Community
27 October 2017 3405 comments
J0E J0E
Share:

Second guessing Pep Guardiola’s starting XI dominates much of the discussion this week as the Spaniard continues to torment us with his teamsheet tinkering. Our Hot Topic posters also find time to discuss whether to hitch a ride on Jose Mourinho’s bus and mull over Harry Kane solutions, while our community scribes analyse the different ways teams build their attacks.

We also welcome back one of last season’s most popular community article series, sift through the best defensive statistics and find out who has got the measure of the Manchester City line-up at the top of our community leagues.

The Community Articles

This week saw the welcome return of YMA’s look at how form and fixture data can help pick the best captain for the next set of fixtures, with Sergio Aguero among the key players to consider for the armband according to his Gameweek 10 preview.

Manchester City assets are also under scrutiny in André94PT’s analysis of the different ways Premier League teams attack, and in Hutch_James’ latest crowd predictions.

Meanwhile, Sky Blues rotation produced mixed results in Gameweek 9 for the Career Hall of Fame top five being tracked by Top Marx.

Elsewhere, Niemi dropped by with the latest news on team form in the Norwegian top flight, as Fantasy Eliteserien nears its nail-biting conclusion.

Don’t forget, if you’ve got some analysis, scout reports or features brewing, be sure to visit our community section to submit your article.

The Hottest Topics

While City’s excellence in attack is not in dispute, what is troubling our community is how much pitch-time their assets will be given.

As our Gameweek 9 rough with the smooth round up of your highs and lows revealed, many were caught out by some surprise omissions from Pep Guardiola’s starting XI last weekend.

We canvassed your views on how you plan to deal with the heavy threat of rotation that looms over City assets, while Ktk Interista attempted to find some method in their manager’s team tinkering. In addition, Ludo’s analysis of Pep’s team sheets left us in no doubt that the Spaniard simply doesn’t care about our Fantasy teams.

The community feels they have a better steer on how City’s rivals Manchester United will set up ahead of the visit of Spurs this Saturday and a trip to Chelsea the following weekend.

Eden Wizard has strong reason to believe Jose Mourinho will be eschewing attack and is  preparing the biggest bus he can find to stop Spurs, although following today’s revelation of Harry Kane’s absence, maybe even Jose will consider changing tact.

But even if the Red Devils may take a more defensive approach, The Twelfth Man believes that Romelu Lukaku owners should keep hold of him, particularly with Kane injured, while unlike City options, the Belgian is at least guaranteed to start.

Among the teams to see an upturn in fortunes from Gameweek 10 is Watford, which has prompted considerable interest in their Brazilian sensation Richarlison, who has scored three times and assisted a further four this season. But while he earned considerable praise on our latest Scoutcast, we asked whether you think he is the real deal.

The young winger also earns a mention in VK’s discussion on the perfect midfield and Pukka–Geoff’s Hot Topic on the increasing competition for midfield places in our Fantasy line-ups.

We also found time to discuss Kane’s dazzling display against Liverpool in Gameweek 9, when he broke his league hoodoo at Wembley by scoring twice. With strong underlying statistics over his barren ‘home’ run, we asked whether Sunday’s turnaround was a victory for number crunching analysis.

But, of course, Kane will sit out Gameweek 10 which today sparked much discussion on possible solutions. First our Hot Topic asked for your plans in light of his absence. Then chatter turned to the Free Hit chip as a possible solution. Tears for Fers turned up to clarify the rules, while Musicholic offered an example of how the chip can impact squad value and budget while active.

Finally, our Live Hall of Fame has been updated to take into account Gameweek 9’s scores, and it revealed that a former number one is staging a dramatic march back to the top.

To view all our discussions please visit our Hot Topics page.

The Members’ Tables

Had enough of Ben Davies failing to make the first XI? Electrue understands your pain and has been taking a look at some replacements to consider.

But those shopping for an alternative to the Spurs defender are urged to steer clear of those highlighted in dingo 1982’s dreadful defences table.

There is further rearguard analysis in Montafly’s comparison of Liverpool and Burnley assets, with both teams having a raft of budget defenders to consider.

Jurgen Klopp’s troops also come under the gaze of Dexter4king, who is in search of their best midfield options.

If you’re a member and are yet to get to grips with the custom statistics tables, you can view this movie for an explanation of how they work. Also, remember to tag them so that people can find the tables with ease.

