169
Pro Pundits - Simon

Why does good FPL form end and what can we do about it? – Part II

In the second of a two-part article, former Fantasy Premier League champion Simon March looks at player and team form.


In my previous article, I discussed how periods of above-average performance among football players will eventually be balanced out by periods of below-average performance and, as a result, we often find ourselves investing in ‘in-form’ FPL players just at the point where their form is about to decline.

While this concept of ‘regressing to the mean’ is a statistical inevitability, it is also a somewhat reductive way of viewing the subject matter at hand. We are, after all, talking about living, breathing human beings, not simply numbers on a spreadsheet. While we can look at how form fluctuates in terms of broad, statistical trends, we also need to consider the fact that teams and players are adaptive, not constant.

With this in mind, and with the objective of continuing this analysis into why form ends and whether this can be predicted, part two of this series will focus on the human element of this equation.

Humans are evolving creatures, responding to changes in our environment and adjusting our behaviours accordingly. Football players, and indeed football teams, are equally adaptive entities. Often, when we look at a player or team in form, we often make the mistake of assuming that things will remain constant and this level of performance will continue indefinitely.

If you accept the common idea that form is connected to confidence levels, this would be an entirely logical viewpoint. If high confidence should help a player play well, playing well should continue to boost confidence, creating a self-sustaining virtuous cycle of positive form.

What this perspective doesn’t consider, however, are the forces working in opposition to this form, both internally and externally and, because humans adapt, the more extreme the levels of form, good or bad, the greater these opposing forces are likely to become.

A team who is performing badly is likely to focus on their key weaknesses whereas a team who is performing well is likely to focus on the things they are doing best, potentially at the expense of other important things. Meanwhile, the teams that face these teams will be trying to exploit their known weakness and nullify their key strengths.

To explain this in more detail, it’s worth considering a famous study from WWII concerning the reinforcing of bomber planes. For a long time, the armour on bomber planes were reinforced based on where bullet holes were found to be clustered upon their return to base. The theory was that, if these were the places most commonly hit by the enemy, then these should be the priority areas to protect.

However, upon observing this practice, the statistician Abraham Wald pointed out that the samples that this theory was based on were comprised entirely of the planes that actually made it back to their base, they didn’t include those that were shot down.

Consequently, he argued, the bullet holes actually highlighted the areas where the plane could survive being hit and it was, in fact, the other areas that needed to be reinforced first.

This effect is referred to as ‘survivorship bias’; a form of sampling bias where the data analysed is unrepresentative due to it having already been filtered of the data that, for whatever reason, didn’t make it to the study. 

We often see a similar effect in football. Teams may appear unstoppable in attack or impregnable in defence but, frequently, this appearance is exaggerated due to the way teams play against them or, often, the way teams don’t play against them.

Teams can appear dominant for long periods of time and perhaps even so dominant that it looks like they might never be dislodged. Think the Arsenal ‘Invincibles’ team of 2003/04, José Mourinho’s Chelsea of the mid-2000s, Pep Guardiola’s Barcelona of 2008 to 2012 or, more recently, Liverpool for the past couple of seasons under Jürgen Klopp.

Over time, however, even the best teams lose their edge. They get so used to what has been working for them working for them, they either stop working on it or, even worse, they only work on it, leaving them vulnerable due to a lack of a viable ‘Plan B’.

Meanwhile, as teams dominate, more data becomes available on how such teams play and how best to play against them. Sometimes all it takes is one tactical innovation; double-marking a certain player, surrendering space on the wings to pack the centre or exploiting an aerial weakness to bring a streak of dominance to an end. Perversely therefore, it is often when teams appear at their most dominant that they are, in fact, at their most vulnerable.

A similar effect can also apply to players. There have been times when certain players such as Leicester’s Jamie Vardy (£10.1m) looked like they might never stop scoring but, eventually, they always do. You cannot achieve extraordinary success without promoting a similar-scale response from the opposition. Equally periods of sustained success can lead to overconfidence in a player, laziness or even choking as the pressure or attention on them mounts. All of these can precipitate a decline in their performance.

Eventually, teams get ‘found out’ by opponents while dangerous players receive increased attention, sometimes nullifying their contribution. This may last until they can adapt to the new challenge.This cycle between observation and adaptation is often a big part of what we are actually referring to when we talk about ‘form’.

