers, GL!

                1. STHH
                  • Fantasy Football Scout Member
                  • 11 Years
                  7 months, 27 days ago

                  You too!

          15. Buck The Trent
            • 14 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Who to get for GW32 and GW33?

            A Asensio
            B Malen

            1. The 12th Man
              • 12 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              I’m doing Foden > Asensio.

              Just for this week I think Malen edges it.

          16. mookie
            • 12 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Checked out how many times I captained Isak. Only last week for his 2 pointer.
            VCed 4 times for 11,17,13 and 13. 🙂

            1. The Knights Template
              • 12 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Poor management!

              1. mookie
                • 12 Years
                7 months, 27 days ago

                Indeed

          17. Torres76
            • 15 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Chances of any more dgw after GW 32 and GW 33?

            Thanks all

            1. Tommy Template
              • 11 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Potentially 36 but potentially not. Depends on lots of things which we wont know about for a few weeks

            2. Torres76
              • 15 Years
              7 months, 27 days ago

              Thanks Jimmy

          18. Ibralicious
            • 11 Years
            7 months, 27 days ago

            Play Rogers or Savinho?