The Community Tournaments

Fabio Borges has regained the lead in Red Lightning’s Top 10k Any Season league, as well as the summit in the FFS Members League, while Damir TeNay still leads the main FFS league and is seventh in the overall standings.

In TorresMagic’s Last Man Standing, the safety score was 39, which saw 202 players depart and over 2,600 remain.

FC Lackless retains top spot in QPR Utd’s FFS Frequent Summer Posters league, and in the FFS Old Farts Club league, PDM has a commanding 21-point lead over second-placed Ross Graham.

Uwais Ahmed remains first in the FFScout Moderators and Contributors league, with Stilicho’s ghost ship team docked in second.

In Heels Over Head’s R U Smarter than 10K Club, for those who have never finished so high, Bargain Hunters is in the lead. Heels Over Head also issued a plea for community members to take part in his expanded draft competition.

If you are running a community tournament and would like the latest scores included in future Community Round-Ups, please email us summary of the current leaders and a link to your league, spreadsheet or head-to-head competition, at jonty@fantasyfootballscout.co.uk.

3,405 Comments Login to Post a Comment
  1. FDMS All Starz
    9 years, 13 days ago

    What is everyone doing with Kane?

    1. Duffy Dunk
      9 years, 13 days ago

      In my starting 11, if he doesn't play, Jones is first on the bench.

    2. Jafalad
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Thinking of booting him for Lacazett along with Stirling.

    3. Reggie Nainggolan
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sold him and already regret it? Gna need to buy him back for 0.1 extra now for next gw

    4. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sold him for Morata. Poch has a history or down playing injuries and I’m not letting 1/8 of my budget sit on the bench. Having Eriksen makes it easier too. If I get burned next week so be it

      1. Gashead9
        9 years, 13 days ago

        As long as you can afford to get him back in if need be?

  2. A Betting Man
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Has anyone attempted to calculate what the expected added value of playing your free chip is?

    I've been aiming for 20 points extra in RMT compared to my old/existing team. I have only managed ~+15, but I'll make the case to myself and anyone who's reading anyway FOR playing my free hit now and not in the mini GW...

    1) I believe that a 4 fixture mini GW is a rarity, you're more likely to have ~6 fixtures. Getting 11 players from 6 fixtures should be no issue, I had 9/10 last year without King and still had a good GW.
    2) You are also less likely to be able to spend your budget on one of these mini GWs. Not that price = points, but there is obviously a correlation.
    3) Teams will be more standardised. They already are but there's punts like Sanchez & Hazard to be had.

    1. Kevtheotter
      9 years, 13 days ago

      There will be multiple DGWs though. Can be used there also. I get your logic but I’d rather take -8 than play it this week.

    2. GuyIncognito
      9 years, 13 days ago

      It's hard to calculate because it has value over multiple gws. People are ignoring the possibility of using it for a DGW but I think that might actually be a good idea depending on the situation because it means you don't suffer the same sort of GW33 rank drop.

      1. A Betting Man
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        9 years, 13 days ago

        You will surely want BB and TC for 2 of the DGWs, no?

        1. GuyIncognito
          9 years, 13 days ago

          TC yes because you aren't losing anything by using it. Like, let's say Kane has Stoke (H) Everton (H) in a DGW you are going to have him anyway so the TC comes at no cost.

          BB I'm not convinced is actually that good because people wreck their teams to bring in goofball bench players who are punts to do anything even in a DGW. So you might gain 10 points for the DGW but you lose points in the weeks surrounding it because those moves are only optimal for one week. That said, BB would be god-mode if we have a week of fixtures called off for weather or security reasons.

          Generally there is too much focus imo in the FPL community on getting one massive gw score rather than steady consistent points. This also affects how people rate players like Eriksen and KDB who get you 6-7-6 rather than 2-12-2.

    3. A Betting Man
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Accidentally pressed submit. Another point specifically on Kane, the avoidance of -4/-8 for many to perform a hokey cokey either next week or within the next 2/3 GWs. This is less likely to be an issue later in the season, when you are very unlikely to have an 'essential' player getting an injury perfectly synced with the mini GW.