So what does this mean for FPL? Well, firstly, we should be particularly wary of players during long scoring streaks and teams who are going through phases of extreme dominance, especially when they are winning games by large margins.

The greater the margin of victory, the greater the likelihood of complacency among the players on the winning side and, for their opponents, there is more information on what to do, or perhaps what not to do, when facing them.

This effect, I’d argue, is part of the reason why we often see teams go from chalking up cricket scores one week to barely having a shot on target the next.

Equally, it means we shouldn’t write off teams who are conceding a lot of goals. Some teams will simply not have the ability or personnel to fix their problems or adapt but some will, and it is unlikely that any team will be working harder on their inadequacies than a team who have just suffered a big defeat. 

This may have significant implications for the much-favoured strategy of ‘targeting the whipping boys’ because the whipping boys may not actually stay whipping boys for as long as we might hope.

At the other end of the spectrum, there is every chance that a team who are keeping many clean sheets will eventually struggle to maintain them. The opportunity for complacency grows with each shut out and, even if by trial and error, the opposition will eventually find their achilles heel.

While I’ve suggested some warning signs for when form might be about to end, it is still very difficult to predict. While teams will not win by 4 goals every match, you also won’t want to sell their assets before that run is over. Equally predicting the exact end or beginning of a period of defensive solidity could involve a lot of guesswork. 

However, this perspective might cause us to show more patience with teams and players who are going through a period of underperformance. For such a player or a team, those problems can compound and cause a drain on your FPL team’s resources, or they may precipitate a rebound in their fortunes, leading to an opportunity. The ability to judge the difference is one of the key skills that really good, or really lucky, FPL managers tend to have.

From a strategic perspective, therefore, the best approach in all respects is likely to be one of moderation. The more you invest into a certain team or fixture, the more exposed you are to any sudden change in their performances so, while by all means target the whipping boys, it’s worth considering whether you really need, say, three players and your Captain tied up in that scenario.

Finally, rather than focusing on the teams who are likely overperforming, we might be better off focusing on the teams who are doing well, but not too well. It is probably no coincidence that the longest unbeaten stretches in football tend to come from teams performing fairly moderately in attack as they never win by enough to become complacent or for opponents to adopt special tactics for them.

Therefore, teams that are winning by smaller margins or attacking players who are delivering a goal or an assist each week may well offer more consistency for longer than teams or players delivering a run of huge hauls.

Why does good FPL form end and what can we do about it?

Check your latest FPL rank LIVE on LiveFPL.net every Gameweek

Become a Member and get unrestricted access to our data and articles

Full-year memberships and monthly subscriptions are now available.

Join now to get the following:

  • Plot your transfer strategies using the fully interactive Season Ticker.
  • Get projections for every Premier League player provided by the Rate My Team statistical model.
  • Use Rate My Team throughout the season to guide your selections and transfers.
  • Get access to over 150+ exclusive members articles over the season.
  • Analyse our OPTA-powered statistic tables specifically tailored for Fantasy Football Managers.
  • Use our exclusive tool to build custom stats tables from over 100 OPTA player and team stats.
  • Enjoy our brand NEW Flat-Track Bully feature which introduces an opposition filter to your tables.
  • View heatmaps and expected goals data for every player.
  • Use our powerful comparison tool to analyse players head-to-head.

ALREADY A USER? CLICK HERE TO UPGRADE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT

NEW TO SCOUT? CLICK HERE TO START A MEMBERSHIP ACCOUNT

169 Comments Post a Comment
  1. Bubbles1985
    • 4 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    What's the WC current scores?

    29 from 5 including Jota captain so far.

    1. Little Red Lacazette
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      20 from 4 incl. cappo. Not good so far.

      1. Bubbles1985
        • 4 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Who was your captain?

        1. Little Red Lacazette
          • 4 Years
          5 months, 8 days ago

          Mo

          1. Bubbles1985
            • 4 Years
            5 months, 8 days ago

            Ouch

    2. Mr. O'Connell
      • 9 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      22 from 7 inc captain. Season. Over.

      1. Bubbles1985
        • 4 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Ok so my 29 ain't too bad considering 5 attackers still to play

        1. Mr. O'Connell
          • 9 Years
          5 months, 8 days ago

          Don't use my score as a benchmark. My GW rank is gonna be in the 7m bracket. Wildcard 1 all over again.

          1. Bubbles1985
            • 4 Years
            5 months, 8 days ago

            Hey it makes me feel better!

        2. pingissimus
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 2 Years
          5 months, 8 days ago

          29 is comfortably above average especially with only 5 played

    3. seewhyaxe
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      35 from 7 if consider captain as 2

    4. Tonyawesome69
      • 2 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      31 from 5 including Salah(c), Alonso no show with Holding 1st bench and Dallas 2nd with 17 points

    5. Miguel Sanchez
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 5 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      53 from 7 (-4) with captain played

      1. Tonyawesome69
        • 2 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Well done on the Dallas jam

      2. Pops15
        • 4 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        32 from 7. Rubbish Sterling (C) punt

        1. TyroneGAA
          • 4 Years
          5 months, 8 days ago

          9 from 5 -4 lol

      3. pingissimus
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 2 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        🙂

        The benefits of zero bench options. Did well to put Dallas ahead of Konsa mind.

      4. Mr. O'Connell
        • 9 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Must be a non-WC team? WC been an absolute curse for most.

    6. tomasjj
      • 7 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      24 from 7.
      Capt. Kane.

    7. Homer21
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      21 from 4 ex Cap

  2. Little Red Lacazette
    • 4 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Nick has been popped out.

  3. HonestBlatter
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 10 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    What has happened to Nick Pope? No GK this week then...DAMN

  4. seewhyaxe
    • 4 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Good to see vydra starting

  5. ⭐ Bemba_Da ⭐
    • 11 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    People have Burnley attackers? What is this?! 😆

    1. diesel001
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Got Vydra. He is bench fodder for me, except for GW33 where I will bench Kane (blank GW) and start Vydra vs Wolves.

    2. tomasjj
      • 7 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Vydra is fodder, as I am in 3-5-2/4-4-2.

  6. CAVEAT KING
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 7 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Amazing:
    Dallas 17 Watkins 8 Meslier 4 coming off my bench. Coufal to come for Dias. Makes a change with 178 points on my bench over the last 10 weeks

    1. pingissimus
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 2 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Brilliant

      35 auto sub points all season here.

      1. CAVEAT KING
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 7 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Yep. I think a lot of us have suffered with the strange season og DGW and BGW issues.

        1. pingissimus
          • Fantasy Football Scout Member
          • 2 Years
          5 months, 8 days ago

          Well truthfully I had next to zero bench right up to 20 or so - at that point Soucek had something like 66% of all my benched points.

          1. CAVEAT KING
            • Fantasy Football Scout Member
            • 7 Years
            5 months, 8 days ago

            I went for cover and got it wrong every week with supposedly logical decisions (smile)

  7. Skloppy Kops
    • 6 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Any chance Shaw gets benched today? Dallas points crying on the bench

    1. Tonyawesome69
      • 2 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      It is possible. Depends if OGS wants telles to have mins before the Europa 2nd leg as Shaw is banned or Shaw is passed fit

      1. Skloppy Kops
        • 6 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Is Shaw fit?

        1. Tonyawesome69
          • 2 Years
          5 months, 8 days ago

          OGS mentioned he had a niggle

          1. Tonyawesome69
            • 2 Years
            5 months, 8 days ago

            But hopes he is available for today

    2. @ocprodigy
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 8 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      If he’s fit he’s starting 100%. Telles will play in Europe.

  8. Railwayman
    • 8 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Where the hell is Pope??? I play him once and the lad disappears from the squad...

    1. Miguel Sanchez
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 5 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Same - Martinez 4 pointer incoming but not the point

      1. pingissimus
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 2 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Given the state of Burnley defence right how I wouldn't be too upset

      2. Baps hunter
        • Fantasy Football Scout Member
        • 3 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        Martinez 4 pts coming and Pope to Lloris was this week was always the plan. Basically watching and hoping now Burnley to concede from a shot that would have been impossible to save.