    4. Goonerforever.
      9 years, 13 days ago

      1. Last year you say you had 9/10 players but I'm sure at least 3 of those players were bought just for that GW and maybe 2 taken out after that.... that's 5 wasted FTs......
      I ratea FTs at 4 points each so thats 20 points before the GW stsrts

  3. Kevtheotter
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Hey guys this look gtg?

    Elliot
    Jones Cresswell Alonso
    Eriksen Richarlison Sterling Choupo
    Morata(c) Aguero Vardy

    Foster Carroll Naughton Mbemba 2.0 ITB

    Armband in the right place?

    Cheers

    1. Francescoli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Morata or Richarlison here

  4. Kasper the ghost keeper
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Own Kane, Davies, and Aguero
    None of my bench likely to play (Wimmer, King, Lee)
    So will probably have at least one 0 pointer.
    Take -8 to go:
    Davies -> Duffy/Kiko
    Lee-> Gross

  5. Francescoli
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Captain:
    A) Sanchez
    B) Lacazette
    C) Salah
    D) Jesus
    E) Morata

    1. JasonG123
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sanchez if you have him.

    2. Teahupo'o
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A

    3. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      C

  6. the snazzy viking
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Wimmer ➡ Duffy for free to assure of 11 starters? Thanks

    1. Kasper the ghost keeper
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Yes. Duffy is a big lump of a lad

    2. Francescoli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Is Wimmer injured? If not, I'd hold him. Stoke have the best run for the next 10 gameweeks.

      1. the snazzy viking
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Not injured but is on the bench

        1. Francescoli
          9 years, 13 days ago

          yeah ok. then do it.

    3. the snazzy viking
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Thanks both, it has been done now because I fear that I’ll sleep in and miss the deadline

  7. Gashead9
    9 years, 13 days ago

    How the hell am I supposed to be able to fit Sanchez into my team! Do we need to? I'm inclined to think much of his success as an fpl asset last term was down to playing a lot of the season up front. There is no way you can fit him into your team without making massive sacrifices elsewhere, and surely there is better value out there. I personally cannot see myself getting him in the near future, or at any point this season, unless he becomes 'consistently explosive'. It's decisions like this that could make or break your season, what a potential differential (and captain) option he could be, but my decision is ultimately down to a loss of confidence in Arsenal, just don't have any faith in them anymore, Barcelona 1 week, Nuneaton the next. Don't think they will make top 4 this season, again, Wenger is taking them backwards, slowly, but surely. What are your thoughts? Will you be getting him in? Do you have faith in Arsenal?

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I don't think it's that hard to fit him in but I opted against it because wanted to play it safe. What is your team rn?

      1. Gashead9
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Foster, Elliot
        Jones, Otamendi, Bavies, Lowe, Mbemba
        Salah, Eriksen, Silva, Richarlison, Tarroll,
        Kane, Jesus, Joselu
        0.8 ITB

        Ideally want rid of Foster, Bavies, Burnley Def for Lowe, and Joselu

        1. Pranav Santhosh
          9 years, 13 days ago

          It is hard to fit him in I was assuming you had a big front 3 where you could downgrade your 3rd forward and use the money to upgrade to Sanchez. With your team wouldn't worry about Sanchez looks like a very nice team foster has tough fixtures coming up maybe get rid of him?

          1. Gashead9
            9 years, 13 days ago

            Thanks. Happy to play Elliot for next 2 gw's so will look to get Foster out after that

            1. Pranav Santhosh
              9 years, 13 days ago

              Fair enough good luck for rest of the season

  8. FDMS All Starz
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Hearing romours kane could be out for 2 weeks, truth or just romours? Is there any reliable source out there stating this?

    1. the snazzy viking
      9 years, 13 days ago

      They probably have no idea what they are talking about

    2. Francescoli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      if it's a hamstring, very likely it could be more than one week.

  9. Ed
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Bench one:

    A) Jones
    B) Cedric
    C) RLC

    1. squ1rrel
      9 years, 13 days ago

      C

    2. JasonG123
      9 years, 13 days ago

      The player with no returns this season...

    3. Francescoli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      C

    4. Gashead9
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Is this a real question? C obviously

  10. JasonG123
    9 years, 13 days ago

    GTG? (-4) 2.2m ITB.

    Pope
    Otamendi Ward Davies
    Hazard Salah (vc) Sterling Richarlison
    Morata (c) Aguero Joselu

    Subs: Elliot // Simpson Carroll Hunemeier

    1. squ1rrel
      9 years, 13 days ago

      GTG

  11. ignis88
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Who would you have as your first sub?
    1) Okazaki
    2) Maguire

    1. EmreCan Hustle
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Okazaki

  12. ChickenTikkaMoSalah
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Current team
    Pope

    Otamendi,Daniels,Trippier

    Richarlison,Sanchez,Zaha,Salah

    Aguero,Lacazette,Diouf

    Bench:Speroni,Serman,Rangel,Hunemeir

    Any thoughts on it? Thanks

    1. EmreCan Hustle
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Looks good. Not sure how long Trippier will continue being first choice now that all full backs are fit.

  13. EmreCan Hustle
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Good Morning DZ!

    Free hit is active.

    Speroni
    Alonso Otamendi Dunk
    Sanchez(C) Hazard Salah Richarlison RLC
    Morata Lacazette
    ----------------------------------------------------------------
    3.9M 4.5M Mariappa Rangel

    Nothing in the bank.

    No City cover, but enough quality differentials.

    Sanchez best captaincy option?

    Thanks.

    1. Tabbara
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Why speroni? Elliot is a better pick for this weekend

      1. EmreCan Hustle
        9 years, 13 days ago

        No cash. Will need to downgrade one of Hazard or Alonso.

        1. Tabbara
          9 years, 13 days ago

          tbh walker is a better pick than alonso,i am a chelsea fan and i doubt that chelsea would keep a CS

          1. EmreCan Hustle
            9 years, 13 days ago

            Yeah, he has unperformed. If it was any other team I would have looked at an Arsenal defender or something. But Bou are very attacking at home and defend badly. I'll consider Walker.

            Cheers.

    2. I AM GROOT!!!
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Downgrade Alonso and upgrade RLC. He played 90 min mid week and may not start.

      1. I AM GROOT!!!
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Also may be try to fit in Sane from city? He has been in devastating form and more likely to start this week

        1. squ1rrel
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Silva is more likely to start.

        2. EmreCan Hustle
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Cheers. I was all set on Sane instead of Hazard but that Sterling bench last week has put me off. Not sure what Pep thinks.

    3. squ1rrel
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sanchez definitely the best captaincy option. Not sure about Hazard, maybe David Silva is a better option? Also you could possibly do Alonso -> Azpi/Luiz and play Pope instead of Speroni...

      1. EmreCan Hustle
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Cheers.

      2. squ1rrel
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Or upgrade RLC.

  14. JasonG123
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Play Joselu (bur) or Simpson (EVE)? Playing double Burnley defence as well...

    1. squ1rrel
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Simpson

    2. EmreCan Hustle
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Joselu. Leicester defense hasn't been great and Simpson offers nothing going forward.

  15. squ1rrel
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Free Hit Team GTG?

    Pope
    Gomez - Bellerin - David Luiz - Otamendi
    Sanchez (c) - Salah - Richarlison - David Silva
    Morata - Lacazette

    First sub: Mariappa

    1. EmreCan Hustle
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Looks great! Thoughts on mine above?

  16. Aubaaaaa
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Which one will score more this week?
    A. Lascelles
    B. Ritchie
    C. Richarlison -4
    D. Eriksen

    1. EmreCan Hustle
      9 years, 13 days ago

      D

    2. the snazzy viking
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A

  17. Tabbara
    9 years, 13 days ago

    GTG?
    Elliot
    Kola Davies Ward
    Sterling Salah Silva Richarlison
    Morata Aguero(c) Abraham
    Foster-Carroll-Naughton-Mbemba

    1. KadMan
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Yes

  18. Who Let The Dirk Kuyt?
    9 years, 13 days ago

    I originally transferred in Aguero for Lukaku this gameweek.

    After injuries to Kane and Coutinho, I decided to play my Free Hit chip.

    Does that mean that my Aguero transfer will also be undone and I lost out on the 0.1mil gained?

    1. EmreCan Hustle
      9 years, 13 days ago

      That's what I was told last night. I took a hit for Coutinho. So wanted to undo the FT.

      1. Who Let The Dirk Kuyt?
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Damn. Forgot to take that into account. Just saw Aguero's price. Meaning I've lost out on 0.2mil

        1. EmreCan Hustle
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Same here. I took a -8 to bring in Aguero and Coutinho. So I'll have to find another way to bring him in. Had exact cash 🙁

  19. Kasper the ghost keeper
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Do ye think Davies will play?

  20. GuillermoDickero
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Anyone fancy a shock clean sheet for Swansea? They do like parking the bus away from home

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Would be surprised considering arsenal finally have the trio of alexis ozil and lacazette

    2. KadMan
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Wouldn't say they'll keep a CS but I don't think they'll be hammered either. Easily expecting them to concede only 1.