  9. Muscout
    • 2 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Any news around Shaw playing or not?

  10. Top Lad Dakes.
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 4 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Gundo cameo means Vydra nailed to my bench, and the Rudiger/Jota fails put me on 20pts from 5 so far... not great.

    Shaw/Johnson autosub for Dias, and then Lingard Kane Son Bruno Vardy(c) to go.

    Big day.

    1. Kun, Ayew Nigerian?
      • 6 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      That's a good score

      I've got 28 from 8 which includes my captain

  11. Vazza
    • 1 Year
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Who to start next week

    A. Gundogan (avl)
    B. Watkins (MCI)

    1. Top Lad Dakes.
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Gundo.

    2. AC Yew
      • 2 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Gundo for another 1 pointer

  12. Mr. O'Connell
    • 9 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Today's wishlist:

    Everyone's players to start so no more spawny bench points
    Kane blank
    Son blank
    Ihenacho blank

    1. Top Lad Dakes.
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Wouldn’t mind all of those except for I would like a Son return tbh... unless I’d otherwise be getting a Shaw haul!

      I’ll add a Vardy haul to the wishlist too 😉

      1. Mr. O'Connell
        • 9 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        I've got Vardy so I'm right there with you.

    2. Baps hunter
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 3 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Same except
      Kane haul
      Son haul
      Nacho haul
      AWB haul 😉

  13. bitm2007
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 7 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Lloris (for McCarthy)
    Shaw, Rudgier, Dias
    Bruno, Son, Salah, Lingard, Gundo
    Kane, Iheanacho

    Martinez, Bamford, Veltman, Struijk

    I'm getting Lloris in for McCarthty for the DGW, Still have BB and will FH GW33.

    What's the best way to find 1m to fund it ?

    A) Martinez to Forster
    B) Shaw to Phillips
    C) Lingard to Saka
    D) Gundo to Jorginiho

    1. Dichio24
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      A, without a doubt

  14. Giggs Boson
    • 10 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    I'm not even playing FPL this year but I always enjoy your articles Simon. Thanks for this. Love the psychology-based perspective.

    For every player performing well, there's an opposition manager working out how to stop him.

    1. Nightcrawler
      • 2 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      This would have been a good year for u to be active considering how underwhelming KDB has been most of the season

  15. wulfrunian
    • 4 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Do you think that Jota could get a rest vs Leeds if he starts on Tuesday?

    1. tomasjj
      • 7 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Yes.

      1. wulfrunian
        • 4 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        cheers.I am looking again their fixtures and is it more likely to get a rest vs Newcastle(easier fixture) 5 days later?

    2. Sif
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 8 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Given how potent he can be off the bench is it worth playing 'guess the rest'?

      1. wulfrunian
        • 4 Years
        5 months, 8 days ago

        I guess you are right.Holding first on the bench.

  16. 03farmboy
    • 2 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Grealish out for Lingard?

    Good move

    1. Sif
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 8 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Answered your own question

    2. BrockLanders
      • 6 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      I would

    3. pingissimus
      • Fantasy Football Scout Member
      • 2 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Mount an alternative - monitor WH today.

  17. BrockLanders
    • 6 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    BREAKING:

    Aubameyang out this afternoon
    @skysportsnews

    1. Gudjohnsen
      • 4 Years
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Any news on Smith-Rowe?

  18. Sif
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 8 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Wood/Vydra going to play nearly the whole game with only Mumbongo on the bench, Barnes & JayRod not in squad.

    1. Party time
      5 months, 8 days ago

      Vydra haul hugely needed here

  19. Tosa86
    • 4 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    news about shaw?is he fit or not?
    i have dallas first bench......

  20. pingissimus
    • Fantasy Football Scout Member
    • 2 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Chelsea really were very good yesterday.

    Palace poor no question but I suspect that was a 3 or 4 goal performance against most of the division. Monitoring slightly dodgy WH defence today to see whether Cresswell to Chelsea mid stacks up for 32/33.

  21. Party time
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Lets go Vydra. Feast on them buddy

  22. Gudjohnsen
    • 4 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Chelsea or Leicester attacker?

  23. Nomar
    • 11 Years
    5 months, 8 days ago

    Since its almost certain now that Norwich are coming back up, who's going to go for Pukki in their GW1 team?