  21. We Will Klopp you
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Best captain of these?

    A) Lacazette
    B) Salah
    C) Aguero
    D) Sane

    1. EmreCan Hustle
      9 years, 13 days ago

      B

    2. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      B

    3. Alex_thekid
      9 years, 13 days ago

      D

    4. Rainer
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I'd go A if I had him.

      Can see Salah's appeal but really don't think Pool will create as much w/o Coutinho & Mane, can see it being a bit of a struggle.

    5. squ1rrel
      9 years, 13 days ago

      A. Wenger trio was insane last week, vs. Swansea home will be even better.

  22. Rainer
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Those that sold Kane, would you be happy not owning him vs Arsenal in GW12?

    For those that don't own Lukaku along with Kane, who would be your priority to get in?

    1. Pranav Santhosh
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Priority would be Kane over lukaku. And I don't mind not owning for gw12 but I will be worried not owning for gw11 and defintely going to make sure I have him from gw13 onwards

    2. Jafooli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      How long you reckon Kane's out for Rainer?

      1. Rainer
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Touch & go for Palace I reckon. Lose vs United and Real and Poch might feel forced to play him... Also, a nice game for him to sit out and have an 'IB injury' too.

        1. Jafooli
          9 years, 13 days ago

          Ah bollocks, really should have sold. Did you sell in the end?

          1. Rainer
            9 years, 13 days ago

            Nope, keeping all the way through.

            1. Jafooli
              9 years, 13 days ago

              Ummmm, any chance it might be Poch mind games ahead of Utd, and he will play? 😀

  23. ROSSI_7
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Kane to Llorente?

    1. squ1rrel
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Definitely not.

  24. squ1rrel
    9 years, 13 days ago

    On Free Hit, should I play Silva or Sane?

    1. Begbie.
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sane imo.

    2. Rainer
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sane, higher ceiling - SHOULD start.

    3. We Will Klopp you
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Sane

  25. Begbie.
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Okay, I'm now convinced Sanchez will be on the bench tomorrow after seeing him with the black bib on. Doing digging through previous sessions those with the black bib are always on the bench.

    1. I AM GROOT!!!
      9 years, 13 days ago

      I don't think the bib theory was 100% correct last time few weeks back. Sanchez will start.

    2. squ1rrel
      9 years, 13 days ago

      If he is then my Free Hit team mis screwed

  26. Rossamous
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Anything worth a hit? Might be able to just squeeze out 11 starters. 0.1 ITB. Bench order is key this week. Everything in order?

    Elliot
    Mee-Alonso-Cresswell
    Richarlison(C)-Gross-Salah-Eriksen
    Vardy-Kun-Kane

    Foster; Mbemba-TC-Naughton

    Thanks for the help all.

  27. Jafooli
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Kane > Aguero/Jesus/Morata (for a hit) or rely on T Carroll/RLC first on bench?

    1. KAPTAIN KANE SERVES THE PAI…
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Kane to Morata imo

    2. Jafooli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      In the end I kept Kane and did Davies & Sterling > Ward & Salah for -4pts.

      But now regretting it......

  28. KAPTAIN KANE SERVES THE PAI…
    9 years, 13 days ago

    The SCENES on here tomorrow when the City line up is released and upfront it's:

    B.Silva | Sterling | Sane

    Can see it happening, and I own both Aguero and Jesus

    1. Jafooli
      9 years, 13 days ago

      And Kane starts along with Bavies & Rose....

      1. KAPTAIN KANE SERVES THE PAI…
        9 years, 13 days ago

        Haha yes

    2. I AM GROOT!!!
      9 years, 13 days ago

      Haha. We never know. Tomorrow it can easily either be:

      Sane- Jesus- Sterling
      Sterling- Aguero- Sane
      Sterling-Aguero- Jesus
      Sane- Jesus- B.Silva

      Phew it goes on ......

  29. whatsgoingon
    9 years, 13 days ago

    Which one is better this game week ?
    A) Dunk
    B) Mee

    Thanks

  30. FFSbet.com
    9 years, 13 days ago

    FH chip affect prices?
    Should be like WC but not sure...when those fallers are back they will rise 0.1?